Jewish Workingmen, by Irving Howe, COMMENTARY

Commentary • 61 Years, 665 Issues, 10,280 Articles, 61,095pp

← Previous ArticleEntire IssueNext Article →

Books in Review

Jewish Workingmen

Class Struggle in the Pale, by Ezra Mendelsohn

by Irving Howe

Commentary, December 1970, pp. 98-99

Show MoreShow AllFinding...Find More

[+]
Issues of the 1940s = 2 Years, 18 Issues, 384 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1948 = 6 Issues, 118 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1949 = 12 Issues, 266 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1950s = 10 Years, 101 Issues, 1,987 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1950 = 6 Issues, 122 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1951 = 12 Issues, 254 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1952 = 12 Issues, 237 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1953 = 11 Issues, 215 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1954 = 6 Issues, 120 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1955 = 12 Issues, 236 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1956 = 12 Issues, 239 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1957 = 6 Issues, 111 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1958 = 12 Issues, 223 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1959 = 12 Issues, 230 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1960s = 10 Years, 118 Issues, 1,787 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1960 = 12 Issues, 207 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1961 = 11 Issues, 196 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1962 = 12 Issues, 174 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1963 = 12 Issues, 173 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1964 = 11 Issues, 156 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1965 = 12 Issues, 174 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1966 = 12 Issues, 206 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1967 = 12 Issues, 180 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1968 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1969 = 12 Issues, 163 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1970s = 10 Years, 116 Issues, 1,637 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1970 = 12 Issues, 154 Articles
  1. [+]
    January 1970 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Joseph M. Proskauer, Arthur A. Cohen, and Milton Hindus, ..., pp. 4-11
    2. TV Journal by Neil Compton, pp. 12-18
    3. Kennedyism by Midge Decter, pp. 19-27
    4. Confessions of a Green Beret by William Pfaff, pp. 28-36
    5. Jewish Class Conflict? by Milton Himmelfarb, pp. 37-42
    6. Is There a Jewish Vote? by Arthur M. Klebanoff, pp. 43-47
    7. The Political Thought of Herbert Marcuse by George Kateb, pp. 48-63
    8. Allen Ginsberg and the 60's by Morris Dickstein, pp. 64-70
    9. Assessing the Six-Day War by Amos Perlmutter, pp. 71-76
    10. [+]
      Documenting the Holocaust by Henriette Boas, pp. 77-79 - 1 Review
      1. The Destruction of the Dutch Jews by Jacob Presser
    11. [+]
      Dreiser Reappraised by Arthur Edelstein, pp. 80-82 - 1 Review
      1. Two Dreisers by Ellen Moers
    12. [+]
      Christian Theology by John Keber, pp. 83-84 - 2 Reviews
      1. Religion and Change by David L. Edwards
      2. Alienation, Atheism, and the Religious Crisis by Thomas F. O'Dea
    13. [+]
      Quest's End by Elizabeth Dalton, pp. 85-86 - 1 Review
      1. The Four-Gated City by Doris Lessing
    14. [+]
      New Politics by Barry Gewen, pp. 87-90 - 1 Review
      1. Ideology in America by Everett Carll Ladd, Jr.
  2. [+]
    February 1970 Issue = 11 Articles
    1. Letters by Noam Chomsky, Richard Goodwin, Gus Tyler, and William Pfaff, ..., pp. 4-24
    2. John V. Lindsay by Roger Starr, pp. 25-49
    3. Zionism for the 70's by Robert Alter, pp. 50-57
    4. Whatever Happened to Criticism? by Alfred Kazin, pp. 58-63
    5. The Paradox of Prosperity by John Lukacs, pp. 64-69
    6. Home Is Two Places by Edward Hoagland, pp. 70-76
    7. [+]
      With-it Movies by William S. Pechter, pp. 77-81 - 6 Reviews
      1. Goodbye, Columbus (1969 Film) by Larry Peerce
      2. If... (1968 Film) by Lindsay Anderson
