Confronting the Holocaust, by Martin Gilbert, COMMENTARY

Commentary • 61 Years, 665 Issues, 10,280 Articles, 61,095pp

← Previous ArticleEntire IssueNext Article →

Books in Review

Confronting the Holocaust

The Holocaust and the Historians, by Lucy S. Dawidowicz

by Martin Gilbert

Commentary, December 1981, pp. 91-93

Show MoreShow AllFinding...Find More

[+]
Issues of the 1940s = 2 Years, 18 Issues, 384 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1948 = 6 Issues, 118 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1949 = 12 Issues, 266 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1950s = 10 Years, 101 Issues, 1,987 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1950 = 6 Issues, 122 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1951 = 12 Issues, 254 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1952 = 12 Issues, 237 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1953 = 11 Issues, 215 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1954 = 6 Issues, 120 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1955 = 12 Issues, 236 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1956 = 12 Issues, 239 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1957 = 6 Issues, 111 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1958 = 12 Issues, 223 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1959 = 12 Issues, 230 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1960s = 10 Years, 118 Issues, 1,787 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1960 = 12 Issues, 207 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1961 = 11 Issues, 196 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1962 = 12 Issues, 174 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1963 = 12 Issues, 173 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1964 = 11 Issues, 156 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1965 = 12 Issues, 174 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1966 = 12 Issues, 206 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1967 = 12 Issues, 180 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1968 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1969 = 12 Issues, 163 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1970s = 10 Years, 116 Issues, 1,637 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1970 = 12 Issues, 154 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1971 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1972 = 12 Issues, 161 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1973 = 12 Issues, 171 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1974 = 12 Issues, 167 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1975 = 10 Issues, 132 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1976 = 11 Issues, 215 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1977 = 12 Issues, 167 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1978 = 11 Issues, 151 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1979 = 12 Issues, 161 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1980s = 10 Years, 114 Issues, 1,617 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1980 = 11 Issues, 191 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1981 = 10 Issues, 138 Articles
  1. [+]
    February 1981 Issue = 15 Articles
    1. Letters by M.H. Blinken, Paul Hollander, and Frederick C. Thayer, ..., pp. 2-22
    2. "Joining the Jackals" by Daniel P. Moynihan, pp. 23-31
    3. Pity the Poor Russians? by Walter Laqueur, pp. 32-41
    4. Why Madame Bovary Couldn't Make Love in the Concrete by Joseph Epstein, pp. 42-47
    5. Deformations of the Holocaust by Robert Alter, pp. 48-54
    6. Toward an Immigration Policy by Samuel Rabinove, pp. 55-57
    7. John Lennon's Mourners by Dorothy Rabinowitz, pp. 58-60
    8. [+]
      The Aging of the New Wave by Richard Grenier, pp. 61-68 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Last Metro (1980 Film) by Francois Truffaut
      2. Mon Oncle d'Amerique (1980 Film) by Alain Resnais
    9. [+]
      Games Writers Play by Pearl K. Bell, pp. 69-73 - 2 Reviews
      1. Nuns and Soldiers by Iris Murdoch
