RSS
Photo Credit: Flickr user Omar Bárcena CC BY-NC 2.0
I am ashamed to say that I have only recently signed up for the daily email from the high caliber British webzine Unherd although I see several of my colleagues have been discovering jewels there for some time.
On Saturday I was alerted to a true masterpiece The corruption of California – Bribery is the only way to get things done, by Matthew Crawford, March 4 2023. It begins:
I backed into a spot where I could watch both entrances of the Papa Johns Pizza parking lot, punctual for my rendezvous. To be safe, I had first taken a slow cruise through the lot, on the lookout for the telltale signs of an unmarked police car. I was here to meet someone I knew only as Smog Lady. Adam, the night manager at Autozone had given me her telephone number. Word on the street was that Smog Lady could get me a smog certificate, and thereby cut the Gordian knot of the California Department of Motor Vehicles bureaucracy.
One of the new things I noticed upon my return [to California] was small signs stuck to the side of a car, or printed on posterboard and erected on a street corner, advertising “DMV services”. After some intercourse with a few of these, always conducted in halting, heavily accented English, I came to understand that these entrepreneurs are “fixers”, a species that most Americans are unacquainted with. If you want to get something done in the developing world, you often need to engage the services of a fixer. This is someone who has connections in the bureaucracy, often by virtue of kinship.
Crawford employed “Smog Lady”
.. a toothless matron who spoke only Chinese beyond a few key words in English such as “odometer” and “VIN number”
who efficiently provided him with a CA smog certificate (without the mandatory vehicle inspection of course).
Crawford muses
California…has become more like the rest of the world, less like the erstwhile United States. The old European ways of procedure-following are anomalous, and perhaps…made sense only within a framework provided by something like Calvinism, Prussian organisation, ecclesiastical administration, or some similarly ascetic institutional morality that is “no respecter of persons”. By contrast, ties of kinship are easy to grasp, more robust, and make sense to more of the world’s peoples as the ground of cooperation…
Sensibly rejecting an explanatory structure from UC-Berkeley’s notably weak conceptualizer Professor Yuri Slezkine, Crawford says the need for “Smog Lady’s”
…services may be taken as an indication of the direction that state bureaucracy takes under conditions of multiculturalism (think Brazil), particularly in the absence of partisan political competition (think Soviet Union).
Pointing out tha
[w]ith the collapse of the Republican Party in California…there is little meaningful distinction to be made between the government and the Democratic Party.
…he argues that the California Department of Motor Vehicles has become a revenue generating fief for factions in the Democratic Party:
The citizenry isn’t feared…In 2018, there was a rash of news stories about five and six hour waits at the DMV…. Covid turned out to be a godsend for the DMV.
The DMV went to an appointment-only system.[California DMV is scaling back over coronavirus. Some employees say it’s not enough, by Leila Miller, Patrick McGreevy, L A Times, March 26, 2020]. Crawford describes the result:
Now there were no lines and, more important, no embarrassing news stories about queues. Problem solved.
To the party-state, citizens with their unending needs are a nuisance.
When Crawford finally got into the DMV to get a California license, he was interested to find out that the written and driving test requirements had been waived. He documents that this practice is rampant in California.
His anthropological analysis of the DMV is astute:
In dropping the pretence of its ostensible mission of public safety, the official DMV was perhaps just acknowledging the reality of the unofficial DMV, the one that is likely to be called “corrupt” by people clinging to First-World norms.
In other words, the DMV is splitting the yield from its exploitation of the public with external (but possibly affiliated) entities.
VDARE.com Editor Peter Brimelow’s 1997 Forbes article Privilege-Seeking? Peter Brimelow’s Interview With Gordon Tullock is a thorough exposition of this phenomenon, technically known to economists as rent seeking.
The beneficiaries are not drawn from the Historic American Nation:
Having now spent some time in DMV offices in the new California, my impression is that the shop floor operates along the lines of ethnic fiefdoms that overlap somewhat, and work fairly smoothly together when necessary. The Hispanic customers speak their own language with a Hispanic teller, the warm tones and easy gestures of which seem very unlike the bureaucratic mode of address that institutional English is adapted to. There are other languages spoken as well…
The occasional appearance of an unaffiliated Anglo-American such as myself is accommodated easily enough, and in such cases tellers are able to code-switch into officialese. But one does wonder if one is being offered quite the same menu of services…
Extensive documentation of cases of direct bribery is supplied.
Crawford concludes with mock cheerfulness:
You, tender reader, might be scandalised by the ways of California’s DMV, but such a response is a hangover from another era…These new populations have found ways to get things done. Bribery is more efficient (and far less crazy-making) than clinging to First-World expectations in a world that has changed. For my part, I am sincerely grateful for the services of Smog Lady. Diversity is our strength.
In 1992 Peter Brimelow wrote in his epochal National Review (!!!) essay Time To Rethink Immigration of his boyhood encounter with American Air Force families fighting the Cold War in 1950s England:
I remember one young wife showing us the first color slides we had ever seen, of Southern California, and explaining that they hoped to move to this breathtaking paradise when they got out of the service.