      3. Easy Rider (1969 Film) by Dennis Hopper
      4. Medium Cool (1969 Film) by Haskell Wexler
      5. Alice's Restaurant (1969 Film) by Arthur Penn
      6. The Rain People (1969 Film) by Francis Ford Coppola
    8. [+]
      The Literary Life by Renee Winegarten, pp. 82-83 - 1 Review
      1. The Rise and Fall of the Man of Letters by John Gross
    9. [+]
      The New Elite by Michael Harrington, p. 84 - 1 Review
      1. The Crisis of Industrial Society by Norman Birnbaum
    10. [+]
      Old-Fashioned Virtues by Dorothy Rabinowitz, pp. 85-86 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Family Carnovsky by Israel J. Singer
      2. Steel and Iron by Israel J. Singer
    11. [+]
      The Rabbi & the Rebbes by David Daiches, pp. 87-90 - 1 Review
      1. Nine and a Half Mystics by Herbert Weiner
  3. [+]
    March 1970 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by Arthur Schlesinger, Jr. and Josiah Lee Auspitz, ..., pp. 4-19
    2. Innocence Restaged by Jack Richardson, pp. 20-28
    3. Nixon So Far by Maurice J. Goldbloom, pp. 29-38
    4. The Poverty of Affluence by Robert Lekachman, pp. 39-44
    5. The U.S., the Arabs & Israel by Anthony Hartley, pp. 45-50
    6. Intermarriage & Jewish Survival by Marshall Sklare, pp. 51-60
    7. Literary Gangsters by Gore Vidal, pp. 61-64
    8. The Future of Prediction by John P. Sisk, pp. 65-70
    9. [+]
      The Princess by Philip Rahv, p. 71 - 1 Review
      1. Only One Year by Svetlana Alliluyeva
    10. [+]
      High Finance by Lawrence Malkin, pp. 72-77 - 1 Review
      1. Money International by Fred Hirsch
    11. [+]
      Cultural Transplants by Martin Jay, pp. 78-84 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Intellectual Migration by Bernard Bailyn and Donald Fleming
      2. The Bauhaus by Hans M. Wingler
    12. [+]
      The Professor & the Police by Walter Goodman, pp. 85-87 - 1 Review
      1. Being Busted by Leslie A. Fiedler
    13. [+]
      Becoming American by Irving Howe, pp. 88-92 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Education of Abraham Cahan by Abraham Cahan
      2. The Downtown Jews by Ronald Sanders
  4. [+]
    April 1970 Issue = 11 Articles
    1. Letters by George Charney, Maurice J. Goldbloom, and Robert L. Heilbroner, ..., pp. 4-17
    2. The TV Season Re-Viewed by Neil Compton, pp. 18-24
    3. Latin America by Norman Gall, pp. 25-37
    4. This Aquarian Age by Milton Himmelfarb, pp. 38-41
    5. Imperialism: I by George Lichtheim, pp. 42-76
    6. Discourses of the Rabbis by Chaim Raphael, pp. 77-79
    7. [+]
      Paranoia at the Movies by Myron Magnet, pp. 80-84 - 1 Review
      1. They Shoot Horses, Don't They? (1969 Film) by Sydney Pollack
    8. [+]
      Black History by David Donald, pp. 85-87 - 1 Review
      1. The American Negro by Ulysses Lee and William Loren Katz
    9. [+]
      P.M. by Robert G. Hazo, p. 88 - 1 Review
      1. Tides of Fortune, 1945-1955 by Harold MacMillan
    10. [+]
      The Critical Moment by John P. Sisk, pp. 89-91 - 1 Review
      1. Literature and the Sixth Sense by Philip Rahv
    11. [+]
      The Surviving Word by Dan Jacobson, pp. 92-98 - 1 Review
      1. A Treasury of Yiddish Verse by Irving Howe and Eliezer Greenberg
  5. [+]
    May 1970 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by George Steiner, Adam Walinsky, and Irving M. Engel, ..., pp. 4-25
    2. [+]
      Z: Politics on Film by Charles W. Brooks, pp. 26-32 - 1 Review
      1. Z (1969 Film) by Constantin Costa-Gavras
    3. Imperialism: II by George Lichtheim, pp. 33-58
    4. Translating the Bible by David Daiches, pp. 59-70
    5. The Obligations of Oppressed Minorities by Michael Walzer, pp. 71-82
    6. On Lea Goldberg & S.Y. Agnon by Robert Alter, pp. 83-88
    7. [+]
      Man in Culture by Irvin Stock, pp. 89-93 - 1 Review
      1. Mr. Sammler's Planet by Saul Bellow
    8. [+]
      Judicial Activism by Leon Friedman, pp. 94-97 - 1 Review
      1. The Supreme Court and the Idea of Progress by Alexander M. Bickel
    9. [+]
      Endgames by Edward Grossman, pp. 98-99 - 1 Review
      1. Smiling Through the Apocalypse by Harold Hayes
    10. [+]
      Tradition & the New by Marvin Fox, pp. 100-103 - 1 Review
