The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersiSteve Blog
Nah, I Guess I Didn't Need to Learn to Spell Pirghoznik's Name After All

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

From the New York Times news section:

Yevgeny V. Prigozhin, the founder of the Wagner mercenary group who staged a brief mutiny against Russia’s military leadership in June, was listed as a passenger on a plane that crashed Wednesday, killing all 10 people aboard, according to Russian aviation authorities. …

The plane left Moscow’s Sheremetyevo airport at about 6 p.m. local time, bound for St. Petersburg, and went down less than 100 miles to the northwest, near the city of Tver. In an article about the crash, the Russian state media agency, RIA Novosti, posted an unconfirmed video, widely shared on social media, that purports to show the plane tumbling from the sky, with smoke billowing.

The crash came hours after Russian authorities said that General Sergei Surovikin, a top officer who was seen as an ally of Mr. Prigozhin, had been relieved of his post. Mr. Surovikin and Mr. Prigozhin were seen as among the most ruthlessly effective Russian military leaders, both sidelined in power struggles with officials who had the ear of President Vladimir V. Putin.

 
Hide 384 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. When you strike at a king, you must kill him.

    • Agree: PaceLaw, PhysicistDave
    • Replies: @Adolf Smith
    @AnotherDad

    The irony: Progozhin was Putin's personal chef...😮

    , @Ebony Obelisk
    @AnotherDad

    NAFO fellas bonked him

    Glory to Ukraine.

    It’s over for Russia.

    Nikki Haley won the debate tonight

    Replies: @tyrone, @Mr. Anon, @rocko

    , @epebble
    @AnotherDad

    Or:


    “Never do an enemy a small injury.”

     

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

  2. Love the inside joke throwbacks!

  3. Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.

    • Agree: bomag, Haxo Angmark
    • LOL: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @tyrone
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle
     
    .....Careful ,a certain government entity is walking to and fro like a roaring lion seeking who it may devour.

    Replies: @Almost Missouri

    , @vinteuil
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.
     
    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I've ever come across here.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin, @Thomm, @AndrewR, @Intelligent Dasein

    , @Buzz Mohawk
    @AnotherDad

    Nah. Vlad's problem is that he didn't have enough children and establish a separate country for himself and his fellow oligarchs.

    , @Just Some JB
    @AnotherDad


    "If Putin had offered me ... a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste."
     
    Great comment. Curious though, how much "practice" do you figure you'd need? lol
    , @Colin Wright
    @AnotherDad


    '...If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.'
     
    Be fair. It's all relative.
    , @Colin Wright
    @AnotherDad


    'If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.'
     
    Putin may have wanted to make a point. 'If you try to do what dude did, I won't surreptitiously try to poison you or something. I'll just flat out kill you -- and I won't hide it. You can write pseudonymous posts on websites and live -- you can't do this.'

    ...Putin apparently felt it necessary to unequivocally assert who was boss man. As Porfirio Diaz once said: 'Senor, to rule Mexico a man must be more than honest.'
    , @Dennis Dale
    @AnotherDad

    Careful, Lee Harvey Oswald was recruited on social media.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

  4. Preegojin

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Santoculto

    Preegogone.

  5. Too soon to tell whodunit, IMHO.

    • Agree: Cagey Beast
    • Replies: @Jack D
    @I, Libertine

    Not really. Putin's silence is deafening. Putin won't even say Navalny's name. When Putin wants you gone it's as if you disappeared. Surovikin also fired at the same time and on the plane was not just Prigozhin but most of his most important deputies including Utkin, who was "Wagner" himself. There was a 2nd plane with more Wagner guys and reportedly they were arrested when they landed.

    This was the Night of the Long Knives.

    Latest thinking is that this was an FSB operation. Bomb on board. It will be interesting to see if Bellingcat can break this open the way they were able to trace Navalny's poisoning. FSB is usually sloppy and leaves fingerprints. But today's wartime Russia is a lot more locked down than it was when Navalny was poisoned.

  6. True story.

    A few decades ago some old guys from Jersey robbed a gambling club in Manhattan where some made men often played, and were caught by the cops. A friend of mine lost thousands. Somehow the money the cops reported recovered was quite a few thousand less than what was stolen.

    I made an over/under bet with a friend as to how soon the first confirmed hit would be. I took under. I won the bet. One of the idiots decided to leave Jersey while out on bail and go back to Manhattan. A few weeks later they found his decomposing body in the trunk of a car in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn. As New Yorkers know, Sheepshead Bay is an area with a lot of “family” enterprises.

    The moral — sometimes it’s a matter of when, not if

    • Replies: @Adolf Smith
    @Paleo Liberal

    Cue "Layla."😥

    , @Sick n' Tired
    @Paleo Liberal

    If that was in the early 80s, my father used to walk our dogs in Sheepshead Bay, since we lived across from the fishing boats. He has a story about walking past a car for a few days and the smell getting noticeably worse, and when the cops finally popped the trunk, it was a dead mob guy with all his cash & jewelry still on him. This was around 1983-84'

    Replies: @Paleo Liberal

  7. Prigozhin wasn’t really a military leader. More of a manager, figurehead for Wagner.

    • Agree: Michael Droy, HammerJack
    • Replies: @Wokechoke
    @Lurker

    More a compromised CIA asset/or Mossad mole.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    , @Jack Armstrong
    @Lurker

    I’m still shorting Wagner Group.

    Replies: @tyrone

    , @Pop Warner
    @Lurker

    Utkin was the actual military leader, and he was on the plane with Prigozhin. In hindsight, it would have been better to keep them separated because they should have known they would be targeted.

    Oh well. Putin seems hellbent on removing any competent commanders in favor of prolonging the war and getting more Russians killed. At this point, I would question whose side he's even on, because he seems to be handing victories to the West now.

    Replies: @Jack D, @Bill Jones

  8. I was trying to figure out why Steve seemed giddy and I figured it out. Mask mandates are returning to businesses and colleges. Lots of rumors about the return of Lockdowns. Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All.

    • Agree: Kratoklastes
    • Replies: @For what it's worth
    @Mike Tre

    "Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All."

    Elections . . . next year. Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns? Last year, they got rid of them in order to control losses in an election.

    There's always an election coming sometime, so you can always say, "Just in time for XYZ."

    Replies: @JR Ewing, @Brutusale

  9. Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine for many years. Prigogine was not just a scientist, but a deep thinking natural philosopher.

    Unlike most Nobelists in the past 50 or so years.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Bardon Kaldian


    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine
     
    There are enough transliterations into English to keep track of. You expect us to recognize those into Walloon?


    https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/web1_coup-niger-1280x720.jpg


    https://www.sidechef.com/recipe/c30095ea-c83d-4c29-9757-6819664c3f64.png?d=1408x1120

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Cagey Beast

    , @Esso
    @Bardon Kaldian

    I have not read Prigogine first hand, but I understand his later alternative work in statistical physics was about irreversibility and "self-organisation". And he tried to find some kind of general law governing them, something to do with nonlinear mathematics and chaos.

    I can sympathize with making connections between dissipation and work and computation and everything (organization, self- or not). It seems kind of obvious there is dissipation in everything. But why try to recover dissipation, which is associated with computation and measurement, which is to say particular and freely varying things, from a general law, why not just let it be? Natural laws are reversible (they act on everything the same and make no distinctions) so far as we know them. Chaos in mathematical physics (chaos in nature is another thing) is an artifact of classical theories.

    Prigožin, may he retire in peace. He was one of the loudest and most visible characters in our time. A very big shot in the ball mill that is Russia. He at the very least had an appearance of being a zealous patriot and looking after the wellbeing of his men. He did not discriminate (well maybe against gays and trannies) and gave opportunities to men from all walks of life. Eloquence was not his strong suit but I'm sure he made up for that by being more truthful than the national average. It was a glorious way to go, still I think he deserved better. We never thought he was going to die of old age.

    , @Esso
    @Bardon Kaldian

    My last reply was hopeless word salad. I mean: Computers are an example of a "dissipative self-organizing system" if any. Trying to model the behavior computers or computer programs with classical dynamical systems or chaos is obviously needless and unmotivated. With biological systems one could do some plausible handwaving in Prigogine's day but it's just as pointless IMO.

    I think the interesting thing here is the relation between the meaning of computations (in the sense if two computations are the same in some sense) and dissipation, and the conservation of some of that meaning by reversible laws.

  10. I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn’t hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.

    He invited the country’s top cameramen to video his purge of tens of people IN THE ROOM while he enjoyed a cigar.

    At one point he even left the dais and microphone entirely to the man he was then forcing into publicly sentencing his own, present, colleagues to death.

    Love him or Like him, Saddam was no coward.

    No Obama drones, Clinton-Trump suicides or Putin polonium for that cat.

    https://youtube.com/shorts/AVXHVTbc3jE?feature=shared

    • Thanks: PaceLaw
    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @ydydy

    Saddam even asked "Is this the bravery of Arabs?" while his future executors were verbally taunting him in preparation for his execution.

    Replies: @ydydy

    , @zoos
    @ydydy


    I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn’t hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.
     
    Now, now! Putin is just wittier about it. I recall when one of his extremely vocal critics–he went after Putin personally–was poisoned with radiation, if memory serves, Putin said, and I’m paraphrasing,"well, if you defect and decide to be a spy against your own country, and talk a lot of shit, sometimes bad things happen. It’s part of that job, isn’t it?"

    I couldn’t really disagree with him.

    Putin reminds me a bit of trump, in that he doesn’t tend to go after people unless they screw with him first. Not saying putin’s a good guy. Just a predictable one. At least you know what you have to do for your plane to crash, so you can plan your day around it.

    Replies: @Anonymous

  11. The Americans, Ukrainians or another Russian rival could have done it but there’s also this:

  12. There seems to be a lot of interpretation in the Russian domestic report about Surovikin (and probably quite a bit in the translation into English). And a hell of a lot more in the western media’s contribution to the report (ie we know he backed Przygozhin so that makes him the first to be sacked – but they don’t know a thing).

    Once again by the way – all the inside gossip about Russia is being leaked by and printed in the mainstream Russian media.
    Do not expect a letter from 50 current and former KGB experts assuring the Russian media that this has “all the Hallmarks of US disinformation”. Russian media are free to write this stuff.

    • Replies: @Almost Missouri
    @Michael Droy


    Do not expect a letter from 50 current and former KGB experts assuring the Russian media that this has “all the Hallmarks of US disinformation”. Russian media are free to write this stuff.
     
    • Juxtapose
  13. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle

    …..Careful ,a certain government entity is walking to and fro like a roaring lion seeking who it may devour.

    • Replies: @Almost Missouri
    @tyrone

    https://dailystormer.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/2722r3df2rrr3MEM210823.jpg.jpg


  14. https://twitter.com/SanderRegter/status/1694433358778900593
    https://twitter.com/bigSAC10/status/1694399416315347352

  15. Live by the sword, die by the sword.

    Feeling listless? Trouble getting up or getting it up? Ask your doctor about Prigozhin™.

    Prigozhin may cause flatulence, blindness, or an inability to fly. Seek medical attention if your erection lasts more than eight hours.

    Ask About Prigozhin.

    BTW, this episode may not necessarily fall into the hands of those here who celebrate it as further confirmation of something not at all debatable: That is, yes, Putin has a habit of assassinating his enemies. So far, he has continued this practice — and this time he used it against “our” ally who ostensibly tried a funny revolt at “our” behest.

    So, what does this mean, really? All we can say for sure is that nothing has changed in Russia, despite “our” attempts.

    We can laugh about it at length here from a distance. Remember: The reason we can is because our ancestors gave us — their Posterity! — a free land on a continent protected by two oceans from the old world’s insanity.

    “We” do not belong in Ukraine, and “we” have no business in that part of the world.

    Go ahread and laugh, while your dollar loses value and your homeland gets invaded according to the will of the very same rulers who took “your” country to fight a war against Russia, half a world away.

    Stupid is as stupid does.

    • Agree: Female in FL
    • Replies: @Captain Tripps
    @Buzz Mohawk

    Agree. (Not commenting enough lately, so button unavailable).

  16. This is most unusual. Putin’s enemies tend to fall out of buildings.

    • Replies: @Haxo Angmark
    @p38ace

    ...or walk into a poisoned umbrella.

  17. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.

    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I’ve ever come across here.

    • Replies: @Joe Stalin
    @vinteuil

    Well, we can all be Walter Mitty on the Internet!

    , @Thomm
    @vinteuil


    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I’ve ever come across here.
     
    AnotherDad has been losing it for some time.

    Isn't Russia a white, Christian country with traditional gender roles? The type he laments about in every other comment of his? And yet, he hates the one man who is arguably trying to preserve such a society : Vladimir Putin.

    For some numbers, AnotherDud comments here about 12-20 times as much as I do :

    From the commenter histories :

    AnotherDad :
    Year 2023 : 1579 comments to date
    Year 2022 : 2643 comments to date
    Year 2021 : 2261 comments
    Year 2020 : 2395 comments

    Thomm :
    Year 2023 : 159 comments to date
    Year 2022 : 221 comments
    Year 2021 : 196 comments
    Year 2020 : 361 comments

    So he comments here 12-13 times more often than I do, depending how you measure it. It is even more if you account for many of my comments being repeat postings of poems and songs I have written. If we take just original comments, then from 1/1/2020-present, he commented here 20 times as much as I did.

    Given his advanced age, isn’t there something else he would rather spend his time on? Or is it true that after the kids leave home and the old folks are empty nesters, older men find a variety of ways to avoid interacting with their wives, up to and including posting the same comment online every day for years?
    , @AndrewR
    @vinteuil

    AnotherBoomer is certainly among the stranger commenters on here.

    It's far from clear that it was Putin who ordered this. Prigozhin had many enemies. But some people here can't stop with the Cold War, neocon Russophobia.

    , @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

  18. Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that’s all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    • Replies: @Wokechoke
    @Bardon Kaldian

    Paris is full of Africa now. Sorry to inform you.

    Replies: @Peter Akuleyev

    , @HA
    @Bardon Kaldian

    "How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common."

    I dunno, he seems to be fitting right in:

    https://twitter.com/DarthPutinKGB/status/1694383541549985973

    (Yes, I know it's been "airbrushed", but really, are the Russians in any position to complain about that?) And I suspect Indians would agree with you that Putin doesn't belong to be standing next to Modi at this point, given how their respective space programs have performed in the last few days, but none of the fanboys want to seem to talk about that. Are any of Putin's paid trolls on Unz-dot-com gonna give us a write up about that at some point?

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    , @Loyalty Over IQ Worship
    @Bardon Kaldian


    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)-
     
    Can you explain why the French are doing it, first? They aren't just hanging around them, they are importing them and the rest of the 3rd world at replacement levels.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Bardon Kaldian

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @Bardon Kaldian

    "How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common."

    It's Europe, wholly in thrall to the US, who've rejected Russia, not the other way round.

    "Needs must when the Devil drives"

    Sad! (especially for Germany, but for all of Europe)

    Still, Russians have been writing about the love/hate Europe relationship for more than a century:

    https://allpoetry.com/The-Scythians


    But if you spurn us, then we shall not mourn.
    We too can reckon perfidy no crime,
    And countless generations yet unborn
    Shall curse your memory till the end of time.

    We shall abandon Europe and her charm.
    We shall resort to Scythian craft and guile.
    Swift to the woods and forests we shall swarm,
    And then look back, and smile our slit-eyed smile.
     

    , @Anon 2
    @Bardon Kaldian

    A common mistake with respect to Russia is to think of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky,
    Rachmaninoff, and the like, as somehow representative of the Russian people.
    No, they’re simply 0.1 percenters that have virtually nothing to do with 99.9%
    of the Russians. Rod Dreher who converted to Eastern Orthodoxy often makes that
    mistake. 0.1 percenters in the Eurasian countries are typically so talented
    that they are bound to create important works of art, literature, and music wherever
    they live. We just don’t hear about them so much if they had the misfortune of being
    born in a small country. Poland, which technically didn’t exist in the 19th century,
    is a good example. Everyone has heard of Alexander Pushkin but few know
    of the great Polish bard Adam Mickiewicz (1798-1855). The Doll (1890) by the
    Polish writer Boleslaw Prus is as great a novel as Anna Karenina, but again very
    few know it even exists.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    , @SFG
    @Bardon Kaldian

    Geopolitics. Whether capitalist and communist or woke capitalist and Christian, the USA and Russia fight over territory like any other great powers.

    , @Ennui
    @Bardon Kaldian

    You forgot about Peter's Westernization push, cutting beards and forcing nobles to give up their caftans for the kind of sus clothes 18th-century Europeans liked. Personally, the caftans looked way more comfortable than the quasi-trans Western shoe buckles and knee breeches and wigs, but who can judge?

    It is odd that a pro-Ukrainian is recognizing that Russians aren't a savage Asiatic horde which is how they are usually described here, wanting to enslave the liberty-loving peoples of Eastern Europe. Shifting the goal posts for propaganda purposes, Bardon?

    At this point, China, India and Iran are looking very reasonable and not evil compared to the NY-London-DC-Tel Aviv-Brussels axis. A live and let live situation. They aren't perfect, but they aren't evil, unlike some power blocks one could name.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Anonymous

    , @BB753
    @Bardon Kaldian

    BRICS is like the G7, ( and a new monetary exchange system). Get over it! They're not gonna open their borders to China or Iran. Open borders is a US and EU thing.

    , @Frau Katze
    @Bardon Kaldian

    It’s worth noting that Stalin, one of the most brutal of the Russian/Soviet leaders, was an ethnic Georgian.

    Replies: @HA

    , @Anonymous
    @Bardon Kaldian

    I don't know why you talk so much about Russians. Croats are basically Catholic Turks and Gypsies who are best known for torturing and slaughtering elderly civilians:

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/croats-slaughter-elderly-by-the-dozen-1600351.html

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    , @vinteuil
    @Bardon Kaldian


    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common.
     
    BK, are you under the impression that Paris today is the Paris of Proust & Debussy?

    When was the last time anybody in Western Europe or the USA wrote a genuinely great ballet, novel or symphony?

    Well, OK, there's Stravinsky's Orfeo, there's Nabokov's Lolita, there's Shostakovich's 15th...

    Uh-oh...

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

  19. @vinteuil
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.
     
    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I've ever come across here.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin, @Thomm, @AndrewR, @Intelligent Dasein

    Well, we can all be Walter Mitty on the Internet!

  20. Did he fake his own death?**

    Putin revenge?
    CIA revenge?
    Ukranian revenge?
    Wagner underboss impatient to be #1 Boss?
    Drunken Russian airplane mechanic?
    Someone aboard had life insurance policy unawares?
    Someone at Wagner upset with Priggy?
    French pissed that Wagner is in Niger?

    **This really wouldn’t be all that hard to fake, take dead bodies from Ukraine, stuff em’ on a helicopter you have rigged not to make it.

    • Replies: @Sick n' Tired
    @Robertson

    They did the same in the beginning of the Dark Knight Rises, extracting an asset, transferring blood to a body double, and crashing a plane to kill everyone on board. Consider everything is a psyop until proven otherwise at this point.

    , @Twinkie
    @Robertson


    Did he fake his own death?**
     
    Note:

    was listed as a passenger
     
    All we know now is that he was on the passenger manifest. And everyone onboard died.

    Until you have the body/DNA, no confirmation.

    Replies: @Alrenous

  21. Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.

    • Replies: @Hypnotoad666
    @Buroaker


    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.
     
    I forgot all about that. They were fake indictments because they never intended to serve anyone in Russia. But then the Internet Research Agency voluntarily appeared and entered a not guilty plea. Since the Russia hoaxers had no actual evidence they had to dismiss the case.