      2. Earthly Powers by Anthony Burgess
    10. [+]
      Speaking for Whitman by Kenneth S. Lynn, pp. 74-77 - 1 Review
      1. Walt Whitman: A Life by Justin Kaplan
    11. [+]
      One Man's Socialism by Michael Novak, pp. 78-79 - 1 Review
      1. Radical Principles by Michael Walzer
    12. [+]
      A Choice of Identity by Jack N. Rakove, pp. 80-81 - 1 Review
      1. Lewis Namier and Zionism by Norman Rose
    13. [+]
      Workers' Paradise? by Steven Plaut, pp. 82-83 - 3 Reviews
      1. Economic Welfare in the Soviet Union by Alastair McAuley
      2. Social and Economic Inequality in the Soviet Union by Murray Yanowitch
      3. Privilege in the Soviet Union by Mervyn Matthews
    14. [+]
      Dramatic Tensions by Stephen Miller, pp. 84-85 - 1 Review
      1. Theater and Revolution by Frederick Brown
    15. [+]
      Priest of Art by Jeffrey Meyers, pp. 86-90 - 1 Review
      1. Lectures on Literature by Vladimir Nabokov and Fredson Bowers
  2. [+]
    March 1981 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Frederick Butzen, Iris Mitgang, and Edith U. Fierst, ..., pp. 2-24
    2. The Election & the Evangelicals by Seymour Martin Lipset and Earl Raab, pp. 25-31
    3. Carter's Last Capitulation by Joseph W. Bishop, Jr., pp. 32-35
    4. What Happened to the Schools by Joseph Adelson, pp. 36-41
    5. Anti-Semitism and American History by Jonathan D. Sarna, pp. 42-47
    6. Healing by Annette Henkin Landau, pp. 48-52
    7. Portrait of a Hero by Ruth R. Wisse, pp. 53-55
    8. American Music by Samuel Lipman, pp. 56-61
    9. [+]
      The Christmas Bombing by Charles Horner, pp. 62-63 - 1 Review
      1. The Prestige Press and the Christmas Bombing, 1972 by Martin F. Herz and Leslie Rider
    10. [+]
      One People? by David Vital, pp. 64-68 - 1 Review
      1. The Jew in the Modern World by Paul Mendes-Flohr and Jehuda Reinharz
    11. [+]
      Political Mania by Peter Shaw, pp. 69-71 - 1 Review
      1. Fire in the Minds of Men by James H. Billington
    12. [+]
      Cynic and Moralist by George Lane, pp. 72-73 - 1 Review
      1. The Letters of Evelyn Waugh by Mark Amory and Evelyn Waugh
    13. [+]
      The Woes of Academe by Chester E. Finn, Jr., pp. 74-76 - 2 Reviews
      1. Group Memory by Alston Chase
      2. Education and the Democratic Ideal by Steven M. Cahn
    14. [+]
      Professional Liberal by Herman Belz, pp. 77-82 - 1 Review
      1. Independent Journey by James F. Simon
  3. [+]
    April 1981 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by Robert Pastor, Dave Van Buren, and John E. Chappell, Jr., ..., pp. 4-28
    2. The Future Danger by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 29-47
    3. Ideology & Supply-Side Economics by Irving Kristol, pp. 48-54
    4. France vs. Israel by Sally Baumann Reynolds, pp. 55-59
    5. Having Babies Again by Naomi Munson, pp. 60-62
    6. "...Who Made me a Woman" by George Jochnowitz, pp. 63-64
    7. [+]
      Napoleon Conquers America by Richard Grenier, pp. 65-70 - 1 Review
      1. Napoleon (1927 Film) by Abel Gance
    8. [+]
      James Michener's Docudramas by Pearl K. Bell, pp. 71-73 - 1 Review
      1. The Covenant by James A. Michener
    9. [+]
      Crisis in the Humanities by Samuel Lipman, pp. 74-76 - 1 Review
      1. The Humanities in American Life
    10. [+]
      "Der Jude" by Hyam Maccoby, pp. 77-78 - 1 Review
      1. The Jew by Arthur A. Cohen and Martin Buber
    11. [+]
      The Fuel of Achievement by Stephen Miller, pp. 79-81 - 1 Review
      1. Ambition: The Secret Passion by Joseph Epstein
    12. [+]
      Profiles in Courage by Maurice Friedberg, pp. 82-83 - 1 Review
      1. Soviet Dissidents by Joshua Rubenstein
    13. [+]
      Race & Society by Jack N. Rakove, pp. 84-90 - 1 Review
      1. White Supremacy by George M. Fredrickson
  4. [+]
    May 1981 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by Charles William Maynes, Robert Kaplan, and Gerald L. Houseman, ..., pp. 4-24
    2. How to Make Peace with the Palestinians by Menahem Milson, pp. 25-35
    3. The Imperial Media by Joseph Kraft, pp. 36-47
    4. Let Me Call You Quota, Sweetheart by Walter Berns, pp. 48-53