      1. Jewish Philosophy in Modern Times by Nathan Rotenstreich
    11. [+]
      Sequels by Dorothy Rabinowitz, pp. 104-107 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Estate by Isaac Bashevis Singer
      2. The Promise by Chaim Potok
    12. [+]
      Secular Humanism by John Weightman, p. 108 - 1 Review
      1. The Science of Freedom by Peter Gay
    13. [+]
      Mr. Secretary by Marcus Cunliffe, pp. 109-114 - 1 Review
      1. Present at the Creation by Dean Acheson
  6. [+]
    June 1970 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by John Marchi, Woody Klein, Midge Decter, and Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., ..., pp. 4-27
    2. Reflections on Earth Day by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 28-30
    3. The Palestinians and Israel by Shlomo Avineri, pp. 31-44
    4. Quackery in the Classroom by Samuel McCracken, pp. 45-58
    5. In Sickness and in Health by Eric J. Cassell, pp. 59-66
    6. Literary Revolutionism by Renee Winegarten, pp. 67-74
    7. Joyce Carol Oates by Elizabeth Dalton, pp. 75-76
    8. Jesus and the Jews by Chaim Raphael, pp. 77-80
    9. [+]
      Mary a la Mode by Edward Grossman, pp. 81-84 - 1 Review
      1. The Writing on the Wall, and Other Literary Essays by Mary McCarthy
    10. [+]
      The Witness by Allen Weinstein, pp. 85-87 - 1 Review
      1. Odyssey of a Friend by William F. Buckley, Jr. and Whittaker Chambers, ...
    11. [+]
      The Commissioner by Edward Jay Epstein, pp. 88-89 - 1 Review
      1. How to Talk Back to Your Television Set by Nicholas Johnson
    12. [+]
      Dialogue by Arthur A. Cohen, pp. 90-91 - 1 Review
      1. Judaism Despite Christianity by Eugen Rosenstock-Huessy and Franz Rosenzweig
    13. [+]
      Rock Criticism by Barry Gewen, pp. 92-98 - 3 Reviews
      1. The Story of Rock by Carl Belz
      2. Rock and Roll Will Stand by Greil Marcus
      3. The Age of Rock by Jonathan Eisen
  7. [+]
    July 1970 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. Letters by Robert Lekachman, Meyer Liben, and Henry M. Pachter, ..., pp. 6-17
    2. Agit-Prop & the Rosenbergs by Allen Weinstein, pp. 18-26
    3. First Things, and Last by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 27-28
    4. Urban Civilization & Its Discontents by Irving Kristol, pp. 29-35
    5. Can Anti-Semitism Be Measured? by Lucy S. Dawidowicz, pp. 36-43
    6. On the Passage of Time by Peter Berlinrut, pp. 44-54
    7. The Shalit Case by Robert Alter, pp. 55-61
    8. The Radicalized Professor by Dorothy Rabinowitz, pp. 62-66
    9. [+]
      Regional History by David Donald, p. 67 - 1 Review
      1. The South and the Nation by Pat Watters
    10. [+]
      Lore & Learning by Robert Ackerman, pp. 68-69 - 2 Reviews
      1. The British Folklorists by Richard M. Dorson
      2. Peasant Customs and Savage Myths by Richard M. Dorson
    11. [+]
      Psychoanalytics Radicals by Martin Peretz, pp. 70-72 - 1 Review
      1. The Freudian Left by Paul Robinson
    12. [+]
      Patterns of Discontent by James R. Adams, pp. 73-75 - 1 Review
      1. Why Men Rebel by Ted Robert Gurr
    13. [+]
      Bitter Comedy by Richard Schickel, pp. 76-82 - 1 Review
      1. Vital Parts by Thomas Berger
  8. [+]
    August 1970 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by George Dennison, John Holt, Ronald Walters, and Charles Weingartner, ..., pp. 4-20
    2. Like Fathers, Like Sons by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 21-22
    3. The Question of Repression by Walter Goodman, pp. 23-28
    4. Holy, Holy, Holy... by Dan Jacobson, pp. 29-34
    5. The Non-Generation Gap by S.M. Lipset and Earl Raab, pp. 35-39
    6. The Grand Illusion by Robert A. Nisbet, pp. 40-44
    7. Is History Dead? by Milton Himmelfarb, pp. 45-49
    8. The Working Theater by Jack Richardson, pp. 50-51
    9. "Matzpen" & Its Sponsors by Carl Gershman, pp. 52-53
    10. [+]
      An American Dream by Stephen Donadio, pp. 54-59 - 1 Review
      1. Zelda: A Biography by Nancy Milford
    11. Deja Vu by Nathan Glazer, pp. 60-63
    12. [+]
      Judaism & Modernism by Irving Greenberg, pp. 64-66 - 1 Review
      1. Birth Control in Jewish Law by David M. Feldman
    13. [+]
      Disillusioned Wisdom by Anthony Hartley, pp. 67-68 - 1 Review