    So if anyone ever says Russia interfered in the 2016 election, the official answer is that the DOJ lost the case and "the Russians" were exonerated. But this is one of those facts the Fake News is prohibited from reporting, so you will never, ever read about it anywhere.
    , @Coemgen
    @Buroaker


    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.
     
    The indictment is at this link: https://www.justice.gov/file/1035477/download
  22. There has been a great deal of drone activity in Muscovite airspace over the last two weeks. Civilian aircraft are especially vulnerable to drone interference or outright attacks. This looks like the Ukrainians trying to keep tensions high betwixt the Russian leadership. I don’t imagine Putin had anything to do with this. Ukraine’s CIA masters are pulling the strings here.

    • Replies: @Diversity Heretic
    @Jack Armstrong

    Agree. If Vladimir Putin had wanted Prigozhin dead he would have been dead long ago and Putin wouldn't kill nine other people and sacrifice a perfectly good business jet to do so. This affair has all the signs of a CIA/MI6/Ukrainian secret service assassination. Wagner has been a huge nuisance in Africa and Prigozhin's elimination may have more to do with that than with Ukraine.

    Replies: @MGB

  23. @vinteuil
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.
     
    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I've ever come across here.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin, @Thomm, @AndrewR, @Intelligent Dasein

    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I’ve ever come across here.

    AnotherDad has been losing it for some time.

    Isn’t Russia a white, Christian country with traditional gender roles? The type he laments about in every other comment of his? And yet, he hates the one man who is arguably trying to preserve such a society : Vladimir Putin.

    For some numbers, AnotherDud comments here about 12-20 times as much as I do :

    From the commenter histories :

    AnotherDad :
    Year 2023 : 1579 comments to date
    Year 2022 : 2643 comments to date
    Year 2021 : 2261 comments
    Year 2020 : 2395 comments

    Thomm :
    Year 2023 : 159 comments to date
    Year 2022 : 221 comments
    Year 2021 : 196 comments
    Year 2020 : 361 comments

    So he comments here 12-13 times more often than I do, depending how you measure it. It is even more if you account for many of my comments being repeat postings of poems and songs I have written. If we take just original comments, then from 1/1/2020-present, he commented here 20 times as much as I did.

    Given his advanced age, isn’t there something else he would rather spend his time on? Or is it true that after the kids leave home and the old folks are empty nesters, older men find a variety of ways to avoid interacting with their wives, up to and including posting the same comment online every day for years?

  24. Surovikin will be the head of the Orchestra now.

  25. I’m shocked, shocked to find out that Prigozhin’s plane crashed, apparently with Prigozhin onboard! What will Comrade Putin do??

  26. Surovkin was canned because he headed up the Russian aerospace program. The recent crash landing on the moon was the latest in a series of spectacular failures by this program. Russia’s rulers sack their generals who fail, the USA’s rulers promote theirs, e.g., the Air-Force-destroying idiot, who is slated for promotion to CJCS.

    Prigozhin’s death was most probably an accident. There are far cleaner ways to take out someone like him.

    If not, then it was a messy assassination by either: (1) the Russian deep state; or (2) either the USA hegemon’s deep state or their sock puppet Zeklensky.

    Doing a qui bono analysis I reject (1) for the following reasons: First, Prigozhin was neutralized as a threat to Putin as soon as his attempted (possibly phony) coup collapsed. Second, killing him now in this way would provide endless propaganda opportunities for Putin’s enemies. We’re already seeing these play out on this site. Third, the Wagner group is set to play a prominent role in ousting the US hegemon from Central Africa. That is something the rulers of France and the USA definitely do not want, although Niger’s population and the populations of its allies seem to appreciate the possibility of Russian and Chinese help. Prigozhin’s violent death can only complicate Wagner group operations in Africa.

    On the other side of this argument, Ukraine and the US hegemon already have a track record of ruthlessly attacking Russian targets, human and infrastructure, inside and outside of Russia. Killing Prigozhin in a targeted terrorist attack on a civilian airplane would have a two-fold benefit. First it would provide anti-Putin propaganda opportunities as suggested above. Second it might very well complicate Russia’s cooperative operations defending Niger, Mali and other central African countries against France and the USA’s neocolonial machinations in central Africa.

  27. @Lurker
    Prigozhin wasn't really a military leader. More of a manager, figurehead for Wagner.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @Jack Armstrong, @Pop Warner

    More a compromised CIA asset/or Mossad mole.

    • Replies: @Mr. XYZ
    @Wokechoke

    Should have moved/fled to Israel, frankly.

  28. Because of the amount of time that had passed, I had come to assume that Putin had some sort of 4-D chess rational for allowing Prigozhin to live. But no, he’s a judo guy after all.

    (Alternative hypothesis: Prigozhin is alive, in a dungeon somewhere, wishing he had been on that plane).

  29. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    Nah. Vlad’s problem is that he didn’t have enough children and establish a separate country for himself and his fellow oligarchs.

    • LOL: Peter Hagendorf
  30. Prigozhin was offered a lenient deal considering what he had done. But he wouldn’t abide by the terms of the agreement.

    • Replies: @Hypnotoad666
    @Anonymous


    Prigozhin was offered a lenient deal considering what he had done. But he wouldn’t abide by the terms of the agreement.
     
    Mental instability, delusions of grandeur, and a big mouth is a bad combination for a former mercenary leader whose only job in life was to keep quiet and keep a low profile.

    Replies: @Colin Wright

  31. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    “If Putin had offered me … a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste.”

    Great comment. Curious though, how much “practice” do you figure you’d need? lol

  32. The US told citizens to leave Belarus immediately just two days ago. Interesting coincidence.

    Allegedly, the internet in the Wagner’s new HQ in Belarus has been shut off (you know, I’m starting to think that trusting Lukashenko’s assurances of safety are not as rock-solid as they seem) but not before they issued this alert:

    Yeah, sure. I’m holding my breath waiting for your next move. On second thought, given how pathetically lame that last Wagner tiff ended, I’m gonna wait and see before heating up any popcorn.

    And I know I’ve been hard on Lil’ BB, but I gotta give him props for finally getting around to some of that de-Nazification he kept promising everyone he was going to carry out. It’s about time, and maybe he can call it a day now and go home. I never really cared for that Adolf guy, either, but I’ll be the first to admit that anyone who can put “I killed Hitler” on his resume the way he can, well, he can’t be all bad.

  33. I’ve heard there were 10 (?) passengers on board. If true, have we heard who they were? It’s worth asking if the others were (also) the intended targets…

    • Agree: Robertson
    • Replies: @Jus' Sayin'...
    @Just Some JB


    I’ve heard there were 10 (?) passengers on board. If true, have we heard who they were? It’s worth asking if the others were (also) the intended targets…
     
    The latest I read is that the passengers were all senior commanders in the Wagner Group. If true, this makes it extremely unlikely that the Russian government, e.g. Putin, arranged this. The Wagner Group is far too useful a Russian paramilitary tool, that Russia would deliberately cripple it in this fashion.
  34. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    Paris is full of Africa now. Sorry to inform you.

    • Replies: @Peter Akuleyev
    @Wokechoke

    Paris is still far less African than any major American city.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Mike Tre

  35. Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would’ve stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn’t care that much about his life, he should’ve just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don’t even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He’s an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @JohnnyWalker123

    Flying as he did, in a small jet -- apparently between Moscow and St. Petersburg, no less, -- would seem careless for a man with his experience and reputation.

    Either something isn't what it seems, or my fundamental theory stands still not disproven:


    Those guys in high places are not any smarter than you or me. Nor do they possess superhuman abilities. Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.
     
    And Lee Oswald really did bring his rifle to work that day, and he really did fire three shots from a window. One hit the target in the head. Not that hard to understand.

    Every man sits on a toilet and shits just like you and me. Nobody is special, and no event is either. Apparently Prickosan, Prigozhen, Prickoman, whatever, was as stupid as any one of us.

    And Vlad is just another Prick in a high place at the present time. And this is none of our business.

    Replies: @Captain Tripps, @MGB

    , @Wokechoke
    @JohnnyWalker123

    What really happened in Bakhmut was that Prigozhin was funneling troops, loot cash gear back and forth. That's why Shoigu dropped all the phosphorus bombs on the western approaches to Bakhmut. He had to die.

    , @Mr. XYZ
    @JohnnyWalker123

    He retreated because he concluded that his chances of success were near-zero, most likely.

    And Putin could have probably killed him in Belarus as well.

    , @SFG
    @JohnnyWalker123

    I never got why he backed down in the first place. Putin was never going to let him live. At least go down in the history books.

    There is, of course, one power that Putin wouldn’t attack directly. If I were Prigozhin, I would have gone to the US embassy and declared that I was a woman and could no longer live in the transphobic environment of Russia. (Not sure being gay would do it anymore.)

    , @John Johnson
    @JohnnyWalker123

    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would’ve stayed in Belarus.

    Because he is the same reckless person that:
    1. Was rich but chose to be a war general in a hot zone
    2. Tried making a deal with the Ukrainians that would kill Rusians
    3. Defied the Kremlin's orders and may have tried instigating a coup

    The fact that he went to Belarus was nuts. He should have taken his gold to Argentina and setup a lair.

    We will probably never know what made him tick. A Batman type nemesis that expects to go down in flames.

  36. Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.

    • LOL: Mr. XYZ
    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @Hypnotoad666

    Agree.

    , @HA
    @Hypnotoad666

    "Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much."

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don't seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @kaganovitch, @anon, @Brutusale

    , @Pixo
    @Hypnotoad666

    Ay comrade, list of Glorious Russia Victories in Great Patriotic Ukraine Not-War Special Military Operation is very long. So long no room here.

    Steve must commence now listen to Scott Ritter’s PedoPodCast. Now free after very short jail!

    , @Peter Akuleyev
    @Hypnotoad666

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Replies: @Redneck Farmer, @Renard, @Anonymous, @AnotherDad

    , @Mark G.
    @Hypnotoad666


    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.
     
    This is just a subjective impression on my part, but the amount of mainstream media coverage of the Ukraine-Russia war seems to be diminishing. The public appears to be souring on our involvement. A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.

    Paying less attention to what is happening on the other side of the planet is a good thing. We have serious problems here at home we need to focus on like controlling our borders, reducing crime, making Social Security solvent for the long term and decreasing our expanding federal government deficits.

    Americans have been kicking the can down the road for decades when it comes to dealing with our problems. They were able to do this because the Boomers entered their peak productive years in the nineteen eighties, and this led to economic growth. For example, Boomers like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. This large generation is now in the process of retiring. We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.

    Replies: @Renard, @Dennis Dale

  37. @Mike Tre
    I was trying to figure out why Steve seemed giddy and I figured it out. Mask mandates are returning to businesses and colleges. Lots of rumors about the return of Lockdowns. Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All.

    Replies: @For what it's worth

    “Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All.”

    Elections . . . next year. Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns? Last year, they got rid of them in order to control losses in an election.

    There’s always an election coming sometime, so you can always say, “Just in time for XYZ.”

    • Replies: @JR Ewing
    @For what it's worth


    Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns?
     
    To make security even more lax in swing states than they already have made it.

    That being said, I share your skepticism that this is really happening. The preponderance of these stories the past few days seems more like wishcasting from the right.

    Replies: @Mike Tre

    , @Brutusale
    @For what it's worth

    This time the government gets a real 1/6. Do you not see the civil unrest that will result from another lockdown or Jab mandate?

  38. @Anonymous
    Prigozhin was offered a lenient deal considering what he had done. But he wouldn’t abide by the terms of the agreement.

    Replies: @Hypnotoad666

    Prigozhin was offered a lenient deal considering what he had done. But he wouldn’t abide by the terms of the agreement.

    Mental instability, delusions of grandeur, and a big mouth is a bad combination for a former mercenary leader whose only job in life was to keep quiet and keep a low profile.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
    @Hypnotoad666


    'Mental instability, delusions of grandeur, and a big mouth is a bad combination for a former mercenary leader whose only job in life was to keep quiet and keep a low profile.'
     
    Of course, you never hear of those who follow your advice.
  39. @Michael Droy
    There seems to be a lot of interpretation in the Russian domestic report about Surovikin (and probably quite a bit in the translation into English). And a hell of a lot more in the western media's contribution to the report (ie we know he backed Przygozhin so that makes him the first to be sacked - but they don't know a thing).

    Once again by the way - all the inside gossip about Russia is being leaked by and printed in the mainstream Russian media.
    Do not expect a letter from 50 current and former KGB experts assuring the Russian media that this has "all the Hallmarks of US disinformation". Russian media are free to write this stuff.

    Replies: @Almost Missouri

    Do not expect a letter from 50 current and former KGB experts assuring the Russian media that this has “all the Hallmarks of US disinformation”. Russian media are free to write this stuff.

    • Juxtapose

    • Thanks: ic1000
  40. @Just Some JB
    I've heard there were 10 (?) passengers on board. If true, have we heard who they were? It's worth asking if the others were (also) the intended targets...

    Replies: @Jus' Sayin'...

    I’ve heard there were 10 (?) passengers on board. If true, have we heard who they were? It’s worth asking if the others were (also) the intended targets…

    The latest I read is that the passengers were all senior commanders in the Wagner Group. If true, this makes it extremely unlikely that the Russian government, e.g. Putin, arranged this. The Wagner Group is far too useful a Russian paramilitary tool, that Russia would deliberately cripple it in this fashion.

    • Agree: Redneck Farmer
  41. @Hypnotoad666
    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn't posted much.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @HA, @Pixo, @Peter Akuleyev, @Mark G.

    Agree.

  42. @Buroaker
    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.

    Replies: @Hypnotoad666, @Coemgen

    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.

    I forgot all about that. They were fake indictments because they never intended to serve anyone in Russia. But then the Internet Research Agency voluntarily appeared and entered a not guilty plea. Since the Russia hoaxers had no actual evidence they had to dismiss the case.

    So if anyone ever says Russia interfered in the 2016 election, the official answer is that the DOJ lost the case and “the Russians” were exonerated. But this is one of those facts the Fake News is prohibited from reporting, so you will never, ever read about it anywhere.

  43. @tyrone
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle
     
    .....Careful ,a certain government entity is walking to and fro like a roaring lion seeking who it may devour.

    Replies: @Almost Missouri

  44. Putin may have lost patience with all the drama that comes along with the Wagner Group and will decide to stick with the regular army from now on. This was released just now:

    Putin decorates tank crew from viral battlefield video
    Heroes of the Zaporozhye clash were honored at the celebration of the WWII victory at Kursk

    https://www.rt.com/russia/581740-alyosha-tank-heroes-putin/

  45. @JohnnyWalker123
    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would've stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn't care that much about his life, he should've just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don't even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He's an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Wokechoke, @Mr. XYZ, @SFG, @John Johnson

    Flying as he did, in a small jet — apparently between Moscow and St. Petersburg, no less, — would seem careless for a man with his experience and reputation.

    Either something isn’t what it seems, or my fundamental theory stands still not disproven:

    Those guys in high places are not any smarter than you or me. Nor do they possess superhuman abilities. Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.

    And Lee Oswald really did bring his rifle to work that day, and he really did fire three shots from a window. One hit the target in the head. Not that hard to understand.

    Every man sits on a toilet and shits just like you and me. Nobody is special, and no event is either. Apparently Prickosan, Prigozhen, Prickoman, whatever, was as stupid as any one of us.

    And Vlad is just another Prick in a high place at the present time. And this is none of our business.

    • Replies: @Captain Tripps
    @Buzz Mohawk

    Keep going, you are on a roll my friend...

    , @MGB
    @Buzz Mohawk


    Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.
     
    luck never hurts. i would say that on average these are relatively high IQ guys, but with pathological levels of ambition. that, and their amorality opens up prospects that people with a moral compass would not imagine, or even consider implementing, but not because the prospects are so mind-bendingly clever.
  46. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    ‘…If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.’

    Be fair. It’s all relative.

  47. Did he just pop up in Africa, or is that a hoax? Also, I don’t care.

  48. @Hypnotoad666
    @Anonymous


    Prigozhin was offered a lenient deal considering what he had done. But he wouldn’t abide by the terms of the agreement.
     
    Mental instability, delusions of grandeur, and a big mouth is a bad combination for a former mercenary leader whose only job in life was to keep quiet and keep a low profile.

    Replies: @Colin Wright

    ‘Mental instability, delusions of grandeur, and a big mouth is a bad combination for a former mercenary leader whose only job in life was to keep quiet and keep a low profile.’

    Of course, you never hear of those who follow your advice.

  49. @Hypnotoad666
    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn't posted much.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @HA, @Pixo, @Peter Akuleyev, @Mark G.

    “Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.”

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don’t seem to have posted much about that, either.

    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    , @kaganovitch
    @HA


    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don’t seem to have posted much about that, either.
     
    Prigozhin's sabotage of the moon landing was the last straw for him. Remember it's the hoarders AND the wreckers.
    , @anon
    @HA


    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go?
     
    How are those uke soldiers with their legs blown off going?

    Replies: @HA

    , @Brutusale
    @HA

    Right! The Russian space agency should just do like Need Another Seven Astronauts and outsource all all of their launches to the private sector.

  50. @JohnnyWalker123
    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would've stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn't care that much about his life, he should've just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don't even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He's an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Wokechoke, @Mr. XYZ, @SFG, @John Johnson

    What really happened in Bakhmut was that Prigozhin was funneling troops, loot cash gear back and forth. That’s why Shoigu dropped all the phosphorus bombs on the western approaches to Bakhmut. He had to die.

  51. @HA
    @Hypnotoad666

    "Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much."

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don't seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @kaganovitch, @anon, @Brutusale

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk’s giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside “their ally’s” country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don’t have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?

    • Replies: @Diversity Heretic
    @Buzz Mohawk

    The TU-95 is a turboprop aircraft, not piston engined. Propellers are by no means obsolete--the Lockheed C-130 uses them, as does the recently-introduced Airbus A-400 transport. And I'm not at all certain that generations of Red Air Force bombers resembled the B-29/TU-4. The piston engine had reached the zenith of its potential by the late 1940s in both the West and the USSR.

    The capabilities of the MiG-15 when it first appeared in Korea were a nasty surprise to the USAF.

    , @PhysicistDave
    @Buzz Mohawk

    Buzz Mohawk wrote to HA:


    Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?
     
    You haven't figured it out, yet?

    Ron doesn't like doxxing, so I won't link to it, but HA let the cat out of the bag a while back if you go through his comments carefully.

    Let's just say it's an ethnic thing (no, he's not Jewish).

    Funny how many different ethnic groups over there hate each other.
    , @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?"

    Says the guy who, according to his comment history, has just posted (or in one case agreed with) FIVE comments on matters related to Russia -- one of which criticizes Steve's recent lack of posting on Russia.

    Maybe you should first take your own advice, fanboy, before pressing it on others.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    , @Jim Don Bob
    @Buzz Mohawk


    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside “their ally’s” country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.
     
    IIRC, the B-29 the Russkies copied had a flak hole in the vertical stabilizer and the Russkies copied that too.
    , @Anonymous
    @Buzz Mohawk

    The N-1 was a workable design, but they killed the program early, the designers expected early failures (same as Space X) a large no of engines can work, but you need to test the engines, the Soviets didn't test all the engines, they build the engines in batches of 10, randomly picked one engine and test fired it, if that engine passed they assumed the other 9 were also good, if they stuck with it, it would have worked, some with SpaceX and their Starship

  52. @ydydy
    I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn't hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.

    He invited the country's top cameramen to video his purge of tens of people IN THE ROOM while he enjoyed a cigar.

    At one point he even left the dais and microphone entirely to the man he was then forcing into publicly sentencing his own, present, colleagues to death.

    Love him or Like him, Saddam was no coward.