    5. The Choice by Jeanette Erlbuam Goldsmith, pp. 54-63
    6. [+]
      The Universe and Dr. Sagan by Jeffrey Marsh, pp. 64-67 - 1 Review
      1. Cosmos by Carl Sagan
    7. Confessions of a Prodigy by Samuel Lipman, pp. 68-72
    8. [+]
      "The Uniforms That Guard Us" by Richard Grenier, pp. 73-81 - 2 Reviews
      1. Breaker Morant (1980 Film) by Bruce Beresford
      2. Fort Apache, the Bronx (1981 Film) by Daniel Petrie
    9. [+]
      Letty in Pogrebinland by Joseph Adelson, pp. 82-85 - 1 Review
      1. Growing Up Free by Letty Cottin Pogrebin
    10. [+]
      Israel & the Disaspora by Robert S. Wistrich, pp. 86-88 - 1 Review
      1. Zionism in Transition by Moshe Davis
    11. [+]
      Crisis in the East by Arch Puddington, pp. 89-91 - 1 Review
      1. The Road to Gdansk by Daniel Singer
    12. [+]
      The Province of Art by Ann Hulbert, pp. 92-93 - 1 Review
      1. Ideas and the Novel by Mary McCarthy
    13. [+]
      Business and Society by Leslie Lenkowsky, pp. 94-98 - 1 Review
      1. Corporations and Their Critics by Thornton Bradshaw and David Vogel
  5. [+]
    June 1981 Issue = 15 Articles
    1. Letters by Sidra Ezrahi, Alvin H. Rosenfeld, and Irving Greenberg, ..., pp. 2-26
    2. Mexico & Other Dominoes by Carlos Rangel, pp. 27-33
    3. The Most Beautiful Woman in Vilna by Ruth R. Wisse, pp. 34-38
    4. In Defense of Religious America by Terry Eastland, pp. 39-45
    5. Locke and the Law of the Sea by Robert A. Goldwin, pp. 46-50
    6. IQ on Trial by Nathan Glazer, pp. 51-59
    7. Rehearsal for the Holocaust? by George Watson, pp. 60-61
    8. [+]
      New Jewish Voices by Pearl K. Bell, pp. 62-66 - 3 Reviews
      1. Ellis Island, and Other Stories by Mark Helprin
      2. The Stolen Jew by Jay Neugeboren
      3. Preparing for Sabbath by Nessa Rapoport
    9. [+]
      Updating James Bond by Richard Grenier, pp. 67-71 - 12 Reviews
      1. Dr. No (1962 Film) by Terence Young
      2. From Russia with Love (1963 Film) by Terence Young
      3. Thunderball (1965 Film) by Terence Young
      4. You Only Live Twice (1967 Film) by Lewis Gilbert
      5. On Her Majesty's Secret Service (1969 Film) by Peter R. Hunt
      6. Live and Let Die (1973 Film) by Guy Hamilton
      7. The Man With The Golden Gun (1974 Film) by Guy Hamilton
      8. The Spy Who Loved Me (1977 Film) by Lewis Gilbert
      9. Moonraker (1979 Film) by Lewis Gilbert
      10. For Your Eyes Only (1981 Film) by John Glen
      11. Eyewitness (1981 Film) by Peter Yates
      12. Nighthawks (1981 Film) by Bruce Malmuth
    10. [+]
      Doing Less by Peter W. Rodman, pp. 72-74 - 1 Review
      1. Solvency: The Price of Survival by James Chace
    11. [+]
      Blind Hatred by Steve Zipperstein, pp. 75-76 - 1 Review
      1. Dostoevsky and the Jews by David I. Goldstein
    12. [+]
      How We Lost? by Seth Cropsey, pp. 77-79 - 1 Review
      1. Self-Destruction by Cincinnatus
    13. [+]
      An American Maugham by George Lane, pp. 80-81 - 1 Review
      1. The Life of John O'Hara by Frank MacShane
    14. [+]
      The Pot Lobby by Bryan Lops, pp. 82-84 - 1 Review
      1. High in America by Patrick Anderson
    15. [+]
      Getting Even by Robert William Kagan, pp. 85-90 - 1 Review
      1. Making Scenes by Robert S. Brustein
  6. [+]
    July 1981 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by David B. Broyles, Seymour Martin Lipset, and Earl Raab, ..., pp. 2-14
    2. The Timerman Case by Mark Falcoff, pp. 15-23
    3. Hemingway's Private War by Kenneth S. Lynn, pp. 24-33
    4. Thinking About Terrorism by James Q. Wilson, pp. 34-39
    5. Hunger and Ideology by Nick Eberstadt, pp. 40-49
    6. Varieties of Jewish Verse by Robert Alter, pp. 50-56
    7. Singing Wolf by Samuel Lipman, pp. 57-61
    8. [+]
      A Soviet "New Wave"? by Richard Grenier, pp. 62-67 - 2 Reviews
      1. Oblomov (1979 Film) by Nikita Mikhalkov
      2. Moscow Does Not Believe in Tears (1980 Film) by Vladimir Menshov
    9. [+]
      The Carter Years by Chester E. Finn, Jr., pp. 68-69 - 1 Review
      1. Governing America by Joseph A. Califano, Jr.
    10. [+]