They will be old now, if they are still alive. I don’t know what they or their children think of the unprecedented experiment being performed, apparently by accident and certainly with no apprehension of the possible consequences, upon the nation they so bravely represented.
I do know, however, that they ought to be asked.
Not only were they not asked, but the feckless California Republican Party has systematically refused to defend them as I discussed in T o California GOP Leadership (Again): LOSE WHITE VOTE, LOSE STATE!!!
California is still about 70% white—a matter of some 28 million people, although that counts white Hispanics. (The actual electorate—American citizens who can vote—of course, is significantly more white, and non-Hispanic). Non-Hispanic whites make up 60% of registered voters in California. Why this population bloc is effectively unrepresented while with similar demographics the GOP controls Texas needs a lot of explaining.
My own view is that the answer is corruption—the iniquitous influence of billionaire donors who for one reason or another (none good) want to prevent the California GOP evolving into the Generic American Party
For quite a while Conservativism Inc used to shill for support by writing detailed discussions about the decline of California, while incredibly not mentioning the impact of immigration. I discussed this in Who killed California? The Neocons.
One of the essays I discussed there even managed to ignore the fate of 1994’s Proposition 187 which would have illegals access to public benefits and schools. This was passed with 59% support in 1994 but murdered by Federal Judge Mariana Pfaelzer with the connivance of the state’s political elite.
So far this has been the pivotal moment for the immigration issue in California. Prominent in marshalling stupid GOP leaders to oppose 187 was Irving Kristol’s son, Bill.
I concluded
Historical causation is intricate. Of course, having a Democratic party owned by certain ethnic minorities deeply saturated in socialist prejudices was going to be a problem. It has been in many US states. But faced with the lethal threat of inundation by economically low quality Hispanics, Californians reacted wisely. They were robbed of the fruits of that wisdom by Neoconservatives, who proceeded to block reconsideration at the State or Federal level for almost a generation.
In Who killed California? The Neocons (3)…and America too? I illustrated how intense this repression was by considering the pitiful groveling that former Reagan speechwriter Peter Robinson felt obliged to do to smuggle in a (absolutely correct) criticism of a particular egregious ignoring of immigration’s role in California’s plight by the horrible Jennifer Rubin.
Matters in California are grim but not in fact desperate. As noted above, the demographics of the state are not actually so different from Texas. Properly marshalling the white vote would give the Democrats a lot of trouble. At the National level, a State of Jefferson would offset the Senate problem. Furthermore a large proportion of the immigrants, illegal and legal, have manifestly very shallow roots in America. When retirement age arrives, many will follow the traditional immigrant path and go home.
But for anything good to happen, the power of the Big Donors over the GOP must be broken.
Email Patrick Cleburne.
English
Arabic
Chinese (Simplified)
Dutch
French
German
Hebrew
Hindi
Italian
Japanese
Korean
Persian
Polish
Portuguese
Russian
Spanish
Swedish
Turkish
Vietnamese
Back when California was more “white,” it was more “socialist.”
College, for instance, was free.
This article is typical modern conservative boilerplate. Some truth in the service of falsity.
This is what happens when jews open the borders of your country.
Riiight. Only the citizens can vote.
My wife and I know two Mexicans who were in California illegally for decades — they finally moved back to Mexico a couple of years ago.
They used to regularly receive ballots in the mail. Being honest people, they didn’t vote, but….
“This is what happens when jews open the borders of your country.”
Yes, and just look who they’re letting in – people who were born and raised in corruption. East Indians? Chinese? Little envelopes filled with cash.
If (((you))) want to get away with blatant monopolies, skimming, fleecing, money laundering, robbing and stealing, the last thing you want is to be surrounded by law-abiding citizens who object to this. Corruption wants to be surrounded by corruption.
They want these types of people in government because they are going to play ball, look the other way, take a bribe, and they won’t lose a moment of sleep over it.
Christians (white Europeans) were raised to be law-abiding, not to lie and cheat and take what’s not theirs, to follow rules. THIS – this right here – is what (((they))) don’t like about us.
They’re not afraid of Christians or white nationalism out of a fear of being strung up or something. No, they fear our way of being because it’s not conducive to corruption.
Blacks, browns and yellows know (((their))) rules and will play. Whites won’t. That is why they hate us. They are trying to drag whites into the Third World, but whites are resisting; they want their First World back.
What you are stating doesn’t hold any water. Great Britain, at the moment it embarked upon conquering the seas and starting off the industrial revolution, was the epitome of a low-trust, corruption-worshipping society. It was renowned throughout the world to be the society that played ball (they invented the rules of most ball games for that purpose), look the other way, take a small bribe, a never lose a moment of sleep about it. Adam Smith extolled that attitude in several sermons : honesty, the care of all beings at state level is not man’s duty but God’s alone, man’s duty, a much humbler one, is to care about what good he might do to his family, his club, his closed friends’ circle at the expense of the public, and God will reward the best players he cherishes.