    No Obama drones, Clinton-Trump suicides or Putin polonium for that cat.

    https://youtube.com/shorts/AVXHVTbc3jE?feature=shared

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @zoos

    Saddam even asked “Is this the bravery of Arabs?” while his future executors were verbally taunting him in preparation for his execution.

    • Replies: @ydydy
    @Mr. XYZ

    He utterly deflated the masked cowards while he stood with a noose around his neck on top of the trapdoor.

    He had a good time of life until the very end.

    Replies: @Hunsdon

  53. @Wokechoke
    @Lurker

    More a compromised CIA asset/or Mossad mole.

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ

    Should have moved/fled to Israel, frankly.

  54. The Babylon Bee covers it best:

    ‘Leader Of Failed Russian Uprising Dead After Accidental Ingestion Of Surface-To-Air Missile’

    Interesting actually that they had to whack him that way. It suggests he would have been able to offer some resistance on the ground.

  55. @JohnnyWalker123
    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would've stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn't care that much about his life, he should've just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don't even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He's an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Wokechoke, @Mr. XYZ, @SFG, @John Johnson

    He retreated because he concluded that his chances of success were near-zero, most likely.

    And Putin could have probably killed him in Belarus as well.

  56. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    “How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common.”

    I dunno, he seems to be fitting right in:

    (Yes, I know it’s been “airbrushed”, but really, are the Russians in any position to complain about that?) And I suspect Indians would agree with you that Putin doesn’t belong to be standing next to Modi at this point, given how their respective space programs have performed in the last few days, but none of the fanboys want to seem to talk about that. Are any of Putin’s paid trolls on Unz-dot-com gonna give us a write up about that at some point?

    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @HA

    Indian space program is a great feat of engineering leading...nowhere, as is the case with most space programs.

    I may be glad for them, but that was expected...

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wq2DoUeEoZw

  57. @ydydy
    I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn't hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.

    He invited the country's top cameramen to video his purge of tens of people IN THE ROOM while he enjoyed a cigar.

    At one point he even left the dais and microphone entirely to the man he was then forcing into publicly sentencing his own, present, colleagues to death.

    Love him or Like him, Saddam was no coward.

    No Obama drones, Clinton-Trump suicides or Putin polonium for that cat.

    https://youtube.com/shorts/AVXHVTbc3jE?feature=shared

    Replies: @Mr. XYZ, @zoos

    I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn’t hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.

    Now, now! Putin is just wittier about it. I recall when one of his extremely vocal critics–he went after Putin personally–was poisoned with radiation, if memory serves, Putin said, and I’m paraphrasing,”well, if you defect and decide to be a spy against your own country, and talk a lot of shit, sometimes bad things happen. It’s part of that job, isn’t it?”

    I couldn’t really disagree with him.

    Putin reminds me a bit of trump, in that he doesn’t tend to go after people unless they screw with him first. Not saying putin’s a good guy. Just a predictable one. At least you know what you have to do for your plane to crash, so you can plan your day around it.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @zoos


    Putin reminds me a bit of trump, in that he doesn’t tend to go after people unless they screw with him first.
     
    As I understand it, the reason Wagner was mad at Putin is that he sent them into battle promising air support and ammunition but both failed to materialize when needed, resulting in unnecessarily heavy casualties. If true, it was Putin who was screwing with Prigozhin.

    Why Putin do this? Maybe it was just the usual incompetence/disorganization and there was no deliberate malice. However I'm sure paranoid Wagnerites assumed Putin was deliberately getting them killed because he feared they would coup him. If true, then a coup is exactly what he deserved. You can't betray someone who already betrayed you.
  58. @Hypnotoad666
    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn't posted much.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @HA, @Pixo, @Peter Akuleyev, @Mark G.

    Ay comrade, list of Glorious Russia Victories in Great Patriotic Ukraine Not-War Special Military Operation is very long. So long no room here.

    Steve must commence now listen to Scott Ritter’s PedoPodCast. Now free after very short jail!

  59. Considering the drone strikes on Moscow, somebody with an itchy button finger makes sense.

  60. I suppose the first order conclusion is “Putin did this” but if so why didn’t he just off him in the immediate aftermath of the failed coup when it could easily be justified? My understanding is that Prigozhin’s quasi-exile was an accord with Putin so that the Wagner mercenaries wouldn’t mutiny and they would resume fighting in the Ukraine – maybe the deal was off and Putin whacked Prigozhin but it’s probably just as likely that another faction of the Russian government did for its own ends. The remaining Wagner troops will naturally suspect Putin, which is a problem that Putin doesn’t need.

    In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don’t kill him. Killing him is not who we are.

    • Agree: Jack Armstrong
    • Replies: @For what it's worth
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don’t kill him. Killing him is not who we are."

    I'd rather be indicted than murdered. So count me on Team Democracy, I guess.

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    , @Wokechoke
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    Shoigu had to get rid of him too.

  61. @AnotherDad

    When you strike at a king, you must kill him.
     

    Replies: @Adolf Smith, @Ebony Obelisk, @epebble

    The irony: Progozhin was Putin’s personal chef…😮

  62. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    I suppose the first order conclusion is "Putin did this" but if so why didn't he just off him in the immediate aftermath of the failed coup when it could easily be justified? My understanding is that Prigozhin's quasi-exile was an accord with Putin so that the Wagner mercenaries wouldn't mutiny and they would resume fighting in the Ukraine - maybe the deal was off and Putin whacked Prigozhin but it's probably just as likely that another faction of the Russian government did for its own ends. The remaining Wagner troops will naturally suspect Putin, which is a problem that Putin doesn't need.

    In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don't kill him. Killing him is not who we are.

    Replies: @For what it's worth, @Wokechoke

    “In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don’t kill him. Killing him is not who we are.”

    I’d rather be indicted than murdered. So count me on Team Democracy, I guess.

    • Agree: Jack D
    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @For what it's worth


    I’d rather be indicted than murdered. So count me on Team Democracy, I guess.
     
    Would you rather live in a cage for all of the days of your dotage, or expire in an instant by way of an explosion and probably without any conscious understanding of the fact of your death?
  63. @For what it's worth
    @Mike Tre

    "Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All."

    Elections . . . next year. Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns? Last year, they got rid of them in order to control losses in an election.

    There's always an election coming sometime, so you can always say, "Just in time for XYZ."

    Replies: @JR Ewing, @Brutusale

    Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns?

    To make security even more lax in swing states than they already have made it.

    That being said, I share your skepticism that this is really happening. The preponderance of these stories the past few days seems more like wishcasting from the right.

    • Replies: @Mike Tre
    @JR Ewing

    Wishcasting from the right? Or cope from the left?

    Here's the primer: Newer, even more deadlier variant!

    https://globalnews.ca/news/9906142/covid-variant-ba286-canada/

    Here's how the snowball starts.

    https://www.dailywire.com/news/georgia-college-has-zero-cases-of-covid-theyre-bringing-the-mask-mandate-back-anyway

    https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/hollywood-studio-covid-rates-mask-mandates-back-1235571466/

    Based on what happened last time, how or why you think "oh, they won't try that again" when they got away with it the first time baffles me.

    And "wishcasting" is a dishonest term. Nobody on the right wants another lockdown just so they can say I told you so. That's pure projection from the left.

  64. @Bardon Kaldian
    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine for many years. Prigogine was not just a scientist, but a deep thinking natural philosopher.

    Unlike most Nobelists in the past 50 or so years.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Esso, @Esso

    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine

    There are enough transliterations into English to keep track of. You expect us to recognize those into Walloon?


    • LOL: Old Prude
    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @Reg Cæsar

    That first pic...god, only genetic engineering can do something. No group of people deserves to be so fugly.

    , @Cagey Beast
    @Reg Cæsar

    That second photo is some nasty looking poutine. Those aren't cheese curds and the gravy is cold. The fries look like they're battered too. Three failures out of three ingredients.

    Good lobster poutine is much better but it's a dish you have to split with someone else; too heavy otherwise.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

  65. @Paleo Liberal
    True story.

    A few decades ago some old guys from Jersey robbed a gambling club in Manhattan where some made men often played, and were caught by the cops. A friend of mine lost thousands. Somehow the money the cops reported recovered was quite a few thousand less than what was stolen.

    I made an over/under bet with a friend as to how soon the first confirmed hit would be. I took under. I won the bet. One of the idiots decided to leave Jersey while out on bail and go back to Manhattan. A few weeks later they found his decomposing body in the trunk of a car in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn. As New Yorkers know, Sheepshead Bay is an area with a lot of “family” enterprises.

    The moral — sometimes it’s a matter of when, not if

    Replies: @Adolf Smith, @Sick n' Tired

    Cue “Layla.”😥

  66. “Overton Window” is shifting…

  67. OT: Fat Man and Little Boy

    • Replies: @Jack Armstrong
    @Hypnotoad666

    Lincoln/Douglas II: The squawking in Milwaukee.

    , @PhysicistDave
    @Hypnotoad666

    Christie isn't quite as senile as Biden.

    Not quite.

    Yet.

  68. Anon[167] • Disclaimer says:

    OT

    I read the higher ed websites and I’ve been noting the increased use of the word “access.”

    Then there’s this:

    Julian R. Williams, who had been vice president for diversity, equity, and inclusion since 2020, is now vice president for access, civil rights, and community engagement. The university also changed its Office of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion to be the Division of Access, Civil Rights, and Community Engagement.

    So I think we’re seeing a terminology transformation in which DEI is DIEing, only to be replaced by a new term that will highlight “access,” along with “community”; and of course “civil rights” is simply the law, so who can complain about that! In fact, there are so many blacks with Ivy League J.D.’s who are underemployed that I predict that they will begin to populate six-figure campus “access” positions.


  69. “Pre” people seem to have a predilection to die in a crash. RIP magnetic, captivating, supremely talented Steve Prefontaine, whom everybody called “Pre” because the full name was too long to pronounce, too hard to spell.

  70. Mr. Prigozhin won’t be joining us for the rest of his life.

    What Henry Kissinger said about America could be said about Vladimir Putin:

    To be an enemy of Putin can be dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal.

  71. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    I suppose the first order conclusion is "Putin did this" but if so why didn't he just off him in the immediate aftermath of the failed coup when it could easily be justified? My understanding is that Prigozhin's quasi-exile was an accord with Putin so that the Wagner mercenaries wouldn't mutiny and they would resume fighting in the Ukraine - maybe the deal was off and Putin whacked Prigozhin but it's probably just as likely that another faction of the Russian government did for its own ends. The remaining Wagner troops will naturally suspect Putin, which is a problem that Putin doesn't need.

    In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don't kill him. Killing him is not who we are.

    Replies: @For what it's worth, @Wokechoke

    Shoigu had to get rid of him too.

  72. @Hypnotoad666
    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn't posted much.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @HA, @Pixo, @Peter Akuleyev, @Mark G.

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    • Agree: Pop Warner
    • Replies: @Redneck Farmer
    @Peter Akuleyev

    As David Bowie pointed out "god is an american ".

    , @Renard
    @Peter Akuleyev

    You have a point. No sane person would deny that the USA is a train wreck at this point, but Russia's considerably worse, and China's not looking so hot at the moment either. Who else is there?


    Americans are just lucky.
     
    It's certainly worked for us before.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @Anonymous

    , @Anonymous
    @Peter Akuleyev


    And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.
     
    States exist in an anarchic world order in which the future is unpredictable. Under such conditions, it's not unusual to see states like Russia lash out when a neighboring state becomes less compliant or increasingly hostile.

    It's not out of the question in the near future that a hawkish US administration will support or encourage a de facto or explicit declaration of independence by Taiwan, inviting a military response from China. In fact, from the US perspective, such a move may be preferable sooner rather than later when/if the military gap between the US and China could be narrower.
    , @AnotherDad
    @Peter Akuleyev


    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.
     
    Agree.

    Even with all the miscalculations and stupidity, no great power in history has had a policy as insane and destructive as the "come invade us!" policy of the "American" establishment.

    Yet, in the last few years, the competing powers--while doing nothing nowhere near as destructive long term--have been on a rampage to shoot themselves in the foot.

    Putin/Russia was in a pretty good place. Russia's long term need was to kick out the illegals from the 'stans and work on "Affordable Family Formation" to get the core Russian population's fertility turned around and eugenic--and avoid long term muslimifaction. So he ... invades Ukraine.

    Without a serious immivasion issue China basically no problems, except turning fertility around eugenically. Otherwise, it could just go about its business and watch the West decay into diversity contention and low IQ mediocrity. Instead, Xi goes around provoking petty military conflicts with the Philippines and India and insists on saber rattling on Taiwan. And then he slams on lockdown for a virus whose effect--punching a bunch of us old folks' tickets a bit early--is actually--to be blunt about it--beneficial to China's demographic mess, tanking the economy and crushing fertility even further.

    The US has its worst administration ever ... yet is still sort of holding its ground cause the other guys suck so badly as well. Just hard to see any leaders who are worth a damn to their people.
  73. @Hypnotoad666
    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn't posted much.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @HA, @Pixo, @Peter Akuleyev, @Mark G.

    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.

    This is just a subjective impression on my part, but the amount of mainstream media coverage of the Ukraine-Russia war seems to be diminishing. The public appears to be souring on our involvement. A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.

    Paying less attention to what is happening on the other side of the planet is a good thing. We have serious problems here at home we need to focus on like controlling our borders, reducing crime, making Social Security solvent for the long term and decreasing our expanding federal government deficits.

    Americans have been kicking the can down the road for decades when it comes to dealing with our problems. They were able to do this because the Boomers entered their peak productive years in the nineteen eighties, and this led to economic growth. For example, Boomers like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. This large generation is now in the process of retiring. We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.

    • Replies: @Renard
    @Mark G.


    A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.
     
    Better late than never. Can we get any of the $250 billion back?

    We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.
     
    And Medicaid, and SNAP EBT... I know! Let's have another 50 million third-world migrants added to the mix.
    , @Dennis Dale
    @Mark G.

    But it’s not “happening on the other side of the world”, it originated here. It’s being propagandized here, funded from here, and it’s distorting our politics here. It’s happening because people in our government think it serves our national interests (or other interests). That Ukrainians and Russians are doing all the dying just makes it more criminal.
    It’s not a distraction, it’s another grand criminal enterprise.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

  74. @AnotherDad

    When you strike at a king, you must kill him.
     

    Replies: @Adolf Smith, @Ebony Obelisk, @epebble

    NAFO fellas bonked him

    Glory to Ukraine.

    It’s over for Russia.

    Nikki Haley won the debate tonight

    • Replies: @tyrone
    @Ebony Obelisk


    Glory to Ukraine.
     
    ....fine, just no more money...

    It’s over for Russia.
     
    ..right ,the war is just about over and Russia wins.
    , @Mr. Anon
    @Ebony Obelisk


    Glory to Ukraine.
     
    Ukraine is a very white country, you know. And a significant number of them are unreconstructed Nazis. I don't think that many Ukrainians long to copulate with people of color, or whatever crude porny formulation you are fond of using. Sounds like a loss for Team Diversity, Tiny Duck, Ebony Obelisk, and other such wokebots.
    , @rocko
    @Ebony Obelisk

    You realize Ukrainians are overwhelmingly white and hs e Nazis in their ranks?

  75. @Peter Akuleyev
    @Hypnotoad666

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Replies: @Redneck Farmer, @Renard, @Anonymous, @AnotherDad

    As David Bowie pointed out “god is an american “.

  76. @Peter Akuleyev
    @Hypnotoad666

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Replies: @Redneck Farmer, @Renard, @Anonymous, @AnotherDad

    You have a point. No sane person would deny that the USA is a train wreck at this point, but Russia’s considerably worse, and China’s not looking so hot at the moment either. Who else is there?

    Americans are just lucky.

    It’s certainly worked for us before.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Renard



    Americans are just lucky.
     
    It’s certainly worked for us before.
     
    "I'd rather be lucky than good" - Chuck Yeager.
    , @Anonymous
    @Renard

    Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done. They’ve also field tested their military and made dramatic improvements. Apparently they’ve killed about 10 Ukrainians for each Russian. I don’t see how any of that hurts Russia or helps the USA. The resources that Russia owns are more valuable than ever by the way.

    China has had a self-inflicted wound because of its Covid neuroticism, but it’s still in an enormous power. People are living so much better than 10 years ago, not to mention 30 years ago. They will be able to act independently and be free of the USA’s bossiness. How is that not a win for them?

    Life in America rolls on, but things aren’t great. There’s a lot of misery out there, and the future looks bleak for future generations.

    Replies: @HA

  77. @Mark G.
    @Hypnotoad666


    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.
     
    This is just a subjective impression on my part, but the amount of mainstream media coverage of the Ukraine-Russia war seems to be diminishing. The public appears to be souring on our involvement. A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.

    Paying less attention to what is happening on the other side of the planet is a good thing. We have serious problems here at home we need to focus on like controlling our borders, reducing crime, making Social Security solvent for the long term and decreasing our expanding federal government deficits.

    Americans have been kicking the can down the road for decades when it comes to dealing with our problems. They were able to do this because the Boomers entered their peak productive years in the nineteen eighties, and this led to economic growth. For example, Boomers like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. This large generation is now in the process of retiring. We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.

    Replies: @Renard, @Dennis Dale

    A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.

    Better late than never. Can we get any of the $250 billion back?

    We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.

    And Medicaid, and SNAP EBT… I know! Let’s have another 50 million third-world migrants added to the mix.

  78. @Paleo Liberal
    True story.

    A few decades ago some old guys from Jersey robbed a gambling club in Manhattan where some made men often played, and were caught by the cops. A friend of mine lost thousands. Somehow the money the cops reported recovered was quite a few thousand less than what was stolen.

    I made an over/under bet with a friend as to how soon the first confirmed hit would be. I took under. I won the bet. One of the idiots decided to leave Jersey while out on bail and go back to Manhattan. A few weeks later they found his decomposing body in the trunk of a car in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn. As New Yorkers know, Sheepshead Bay is an area with a lot of “family” enterprises.

    The moral — sometimes it’s a matter of when, not if

    Replies: @Adolf Smith, @Sick n' Tired

    If that was in the early 80s, my father used to walk our dogs in Sheepshead Bay, since we lived across from the fishing boats. He has a story about walking past a car for a few days and the smell getting noticeably worse, and when the cops finally popped the trunk, it was a dead mob guy with all his cash & jewelry still on him. This was around 1983-84′

    • Replies: @Paleo Liberal
    @Sick n' Tired

    No, this was the late 80s.

    Which means, either your father was wrong about the year, or more likely leaving dead bodies in the trunk of a car in Sheepshead Bay was a way the mob sent a message.

  79. @Robertson
    Did he fake his own death?**

    Putin revenge?
    CIA revenge?
    Ukranian revenge?
    Wagner underboss impatient to be #1 Boss?
    Drunken Russian airplane mechanic?
    Someone aboard had life insurance policy unawares?
    Someone at Wagner upset with Priggy?
    French pissed that Wagner is in Niger?

    **This really wouldn't be all that hard to fake, take dead bodies from Ukraine, stuff em' on a helicopter you have rigged not to make it.

    Replies: @Sick n' Tired, @Twinkie

    They did the same in the beginning of the Dark Knight Rises, extracting an asset, transferring blood to a body double, and crashing a plane to kill everyone on board. Consider everything is a psyop until proven otherwise at this point.

  80. @vinteuil
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.
     
    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I've ever come across here.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin, @Thomm, @AndrewR, @Intelligent Dasein

    AnotherBoomer is certainly among the stranger commenters on here.

    It’s far from clear that it was Putin who ordered this. Prigozhin had many enemies. But some people here can’t stop with the Cold War, neocon Russophobia.

  81. Anonymous[170] • Disclaimer says:

    Prigozhin’s death, plane crash, SAM fire, et al. is just another ruse.