      Class, Culture & Society by Michael Novak, pp. 70-71 - 1 Review
      1. The Winding Passage by Daniel Bell
    11. [+]
      Second Generation by David Singer, pp. 72-74 - 1 Review
      1. At Home in America by Deborah Dash Moore
    12. [+]
      Giving Up by Penn Kemble, pp. 75-76 - 1 Review
      1. Real Security by Richard J. Barnet
    13. [+]
      The Spirit of Enterprise by Adam Meyerson, pp. 77-82 - 1 Review
      1. Wealth and Poverty by George Gilder
  7. [+]
    August 1981 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Sidney Hook, Richard Holbrooke, and Elias M. Schwarzbart, ..., pp. 4-18
    2. Hollanditis by Walter Laqueur, pp. 19-26
    3. Are Jews Becoming Republican? by Milton Himmelfarb, pp. 27-31
    4. Central America and Its Enemies by Constantine Menges, pp. 32-38
    5. The Politics of Muslim Anti-Semitism by Daniel Pipes, pp. 39-45
    6. The Case of Janet Cooke by Naomi Munson, pp. 46-50
    7. The Noblest Distraction by Joseph Epstein, pp. 51-55
    8. [+]
      Self-Seekers by Pearl K. Bell, pp. 56-59 - 3 Reviews
      1. Tar Baby by Toni Morrison
      2. World Without End by Francine du Plessix Gray
      3. The White Hotel by D.M. Thomas
    9. [+]
      Kid Stuff by Richard Grenier, pp. 60-65 - 1 Review
      1. Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981 Film) by Steven Spielberg
    10. [+]
      Of Arms & Men by Eliot A. Cohen, pp. 66-68 - 1 Review
      1. National Defense by James Fallows
    11. [+]
      Back to the Melting Pot? by Howard Brotz, pp. 69-71 - 1 Review
      1. The Ethnic Myth by Stephen Steinberg
    12. [+]
      Roots of Resistance by Jack N. Rakove, pp. 72-73 - 1 Review
      1. American Patriots and the Rituals of Revolution by Peter Shaw
    13. [+]
      Judicial Philosophy by Herman Belz, pp. 74-77 - 1 Review
      1. The Enigma of Felix Frankfurter by H.N. Hirsch
    14. [+]
      Nationalism vs. Ideology by Maurice Friedberg, pp. 78-82 - 2 Reviews
      1. Russia's Failed Revolutions by Adam B. Ulam
      2. The Rise of the Gulag by Alain Besancon
  8. [+]
    September 1981 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Leopoldo Lopez, Willard L. Beaulac, and Samuel Rabinove, ..., pp. 4-26
    2. The Middle East by Robert W. Tucker, pp. 27-36
    3. Human Rights and American Power by Samuel P. Huntington, pp. 37-43
    4. CBS vs. Defense by Joshua Muravchik and John E. Haynes, pp. 44-55
    5. [+]
      Philip Roth Then and Now by Ruth R. Wisse, pp. 56-60 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Ghost Writer by Philip Roth
      2. Zuckerman Unbound by Philip Roth
    6. The Quintessential Liberal by Robert Nisbet, pp. 61-63
    7. From the Memoirs of an Administrator by John Hollander, p. 64
    8. John Hinckley by Peter Shaw, pp. 65-66
    9. The Mogul Who Loved Art by David Aberbach, pp. 67-71
    10. [+]
      Futurist Manifesto by Roger Starr, pp. 72-75 - 1 Review
      1. The World Challenge by Jean-Jacques Servan-Schreiber
    11. [+]
      Jesus as Jew by Hillel Halkin, pp. 76-79 - 1 Review
      1. Revolution in Judaea by Hyam Maccoby
    12. [+]
      Radical's Journey by James Nuechterlein, pp. 80-81 - 1 Review
      1. A Life in Two Centuries by Bertram D. Wolfe
    13. [+]
      Foundlings and Bastards by Renee Winegarten, pp. 82-84 - 1 Review
      1. Origins of the Novel by Marthe Robert
    14. [+]
      Thought Control by Arch Puddington, pp. 85-90 - 1 Review
      1. The Bureaucracy of Truth by Paul Lendvai
  9. [+]
    October 1981 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by Robert Moses Shapiro, Gregory J. Lanning, and George Watson, ..., pp. 4-28
    2. Speaking to the Third World by Peter L. Berger, pp. 29-36
    3. On the Ninth of Ab by Frank Talmage, pp. 37-43
    4. The Surrealists in New York by Lionel Abel, pp. 44-54
    5. Bribing Delinquents to be Good by Susan Seidner Adler, pp. 55-61
    6. Beyond Nuremberg by Allan Gerson, pp. 62-66
    7. [+]
      Arms & the Movies by Richard Grenier, pp. 67-71 - 2 Reviews
      1. M*A*S*H (1970 Film) by Robert Altman
      2. Stripes (1981 Film) by Ivan Reitman
    8. [+]
      Sequels by Pearl K. Bell, pp. 72-75 - 2 Reviews
