, by Lionel Trilling, THE PARTISAN REVIEW

The Partisan Review • 65 Years, 285 Issues, 6,038 Articles, 41,112pp

← Previous ArticleEntire IssueNext Article →

On the "Brooks-Macleish Thesis"

by Lionel Trilling

The Partisan Review, January 1942, p. 46

Show MoreShow AllFinding...Find More

[+]
Issues of the 1930s = 6 Years, 29 Issues, 494 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1934 = 5 Issues, 86 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1935 = 4 Issues, 74 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1936 = 6 Issues, 104 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1937 = 1 Issue, 18 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1938 = 9 Issues, 114 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1939 = 4 Issues, 98 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1940s = 10 Years, 65 Issues, 1,109 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1940 = 6 Issues, 90 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1941 = 6 Issues, 92 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1942 = 6 Issues, 127 Articles
  1. [+]
    January 1942 Issue = 33 Articles
    1. A Statement, p. 2
    2. Stendhal by William Troy, pp. 3-21
    3. Separation by D.S. Savage, p. 22
    4. On the Eve by Victor Serge, pp. 23-33
    5. Montrachet-le-Jardin by Wallace Stevens, pp. 34-37
    6. On the "Brooks-Macleish Thesis" by Allen Tate, p. 38
    7. --- by William Carlos Williams, p. 39
    8. --- by John Crowe Ransom, p. 40
    9. --- by Henry Miller, p. 41
    10. --- by Louise Bogan, p. 42
    11. --- by James T. Farrell, pp. 43-45
    12. --- by Lionel Trilling, p. 46
    13. Contributors, p. 47
    14. Mighty Good to Me by Lewis Fisher, pp. 48-51
    15. The Dial by Marianne Moore, pp. 52-57
    16. The Country Was by Randall Jarrell, pp. 58-59
    17. The Immigrants by Lionel Abel, p. 60
    18. What of the Chain Remains by Lionel Abel, p. 60
    19. Etching by J. Patrick Byrne, p. 61
    20. Winter 1939 by Paul Goodman, p. 62
    21. War and the Writer by Stephen Spender, pp. 63-66
    22. B.T.N.I. by Rayner Heppenstall, pp. 67-69
    23. Letter from the Country by D.S. Savage, pp. 70-72
    24. Controversy by Nicholas Moore and George Orwell, pp. 73-75
    25. [+]
      The Burnhamian Revolution by Dwight Macdonald, pp. 76-84 - 1 Review
      1. The Managerial Revolution by James Burnham
    26. [+]
      Review The Colossus of Maroussi, by Henry Miller by H.J. Kaplan, p. 85 - 1 Review
      1. The Colossus of Maroussi by Henry Miller
    27. [+]
      Review Let Us Now Praise Famous Men, by James Agee an... by Paul Goodman, p. 86 - 1 Review
      1. Let Us Now Praise Famous Men by James Agee and Walker Evans
    28. [+]
      Review Between the Acts, by Virginia Woolf by Harold Rosenberg, p. 87 - 1 Review
      1. Between the Acts by Virginia Woolf
    29. [+]
      Review Awake! and Other Wartime Poems, by W.R. Rodgers by F.W. Dupee, p. 88 - 1 Review
      1. Awake! and Other Wartime Poems by W.R. Rodgers
    30. [+]
      Review Great Soldiers of the Two World Wars, by H.A. ... by Karl Korsch, p. 89 - 1 Review
      1. Great Soldiers of the Two World Wars by H.A. de Weerd
    31. [+]
      Review So It Doesn't Whistle, by Robert Paul Smith by Weldon Kees, p. 89 - 1 Review
      1. So It Doesn't Whistle by Robert Paul Smith
    32. A Communication by Louis Clair, pp. 90-92
    33. Letters, pp. 93-98
  2. [+]
    March 1942 Issue = 23 Articles
    1. Marianka by Jean Malaquais, pp. 98-114
    2. A Letter to the Editors by T.S. Eliot, pp. 115-116
    3. Writers and Defeat by Frank Jones, pp. 117-124
    4. Sweeney Soby and Surrealism by George L.K. Morris, pp. 125-126
    5. [+]
      Three Current Art Books by Clement Greenberg, pp. 127-129 - 3 Reviews
      1. Vlaminck by Klaus G. Perls
      2. Paul Klee: Paintings, Watercolors, 1913 to 1939 by Karl Nierendorf and Paul Klee
      3. They Taught Themselves by Sidney Janis
    6. Note by the Editor, p. 130