    It was staged and actually no one was aboard. Perhaps because I’m a former investigator it jumped out at me that this was staged when I saw a video of the passengers boarding the Embraer 600. Then I saw Russian intel sources disseminating this video along with other confirmatory evidence. C’mon man, you don’t need to be a Colombo to see this is staged to look like a death.

    How the hell are so many smart people so damn gullible??

  82. Prigozhin’s name will far outshine yours, you pathetic, childish old man.

  83. Anonymous[214] • Disclaimer says:
    @Peter Akuleyev
    @Hypnotoad666

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Replies: @Redneck Farmer, @Renard, @Anonymous, @AnotherDad

    And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    States exist in an anarchic world order in which the future is unpredictable. Under such conditions, it’s not unusual to see states like Russia lash out when a neighboring state becomes less compliant or increasingly hostile.

    It’s not out of the question in the near future that a hawkish US administration will support or encourage a de facto or explicit declaration of independence by Taiwan, inviting a military response from China. In fact, from the US perspective, such a move may be preferable sooner rather than later when/if the military gap between the US and China could be narrower.

  84. @Robertson
    Did he fake his own death?**

    Putin revenge?
    CIA revenge?
    Ukranian revenge?
    Wagner underboss impatient to be #1 Boss?
    Drunken Russian airplane mechanic?
    Someone aboard had life insurance policy unawares?
    Someone at Wagner upset with Priggy?
    French pissed that Wagner is in Niger?

    **This really wouldn't be all that hard to fake, take dead bodies from Ukraine, stuff em' on a helicopter you have rigged not to make it.

    Replies: @Sick n' Tired, @Twinkie

    Did he fake his own death?**

    Note:

    was listed as a passenger

    All we know now is that he was on the passenger manifest. And everyone onboard died.

    Until you have the body/DNA, no confirmation.

    • Agree: Hypnotoad666
    • Replies: @Alrenous
    @Twinkie

    Until body:
    It's a great way to fake your own death. Plane crash assassination is extremely common and thus plausible. Putin can be seen to be lethally harsh against his enemies without having to actually kill anyone aside from ukronazis committing suicide by SMO.

  85. @Hypnotoad666
    OT: Fat Man and Little Boy

    https://twitter.com/GovChristie/status/1694523799780180315?s=19

    Replies: @Jack Armstrong, @PhysicistDave

    Lincoln/Douglas II: The squawking in Milwaukee.

  86. @HA
    @Hypnotoad666

    "Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much."

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don't seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @kaganovitch, @anon, @Brutusale

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don’t seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Prigozhin’s sabotage of the moon landing was the last straw for him. Remember it’s the hoarders AND the wreckers.

    • Thanks: Redneck Farmer
  87. @AnotherDad

    When you strike at a king, you must kill him.
     

    Replies: @Adolf Smith, @Ebony Obelisk, @epebble

    Or:

    “Never do an enemy a small injury.”

    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @epebble

    That's Machiavelli I think:


    "Men avenge slight injuries, but not grave ones"

    "He who draws his sword against his prince should throw away the scabbard"
     
  88. @Lurker
    Prigozhin wasn't really a military leader. More of a manager, figurehead for Wagner.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @Jack Armstrong, @Pop Warner

    I’m still shorting Wagner Group.

    • Replies: @tyrone
    @Jack Armstrong


    I’m still shorting Wagner Group.
     
    .....It'll be back under new management ,most likely under greater FSB control , mercenary forces are too useful to dispense with.
  89. @Renard
    @Peter Akuleyev

    You have a point. No sane person would deny that the USA is a train wreck at this point, but Russia's considerably worse, and China's not looking so hot at the moment either. Who else is there?


    Americans are just lucky.
     
    It's certainly worked for us before.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @Anonymous

    Americans are just lucky.

    It’s certainly worked for us before.

    “I’d rather be lucky than good” – Chuck Yeager.

  90. To be fair, lots of people can’t spell Sailer either. I’ve seen him called “Sailor” many times, even by his own commenters.

    Anyway — to learn the correct spelling of Pirygozhin’s name, any information on his supposed death (seems fake to me, so far), or in fact anything related to international politics, the last place I’d go to would be Sailer’s blog…

    But to read snarky comments about the latest NYT Op-Ed about race? Then, yes, maybe.

  91. @Peter Akuleyev
    @Hypnotoad666

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Replies: @Redneck Farmer, @Renard, @Anonymous, @AnotherDad

    Deep State has been in cheering mode since January 2022. Russia just keeps going from bad to worse, and now China has started to crack as well. No one could have imagined two years ago that the US would be in the power position it currently finds itself in. And, at least on the surface, due to self inflicted wounds by its chief rivals not American competence. I mean I guess the Deep State is so amazingly competent that they tricked Putin into a disastrous invasion and convinced Xi to combine a ridiculous overreaction to COVID with an already disastrous plunge in fertility but I think Americans are just lucky.

    Agree.

    Even with all the miscalculations and stupidity, no great power in history has had a policy as insane and destructive as the “come invade us!” policy of the “American” establishment.

    Yet, in the last few years, the competing powers–while doing nothing nowhere near as destructive long term–have been on a rampage to shoot themselves in the foot.

    Putin/Russia was in a pretty good place. Russia’s long term need was to kick out the illegals from the ‘stans and work on “Affordable Family Formation” to get the core Russian population’s fertility turned around and eugenic–and avoid long term muslimifaction. So he … invades Ukraine.

    Without a serious immivasion issue China basically no problems, except turning fertility around eugenically. Otherwise, it could just go about its business and watch the West decay into diversity contention and low IQ mediocrity. Instead, Xi goes around provoking petty military conflicts with the Philippines and India and insists on saber rattling on Taiwan. And then he slams on lockdown for a virus whose effect–punching a bunch of us old folks’ tickets a bit early–is actually–to be blunt about it–beneficial to China’s demographic mess, tanking the economy and crushing fertility even further.

    The US has its worst administration ever … yet is still sort of holding its ground cause the other guys suck so badly as well. Just hard to see any leaders who are worth a damn to their people.

  92. Headline mad me laugh out loud for the first time today! – Great way to start into a day – thx.!

  93. @Ebony Obelisk
    @AnotherDad

    NAFO fellas bonked him

    Glory to Ukraine.

    It’s over for Russia.

    Nikki Haley won the debate tonight

    Replies: @tyrone, @Mr. Anon, @rocko

    Glory to Ukraine.

    ….fine, just no more money…

    It’s over for Russia.

    ..right ,the war is just about over and Russia wins.

  94. @Jack Armstrong
    @Lurker

    I’m still shorting Wagner Group.

    Replies: @tyrone

    I’m still shorting Wagner Group.

    …..It’ll be back under new management ,most likely under greater FSB control , mercenary forces are too useful to dispense with.

  95. Anonymous[242] • Disclaimer says:
    @Renard
    @Peter Akuleyev

    You have a point. No sane person would deny that the USA is a train wreck at this point, but Russia's considerably worse, and China's not looking so hot at the moment either. Who else is there?


    Americans are just lucky.
     
    It's certainly worked for us before.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @Anonymous

    Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done. They’ve also field tested their military and made dramatic improvements. Apparently they’ve killed about 10 Ukrainians for each Russian. I don’t see how any of that hurts Russia or helps the USA. The resources that Russia owns are more valuable than ever by the way.

    China has had a self-inflicted wound because of its Covid neuroticism, but it’s still in an enormous power. People are living so much better than 10 years ago, not to mention 30 years ago. They will be able to act independently and be free of the USA’s bossiness. How is that not a win for them?

    Life in America rolls on, but things aren’t great. There’s a lot of misery out there, and the future looks bleak for future generations.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Anonymous

    "Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done."

    Yeah, sure, it's always sunny in Moscow, at least when the drones aren't dropping bombs and scuttled moon landings aren't raining down shards of debris. Shame about Finland and Sweden, tho. Maybe if Russia hadn't been so distracted by Ukraine, NATO and Soros wouldn't have been able to slip two whole extra bordering states in there after decades of rejection. Looks like the old one-two-misdirection psych finally did the trick.

    And according to the latest troll propaganda, once Poland swoops in and takes Western Ukraine for itself, isn't Russia back to being crammed right next to a NATO state with no buffer in between, except one that mistrusts it far more than Ukraine ever did? And you don't see how any of that hurts Russia?

    Like I said, according to the fanboys, every hand's a winner as long as Putin is holding the cards. Weird how that works.

    Replies: @Zelo, @dimples

  96. @Reg Cæsar
    @Bardon Kaldian


    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine
     
    There are enough transliterations into English to keep track of. You expect us to recognize those into Walloon?


    https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/web1_coup-niger-1280x720.jpg


    https://www.sidechef.com/recipe/c30095ea-c83d-4c29-9757-6819664c3f64.png?d=1408x1120

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Cagey Beast

    That first pic…god, only genetic engineering can do something. No group of people deserves to be so fugly.

  97. @Jack Armstrong
    There has been a great deal of drone activity in Muscovite airspace over the last two weeks. Civilian aircraft are especially vulnerable to drone interference or outright attacks. This looks like the Ukrainians trying to keep tensions high betwixt the Russian leadership. I don’t imagine Putin had anything to do with this. Ukraine’s CIA masters are pulling the strings here.

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic

    Agree. If Vladimir Putin had wanted Prigozhin dead he would have been dead long ago and Putin wouldn’t kill nine other people and sacrifice a perfectly good business jet to do so. This affair has all the signs of a CIA/MI6/Ukrainian secret service assassination. Wagner has been a huge nuisance in Africa and Prigozhin’s elimination may have more to do with that than with Ukraine.

    • Replies: @MGB
    @Diversity Heretic

    If Prigozhin is dead, I would think that if it were the Russians they would have wanted it done out of country, in Africa for example. Private planes exploding in Russian airspace is not a good look for Russia, and a war zone in Africa is better cover for anyone who wants to obfuscate. The spectacle of the assassination in Russia makes Russia look like a banana republic. Of course, it doesn’t have to be a single culprit. Maybe a special team for, I don’t know, some oligarchs of suspect national loyalty do it for ‘Putin’, and they just do it in Russia, so more than one itch is scratched.

  98. @HA
    @Bardon Kaldian

    "How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common."

    I dunno, he seems to be fitting right in:

    https://twitter.com/DarthPutinKGB/status/1694383541549985973

    (Yes, I know it's been "airbrushed", but really, are the Russians in any position to complain about that?) And I suspect Indians would agree with you that Putin doesn't belong to be standing next to Modi at this point, given how their respective space programs have performed in the last few days, but none of the fanboys want to seem to talk about that. Are any of Putin's paid trolls on Unz-dot-com gonna give us a write up about that at some point?

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    Indian space program is a great feat of engineering leading…nowhere, as is the case with most space programs.

    I may be glad for them, but that was expected…

  99. @Ebony Obelisk
    @AnotherDad

    NAFO fellas bonked him

    Glory to Ukraine.

    It’s over for Russia.

    Nikki Haley won the debate tonight

    Replies: @tyrone, @Mr. Anon, @rocko

    Glory to Ukraine.

    Ukraine is a very white country, you know. And a significant number of them are unreconstructed Nazis. I don’t think that many Ukrainians long to copulate with people of color, or whatever crude porny formulation you are fond of using. Sounds like a loss for Team Diversity, Tiny Duck, Ebony Obelisk, and other such wokebots.

  100. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    The TU-95 is a turboprop aircraft, not piston engined. Propellers are by no means obsolete–the Lockheed C-130 uses them, as does the recently-introduced Airbus A-400 transport. And I’m not at all certain that generations of Red Air Force bombers resembled the B-29/TU-4. The piston engine had reached the zenith of its potential by the late 1940s in both the West and the USSR.

    The capabilities of the MiG-15 when it first appeared in Korea were a nasty surprise to the USAF.

  101. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    Buzz Mohawk wrote to HA:

    Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?

    You haven’t figured it out, yet?

    Ron doesn’t like doxxing, so I won’t link to it, but HA let the cat out of the bag a while back if you go through his comments carefully.

    Let’s just say it’s an ethnic thing (no, he’s not Jewish).

    Funny how many different ethnic groups over there hate each other.

  102. @Hypnotoad666
    OT: Fat Man and Little Boy

    https://twitter.com/GovChristie/status/1694523799780180315?s=19

    Replies: @Jack Armstrong, @PhysicistDave

    Christie isn’t quite as senile as Biden.

    Not quite.

    Yet.

  103. @HA
    @Hypnotoad666

    "Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much."

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don't seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @kaganovitch, @anon, @Brutusale

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go?

    How are those uke soldiers with their legs blown off going?

    • Replies: @HA
    @anon

    "How are those uke soldiers with their legs blown off going?"

    Some are still fighting, thanks for asking. As for the rest, well, even some of them are doing a lot better than you, I'm guessing. So sad, these fanboys -- do they really think a vatnik's legs doesn't blow off just as easily? Is that what Putin is telling them?

  104. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)-

    Can you explain why the French are doing it, first? They aren’t just hanging around them, they are importing them and the rest of the 3rd world at replacement levels.

    • Agree: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @Loyalty Over IQ Worship

    Paris used to be the classic place to go for a romantic long weekend.

    These days? Budapest, Copenhagen?

    My kids are big travellers but Paris doesn't seem to be on the mental radar any more.

    (I think at least one other passenger was a senior military leader who Russia would miss...)

    , @Bardon Kaldian
    @Loyalty Over IQ Worship

    This is another question & is answerable only if we analyze French history in the past 200-250 years & it has nothing to do with Russia.

  105. @Buroaker
    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.

    Replies: @Hypnotoad666, @Coemgen

    Prigozhin was one of 13 Russians indicted by Andrew Weissmann and Rod Rosenstein for interfering in the American election through the Internet Research Agency.

    The indictment is at this link: https://www.justice.gov/file/1035477/download

  106. @epebble
    @AnotherDad

    Or:


    “Never do an enemy a small injury.”

     

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    That’s Machiavelli I think:

    “Men avenge slight injuries, but not grave ones”

    “He who draws his sword against his prince should throw away the scabbard”

  107. @Loyalty Over IQ Worship
    @Bardon Kaldian


    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)-
     
    Can you explain why the French are doing it, first? They aren't just hanging around them, they are importing them and the rest of the 3rd world at replacement levels.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Bardon Kaldian

    Paris used to be the classic place to go for a romantic long weekend.

    These days? Budapest, Copenhagen?

    My kids are big travellers but Paris doesn’t seem to be on the mental radar any more.

    (I think at least one other passenger was a senior military leader who Russia would miss…)

  108. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    “How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common.”

    It’s Europe, wholly in thrall to the US, who’ve rejected Russia, not the other way round.

    “Needs must when the Devil drives”

    Sad! (especially for Germany, but for all of Europe)

    Still, Russians have been writing about the love/hate Europe relationship for more than a century:

    https://allpoetry.com/The-Scythians

    But if you spurn us, then we shall not mourn.
    We too can reckon perfidy no crime,
    And countless generations yet unborn
    Shall curse your memory till the end of time.

    We shall abandon Europe and her charm.
    We shall resort to Scythian craft and guile.
    Swift to the woods and forests we shall swarm,
    And then look back, and smile our slit-eyed smile.

  109. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    A common mistake with respect to Russia is to think of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky,
    Rachmaninoff, and the like, as somehow representative of the Russian people.
    No, they’re simply 0.1 percenters that have virtually nothing to do with 99.9%
    of the Russians. Rod Dreher who converted to Eastern Orthodoxy often makes that
    mistake. 0.1 percenters in the Eurasian countries are typically so talented
    that they are bound to create important works of art, literature, and music wherever
    they live. We just don’t hear about them so much if they had the misfortune of being
    born in a small country. Poland, which technically didn’t exist in the 19th century,
    is a good example. Everyone has heard of Alexander Pushkin but few know
    of the great Polish bard Adam Mickiewicz (1798-1855). The Doll (1890) by the
    Polish writer Boleslaw Prus is as great a novel as Anna Karenina, but again very
    few know it even exists.

    • Agree: Peter Akuleyev
    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @Anon 2

    I wouldn't say Prus is of such eminence, but informed people know about Poles, from Kopernik, Jan Sobieski (who definitely defeated the Ottoman menace lasting more than three centuries), Mickiewicz (who is a better poet than Pushkin, although I read him only in translation- I just don't care for Romantic epoch of Byron, Leopardi, Hugo, Vigny, Lenau,..), Slowacki, Chopin, Sienkiewicz, Smoluchowski, Banach, Stokowski, Reymont, Gombrowicz, Nalkowska, Lem, Andrzejewski, Iwaszkiewicz, Milosz, Kolakowski, Kieslowski, Wajda, Holland, ...  

    Even not mentioning people wholly or partially of Polish origin who contributed to other cultures like Conrad, Lobachevsky, Boudenay, Stravinsky, Olyesha,...

  110. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    Geopolitics. Whether capitalist and communist or woke capitalist and Christian, the USA and Russia fight over territory like any other great powers.

  111. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    You forgot about Peter’s Westernization push, cutting beards and forcing nobles to give up their caftans for the kind of sus clothes 18th-century Europeans liked. Personally, the caftans looked way more comfortable than the quasi-trans Western shoe buckles and knee breeches and wigs, but who can judge?

    It is odd that a pro-Ukrainian is recognizing that Russians aren’t a savage Asiatic horde which is how they are usually described here, wanting to enslave the liberty-loving peoples of Eastern Europe. Shifting the goal posts for propaganda purposes, Bardon?

    At this point, China, India and Iran are looking very reasonable and not evil compared to the NY-London-DC-Tel Aviv-Brussels axis. A live and let live situation. They aren’t perfect, but they aren’t evil, unlike some power blocks one could name.

    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @Ennui

    Yet another example of black-and -white approach. Putin is anti-Peter in his activity & his ideological struggle against Westernization is the best example of how he is deeply historically wrong. His, and those Russians who support him, is a collective emotional-cognitive defeat of epic proportions.

    That goes far beyond geopolitics, NATO or gays. Russia under Putin is committing a national suicide because she has unleashed the worst Asiatic traits in collective identity/being & has explicitly denied its "racial"-cultural-historical identity through a pack of lies & civilizational orientation toward China, India, Iran, Turkey... countries completely alien & historical enemies of Russia.

    That is a truly epic identitarian disorder & derangement.

    Replies: @Loyalty Over IQ Worship

    , @Anonymous
    @Ennui

    Bardon is just a romantic who refuses to see the West for what it is, and overidentifies with his idealized image of it despite the fact his people have never truly been accepted as part of it. Or maybe he's such a Western fanboy because of it, now that I think about it.

    Paris, sadly, is truly disgusting.

  112. @JohnnyWalker123
    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would've stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn't care that much about his life, he should've just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don't even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He's an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Wokechoke, @Mr. XYZ, @SFG, @John Johnson

    I never got why he backed down in the first place. Putin was never going to let him live. At least go down in the history books.

    There is, of course, one power that Putin wouldn’t attack directly. If I were Prigozhin, I would have gone to the US embassy and declared that I was a woman and could no longer live in the transphobic environment of Russia. (Not sure being gay would do it anymore.)

  113. “the senior commander of the Wagner Private Military Company, Dmitry Utkin, and Valery Chekalov, responsible for the company’s logistics” are on the list – why would Russia want to polish off competent military people?I

    Some online person has theorised that Macron did a deal with Putin – you stop Wagner in Niger so we get our uranium/plutonium back and keep the CFA as local currency, I’ll get EU to wind back on Ukraine. Trouble with the theory is, does Macron have that kind of power any more, if he ever did?

  114. Putin may have done this but it’s just as likely that an outside party did.

    Who else was on board?