      1. Rabbit Is Rich by John Updike
      2. Reinhart's Women by Thomas Berger
    9. [+]
      American Mosaic by William Petersen, pp. 76-77 - 1 Review
      1. Ethnic America by Thomas Sowell
    10. [+]
      Surveying the 70's by Robert William Kagan, pp. 78-80 - 1 Review
      1. New Rules by Daniel Yankelovich
    11. [+]
      Early American by David Singer, pp. 81-83 - 1 Review
      1. Jacksonian Jew by Jonathan D. Sarna
    12. [+]
      The "Art" of Jazz by Robert Richman, pp. 84-85 - 1 Review
      1. Riding on a Blue Note by Gary Giddins
    13. [+]
      Remaining Human by Leonard Schapiro, pp. 86-90 - 1 Review
      1. Within the Whirlwind by Eugenia Ginzburg
  10. [+]
    December 1981 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Bill Leonard, Judy Crichton, and Robert J. Spitzer, ..., pp. 4-24
    2. Appeasement & the AWACs by Robert W. Tucker, pp. 25-30
    3. Can El Salvador Be Saved? by Max Singer, pp. 31-36
    4. A New Direction for American Jews by Murray Friedman, pp. 37-44
    5. Patenting Life by Leon R. Kass, pp. 45-57
    6. My Friend Walter Benjamin by Gershom Scholem, pp. 58-69
    7. Children of Chopin by Samuel Lipman, pp. 70-74
    8. Why "Nicholas Nickleby"? by Myron Magnet, pp. 75-78
    9. [+]
      Our Lady of Corruption by Richard Grenier, pp. 79-83 - 1 Review
      1. True Confessions (1981 Film) by Ulu Grosbard
    10. [+]
      Fellow-Travelers' Tales by Leonard Schapiro, pp. 84-85 - 1 Review
      1. Political Pilgrims by Paul Hollander
    11. [+]
      A Life in Politics by Nathan Glazer, pp. 86-88 - 1 Review
      1. Javits by Jacob K. Javits and Rafael Steinberg
    12. [+]
      Fighting Castro by Mark Falcoff, pp. 89-90 - 1 Review
      1. Tocayo by Antonio Navarro
    13. [+]
      Confronting the Holocaust by Martin Gilbert, pp. 91-93 - 1 Review
      1. The Holocaust and the Historians by Lucy S. Dawidowicz
    14. [+]
      The Forgotten War by Arch Puddington, pp. 94-98 - 1 Review
      1. The Struggle for Afghanistan by Nancy Peabody Newell and Richard S. Newell
3. [+]
  Issues of 1982 = 11 Issues, 143 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1983 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1984 = 12 Issues, 163 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1985 = 10 Issues, 156 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1986 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1987 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1988 = 12 Issues, 200 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1989 = 12 Issues, 152 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1990s = 10 Years, 114 Issues, 1,663 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1990 = 12 Issues, 165 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1991 = 12 Issues, 150 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1992 = 12 Issues, 185 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1993 = 12 Issues, 151 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1994 = 12 Issues, 162 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1995 = 12 Issues, 225 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1996 = 10 Issues, 174 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1997 = 11 Issues, 158 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1998 = 10 Issues, 136 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1999 = 11 Issues, 157 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 2000s = 9 Years, 84 Issues, 1,205 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 2000 = 10 Issues, 150 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 2001 = 11 Issues, 147 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 2002 = 11 Issues, 148 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 2003 = 11 Issues, 159 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 2004 = 11 Issues, 142 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 2005 = 11 Issues, 186 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 2006 = 7 Issues, 98 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 2007 = 3 Issues, 54 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 2008 = 9 Issues, 121 Articles