    7. Palingenesis by Isabella Fey, pp. 131-132
    8. To Whitman by Jackson Mathews, p. 133
    9. The Answer Usually Comes in Words by Oscar Williams, p. 134
    10. The Mirage by Oscar Williams, p. 135
    11. In the Tunnel by E.L. Mayo, p. 136
    12. Ballad of the Long-Legged Bait by Dylan Thomas, pp. 137-140
    13. The Shape of the Screen and the Darkness of the Theater by Paul Goodman, pp. 141-152
    14. London Letter by George Orwell, pp. 153-159
    15. [+]
      The Moscow Trials, 1942 Version by Leon Colbert, pp. 160-163 - 1 Review
      1. Mission to Moscow by Joseph Edward Davies
    16. [+]
      One Out of Five by Oscar Williams, pp. 164-165 - 1 Review
      1. Five Young American Poets: Second Series, 1941
    17. [+]
      The British Genius by Dwight Macdonald, pp. 166-168 - 1 Review
      1. The Lion and the Unicorn by George Orwell
    18. [+]
      Review Design for Power, by Frederick L. Schuman and ... by Sidney Hook, p. 169 - 1 Review
      1. Design for Power by Frederick L. Schuman and George D. Brodsky
    19. [+]
      Review The Language of Poetry, by Allen Tate by William Troy, p. 169 - 1 Review
      1. The Language of Poetry by Allen Tate
    20. [+]
      3 Reviews Canibales Politicos, by Julian Gorkin by Etiemble, pp. 170-171 - 3 Reviews
      1. Canibales Politicos by Julian Gorkin
      2. A Donde va Francia? by Marceau Pivert
      3. Hitler Contra Stalin by Victor Serge
    21. "Dangerous Thoughts", pp. 172-173
    22. Letter to the President of Mexico, pp. 174-175
    23. Letters, pp. 176-178
  3. [+]
    May 1942 Issue = 19 Articles
    1. The Mexican General by Saul Bellow, pp. 178-194
    2. Swann and Hamlet by Wallace Fowlie, pp. 195-202
    3. As to Values and Facts by Max Eastman and James T. Farrell, pp. 203-212
    4. Josephine, The Songstress by Franz Kafka, pp. 213-228
    5. The Sense of the Past by Lionel Trilling, pp. 229-241
    6. Transfigured Night!---Schoenberg by Byron Vazakas, p. 242
    7. Waiting at the December Bridge by Byron Vazakas, p. 243
    8. The Countries of Woman by Winthrop Palmer, pp. 244-245
    9. The Drunken Boy by Alfred Hayes, pp. 246-247
    10. Savannah Georgia by Eve Merriam, p. 248
    11. On Being Ill by Eve Merriam, p. 249
    12. Cagliostro and the Charlatan State by Egidio Mattina, pp. 250-254
    13. Contributors, p. 255
    14. [+]
      The Historian as Moralist by Ernest Nagel, pp. 256-258 - 1 Review
      1. A Generation of Materialism, 1871-1900 by Carlton J.H. Hayes
    15. [+]
      Loose Talk about Joyce by Lionel Abel, p. 259 - 1 Review
      1. James Joyce: A Critical Introduction by Harry Levin
    16. [+]
      Poems in Exile by Christopher Isherwood, pp. 260-261 - 1 Review
      1. Fuerchte Dict Nicht! by Berthold Viertel
    17. [+]
      Yogi-Bogey by Richard V. Chase, pp. 262-263 - 1 Review
      1. Grey Eminence by Aldous Huxley
    18. [+]
      The Ego at Large by H.P. Lazarus, pp. 264-266 - 3 Reviews
      1. The Real Life of Sebastian Knight by Vladimir Nabokov
      2. The Wisdom of the Heart by Henry Miller
      3. The Wife of Martin Guerre by Janet Lewis
    19. Letters, pp. 267-274
  4. [+]
    July 1942 Issue = 19 Articles
    1. The British Crisis by George Orwell, pp. 274-280
    2. At the Foot of the Page by Lionel Abel, pp. 281-288
    3. Carmen XI by Robert Fitzgerald, p. 289
    4. Poem by Ronald Hambleton, p. 289
    5. Sockeye Salmon by Ronald Hambleton, p. 290
    6. As Though from Love by Lenore G. Marshall, pp. 291-292
    7. Haircut by Karl J. Shapiro, p. 293
    8. The (American) People's Century by Dwight Macdonald, pp. 294-309
    9. Contributors, p. 310
    10. A Magazine and Some People in Paris by Allanah Harper, pp. 311-320
    11. The Story of Stefan George by Eric Russell Bentley, pp. 321-330
    12. The Irish Setter by Karl Warndorf, pp. 331-335
    13. [+]
      The Rewards of Patience by W.H. Auden, pp. 336-339 - 1 Review
      1. Poems and New Poems by Louise Bogan