    In addition to Prigozhin, Rosaviatsiya said Dmitry Utkin – a former Russian special forces operator and alleged co-founder of the PMC – was also traveling on the jet, as was Valery Chekalov, whom the US considers to be the deputy head of Wagner. The remaining passengers listed were Sergey Propustin, Evgeny Makaryan, Alexander Totmin, and Nikolay Matuseev, identified by Russian news outlets as Wagner.

    https://www.rt.com/russia/581735-prigozhin-plane-crash-facts/

    If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance. Then Jack D might concede the point.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance."

    You mean to say someone did do this? Yeah, makes sense--I mean, given that the Russians "confirmed" that Prigozhin's body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he's dead? What other evidence does anyone need other than a press-release "confirmation" by Russian authorities? And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @kaganovitch

    , @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast

    If it was the Russians who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. The wreckage was still burning and guys here were already posting denials and conspiracy theories. Like I said then, at least wait for the official Russian lie so that you can present a unified front like in the Communist days.

    Was it the Americans or the Ukrainians? A lot of the Rushists are trying to blur Ukraine/NATO together on every occasion because being defeated by NATO or the US looks better than being defeated by a bunch of Khokhols.

    It will be interesting to see IF there is an official Russian version, beyond "engine trouble". Are they working on concocting a story or is the silence deliberate because Prigozhin is an unperson now?

    Replies: @Peter Akuleyev, @Bardon Kaldian

  115. @Buzz Mohawk
    Live by the sword, die by the sword.

    Feeling listless? Trouble getting up or getting it up? Ask your doctor about Prigozhin™.

    Prigozhin may cause flatulence, blindness, or an inability to fly. Seek medical attention if your erection lasts more than eight hours.

    Ask About Prigozhin.


    https://teddy-land.com/resources/115/thumbs/Teddy-land-Gary-Larson-Beyond-The-Far-Side.jpg


    BTW, this episode may not necessarily fall into the hands of those here who celebrate it as further confirmation of something not at all debatable: That is, yes, Putin has a habit of assassinating his enemies. So far, he has continued this practice -- and this time he used it against "our" ally who ostensibly tried a funny revolt at "our" behest.

    So, what does this mean, really? All we can say for sure is that nothing has changed in Russia, despite "our" attempts.

    We can laugh about it at length here from a distance. Remember: The reason we can is because our ancestors gave us -- their Posterity! -- a free land on a continent protected by two oceans from the old world's insanity.

    "We" do not belong in Ukraine, and "we" have no business in that part of the world.

    Go ahread and laugh, while your dollar loses value and your homeland gets invaded according to the will of the very same rulers who took "your" country to fight a war against Russia, half a world away.

    Stupid is as stupid does.

    Replies: @Captain Tripps

    Agree. (Not commenting enough lately, so button unavailable).

  116. @Buzz Mohawk
    @JohnnyWalker123

    Flying as he did, in a small jet -- apparently between Moscow and St. Petersburg, no less, -- would seem careless for a man with his experience and reputation.

    Either something isn't what it seems, or my fundamental theory stands still not disproven:


    Those guys in high places are not any smarter than you or me. Nor do they possess superhuman abilities. Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.
     
    And Lee Oswald really did bring his rifle to work that day, and he really did fire three shots from a window. One hit the target in the head. Not that hard to understand.

    Every man sits on a toilet and shits just like you and me. Nobody is special, and no event is either. Apparently Prickosan, Prigozhen, Prickoman, whatever, was as stupid as any one of us.

    And Vlad is just another Prick in a high place at the present time. And this is none of our business.

    Replies: @Captain Tripps, @MGB

    Keep going, you are on a roll my friend…

    • Thanks: Buzz Mohawk
  117. @Mr. XYZ
    @ydydy

    Saddam even asked "Is this the bravery of Arabs?" while his future executors were verbally taunting him in preparation for his execution.

    Replies: @ydydy

    He utterly deflated the masked cowards while he stood with a noose around his neck on top of the trapdoor.

    He had a good time of life until the very end.

    • Replies: @Hunsdon
    @ydydy

    "Nothing in his life became him like the leaving of it." He went down game, and that has to count.

  118. @Sick n' Tired
    @Paleo Liberal

    If that was in the early 80s, my father used to walk our dogs in Sheepshead Bay, since we lived across from the fishing boats. He has a story about walking past a car for a few days and the smell getting noticeably worse, and when the cops finally popped the trunk, it was a dead mob guy with all his cash & jewelry still on him. This was around 1983-84'

    Replies: @Paleo Liberal

    No, this was the late 80s.

    Which means, either your father was wrong about the year, or more likely leaving dead bodies in the trunk of a car in Sheepshead Bay was a way the mob sent a message.

  119. It’s just now I learned the French spell his name “Evgueni Prigojine”*. Judging by the Wikipedia entries, his first and last names are spelled all sorts of ways in our alphabet. They really need to standardise this.

    * https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evgueni_Prigojine

  120. @Diversity Heretic
    @Jack Armstrong

    Agree. If Vladimir Putin had wanted Prigozhin dead he would have been dead long ago and Putin wouldn't kill nine other people and sacrifice a perfectly good business jet to do so. This affair has all the signs of a CIA/MI6/Ukrainian secret service assassination. Wagner has been a huge nuisance in Africa and Prigozhin's elimination may have more to do with that than with Ukraine.

    Replies: @MGB

    If Prigozhin is dead, I would think that if it were the Russians they would have wanted it done out of country, in Africa for example. Private planes exploding in Russian airspace is not a good look for Russia, and a war zone in Africa is better cover for anyone who wants to obfuscate. The spectacle of the assassination in Russia makes Russia look like a banana republic. Of course, it doesn’t have to be a single culprit. Maybe a special team for, I don’t know, some oligarchs of suspect national loyalty do it for ‘Putin’, and they just do it in Russia, so more than one itch is scratched.

    • Thanks: Hunsdon
  121. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    “Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?”

    Says the guy who, according to his comment history, has just posted (or in one case agreed with) FIVE comments on matters related to Russia — one of which criticizes Steve’s recent lack of posting on Russia.

    Maybe you should first take your own advice, fanboy, before pressing it on others.

    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @HA

    "FIVE comments on matters related to Russia... fanboy..."

    SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States...


    Matthew 7:3-5


    And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

    Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

    Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.
     

    Replies: @HA

    , @Jack D
    @HA

    At what point does "I don't care about this war one way or the other" or "all I want is for the shooting to stop" become a thinly disguised version of "I really want Russia to win"? It's like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it's obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @William Badwhite

  122. @For what it's worth
    @Mike Tre

    "Just in time for the elections next year, which of course has nothing at all, at all, to do with it. Nothing. At. All."

    Elections . . . next year. Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns? Last year, they got rid of them in order to control losses in an election.

    There's always an election coming sometime, so you can always say, "Just in time for XYZ."

    Replies: @JR Ewing, @Brutusale

    This time the government gets a real 1/6. Do you not see the civil unrest that will result from another lockdown or Jab mandate?

  123. @Anonymous
    @Renard

    Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done. They’ve also field tested their military and made dramatic improvements. Apparently they’ve killed about 10 Ukrainians for each Russian. I don’t see how any of that hurts Russia or helps the USA. The resources that Russia owns are more valuable than ever by the way.

    China has had a self-inflicted wound because of its Covid neuroticism, but it’s still in an enormous power. People are living so much better than 10 years ago, not to mention 30 years ago. They will be able to act independently and be free of the USA’s bossiness. How is that not a win for them?

    Life in America rolls on, but things aren’t great. There’s a lot of misery out there, and the future looks bleak for future generations.

    Replies: @HA

    “Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done.”

    Yeah, sure, it’s always sunny in Moscow, at least when the drones aren’t dropping bombs and scuttled moon landings aren’t raining down shards of debris. Shame about Finland and Sweden, tho. Maybe if Russia hadn’t been so distracted by Ukraine, NATO and Soros wouldn’t have been able to slip two whole extra bordering states in there after decades of rejection. Looks like the old one-two-misdirection psych finally did the trick.

    And according to the latest troll propaganda, once Poland swoops in and takes Western Ukraine for itself, isn’t Russia back to being crammed right next to a NATO state with no buffer in between, except one that mistrusts it far more than Ukraine ever did? And you don’t see how any of that hurts Russia?

    Like I said, according to the fanboys, every hand’s a winner as long as Putin is holding the cards. Weird how that works.

    • Replies: @Zelo
    @HA

    You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard so this is projection on your part.

    You're also being dishonest when you act like the "troll propaganda" is coming mainly from Russia. It's well documented that there's a heavily funded campaign to convince Americans to keep supporting Ukraine by various governments, NGOs, and folks like George Soros.

    Replies: @HA

    , @dimples
    @HA

    I guess Putin factored in that the inhabitants of Finland and Sweden are relatively sane, whereas the Ukes were mentally retarded Nazis. Which would you like as your next door neighbour?

    Replies: @HA

  124. @HA
    @Hypnotoad666

    "Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much."

    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go? So many Putin fanboys around here, but they don't seem to have posted much about that, either.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @kaganovitch, @anon, @Brutusale

    Right! The Russian space agency should just do like Need Another Seven Astronauts and outsource all all of their launches to the private sector.

  125. @Cagey Beast
    Putin may have done this but it's just as likely that an outside party did.

    Who else was on board?

    In addition to Prigozhin, Rosaviatsiya said Dmitry Utkin – a former Russian special forces operator and alleged co-founder of the PMC – was also traveling on the jet, as was Valery Chekalov, whom the US considers to be the deputy head of Wagner. The remaining passengers listed were Sergey Propustin, Evgeny Makaryan, Alexander Totmin, and Nikolay Matuseev, identified by Russian news outlets as Wagner.
     
    https://www.rt.com/russia/581735-prigozhin-plane-crash-facts/

    If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it's fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance. Then Jack D might concede the point.

    Replies: @HA, @Jack D

    “If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance.”

    You mean to say someone did do this? Yeah, makes sense–I mean, given that the Russians “confirmed” that Prigozhin’s body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he’s dead? What other evidence does anyone need other than a press-release “confirmation” by Russian authorities? And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @HA


    I mean, given that the Russians “confirmed” that Prigozhin’s body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he’s dead?
     
    So you're taking that angle? I did not see that coming. I guess the only thing I can be certain of is that you'll be highly indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us and that you'll use the word "fanboy" a lot.

    Replies: @HA

    , @kaganovitch
    @HA


    And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?
     
    That's some pricey artisan shashlik there! I would have thought 100 rubles would cover it.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

  126. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance."

    You mean to say someone did do this? Yeah, makes sense--I mean, given that the Russians "confirmed" that Prigozhin's body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he's dead? What other evidence does anyone need other than a press-release "confirmation" by Russian authorities? And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @kaganovitch

    I mean, given that the Russians “confirmed” that Prigozhin’s body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he’s dead?

    So you’re taking that angle? I did not see that coming. I guess the only thing I can be certain of is that you’ll be highly indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us and that you’ll use the word “fanboy” a lot.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us"

    Indignant? Can you not read the room? Lil' BB would have to haul himself up way more than a few rungs on the credibility ladder to get people indignant at this point. To everyone outside the Wagner group and the ever-faithful fanboy lackeys -- including an increasing number of Muscovites having to dodge 1) Ukrainian drones, 2) lunar module fragments, and now 3) Wagnerite body parts -- he's languishing down at laughingstock level. He should be so lucky as to crawl back to indignation-level cringe at some point before he croaks.

    I don't know what makes him more pathetic/laughable, the fact that he allowed a mutineer like Prigozhin to live this long or the fact that Prigozhin had to basically (and yes, stupidly) serve himself and his entire high command in a single private airplane for easy disposal before anything was done to him. Or else, that the US and Ukraine are, as you're implying, able to pick off planes right under Lil' BB's nose on the outskirts of Moscow (but which curiously contain political enemies that just so happen to also be -- as you yourself admitted -- on his own death-wish betrayal list). Or even that Prigozhin paid a bunch of people off in order to stage his death and retire into quiet anonymity, raping African women in the relative quiet of his Heart-of-Darkness compound. By all means, toss that last hypothesis into the mix, too. I myself don't think any of this makes Putin shine all that brightly, I'll give you that. But indignant? No, as always, you fanboys love to project.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

  127. Lol, thats true of every country. Do you think that the talented Fatmericans are much more than 0.1%? But they have better promotion.

    As for the rest, it has little to do with the country but more to do with language and environment. Conrad wrote in English, if he hadn’t no one would have heard of him.

    But Gombrowicz became more or less known even though he wrote in Polish and lived in Argentina.

    Lots of foreign artists and painters lived in Paris and became famous for the contacts made there, because it was the cultural capital of the time. Like later NY.

    Being Jewish counts too, or no one would have heard of Ginsberg or Tristan Tzara.

  128. @Buzz Mohawk
    @JohnnyWalker123

    Flying as he did, in a small jet -- apparently between Moscow and St. Petersburg, no less, -- would seem careless for a man with his experience and reputation.

    Either something isn't what it seems, or my fundamental theory stands still not disproven:


    Those guys in high places are not any smarter than you or me. Nor do they possess superhuman abilities. Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.
     
    And Lee Oswald really did bring his rifle to work that day, and he really did fire three shots from a window. One hit the target in the head. Not that hard to understand.

    Every man sits on a toilet and shits just like you and me. Nobody is special, and no event is either. Apparently Prickosan, Prigozhen, Prickoman, whatever, was as stupid as any one of us.

    And Vlad is just another Prick in a high place at the present time. And this is none of our business.

    Replies: @Captain Tripps, @MGB

    Mostly they are placed where they are via happenstance.

    luck never hurts. i would say that on average these are relatively high IQ guys, but with pathological levels of ambition. that, and their amorality opens up prospects that people with a moral compass would not imagine, or even consider implementing, but not because the prospects are so mind-bendingly clever.

  129. @HA
    @Anonymous

    "Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done."

    Yeah, sure, it's always sunny in Moscow, at least when the drones aren't dropping bombs and scuttled moon landings aren't raining down shards of debris. Shame about Finland and Sweden, tho. Maybe if Russia hadn't been so distracted by Ukraine, NATO and Soros wouldn't have been able to slip two whole extra bordering states in there after decades of rejection. Looks like the old one-two-misdirection psych finally did the trick.

    And according to the latest troll propaganda, once Poland swoops in and takes Western Ukraine for itself, isn't Russia back to being crammed right next to a NATO state with no buffer in between, except one that mistrusts it far more than Ukraine ever did? And you don't see how any of that hurts Russia?

    Like I said, according to the fanboys, every hand's a winner as long as Putin is holding the cards. Weird how that works.

    Replies: @Zelo, @dimples

    You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard so this is projection on your part.

    You’re also being dishonest when you act like the “troll propaganda” is coming mainly from Russia. It’s well documented that there’s a heavily funded campaign to convince Americans to keep supporting Ukraine by various governments, NGOs, and folks like George Soros.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Zelo

    "You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard. You’re also being dishonest when you act like the 'troll propaganda'..."

    Riding his jock? The fanboys sure do love their porn metaphors, I'll give them that. Like the saying goes, you gotta write what you know -- no matter what it reveals about you. And as much as they dislike being called "fanboys", I'm getting the sense they can't take being called "trolls" either. What a bunch of whiners.

    And you'll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn't notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you're angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    And as for all that money Soros is tossing around to further Ukrainian support, it sure seems to have bypassed Unz-dot-com. The same cannot be said about Moscow trolls (and fellow travelers and useful idiots) who keep an active presence here. So much for your honesty.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Bardon Kaldian, @Zelo

  130. @vinteuil
    @AnotherDad


    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.
     
    This is, quite possibly, the single strangest comment I've ever come across here.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin, @Thomm, @AndrewR, @Intelligent Dasein

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn’t have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin’s vacillation when it comes to fighting this “existential” war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn’t matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time—it was high time long ago—to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin’s countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. “The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain,” my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he’s not a wartime consigliere.

    • Replies: @MGB
    @Intelligent Dasein


    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation
     
    I'm not sure that's obvious. FUKUS is a motivated player given what the Russians are getting up to in darkest Africa. It is highly unlikely that this was the work of 'Putin', and there is a history of inconvenient folks, apparently aligned with Russia, getting offed inside Russia. Back in 2014 after a meeting with Medvedev about investment plans in Russia, Total's de Margerie was killed by a drunk snowplow driver on a Moscow runway, allegedly. Around that time he was advocating closer, more secure ties to Russian gas/oil supplies, including infrastructure investment, contradicting the prevailing sanctions narrative. (This occurred at the Vnukovo airport, an airfield for dignitaries, not Domodedovo for the hoipolloi, so if he was assassinated it was a double strike, killing the 'traitor' and sending a message about security.
    , @John Johnson
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation

    His plane went down after leaving Moscow and witnesses described explosions that are characteristic of a surface to air missile.

    Putin has killed his own allies for simply being against the war but you believe that assuming he killed Prigozhin is the stupid position?

    Why would the Ukrainians want to kill Prigozhin after he humiliated Putin? Why kill the thorn in the side of the dictator?

    https://s.france24.com/media/display/7edd66fa-41f2-11ee-bac9-005056a90284/eeb122432726dc3846b97722e326231de961ad02.jpg

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @vinteuil
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Wow, ID - maybe, after all, you have the talent to write that novel about the brothers Gracchi that I've been wanting to commission from you.


    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.
     
    Heck if I know.
    , @Jack D
    @Intelligent Dasein

    "This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation"

    If someone says something is obvious, then it's the opposite. If it was really obvious you wouldn't have to say it.


    It is high time—it was high time long ago—to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.
     
    LOL. Maybe this hasn't been done because it's not within Russia's capability short of starting a nuclear war and Russia doesn't dare to start a nuclear war?

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky,
     
    Neat trick Hitler/Stalin worthy trick - assassinate Prigozhin, blame it on your enemies and then attack them. However, see above. If Russia was capable of (non-nuclear) high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, they would have done them already. What do you think they have been trying to do for the last 18 months?

    Lots of folks here have drunk the Rushist Kool-Aid (stronger than vodka) but you must have drunk a gallon of the stuff. Even Russians are not so deluded anymore.

    , @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.
     
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/putin-says-prigozhin-made-serious-mistakes-in-first-remarks-since-plane-crash-that-likely-killed-the-wagner-boss/ar-AA1fJPFK

    "With regard to this plane crash, first of all, I want to express my sincere condolences to the families of all the victims. It's always a tragedy," Putin said in a televised speech.

    "I've known Prigozhin for a long time, since the early '90′s," Putin said, describing him as a "talented businessman" with a "complicated fate" who "made serious mistakes in his life."

    The Russian leader stopped short of confirming Prigozhin's death but did speak in the past tense when referring to the 62-year-old. Putin said an investigation into what happened to the private jet carrying 10 people and departing from Moscow to St. Petersburg was already underway.
     
    To what "serious mistakes" of Prigozhin could Putin be referring? And what's a "complicated fate"?

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.
     
    Still smarter than everyone else, are you?

    Do you have a blog? If it's full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while. It's like the Onion, only much more demented. Kinda like a movie so bad, it's unintentionally funny and is, therefore, good. Keep it up, rocket scientist.

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @HA

  131. @JR Ewing
    @For what it's worth


    Why/how would Democrats gain in elections from having masks and lockdowns?
     
    To make security even more lax in swing states than they already have made it.

    That being said, I share your skepticism that this is really happening. The preponderance of these stories the past few days seems more like wishcasting from the right.

    Replies: @Mike Tre

    Wishcasting from the right? Or cope from the left?