      1. Notebooks of a Dilettante by Leopold Tyrmand
    14. [+]
      Highbrowland by Midge Decter, pp. 69-74 - 1 Review
      1. Nothing But a Fine Tooth Comb by David T. Bazelon
  9. [+]
    September 1970 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. Letters by Joyce Carol Oates, Richard E. Rubenstein, and Don Peretz, ..., pp. 4-22
    2. Revolutionary Suicide by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 23-24
    3. [+]
      M*A*S*H-22 by William S. Pechter, pp. 25-34 - 3 Reviews
      1. Catch-22 (1970 Film) by Mike Nichols
      2. M*A*S*H (1970 Film) by Robert Altman
      3. Getting Straight (1970 Film) by Richard Rush
    4. A Perspective on the Panthers by Tom Milstein, pp. 35-44
    5. What is Society? by Lionel Abel, pp. 45-56
    6. The Future of Social Democracy by John Mander, pp. 57-68
    7. The Traveler and His Telling by E.M. Broner, pp. 69-74
    8. In Search of Cecil Roth by Chaim Raphael, pp. 75-80
    9. The Activist Cleric by Dorothy Rabinowitz, pp. 81-84
    10. [+]
      Decline and Fall by Marcus Cunliffe, pp. 85-87 - 1 Review
      1. The End of the American Era by Andrew Hacker
    11. [+]
      The Besht by Arthur A. Cohen, pp. 88-89 - 1 Review
      1. In Praise of the Baal Shem Tov by Dan Ben-Amos and Jerome R. Mintz
    12. [+]
      Inside City Hall by Jerome Zukosky, pp. 90-92 - 1 Review
      1. Lindsay's Promise: The Dream that Failed by Woody Klein
    13. [+]
      The Moviegoer by Joseph Epstein, pp. 93-94 - 1 Review
      1. Going Steady by Pauline Kael
    14. [+]
      Paying for the Good Life by Lawrence Malkin, pp. 95-100 - 2 Reviews
      1. Technology and Growth: The Price We Pay by E.J. Mishan
      2. Twenty-One Popular Economic Fallacies by E.J. Mishan
  10. [+]
    October 1970 Issue = 12 Articles
    1. Letters by Noam Chomsky, Arie Bober, Murray Kempton, and Eric Bentley, ..., pp. 5-29
    2. Laws, Kings, and Cures by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 30-32
    3. The Liberated Woman by Midge Decter, pp. 33-44
    4. Cairo Journal by Joan Colebrook, pp. 45-56
    5. Who Needs the Liberals? by Penn Kemble, pp. 57-64
    6. Catharsis, Linguistics & All That by John Thompson, pp. 65-73
    7. On Being Deradicalized by Nathan Glazer, pp. 74-80
    8. Eliot, Lawrence & the Jews by Robert Alter, pp. 81-86
    9. [+]
      Southern Paternalism by Allen Weinstein, pp. 87-88 - 1 Review
      1. The World the Slaveholders Made by Eugene D. Genovese
    10. [+]
      The Fifth Candidate by Charles W. Brooks, pp. 89-93 - 1 Review
      1. Managing Mailer by Joe Flaherty
    11. [+]
      Weimar by Lewis D. Wurgaft, pp. 94-99 - 1 Review
      1. Germans and Jews by George L. Mosse
    12. [+]
      Kidstuff by Samuel McCracken, pp. 100-106 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Strawberry Statement by James S. Kunen
      2. Push Comes to Shove by Steven Kelman
  11. [+]
    November 1970 Issue = 12 Articles
    1. The Idea of Crisis by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 4-5
    2. Letters by John Simon, Julius Novick, Allen Weinstein, and Ernest van den Haag, ..., pp. 6-39
    3. Is the Urban Crisis Real? by Jerome Zukosky and Irving Kristol, pp. 40-48
    4. The Case of the "New York Review" by Dennis H. Wrong, pp. 49-63
    5. Jews in the Mind of France by Renee Winegarten, pp. 64-68
    6. Nixon, the Senate & the War by N. Gordon Levin, Jr., pp. 69-84
    7. In Hitler's Service by Lucy S. Dawidowicz, pp. 85-89
    8. [+]
      Movie Chronicle by William S. Pechter, pp. 90-92 - 4 Reviews
      1. Ned Kelly (1970 Film) by Tony Richardson
      2. Performance (1970 Film) by Nicolas Roeg and Donald Cammell
      3. The Kremlin Letter (1970 Film) by John Huston
      4. Myra Breckinridge (1970 Film) by Michael Sarne
    9. [+]
      Hemingway by Stephen Donadio, pp. 93-98 - 1 Review
      1. Islands in the Stream by Ernest Hemingway
    10. [+]
      The Prophet Confronted by Herbert N. Schneidau, pp. 99-102 - 1 Review
      1. The New Reformation by Paul Goodman
    11. [+]
      Jewish Theology by Michael A. Meyer, pp. 103-105 - 1 Review
      1. Arguments and Doctrines by Arthur A. Cohen
    12. [+]
      Ethnic Joke by Cynthia Ozick, pp. 106-116 - 1 Review