    14. [+]
      All Fingers and No Hands by Frank Jones, p. 340 - 1 Review
      1. The Grand Piano by Paul Goodman
    15. [+]
      An American Life by Christopher Isherwood, pp. 341-342 - 1 Review
      1. Memoirs by Sherwood Anderson
    16. [+]
      From Under the Lid by Werner Bloch, pp. 343-344 - 1 Review
      1. On the Marble Cliffs by Ernst Junger
    17. [+]
      In All Directions by Randall Jarrell, pp. 345-347 - 1 Review
      1. New Directions 1941 by James Laughlin
    18. Better Judgment and "Public Conscience" by Paul Goodman, pp. 348-350
    19. Letters, pp. 351-354
  5. [+]
    September 1942 Issue = 20 Articles
    1. The World Historians by Karl Korsch, pp. 354-371
    2. The Tendency of History by Henry Adams, pp. 372-378
    3. Ferrero and the Decline of Civilizations by Ignazio Silone, pp. 379-383
    4. The Son of God by Harvey Breit, pp. 384-385
    5. The Statues in Parliament Square by Julian Symons, p. 386
    6. Reflections in Bed by Julian Symons, p. 387
    7. In Memory by Victor Serge, pp. 388-391
    8. The Profession of Poetry by Harold Rosenberg, pp. 392-412
    9. Contributors, p. 413
    10. Pacifism and the War by D.S. Savage, pp. 414-415
    11. --- by George Woodcock, p. 416
    12. --- by Alex Comfort, pp. 417-418
    13. --- by George Orwell, pp. 419-421
    14. [+]
      Old Methods, New Horizons by F.O. Matthiessen, pp. 422-425 - 2 Reviews
      1. The Wind Blew from the East by Ferner Nuhn
      2. Writers in Crisis by Maxwell D. Geismar
    15. [+]
      A Slum on the Way to the End of the Night by Gertrude Buckman, pp. 426-427 - 1 Review
      1. Never Come Morning by Nelson Algren
    16. [+]
      Confound the Wiseguy by H.J. Kaplan, pp. 428-431 - 1 Review
      1. Confound the Wise by Nicolas Calas
    17. [+]
      Locating the Enemy by C. Wright Mills, pp. 432-436 - 1 Review
      1. Behemoth by Franz L. Neumann
    18. [+]
      2. Something New on the New Order The Structure of the Nazi Economy, by Maxine Y... by J.R. Stanwell, pp. 437-439 - 1 Review
      1. The Structure of the Nazi Economy by Maxine Y. Sweezy
    19. With the Little Mags by Harvey Breit, pp. 440-444
    20. Letters, pp. 445-450
  6. [+]
    November 1942 Issue = 13 Articles
    1. The Music of Poetry by T.S. Eliot, pp. 450-465
    2. Ellen Terhune by Edmund Wilson, pp. 466-475
    3. Political Notes by Dwight Macdonald, pp. 476-482
    4. On the Decline of Naturalism by Philip Rahv, pp. 483-493
    5. London Letter by George Orwell, pp. 494-498
    6. Police Sergeant Malone and the Six Dead Drinkers by Horace Gregory, pp. 499-501
    7. [+]
      Film Chronicle by Dwight Macdonald, pp. 502-528 - 1 Review
      1. The Film Sense by Sergei Eisenstein
    8. [+]
      The Spirtual Underground by William Phillips, pp. 529-531 - 1 Review
      1. The Seed Beneath the Snow by Ignazio Silone
    9. [+]
      Poets, English and American by Clement Greenberg, pp. 532-536 - 5 Reviews
      1. Blood for a Stranger by Randall Jarrell
      2. The Second World by R.P. Blackmur
      3. Lyra: an Anthology of New Lyric by Alex Comfort and Robert Greacen
      4. Three New Poets by Roy McFadden
      5. Ruins and Visions by Stephen Spender
    10. [+]
      Button, Button by Robert Penn Warren, pp. 537-539 - 1 Review
      1. The Company She Keeps by Mary McCarthy
    11. [+]
      Miss Rukeyser's Marine Poem by Weldon Kees, p. 540 - 1 Review
      1. Wake Island by Muriel Rukeyser
    12. [+]
      Portrait of a Historian by Melvin J. Lasky, pp. 540-542 - 1 Review
      1. As Lord Acton Says by F.E. Lally
    13. Letters, pp. 543-546
4. [+]