A renowned author who bemoaned the loss of that corruption-worshipping mentality in favour of the “Prussian” socialist ideal of law-abiding citizen was Rydyar Kipling : most of his work is nostalgia for the times the Great Conquering England didn’t care for any rules but for victory only through the acceptance of the rules of nature’s game only, which consists in great part in seing no evil, speaking no evil, hearing no evil while evil happens all around you. That attitude was then renowned as the one and only one God would reward with riches. By that time, Latin America, mostly thanks to its heavy-duty Catholic culture, defined itself as all too rule-abiding and public-good-conscious. In France and Italy law abiding culture has always been regarded as the hallmark of inferior classes and conquered peoples : there are those who were created by God to write the laws and those who were created to obey them, as Nietzsche extolled what he loved about the greater Western civilization as jeopardized by humanistic liberalism. The industrial revolution itself was seen as an accepted form of evil committed against the former order of things. May I remind you that America was not conquered by law abiding people but by grifters and gangsters and that the richest states are those than remained close to that original gangster mentality.
The problem is that the former children of the pirates and conquering gangsters … fell prey to the socialist ideal while it took its political constitution way too seriously : originally the constitution was never meant to be applied for real but only to sell the product called America.
The US became a world class industrial power by stealing patents from Germany and Austria several times (and in many ways) and by giving little enveloppes full of cash to all sorts of people from central Europe, resulting in a brain drain (the intellectual class is the most corruptible one in every land and clime) that depleted of their riches most of the US’ former competitors. Ukraine is but one of those countries where money is still made that old fashioned way.
White California passed and implemented the Chinese Exclusion Acts. The White workers then may have had an appetite for some socialistic measure but they were clear headed about the cheap labor threat.
Political dynamics are quite different in an homogenous White community than they are in a muti-ethnic mess. Especially when the average IQ of some of the new groups is so low.
“But for any good to happen, the power of big donors over the GOP must be broken”. The day that happens it will no longer be the GOP as it has always been. It should be called the Golden Bull party.
“The US became a world class industrial power by stealing patents from Germany and Austria…”
Yes, and this still goes on today. Israel stealing, China stealing, U.S. stealing. Heck, often the intellectual property is just handed over to foreign countries, but always with strings attached. Might not be an envelope full of cash, but more like: “We won’t bomb the sh*t out of your country or kill you if you accept this gift (the intellectual property) and play ball with us. Think long and hard before you suffer from a necessary plane crash.” Part of doing business. Even the President of the United States (Biden) is taking cash bribes from China and Ukraine.
“Ukraine is but one of those countries where money is still made that old fashioned way.”
And this is what? Good? Something to emulate? Something to just shrug off?
The average American citizen had little to do with any of the corruption you’re talking about. They lived a decent, honest, hard-working life. They followed rules, sent their children to school, didn’t steal from their neighbors, didn’t have the need to lock their doors at night, and certainly were not involved (the majority of them, anyway) in any type of corruption.
What is happening now is a far cry from what these people experienced growing up. What they see now is a country full of dual-citizens whose sole purpose is to take what they can get, and a business class (thanks to the politicians they pay off) who welcomes them in.
The political class tries to shut down the objections of the white European stock by calling them “racists” (as if whites are any more racist than any other ethnic tribe!) when they know full well that what whites long for and what they want back is an honest and moral way of life. This is what made America great.
The establishment fear Christianity and white nationalism for what they represent: a turning away from the grift/hustling/corruption that so benefits them. This is what they fear.
‘A renowned author who bemoaned the loss of that corruption-worshipping mentality in favour of the “Prussian” socialist ideal of law-abiding citizen was Rydyar Kipling ‘
Rudyard Kipling.
I have heard that some Lat. American governments are releasing convicted murderers and mental patients and then busing them to our southern border to be released into the wild. I wonder if Jews have something to do with this conspiracy against the USA.
YES. California county governments emit massive blasts of mail-in ballots while deliberately putting in as little effort as possible to cull the voter rolls of people who have died, moved out of the county/state, or been convicted of a felony.
At each of our California addresses, we have received mail-in ballots addressed to a stranger at our address, before every election. We write “no such addressee — return to sender” and put them in the mailbox. Let’s just say we’re not real confident that the employees of the “Secretary of State” or county election office will endeavor to have that person removed from the voter rolls at that address….
Other mail-in ballots are seen strewn out in the open in our apartment building’s mail areas, not in a mailbox, available for anyone to take and use. Same experience in two previous buildings. Wonder why the postal “service” employees are doing that, routinely….
“Releasing … mental patients”: hey bigot, here in Los Angeles we call them neighbors. Now get the fuck out of here with your intolerance or we’ll destroy your career and life for your fucking intolerant opinions 😉
Because love trumps hate. And hate beats Trump. And hate has no home here. That’s why we hate fucking hateful people like you, and your family too.
Signed,
A Tolerant Progressive Angeleno
‘…“Releasing … mental patients”: hey bigot, here in Los Angeles we call them neighbors…’
Yeah; but that’s been true for a long time. I can remember the neighbors I had in Echo Park back in the Eighties.
People get paid to collect those discarded mail-in ballots strewn around the mailboxes of apartment buildings.
They are aggregated and put on standby if needed around midnight on election day.