    Here’s the primer: Newer, even more deadlier variant!

    https://globalnews.ca/news/9906142/covid-variant-ba286-canada/

    Here’s how the snowball starts.

    https://www.dailywire.com/news/georgia-college-has-zero-cases-of-covid-theyre-bringing-the-mask-mandate-back-anyway

    https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/hollywood-studio-covid-rates-mask-mandates-back-1235571466/

    Based on what happened last time, how or why you think “oh, they won’t try that again” when they got away with it the first time baffles me.

    And “wishcasting” is a dishonest term. Nobody on the right wants another lockdown just so they can say I told you so. That’s pure projection from the left.

  132. @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?"

    Says the guy who, according to his comment history, has just posted (or in one case agreed with) FIVE comments on matters related to Russia -- one of which criticizes Steve's recent lack of posting on Russia.

    Maybe you should first take your own advice, fanboy, before pressing it on others.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    “FIVE comments on matters related to Russia… fanboy…”

    SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States…

    Matthew 7:3-5

    And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

    Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

    Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother’s eye.

    • Replies: @HA
    @YetAnotherAnon

    "SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States…"

    Try and keep up. I'm not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I'm not the hypocrite, here, I'm just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla... oh, wait, you're a fanboy. Never mind.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @AKAHorace

  133. The most important war since WWII and all the commentary we get from Steve are snarky remarks about Prigozhin.

  134. @Santoculto
    Preegojin

    Replies: @Jack D

    Preegogone.

  135. @I, Libertine
    Too soon to tell whodunit, IMHO.

    Replies: @Jack D

    Not really. Putin’s silence is deafening. Putin won’t even say Navalny’s name. When Putin wants you gone it’s as if you disappeared. Surovikin also fired at the same time and on the plane was not just Prigozhin but most of his most important deputies including Utkin, who was “Wagner” himself. There was a 2nd plane with more Wagner guys and reportedly they were arrested when they landed.

    This was the Night of the Long Knives.

    Latest thinking is that this was an FSB operation. Bomb on board. It will be interesting to see if Bellingcat can break this open the way they were able to trace Navalny’s poisoning. FSB is usually sloppy and leaves fingerprints. But today’s wartime Russia is a lot more locked down than it was when Navalny was poisoned.

  136. @Cagey Beast
    Putin may have done this but it's just as likely that an outside party did.

    Who else was on board?

    In addition to Prigozhin, Rosaviatsiya said Dmitry Utkin – a former Russian special forces operator and alleged co-founder of the PMC – was also traveling on the jet, as was Valery Chekalov, whom the US considers to be the deputy head of Wagner. The remaining passengers listed were Sergey Propustin, Evgeny Makaryan, Alexander Totmin, and Nikolay Matuseev, identified by Russian news outlets as Wagner.
     
    https://www.rt.com/russia/581735-prigozhin-plane-crash-facts/

    If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it's fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance. Then Jack D might concede the point.

    Replies: @HA, @Jack D

    If it was the Russians who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. The wreckage was still burning and guys here were already posting denials and conspiracy theories. Like I said then, at least wait for the official Russian lie so that you can present a unified front like in the Communist days.

    Was it the Americans or the Ukrainians? A lot of the Rushists are trying to blur Ukraine/NATO together on every occasion because being defeated by NATO or the US looks better than being defeated by a bunch of Khokhols.

    It will be interesting to see IF there is an official Russian version, beyond “engine trouble”. Are they working on concocting a story or is the silence deliberate because Prigozhin is an unperson now?

    • Replies: @Peter Akuleyev
    @Jack D

    Like a lot of weird conspiracy theories connected to Russia , the “Putin didn’t do it” theory actually implies Putin is a weak cuck with no control over what happens on his own territory. If Putin didn’t order Prigozhin killed, patriots should demand he resign. Likewise if the Americans blew up the pipeline, why can’t the Russians get their act together to demand recompense and take their demands to the UN? What a sad weak country if the US pushes them around so easily. Same again with the “Ukrainians blew up the dam” story. What corrupt incompetents the Russian military must be to let Ukrainians infiltrate a strategic piece of infrastructure under Russian control.

    No one has more contempt for Russians than the supposed “Putin fans” who push this nonsense.

    , @Bardon Kaldian
    @Jack D

    It says something about a country that speculations are, all of them, somehow naturally describing a gangster state.

  137. @Lurker
    Prigozhin wasn't really a military leader. More of a manager, figurehead for Wagner.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @Jack Armstrong, @Pop Warner

    Utkin was the actual military leader, and he was on the plane with Prigozhin. In hindsight, it would have been better to keep them separated because they should have known they would be targeted.

    Oh well. Putin seems hellbent on removing any competent commanders in favor of prolonging the war and getting more Russians killed. At this point, I would question whose side he’s even on, because he seems to be handing victories to the West now.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Pop Warner

    Putin is on Putin's side, just as he always has been. The name of the game is not winning in Ukraine (anymore) or conserving Russian lives (which it never was, other than Putin's own) but keeping himself and his cronies in power.

    Prigozhin and Wagner challenged that so they had to go, even though they were in some respects valuable. Their value did not outweigh their danger. They had already been withdrawn from Ukraine so it will have no impact on that war. Presumably the Russian Army and the oligarchs will try to roll up what remains of Wagner in Belarus, Syria and Africa and bring them under their control. The Wagner leaders who are not dead (apparently there was a 2nd Wagner plane and according to rumor those on it were arrested when they landed) will be given the choice of swearing loyalty to Putin or unspecified consequences, keeping in mind the "assurances that Prigozhin himself had supposedly received.

    The best source for understanding all of this is watching The Godfather movies. If you think of Putin as the head of a powerful crime family, it all makes sense.

    , @Bill Jones
    @Pop Warner

    I like your confidence in asserting that you know who was on the plane.

  138. @Ennui
    @Bardon Kaldian

    You forgot about Peter's Westernization push, cutting beards and forcing nobles to give up their caftans for the kind of sus clothes 18th-century Europeans liked. Personally, the caftans looked way more comfortable than the quasi-trans Western shoe buckles and knee breeches and wigs, but who can judge?

    It is odd that a pro-Ukrainian is recognizing that Russians aren't a savage Asiatic horde which is how they are usually described here, wanting to enslave the liberty-loving peoples of Eastern Europe. Shifting the goal posts for propaganda purposes, Bardon?

    At this point, China, India and Iran are looking very reasonable and not evil compared to the NY-London-DC-Tel Aviv-Brussels axis. A live and let live situation. They aren't perfect, but they aren't evil, unlike some power blocks one could name.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Anonymous

    Yet another example of black-and -white approach. Putin is anti-Peter in his activity & his ideological struggle against Westernization is the best example of how he is deeply historically wrong. His, and those Russians who support him, is a collective emotional-cognitive defeat of epic proportions.

    That goes far beyond geopolitics, NATO or gays. Russia under Putin is committing a national suicide because she has unleashed the worst Asiatic traits in collective identity/being & has explicitly denied its “racial”-cultural-historical identity through a pack of lies & civilizational orientation toward China, India, Iran, Turkey… countries completely alien & historical enemies of Russia.

    That is a truly epic identitarian disorder & derangement.

    • Replies: @Loyalty Over IQ Worship
    @Bardon Kaldian

    Why do you put "racial" identity in quotes? You don't think race is real?

  139. @Loyalty Over IQ Worship
    @Bardon Kaldian


    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)-
     
    Can you explain why the French are doing it, first? They aren't just hanging around them, they are importing them and the rest of the 3rd world at replacement levels.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Bardon Kaldian

    This is another question & is answerable only if we analyze French history in the past 200-250 years & it has nothing to do with Russia.

  140. @Anon 2
    @Bardon Kaldian

    A common mistake with respect to Russia is to think of Tolstoy, Dostoevsky,
    Rachmaninoff, and the like, as somehow representative of the Russian people.
    No, they’re simply 0.1 percenters that have virtually nothing to do with 99.9%
    of the Russians. Rod Dreher who converted to Eastern Orthodoxy often makes that
    mistake. 0.1 percenters in the Eurasian countries are typically so talented
    that they are bound to create important works of art, literature, and music wherever
    they live. We just don’t hear about them so much if they had the misfortune of being
    born in a small country. Poland, which technically didn’t exist in the 19th century,
    is a good example. Everyone has heard of Alexander Pushkin but few know
    of the great Polish bard Adam Mickiewicz (1798-1855). The Doll (1890) by the
    Polish writer Boleslaw Prus is as great a novel as Anna Karenina, but again very
    few know it even exists.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    I wouldn’t say Prus is of such eminence, but informed people know about Poles, from Kopernik, Jan Sobieski (who definitely defeated the Ottoman menace lasting more than three centuries), Mickiewicz (who is a better poet than Pushkin, although I read him only in translation- I just don’t care for Romantic epoch of Byron, Leopardi, Hugo, Vigny, Lenau,..), Slowacki, Chopin, Sienkiewicz, Smoluchowski, Banach, Stokowski, Reymont, Gombrowicz, Nalkowska, Lem, Andrzejewski, Iwaszkiewicz, Milosz, Kolakowski, Kieslowski, Wajda, Holland, …  

    Even not mentioning people wholly or partially of Polish origin who contributed to other cultures like Conrad, Lobachevsky, Boudenay, Stravinsky, Olyesha,…

    • Agree: Anon 2
  141. @ydydy
    @Mr. XYZ

    He utterly deflated the masked cowards while he stood with a noose around his neck on top of the trapdoor.

    He had a good time of life until the very end.

    Replies: @Hunsdon

    “Nothing in his life became him like the leaving of it.” He went down game, and that has to count.

  142. @anon
    @HA


    Hey, how did that Russian moon landing go?
     
    How are those uke soldiers with their legs blown off going?

    Replies: @HA

    “How are those uke soldiers with their legs blown off going?”

    Some are still fighting, thanks for asking. As for the rest, well, even some of them are doing a lot better than you, I’m guessing. So sad, these fanboys — do they really think a vatnik’s legs doesn’t blow off just as easily? Is that what Putin is telling them?

  143. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside “their ally’s” country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    IIRC, the B-29 the Russkies copied had a flak hole in the vertical stabilizer and the Russkies copied that too.

  144. @Wokechoke
    @Bardon Kaldian

    Paris is full of Africa now. Sorry to inform you.

    Replies: @Peter Akuleyev

    Paris is still far less African than any major American city.

    • Agree: Bardon Kaldian
    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @Peter Akuleyev

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PUATA2Ry7q0

    , @Mike Tre
    @Peter Akuleyev

    And your point is what, exactly?

    Paris is more African now than it was 50 years ago, when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction. So you don't seem to have a point, unless it is to applaud the negrofication of the West.

    Replies: @Twinkie

  145. By far the most insightful (but still concise) account of
    Prigozhin’s assassination is by Misha Firer on Quora.

  146. @Peter Akuleyev
    @Wokechoke

    Paris is still far less African than any major American city.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Mike Tre

  147. @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast

    If it was the Russians who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. The wreckage was still burning and guys here were already posting denials and conspiracy theories. Like I said then, at least wait for the official Russian lie so that you can present a unified front like in the Communist days.

    Was it the Americans or the Ukrainians? A lot of the Rushists are trying to blur Ukraine/NATO together on every occasion because being defeated by NATO or the US looks better than being defeated by a bunch of Khokhols.

    It will be interesting to see IF there is an official Russian version, beyond "engine trouble". Are they working on concocting a story or is the silence deliberate because Prigozhin is an unperson now?

    Replies: @Peter Akuleyev, @Bardon Kaldian

    Like a lot of weird conspiracy theories connected to Russia , the “Putin didn’t do it” theory actually implies Putin is a weak cuck with no control over what happens on his own territory. If Putin didn’t order Prigozhin killed, patriots should demand he resign. Likewise if the Americans blew up the pipeline, why can’t the Russians get their act together to demand recompense and take their demands to the UN? What a sad weak country if the US pushes them around so easily. Same again with the “Ukrainians blew up the dam” story. What corrupt incompetents the Russian military must be to let Ukrainians infiltrate a strategic piece of infrastructure under Russian control.

    No one has more contempt for Russians than the supposed “Putin fans” who push this nonsense.

    • Thanks: Jack D
    • LOL: Twinkie
  148. @Ebony Obelisk
    @AnotherDad

    NAFO fellas bonked him

    Glory to Ukraine.

    It’s over for Russia.

    Nikki Haley won the debate tonight

    Replies: @tyrone, @Mr. Anon, @rocko

    You realize Ukrainians are overwhelmingly white and hs e Nazis in their ranks?

  149. @Cagey Beast
    @HA


    I mean, given that the Russians “confirmed” that Prigozhin’s body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he’s dead?
     
    So you're taking that angle? I did not see that coming. I guess the only thing I can be certain of is that you'll be highly indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us and that you'll use the word "fanboy" a lot.

    Replies: @HA

    “indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us”

    Indignant? Can you not read the room? Lil’ BB would have to haul himself up way more than a few rungs on the credibility ladder to get people indignant at this point. To everyone outside the Wagner group and the ever-faithful fanboy lackeys — including an increasing number of Muscovites having to dodge 1) Ukrainian drones, 2) lunar module fragments, and now 3) Wagnerite body parts — he’s languishing down at laughingstock level. He should be so lucky as to crawl back to indignation-level cringe at some point before he croaks.

    I don’t know what makes him more pathetic/laughable, the fact that he allowed a mutineer like Prigozhin to live this long or the fact that Prigozhin had to basically (and yes, stupidly) serve himself and his entire high command in a single private airplane for easy disposal before anything was done to him. Or else, that the US and Ukraine are, as you’re implying, able to pick off planes right under Lil’ BB’s nose on the outskirts of Moscow (but which curiously contain political enemies that just so happen to also be — as you yourself admitted — on his own death-wish betrayal list). Or even that Prigozhin paid a bunch of people off in order to stage his death and retire into quiet anonymity, raping African women in the relative quiet of his Heart-of-Darkness compound. By all means, toss that last hypothesis into the mix, too. I myself don’t think any of this makes Putin shine all that brightly, I’ll give you that. But indignant? No, as always, you fanboys love to project.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    "Lil'BB"? Can't you even bother to come up with a nickname for Putin that works in English? I only get who you're referring to based on the context and knowing Russians refer to Putin by the initials of his first name and patronymic "VV" and that the Cyrillic letter that looks like a B is pronounced as a V.

  150. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    BRICS is like the G7, ( and a new monetary exchange system). Get over it! They’re not gonna open their borders to China or Iran. Open borders is a US and EU thing.

  151. @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation

    I’m not sure that’s obvious. FUKUS is a motivated player given what the Russians are getting up to in darkest Africa. It is highly unlikely that this was the work of ‘Putin’, and there is a history of inconvenient folks, apparently aligned with Russia, getting offed inside Russia. Back in 2014 after a meeting with Medvedev about investment plans in Russia, Total’s de Margerie was killed by a drunk snowplow driver on a Moscow runway, allegedly. Around that time he was advocating closer, more secure ties to Russian gas/oil supplies, including infrastructure investment, contradicting the prevailing sanctions narrative. (This occurred at the Vnukovo airport, an airfield for dignitaries, not Domodedovo for the hoipolloi, so if he was assassinated it was a double strike, killing the ‘traitor’ and sending a message about security.

  152. @YetAnotherAnon
    @HA

    "FIVE comments on matters related to Russia... fanboy..."

    SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States...


    Matthew 7:3-5


    And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?

    Or how wilt thou say to thy brother, Let me pull out the mote out of thine eye; and, behold, a beam is in thine own eye?

    Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye.
     

    Replies: @HA

    “SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States…”

    Try and keep up. I’m not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I’m not the hypocrite, here, I’m just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla… oh, wait, you’re a fanboy. Never mind.

    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @HA

    NINE now...

    Just a thought - the Frogs do have previous in that they blew up a Greenpeace ship which was monitoring French nuclear testing way back in the 1970s.

    3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there's a motive there...while Russia will miss these guys. Not a great PR week for Russia, although Saudis, Iran, Egypt and UAE joining BRICS is a biggie. Half the Middle East.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Service_de_documentation_ext%C3%A9rieure_et_de_contre-espionnage


    One SDECE agent, Philippe L. Thyaud de Vosjolo, wrote in his 1970 memoir Lamia: "Dozens of assassinations were carried out. Besides the use of guns or knives, more sophisticated methods had been perfected. Carbon dioxide guns ejecting small syringes had been purchased in the United States-but the SDECE people substituted the tranquilizing drug with a lethal poison. The victim showed all the symptoms of having suffered a heart attack". Besides for members of the FLN, the SDECE killed left-wing French intellectuals who supported the FLN, arms dealers and other anti-French nationalists in Africa. The SDECE also engaged in hijacking six ships bound for Algeria with arms for the FLN between 1956–61, and blew up one ship packed with weapons for the FLN in Hamburg harbor with a naval mine.
     
    Never realised SDECE supported Quebec seperatists, but it makes sense.

    Now this is the reason why some people want to be President.


    "On the night of 13 May 1978, Denard and 42 other mercenaries landed on Grande Comore, almost effortlessly annihilated the Comorian forces and by the morning the Comoros was theirs. President Soilih was high on marijuana and naked in his bed together with three nude teenage schoolgirls watching a pornographic film, when Denard kicked in the door to his room to inform him that he was no longer president and had Soilih taken out to be "shot while trying to escape"."

     
    They have form for inside Russia operations.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directorate-General_for_External_Security#2010s


    "In 2014, DGSE in a joint operation with AIVD, had successfully infiltrated and planted hidden cameras in Cyber Operations Center under SVR in Russia"
     

    Replies: @HA

    , @AKAHorace
    @HA


    Try and keep up. I’m not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I’m not the hypocrite, here, I’m just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla… oh, wait, you’re a fanboy. Never mind.
     
    My theory. The whole Ukrainian/Russian conflict is a sideshow in the central titanic struggle of intellects on Steve Sailer's comments threads. Keep posting boys. Remember, for every post that goes unchallenged the Ukrainian fascists/Russian Orcs advance five miles.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

  153. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "indignant at the stupidity of the rest of us"

    Indignant? Can you not read the room? Lil' BB would have to haul himself up way more than a few rungs on the credibility ladder to get people indignant at this point. To everyone outside the Wagner group and the ever-faithful fanboy lackeys -- including an increasing number of Muscovites having to dodge 1) Ukrainian drones, 2) lunar module fragments, and now 3) Wagnerite body parts -- he's languishing down at laughingstock level. He should be so lucky as to crawl back to indignation-level cringe at some point before he croaks.

    I don't know what makes him more pathetic/laughable, the fact that he allowed a mutineer like Prigozhin to live this long or the fact that Prigozhin had to basically (and yes, stupidly) serve himself and his entire high command in a single private airplane for easy disposal before anything was done to him. Or else, that the US and Ukraine are, as you're implying, able to pick off planes right under Lil' BB's nose on the outskirts of Moscow (but which curiously contain political enemies that just so happen to also be -- as you yourself admitted -- on his own death-wish betrayal list). Or even that Prigozhin paid a bunch of people off in order to stage his death and retire into quiet anonymity, raping African women in the relative quiet of his Heart-of-Darkness compound. By all means, toss that last hypothesis into the mix, too. I myself don't think any of this makes Putin shine all that brightly, I'll give you that. But indignant? No, as always, you fanboys love to project.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    “Lil’BB”? Can’t you even bother to come up with a nickname for Putin that works in English? I only get who you’re referring to based on the context and knowing Russians refer to Putin by the initials of his first name and patronymic “VV” and that the Cyrillic letter that looks like a B is pronounced as a V.

  154. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    It’s worth noting that Stalin, one of the most brutal of the Russian/Soviet leaders, was an ethnic Georgian.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Frau Katze

    "It’s worth noting that Stalin, one of the most brutal of the Russian/Soviet leaders, was an ethnic Georgian."