  Issues of 1943 = 5 Issues, 75 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1944 = 4 Issues, 93 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1945 = 4 Issues, 85 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1946 = 5 Issues, 101 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1947 = 5 Issues, 84 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1948 = 12 Issues, 190 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1949 = 12 Issues, 172 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1950s = 7 Years, 29 Issues, 494 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1951 = 6 Issues, 86 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1954 = 4 Issues, 58 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1955 = 3 Issues, 48 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1956 = 4 Issues, 67 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1957 = 4 Issues, 77 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1958 = 4 Issues, 71 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1959 = 4 Issues, 87 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1960s = 10 Years, 36 Issues, 688 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1960 = 4 Issues, 77 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1961 = 4 Issues, 62 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1962 = 4 Issues, 82 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1963 = 3 Issues, 54 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1964 = 4 Issues, 84 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1965 = 3 Issues, 66 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1966 = 3 Issues, 49 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1967 = 4 Issues, 87 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1968 = 4 Issues, 74 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1969 = 3 Issues, 53 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1970s = 10 Years, 39 Issues, 847 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1970 = 4 Issues, 59 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1971 = 4 Issues, 53 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1972 = 4 Issues, 82 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1973 = 3 Issues, 64 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1974 = 4 Issues, 87 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1975 = 4 Issues, 99 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1976 = 4 Issues, 100 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1977 = 4 Issues, 113 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1978 = 4 Issues, 92 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1979 = 4 Issues, 98 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1980s = 10 Years, 39 Issues, 1,003 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1980 = 4 Issues, 115 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1981 = 4 Issues, 95 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1982 = 4 Issues, 95 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1983 = 4 Issues, 93 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1984 = 4 Issues, 116 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1985 = 3 Issues, 78 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1986 = 4 Issues, 89 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1987 = 4 Issues, 107 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1988 = 4 Issues, 109 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1989 = 4 Issues, 106 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 1990s = 10 Years, 40 Issues, 1,206 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 1990 = 4 Issues, 139 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 1991 = 4 Issues, 113 Articles
3. [+]
  Issues of 1992 = 4 Issues, 114 Articles
4. [+]
  Issues of 1993 = 4 Issues, 111 Articles
5. [+]
  Issues of 1994 = 4 Issues, 118 Articles
6. [+]
  Issues of 1995 = 4 Issues, 128 Articles
7. [+]
  Issues of 1996 = 4 Issues, 126 Articles
8. [+]
  Issues of 1997 = 4 Issues, 103 Articles
9. [+]
  Issues of 1998 = 4 Issues, 125 Articles
10. [+]
  Issues of 1999 = 4 Issues, 129 Articles
[+]
Issues of the 2000s = 2 Years, 8 Issues, 197 Articles
1. [+]
  Issues of 2000 = 4 Issues, 98 Articles
2. [+]
  Issues of 2001 = 4 Issues, 99 Articles