      1. Bech: A Book by John Updike
  12. [+]
    December 1970 Issue = 14 Articles
    1. The New Hypocrisies by Norman Podhoretz, pp. 5-7
    2. Letters by E.J. Mishan, Lawrence Malkin, Paul O'Dwyer, and Penn Kemble, ..., pp. 8-30
    3. The Deadly Innocences of American Jews by Earl Raab, pp. 31-39
    4. An Epistle to the Americans by Robert A. Nisbet, pp. 40-45
    5. Consciousness III by Roger Starr, pp. 46-54
    6. Lysergic Gotterdammerung by David L. Bromwich, pp. 55-59
    7. Babysitting by Johanna Kaplan, pp. 60-66
    8. Terrorism & Preventive Detention by Alan M. Dershowitz, pp. 67-78
    9. The Topless Tower of Babylon by Milton Himmelfarb, pp. 79-82
    10. Sex and Armaggedon by John P. Sisk, pp. 83-94
    11. [+]
      Objectivity by Stanley Rothman, pp. 95-97 - 1 Review
      1. The Coming Crisis of Western Sociology by Alvin W. Gouldner
    12. [+]
      Jewish Workingmen by Irving Howe, pp. 98-99 - 1 Review
      1. Class Struggle in the Pale by Ezra Mendelsohn
    13. [+]
      Speaking Out in Russia by Maurice Friedberg, pp. 100-104 - 1 Review
      1. In Quest of Justice by Abraham Brumberg
    14. [+]
      Our Time & the Left by Lionel Abel, pp. 105-114 - 1 Review
      1. Standing Fast by Harvey Swados
2. [+]
  Issues of 1971 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1972 = 12 Issues, 161 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1973 = 12 Issues, 171 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1974 = 12 Issues, 167 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1975 = 10 Issues, 132 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1976 = 11 Issues, 215 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1977 = 12 Issues, 167 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1978 = 11 Issues, 151 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1979 = 12 Issues, 161 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1980s = 10 Years, 114 Issues, 1,617 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1980 = 11 Issues, 191 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1981 = 10 Issues, 138 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1982 = 11 Issues, 143 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1983 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1984 = 12 Issues, 163 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1985 = 10 Issues, 156 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1986 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1987 = 12 Issues, 158 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1988 = 12 Issues, 200 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1989 = 12 Issues, 152 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1990s = 10 Years, 114 Issues, 1,663 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1990 = 12 Issues, 165 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1991 = 12 Issues, 150 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1992 = 12 Issues, 185 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1993 = 12 Issues, 151 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1994 = 12 Issues, 162 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1995 = 12 Issues, 225 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1996 = 10 Issues, 174 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1997 = 11 Issues, 158 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1998 = 10 Issues, 136 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1999 = 11 Issues, 157 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 2000s = 9 Years, 84 Issues, 1,205 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 2000 = 10 Issues, 150 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 2001 = 11 Issues, 147 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 2002 = 11 Issues, 148 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 2003 = 11 Issues, 159 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 2004 = 11 Issues, 142 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 2005 = 11 Issues, 186 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 2006 = 7 Issues, 98 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 2007 = 3 Issues, 54 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 2008 = 9 Issues, 121 Articles