    It isn't really all that noteworthy. Some say the greatest Greek of them all was a Macedonian hillbilly. Herr Über-Deutsche was actually an Austrian. And the Frenchiest of Frenchmen was arguably a certain Corsican. That's just how it goes. Some of the most hard-core white supremacists out there have a decidedly non-Aryan grandparent or grandma they're all "So what?" about.

  155. @Zelo
    @HA

    You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard so this is projection on your part.

    You're also being dishonest when you act like the "troll propaganda" is coming mainly from Russia. It's well documented that there's a heavily funded campaign to convince Americans to keep supporting Ukraine by various governments, NGOs, and folks like George Soros.

    Replies: @HA

    “You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard. You’re also being dishonest when you act like the ‘troll propaganda’…”

    Riding his jock? The fanboys sure do love their porn metaphors, I’ll give them that. Like the saying goes, you gotta write what you know — no matter what it reveals about you. And as much as they dislike being called “fanboys”, I’m getting the sense they can’t take being called “trolls” either. What a bunch of whiners.

    And you’ll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn’t notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you’re angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    And as for all that money Soros is tossing around to further Ukrainian support, it sure seems to have bypassed Unz-dot-com. The same cannot be said about Moscow trolls (and fellow travelers and useful idiots) who keep an active presence here. So much for your honesty.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @HA

    And you’ll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn’t notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you’re angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    It's a very bizarre phenomenon that we have observed in Putin defenders since the beginning of the war.

    They seem obsessed with Zelensky and assume we idolize him like they do with Putin. They don't seem to realize that they are usually the only ones talking about him. It's a classic case of projection. They don't get that we aren't tribal alpha brained to Zelensky.

    Even stranger is that they think Zelensky is keeping Ukraine in the war. As if the country would accept Russian rule without him.

    Polls show that a strong majority of the Ukrainian public supports the war. Zelensky openly states that he defaults to his generals. Which means his replacement would continue the same policy.

    MacGregor and Ritter are the same way. They will speak of Zelensky as if he is also a dictator and has a cult following. They seem to view this as a war of competing dictators. When MacGregor speaks of Zelensky it looks like a vein is going to pop out of his head. He can't talk about the war without mentioning Zelensky. The will denigrate him as an actor but then speak of him as he if has Jewish spell powers. No mention that Putin has closer ties to Israel and in fact Israel again turned down a weapons request from Ukraine.

    Replies: @HA

    , @Bardon Kaldian
    @HA

    Everything aside, American Putin's supporters are first & foremost moral abominations.

    , @Zelo
    @HA

    Your little feelings get upset when the Fanboy accusation is turned back on you. The truth is you guys have some weird ethnic hatred going on and you're getting hundreds of thousands of people killed. You are all mentally unstable.

    You had the same style of argument with Covid. You went into hysterical personal attacks. You have a thin veneer of lawyerly dramatics without engaging the topic like a grown man.

    Replies: @HA

  156. @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation

    His plane went down after leaving Moscow and witnesses described explosions that are characteristic of a surface to air missile.

    Putin has killed his own allies for simply being against the war but you believe that assuming he killed Prigozhin is the stupid position?

    Why would the Ukrainians want to kill Prigozhin after he humiliated Putin? Why kill the thorn in the side of the dictator?

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance. "Russia had nothing to do with the kindergarten bombing that will happen tomorrow in Odessa. That was a Ukrainian false flag operation to make Russia look bad. " Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Putin came out with a statement and he said:


    And indeed, if they were there, the initial data seems to indicate that Wagner employees were also there, I would like to note that these are people who have made a significant contribution to our common cause of fighting the neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine.
     
    One of the guys who died was Utkin (AKA "Wagner" himself, because he admired the Nazi's favorite composer) who had neo-Nazi tattoos.

    https://romea.cz/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fromea.cz%2Fapp%2Fuploads%2F2022%2F02%2Futkin.jpg&w=640&q=75

    https://romea.cz/en/world/the-times-putin-has-sent-mercenaries-to-kyiv-led-by-an-admirer-of-the-nazis-to-murder-zelenskyy-and-the-klitschko-brothers

    So who are the Nazis here?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @John Johnson

  157. @HA
    @Zelo

    "You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard. You’re also being dishonest when you act like the 'troll propaganda'..."

    Riding his jock? The fanboys sure do love their porn metaphors, I'll give them that. Like the saying goes, you gotta write what you know -- no matter what it reveals about you. And as much as they dislike being called "fanboys", I'm getting the sense they can't take being called "trolls" either. What a bunch of whiners.

    And you'll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn't notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you're angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    And as for all that money Soros is tossing around to further Ukrainian support, it sure seems to have bypassed Unz-dot-com. The same cannot be said about Moscow trolls (and fellow travelers and useful idiots) who keep an active presence here. So much for your honesty.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Bardon Kaldian, @Zelo

    And you’ll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn’t notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you’re angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    It’s a very bizarre phenomenon that we have observed in Putin defenders since the beginning of the war.

    They seem obsessed with Zelensky and assume we idolize him like they do with Putin. They don’t seem to realize that they are usually the only ones talking about him. It’s a classic case of projection. They don’t get that we aren’t tribal alpha brained to Zelensky.

    Even stranger is that they think Zelensky is keeping Ukraine in the war. As if the country would accept Russian rule without him.

    Polls show that a strong majority of the Ukrainian public supports the war. Zelensky openly states that he defaults to his generals. Which means his replacement would continue the same policy.

    MacGregor and Ritter are the same way. They will speak of Zelensky as if he is also a dictator and has a cult following. They seem to view this as a war of competing dictators. When MacGregor speaks of Zelensky it looks like a vein is going to pop out of his head. He can’t talk about the war without mentioning Zelensky. The will denigrate him as an actor but then speak of him as he if has Jewish spell powers. No mention that Putin has closer ties to Israel and in fact Israel again turned down a weapons request from Ukraine.

    • Agree: Bardon Kaldian
    • Thanks: HA, Jack D
    • Replies: @HA
    @John Johnson

    "They seem obsessed with Zelensky and assume we idolize him like they do with Putin."

    They also don't want to mention the Ukrainian military leaders that Zelensky defers to, like Zaluzhny and Budanov, since for months they claimed both were dead (or sidelined after receiving a craniotomy), or else just deep fakes. So they're left with playing projection games about how it's actually Ukraine that is run by an increasingly unhinged dictator.

    Here's Budanov -- or some deep fake AI, depending on who you listen to -- trolling the Russians with a taste of their own medicine.

  158. @Frau Katze
    @Bardon Kaldian

    It’s worth noting that Stalin, one of the most brutal of the Russian/Soviet leaders, was an ethnic Georgian.

    Replies: @HA

    “It’s worth noting that Stalin, one of the most brutal of the Russian/Soviet leaders, was an ethnic Georgian.”

    It isn’t really all that noteworthy. Some say the greatest Greek of them all was a Macedonian hillbilly. Herr Über-Deutsche was actually an Austrian. And the Frenchiest of Frenchmen was arguably a certain Corsican. That’s just how it goes. Some of the most hard-core white supremacists out there have a decidedly non-Aryan grandparent or grandma they’re all “So what?” about.

    • Agree: Bardon Kaldian
  159. @Bardon Kaldian
    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine for many years. Prigogine was not just a scientist, but a deep thinking natural philosopher.

    Unlike most Nobelists in the past 50 or so years.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Esso, @Esso

    I have not read Prigogine first hand, but I understand his later alternative work in statistical physics was about irreversibility and “self-organisation”. And he tried to find some kind of general law governing them, something to do with nonlinear mathematics and chaos.

    I can sympathize with making connections between dissipation and work and computation and everything (organization, self- or not). It seems kind of obvious there is dissipation in everything. But why try to recover dissipation, which is associated with computation and measurement, which is to say particular and freely varying things, from a general law, why not just let it be? Natural laws are reversible (they act on everything the same and make no distinctions) so far as we know them. Chaos in mathematical physics (chaos in nature is another thing) is an artifact of classical theories.

    Prigožin, may he retire in peace. He was one of the loudest and most visible characters in our time. A very big shot in the ball mill that is Russia. He at the very least had an appearance of being a zealous patriot and looking after the wellbeing of his men. He did not discriminate (well maybe against gays and trannies) and gave opportunities to men from all walks of life. Eloquence was not his strong suit but I’m sure he made up for that by being more truthful than the national average. It was a glorious way to go, still I think he deserved better. We never thought he was going to die of old age.

  160. I’m focusing on the “presumed dead” part. I know there’s not much chance of the guy turning up with a bestseller survival story to parlay into a hit film starring… I don’t know, whatever trendy box office wunderkind that can kinda look like him with enough CG and prosthetics. It would do wonders for Wagner recruitment.

  161. The average Sailer headline is better than the average NYTimes article.

  162. @HA
    @YetAnotherAnon

    "SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States…"

    Try and keep up. I'm not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I'm not the hypocrite, here, I'm just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla... oh, wait, you're a fanboy. Never mind.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @AKAHorace

    NINE now…

    Just a thought – the Frogs do have previous in that they blew up a Greenpeace ship which was monitoring French nuclear testing way back in the 1970s.

    3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there’s a motive there…while Russia will miss these guys. Not a great PR week for Russia, although Saudis, Iran, Egypt and UAE joining BRICS is a biggie. Half the Middle East.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Service_de_documentation_ext%C3%A9rieure_et_de_contre-espionnage

    One SDECE agent, Philippe L. Thyaud de Vosjolo, wrote in his 1970 memoir Lamia: “Dozens of assassinations were carried out. Besides the use of guns or knives, more sophisticated methods had been perfected. Carbon dioxide guns ejecting small syringes had been purchased in the United States-but the SDECE people substituted the tranquilizing drug with a lethal poison. The victim showed all the symptoms of having suffered a heart attack”. Besides for members of the FLN, the SDECE killed left-wing French intellectuals who supported the FLN, arms dealers and other anti-French nationalists in Africa. The SDECE also engaged in hijacking six ships bound for Algeria with arms for the FLN between 1956–61, and blew up one ship packed with weapons for the FLN in Hamburg harbor with a naval mine.

    Never realised SDECE supported Quebec seperatists, but it makes sense.

    Now this is the reason why some people want to be President.

    “On the night of 13 May 1978, Denard and 42 other mercenaries landed on Grande Comore, almost effortlessly annihilated the Comorian forces and by the morning the Comoros was theirs. President Soilih was high on marijuana and naked in his bed together with three nude teenage schoolgirls watching a pornographic film, when Denard kicked in the door to his room to inform him that he was no longer president and had Soilih taken out to be “shot while trying to escape”.”

    They have form for inside Russia operations.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directorate-General_for_External_Security#2010s

    “In 2014, DGSE in a joint operation with AIVD, had successfully infiltrated and planted hidden cameras in Cyber Operations Center under SVR in Russia”

    • Replies: @HA
    @YetAnotherAnon

    "NINE now…"

    Again, try not to be a dullard. If I were criticizing others for posting too much while dispensing nine comments of my own, you'd have something worth arguing about. But I didn't do that, did I? I don't have a problem with Buzz's five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much. So go harangue him.

    "3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there’s a motive there…while Russia will miss these guys."

    I was assured by more than one fan of Lil' BB that Prigozhin's mutiny was actually an ingenious psy-op that would set-up Wagner so as to be able to attack Kyiv from Ukraine's nearby border with Belorussia. Lil' BB must never be under-appreciated!

    But since that hasn't played out according to plan, can we at least finally admit that Putin was an incompetent buffoon to let a bunch of mercenaries get as far as Voronezh in the first place? And why not arrest them then and there? I mean, did someone shoot down QAnon Shaman in a plane after Jan 6, or did they just arrest the guy, tell him to take off his Fred Flinstone hat, and get his contrite self into a courthouse at the duly appointed hour? You know, like actual functioning countries do?

    And in speaking of "motive", I take it you're going to rev us up for one more rousing cheer of "cui bono?", am I right? If so, you wouldn't be the first. But the problem with yammering cui bono whenever one has trouble coming up with an original thought is that there's an underlying assumption of competence, which is generally not how the world operates. I actually see people shoot themselves in the foot all the time on these threads. There's no "bono" there -- they just let a situation get way beyond whatever some competent person would have allowed. Which I'm thinking is what you and those like you need to acknowledge, if not about this crash (or assassination, if you insist), then about the mutiny that led up to the crash. Yes, I guess someone is slapping themselves on the back for skillfully slipping a bomb onto a plane or shooting the plane down with a well-aimed AA missile or somesuch, but no matter how many skilled somersaults the clown performs in order to put out the fire emanating from his backside, it's still a clown show whose plot line is one of ridiculous incompetence.

    But I guess an admission like that is asking for too much. No, I'm anticipating assurances that much like poor Gunga Din, squattin’ on the coals, and givin’ drink to poor damned souls far from the living Gawd that made 'im, Prigozhin will continue to do what he was doing earlier, but having graduated beyond recruiting prisoners, he'll now be conscripting the demons of hell to fight for his boss in what he'll argue is an easy transition, at which point the "gloves will finally come off", as Macgregor puts it, and we'll finally get that much-anticipated pincer movement that shoves the Ukrainians into a cauldron (and hey, the demons of hell know all about cauldrons).

    I.e. this is all just another brilliant psy-op just like that earlier mutiny was, and Putin, I'll be assured yet again, is the ever-competent genius he always was.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

  163. Anonymous[360] • Disclaimer says:
    @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA

    The Soviet N-1 rocket blew up because it had too many small engines clustered together in a desparate attempt to compensate for the fact that they could not match the American ability to build truly large engines.

    Hate to say it, but Elon Musk's giant rocket suffers from the same problem, and it blew up too.

    Russians have always tried to copy American things. When an American bomber crew had to make an emergency landing inside "their ally's" country, the Soviet Union, during WWII, the Russians impounded the American B-29 and never gave it back.

    They proceeded to copy everything in that plane, and thereafter generations of Russian bombers highly resembled the old B-29. Even their ancient but still in service Tu-95 still does in ways, with its piston engines and loud propellers. Propellers!

    Okay, so your reply has nothing at all to do with this American proxy war on present-day Russia. So, what is your point? Russians are funny, yes, but we don't have anything to do with them, so why do you care so much?

    Really, Why Do You -- and others like you -- Care So Much?

    Replies: @Diversity Heretic, @PhysicistDave, @HA, @Jim Don Bob, @Anonymous

    The N-1 was a workable design, but they killed the program early, the designers expected early failures (same as Space X) a large no of engines can work, but you need to test the engines, the Soviets didn’t test all the engines, they build the engines in batches of 10, randomly picked one engine and test fired it, if that engine passed they assumed the other 9 were also good, if they stuck with it, it would have worked, some with SpaceX and their Starship

  164. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    ‘If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that’s Putin, “pointlesswasteovich” ought to be the guy’s middle name.’

    Putin may have wanted to make a point. ‘If you try to do what dude did, I won’t surreptitiously try to poison you or something. I’ll just flat out kill you — and I won’t hide it. You can write pseudonymous posts on websites and live — you can’t do this.’

    …Putin apparently felt it necessary to unequivocally assert who was boss man. As Porfirio Diaz once said: ‘Senor, to rule Mexico a man must be more than honest.’

  165. Also on the plane was the #2 of wagner, so it’s a buy one get one free in terms of decapitations

  166. @Peter Akuleyev
    @Wokechoke

    Paris is still far less African than any major American city.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Mike Tre

    And your point is what, exactly?

    Paris is more African now than it was 50 years ago, when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction. So you don’t seem to have a point, unless it is to applaud the negrofication of the West.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Mike Tre


    when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction
     
    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites - especially Asians - seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    https://cdn.abcotvs.com/dip/images/6246380_061320-cc-ap-seattle-chaz-im.jpg

    Replies: @John Johnson

  167. @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast

    If it was the Russians who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. The wreckage was still burning and guys here were already posting denials and conspiracy theories. Like I said then, at least wait for the official Russian lie so that you can present a unified front like in the Communist days.

    Was it the Americans or the Ukrainians? A lot of the Rushists are trying to blur Ukraine/NATO together on every occasion because being defeated by NATO or the US looks better than being defeated by a bunch of Khokhols.

    It will be interesting to see IF there is an official Russian version, beyond "engine trouble". Are they working on concocting a story or is the silence deliberate because Prigozhin is an unperson now?

    Replies: @Peter Akuleyev, @Bardon Kaldian

    It says something about a country that speculations are, all of them, somehow naturally describing a gangster state.

  168. @HA
    @Zelo

    "You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard. You’re also being dishonest when you act like the 'troll propaganda'..."

    Riding his jock? The fanboys sure do love their porn metaphors, I'll give them that. Like the saying goes, you gotta write what you know -- no matter what it reveals about you. And as much as they dislike being called "fanboys", I'm getting the sense they can't take being called "trolls" either. What a bunch of whiners.

    And you'll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn't notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you're angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    And as for all that money Soros is tossing around to further Ukrainian support, it sure seems to have bypassed Unz-dot-com. The same cannot be said about Moscow trolls (and fellow travelers and useful idiots) who keep an active presence here. So much for your honesty.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Bardon Kaldian, @Zelo

    Everything aside, American Putin’s supporters are first & foremost moral abominations.

  169. @Pop Warner
    @Lurker

    Utkin was the actual military leader, and he was on the plane with Prigozhin. In hindsight, it would have been better to keep them separated because they should have known they would be targeted.

    Oh well. Putin seems hellbent on removing any competent commanders in favor of prolonging the war and getting more Russians killed. At this point, I would question whose side he's even on, because he seems to be handing victories to the West now.

    Replies: @Jack D, @Bill Jones

    Putin is on Putin’s side, just as he always has been. The name of the game is not winning in Ukraine (anymore) or conserving Russian lives (which it never was, other than Putin’s own) but keeping himself and his cronies in power.

    Prigozhin and Wagner challenged that so they had to go, even though they were in some respects valuable. Their value did not outweigh their danger. They had already been withdrawn from Ukraine so it will have no impact on that war. Presumably the Russian Army and the oligarchs will try to roll up what remains of Wagner in Belarus, Syria and Africa and bring them under their control. The Wagner leaders who are not dead (apparently there was a 2nd Wagner plane and according to rumor those on it were arrested when they landed) will be given the choice of swearing loyalty to Putin or unspecified consequences, keeping in mind the “assurances that Prigozhin himself had supposedly received.

    The best source for understanding all of this is watching The Godfather movies. If you think of Putin as the head of a powerful crime family, it all makes sense.

  170. @John Johnson
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation

    His plane went down after leaving Moscow and witnesses described explosions that are characteristic of a surface to air missile.

    Putin has killed his own allies for simply being against the war but you believe that assuming he killed Prigozhin is the stupid position?

    Why would the Ukrainians want to kill Prigozhin after he humiliated Putin? Why kill the thorn in the side of the dictator?

    https://s.france24.com/media/display/7edd66fa-41f2-11ee-bac9-005056a90284/eeb122432726dc3846b97722e326231de961ad02.jpg

    Replies: @Jack D

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance. “Russia had nothing to do with the kindergarten bombing that will happen tomorrow in Odessa. That was a Ukrainian false flag operation to make Russia look bad. ” Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Putin came out with a statement and he said:

    And indeed, if they were there, the initial data seems to indicate that Wagner employees were also there, I would like to note that these are people who have made a significant contribution to our common cause of fighting the neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine.

    One of the guys who died was Utkin (AKA “Wagner” himself, because he admired the Nazi’s favorite composer) who had neo-Nazi tattoos.

    https://romea.cz/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fromea.cz%2Fapp%2Fuploads%2F2022%2F02%2Futkin.jpg&w=640&q=75

    https://romea.cz/en/world/the-times-putin-has-sent-mercenaries-to-kyiv-led-by-an-admirer-of-the-nazis-to-murder-zelenskyy-and-the-klitschko-brothers

    So who are the Nazis here?

    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?
     
    He very well may do bad things but he doesn't do them to me.

    The idea that the American government can boast about killing Russians through a proxy and that this will have no future costs to the United States is simply ludicrous.

    Perhaps if these people wanted everyone to give Putin the Hitler treatment they shouldn't have fabricated an immense hoax within which roughly half the country was identified as Russian collaborators?

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @John Johnson
    @Jack D

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance.

    That's actually a really good point. Can the Putin defenders here agree that the next 5 atrocities will not be caused by Putin? Why or why not?

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Why would Ukraine/CIA/Shadow Jews conspire to take out Prigozhin after his armed rebellion? It doesn't make any sense.

    Originally they told us that Putin was playing 5d chess and Prighozhin's threats were all part of a ruse. Both Ritter and Moon of Alabama maintained that position. In fact MoA even mocked any suggestion that Prigozhin could be a threat.

    Now they are trying to believe that Putin didn't murder him because.......revenge would be out of character for him? The describe his war as revenge against the West.

    Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    It seems to me that a scripted bot could post for them:

    Clearly the (undesirable_event) was caused by (randomize:CIA/US/JEWs/NATO) and anyone who says otherwise is a (randomize:Idiot/Informant/Jew/Nazi). I heard recently on (randomize:MacGregor/Ritter/Tucker) that Ukraine will lose in (randomize(24 hours/2 weeks/1 month). I'm not one of those MSM bots like you. I have my own thoughts on (undesirable_event) thank you very much.

  171. @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "Really, Why Do You — and others like you — Care So Much?"

    Says the guy who, according to his comment history, has just posted (or in one case agreed with) FIVE comments on matters related to Russia -- one of which criticizes Steve's recent lack of posting on Russia.

    Maybe you should first take your own advice, fanboy, before pressing it on others.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”? It’s like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it’s obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”? It’s like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it’s obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?
     
    I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended.

    If that means Putin succeeds to some degree and makes gains in the former Ukraine then I can accept this circumstance. All the more if the result is a more stable geopolitical reality in Eastern Europe which halts provocative NATO expansion Eastward. Those people, nominally "Americans" are much more my enemy than Vladimir Putin or any Russian. The past years have made that fact plain.

    I don't believe I need to fool you for any purpose. What is happening is simply not in the interest of the United States and I feel very comfortable saying so unequivocally.

    Replies: @HA

    , @William Badwhite
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”?
     
    It doesn't, other than in your fevered mind. Not everyone shares your obsessions.

    Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

     

    More of your mind-reading. I can't for the life of me understand why so many other commenters call you dishonest.

    The last 15 or so comments on this thread are hilarious. Starting around 142 we get comments from: HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack. Complete with them thanking each other and calling people “Rushists” and “Putinists” and “fanboys” and then Johann “German Jack” Ricke, whose comment history consists mostly of agreeing with Jack, agreeing with Jack. You guys should start a band or something.

    Agree: Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA, @HA, @Mr Mox

  172. @For what it's worth
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "In any event, in a Democracy what you do is have four jurisdictional prosecutorial authorities indict Prigozhin and everyone he ever talked to ninety-one times in the span of a few months, you don’t kill him. Killing him is not who we are."

    I'd rather be indicted than murdered. So count me on Team Democracy, I guess.

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    I’d rather be indicted than murdered. So count me on Team Democracy, I guess.

    Would you rather live in a cage for all of the days of your dotage, or expire in an instant by way of an explosion and probably without any conscious understanding of the fact of your death?

  173. @Jack D
    @HA

    At what point does "I don't care about this war one way or the other" or "all I want is for the shooting to stop" become a thinly disguised version of "I really want Russia to win"? It's like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it's obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @William Badwhite

    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”? It’s like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it’s obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended.

    If that means Putin succeeds to some degree and makes gains in the former Ukraine then I can accept this circumstance. All the more if the result is a more stable geopolitical reality in Eastern Europe which halts provocative NATO expansion Eastward. Those people, nominally “Americans” are much more my enemy than Vladimir Putin or any Russian. The past years have made that fact plain.

    I don’t believe I need to fool you for any purpose. What is happening is simply not in the interest of the United States and I feel very comfortable saying so unequivocally.

    • Agree: Buzz Mohawk
    • Replies: @HA
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended."

    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated. But I see precious little evidence for that, and conclude that you're just fine with all that. To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it's actually America that's escalating us towards some Armageddon -- and that's not a problem, either.

    That being the case, you're about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called "peace advocates" were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn't at all surprising since it's coming from the very same sources.

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)

  174. @Jack D
    @HA

    At what point does "I don't care about this war one way or the other" or "all I want is for the shooting to stop" become a thinly disguised version of "I really want Russia to win"? It's like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it's obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @William Badwhite

    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”?

    It doesn’t, other than in your fevered mind. Not everyone shares your obsessions.

    Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

    More of your mind-reading. I can’t for the life of me understand why so many other commenters call you dishonest.

    The last 15 or so comments on this thread are hilarious. Starting around 142 we get comments from: HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack. Complete with them thanking each other and calling people “Rushists” and “Putinists” and “fanboys” and then Johann “German Jack” Ricke, whose comment history consists mostly of agreeing with Jack, agreeing with Jack. You guys should start a band or something.

    Agree: Johann Ricke

    • Agree: William Badwhite, MGB
    • LOL: res
    • Replies: @HA
    @William Badwhite

    "HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack."

    Oh, OK, I get it. You don't want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win. You're not obsessed with Putin at all -- you just really need to be seeking professional help for your manic I-see-him-everywhere obsession with Jack.

    Just for you, I stuck "anti-obsession medication" into Google MD, and it says your doctor might at some point suggest Anafranil or Prozac. Consider that a heads-up.

    Replies: @William Badwhite

    , @HA
    @William Badwhite

    "HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack."

    Also note the anomalous "poor FRAU KATZE". I.e. as obsessed as he is with outsider and "Foreign" Jacks, and really any Jacks at all, he somehow failed to notice that he wound up favoring and empathizing someone whose name is explicitly foreign. It's like the last few lines of some rightfully forgotten O. Henry story that an editor trashcanned because it was too obviously fictional.

    , @Mr Mox
    @William Badwhite

    You guys should start a band or something.

    But what should they call the band? "Pavlov's Dogs" perhaps? Whenever Russia/Putin Ukraine/Zelensky is mentioned, they predictably pop up and start salivating.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Mike Tre

  175. @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance. "Russia had nothing to do with the kindergarten bombing that will happen tomorrow in Odessa. That was a Ukrainian false flag operation to make Russia look bad. " Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Putin came out with a statement and he said:


    And indeed, if they were there, the initial data seems to indicate that Wagner employees were also there, I would like to note that these are people who have made a significant contribution to our common cause of fighting the neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine.
     
    One of the guys who died was Utkin (AKA "Wagner" himself, because he admired the Nazi's favorite composer) who had neo-Nazi tattoos.

    https://romea.cz/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fromea.cz%2Fapp%2Fuploads%2F2022%2F02%2Futkin.jpg&w=640&q=75

    https://romea.cz/en/world/the-times-putin-has-sent-mercenaries-to-kyiv-led-by-an-admirer-of-the-nazis-to-murder-zelenskyy-and-the-klitschko-brothers

    So who are the Nazis here?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @John Johnson

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    He very well may do bad things but he doesn’t do them to me.

    The idea that the American government can boast about killing Russians through a proxy and that this will have no future costs to the United States is simply ludicrous.

    Perhaps if these people wanted everyone to give Putin the Hitler treatment they shouldn’t have fabricated an immense hoax within which roughly half the country was identified as Russian collaborators?

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    Ah, the "No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger" argument.

    First of all, you, unlike some folks here, actually admit that Putin does bad things. The ink wasn't even dry on the headlines before some people here started saying that it was a US or Ukrainian operation or maybe it didn't even happen or whatever. Anything but what it appeared to be on its face, which was that Putin was taking revenge on his enemies as he often does.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn't done anything to you YET doesn't mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Probably Ali was right that the Vietnamese Communists mostly just wanted hegemony over all of Vietnam and were not coming for Honolulu or even Tokyo. However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over "Russian World" and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy given the current day reality of Russia where they have to depend on Iran for drones but if a genie gave Putin 3 wishes this would be one of them. If he doesn't achieve it in his lifetime, it won't be for lack of trying. If he can't have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Alec Leamas (working from home), @dimples

  176. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    I don’t know why you talk so much about Russians. Croats are basically Catholic Turks and Gypsies who are best known for torturing and slaughtering elderly civilians:

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/croats-slaughter-elderly-by-the-dozen-1600351.html

    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @Anonymous

    Our people don't fully understand how much we reset them with that Storm.

    The political and geographical capital of 2 Serbian uprisings, 2 Balkan wars, 2 world wars went to dust and ashes in 2 months of 1995.

    Two hundred years of the development of the Serbian state and Serbian political thought, expansion and unification of the Serbs on both sides of the Drina river (Greater Serbia) imploded epically and irretrievably went into the dustbin of history.

    In addition, we destroyed the image of them, dominant among their Western allies as the victorious side, and those who comforted them, rooted for them and let them rule from Karavanke to Vardar are now playing tricks on them with genocide and Kosovo.

    Bonus points for Tuđman, he directly knocked Montenegro and Kosovo out of Serbia with an epic defeat - nobody wants to be part of a defeated and hated country.

    And what would have happened if we had continued and taken Banja Luka, we would have dismantled them like Stalin Germany’s imperial ambitions- forever.

    Replies: @Anonymous

  177. @JohnnyWalker123
    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would've stayed in Belarus.

    If he really didn't care that much about his life, he should've just attempted to topple Putin during his initial rebellion. I don't even understand why he retreated after coming so close to Moscow.

    He's an enigmatic & nonsensical character.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Wokechoke, @Mr. XYZ, @SFG, @John Johnson

    Why the hell did Yevgeny Prigozhin go back to Russia? If I was Prigozhin, I would’ve stayed in Belarus.

    Because he is the same reckless person that:
    1. Was rich but chose to be a war general in a hot zone
    2. Tried making a deal with the Ukrainians that would kill Rusians
    3. Defied the Kremlin’s orders and may have tried instigating a coup

    The fact that he went to Belarus was nuts. He should have taken his gold to Argentina and setup a lair.

    We will probably never know what made him tick. A Batman type nemesis that expects to go down in flames.

  178. @Reg Cæsar
    @Bardon Kaldian


    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine
     
    There are enough transliterations into English to keep track of. You expect us to recognize those into Walloon?


    https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/web1_coup-niger-1280x720.jpg


    https://www.sidechef.com/recipe/c30095ea-c83d-4c29-9757-6819664c3f64.png?d=1408x1120

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Cagey Beast

    That second photo is some nasty looking poutine. Those aren’t cheese curds and the gravy is cold. The fries look like they’re battered too. Three failures out of three ingredients.

    Good lobster poutine is much better but it’s a dish you have to split with someone else; too heavy otherwise.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Cagey Beast

    The Manx were making poutine a good century before the Canucks. It's their national dish. But give a knockoff a French name, and it takes off.

    Same thing happened with sudoku, which was invented in Indiana.

  179. @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW'S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance. "Russia had nothing to do with the kindergarten bombing that will happen tomorrow in Odessa. That was a Ukrainian false flag operation to make Russia look bad. " Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Putin came out with a statement and he said:


    And indeed, if they were there, the initial data seems to indicate that Wagner employees were also there, I would like to note that these are people who have made a significant contribution to our common cause of fighting the neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine.
     
    One of the guys who died was Utkin (AKA "Wagner" himself, because he admired the Nazi's favorite composer) who had neo-Nazi tattoos.

    https://romea.cz/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fromea.cz%2Fapp%2Fuploads%2F2022%2F02%2Futkin.jpg&w=640&q=75

    https://romea.cz/en/world/the-times-putin-has-sent-mercenaries-to-kyiv-led-by-an-admirer-of-the-nazis-to-murder-zelenskyy-and-the-klitschko-brothers

    So who are the Nazis here?

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home), @John Johnson

    ID is behind the 8 ball in denying YESTERDAY’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY. The really smart Rushists deny TOMORROW’S RUSSIAN ATROCITY in advance.

    That’s actually a really good point. Can the Putin defenders here agree that the next 5 atrocities will not be caused by Putin? Why or why not?

    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?

    Why would Ukraine/CIA/Shadow Jews conspire to take out Prigozhin after his armed rebellion? It doesn’t make any sense.

    Originally they told us that Putin was playing 5d chess and Prighozhin’s threats were all part of a ruse. Both Ritter and Moon of Alabama maintained that position. In fact MoA even mocked any suggestion that Prigozhin could be a threat.

    Now they are trying to believe that Putin didn’t murder him because…….revenge would be out of character for him? The describe his war as revenge against the West.

    Normally they wait until 5 minutes after the atrocity to deny it, whatever it is, but the smart move is to deny it in advance so you can be the first.

    It seems to me that a scripted bot could post for them:

    Clearly the (undesirable_event) was caused by (randomize:CIA/US/JEWs/NATO) and anyone who says otherwise is a (randomize:Idiot/Informant/Jew/Nazi). I heard recently on (randomize:MacGregor/Ritter/Tucker) that Ukraine will lose in (randomize(24 hours/2 weeks/1 month). I’m not one of those MSM bots like you. I have my own thoughts on (undesirable_event) thank you very much.

    • LOL: Jack D
  180. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    Does Putin or Russia EVER do anything bad or it is ALWAYS a Ukrainian/NATO/US false flag operation?
     
    He very well may do bad things but he doesn't do them to me.

    The idea that the American government can boast about killing Russians through a proxy and that this will have no future costs to the United States is simply ludicrous.

    Perhaps if these people wanted everyone to give Putin the Hitler treatment they shouldn't have fabricated an immense hoax within which roughly half the country was identified as Russian collaborators?

    Replies: @Jack D

    Ah, the “No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger” argument.

    First of all, you, unlike some folks here, actually admit that Putin does bad things. The ink wasn’t even dry on the headlines before some people here started saying that it was a US or Ukrainian operation or maybe it didn’t even happen or whatever. Anything but what it appeared to be on its face, which was that Putin was taking revenge on his enemies as he often does.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Probably Ali was right that the Vietnamese Communists mostly just wanted hegemony over all of Vietnam and were not coming for Honolulu or even Tokyo. However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over “Russian World” and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy given the current day reality of Russia where they have to depend on Iran for drones but if a genie gave Putin 3 wishes this would be one of them. If he doesn’t achieve it in his lifetime, it won’t be for lack of trying. If he can’t have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Jack D


    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.
     
    "Waited too long" to do what?

    How would you specifically prevent the “bad man” from doing something bad to you?

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    Ah, the “No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger” argument.
     
    Is it an argument? I rather see it as an acknowledgement that our interests don't conflict.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.
     
    Perhaps it has escaped your notice that the U.S. has gone around the world during the past 20 years or so killing bad men first so they can't kill us later (well, sometimes we help bad men hurt the worse men, or sometimes the bad men become 'moderate rebels' - aw hell, you get it). I don't see this as having been good policy. It's not our job to get rid of all of the World's bad men.

    However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over “Russian World” and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.
     
    I very much doubt that even my summer home is situate within the bounds of Putin's expansionist "Russian World."

    If he doesn’t achieve it in his lifetime, it won’t be for lack of trying. If he can’t have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.
     
    Well, it seems he's positively stuffed with a few parts of Eastern Ukraine. I think I will be able to dine in peace myself.

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @dimples
    @Jack D

    "In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy.......".

    It sure does, although it may work after Fatmerika becomes overrun with wetbacks. The taxes just won't be there to pay for all the totalitarian accessories.

  181. • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @Cagey Beast

    This explains a lot. White carpet and white leather. That's just asking for trouble right there. Spill one glass of Cabernet and the whole plane is ruined. A disaster waiting to happen.

  182. @Bardon Kaldian
    Momentarily putting aside Ukrainian heroic-tragic birth of the nation, I am always reminded of the complete misfire of Russians with imperialist Euro-Asian savagery. The worst part of their complex identity has resurfaced & is dragging them down into the abyss.

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony .... to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common. Neither in looks nor in cultural code nor in historical destiny.

    One can appreciate those old & populous counties from an emotional-cultural distance, but that's all.

    Two great European peoples, Germans and Russians, have infinite capacity for causing misery both to themselves & to others.

    Replies: @Wokechoke, @HA, @Loyalty Over IQ Worship, @YetAnotherAnon, @Anon 2, @SFG, @Ennui, @BB753, @Frau Katze, @Anonymous, @vinteuil

    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common.

    BK, are you under the impression that Paris today is the Paris of Proust & Debussy?

    When was the last time anybody in Western Europe or the USA wrote a genuinely great ballet, novel or symphony?

    Well, OK, there’s Stravinsky’s Orfeo, there’s Nabokov’s Lolita, there’s Shostakovich’s 15th…

    Uh-oh…

    • Replies: @Bardon Kaldian
    @vinteuil

    When anyone from indigenous South Africa wrote anything worth reading?

    Replies: @vinteuil

  183. @YetAnotherAnon
    @HA

    NINE now...

    Just a thought - the Frogs do have previous in that they blew up a Greenpeace ship which was monitoring French nuclear testing way back in the 1970s.

    3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there's a motive there...while Russia will miss these guys. Not a great PR week for Russia, although Saudis, Iran, Egypt and UAE joining BRICS is a biggie. Half the Middle East.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Service_de_documentation_ext%C3%A9rieure_et_de_contre-espionnage


    One SDECE agent, Philippe L. Thyaud de Vosjolo, wrote in his 1970 memoir Lamia: "Dozens of assassinations were carried out. Besides the use of guns or knives, more sophisticated methods had been perfected. Carbon dioxide guns ejecting small syringes had been purchased in the United States-but the SDECE people substituted the tranquilizing drug with a lethal poison. The victim showed all the symptoms of having suffered a heart attack". Besides for members of the FLN, the SDECE killed left-wing French intellectuals who supported the FLN, arms dealers and other anti-French nationalists in Africa. The SDECE also engaged in hijacking six ships bound for Algeria with arms for the FLN between 1956–61, and blew up one ship packed with weapons for the FLN in Hamburg harbor with a naval mine.
     
    Never realised SDECE supported Quebec seperatists, but it makes sense.

    Now this is the reason why some people want to be President.


    "On the night of 13 May 1978, Denard and 42 other mercenaries landed on Grande Comore, almost effortlessly annihilated the Comorian forces and by the morning the Comoros was theirs. President Soilih was high on marijuana and naked in his bed together with three nude teenage schoolgirls watching a pornographic film, when Denard kicked in the door to his room to inform him that he was no longer president and had Soilih taken out to be "shot while trying to escape"."

     
    They have form for inside Russia operations.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directorate-General_for_External_Security#2010s


    "In 2014, DGSE in a joint operation with AIVD, had successfully infiltrated and planted hidden cameras in Cyber Operations Center under SVR in Russia"
     

    Replies: @HA

    “NINE now…”

    Again, try not to be a dullard. If I were criticizing others for posting too much while dispensing nine comments of my own, you’d have something worth arguing about. But I didn’t do that, did I? I don’t have a problem with Buzz’s five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much. So go harangue him.

    “3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there’s a motive there…while Russia will miss these guys.”

    I was assured by more than one fan of Lil’ BB that Prigozhin’s mutiny was actually an ingenious psy-op that would set-up Wagner so as to be able to attack Kyiv from Ukraine’s nearby border with Belorussia. Lil’ BB must never be under-appreciated!

    But since that hasn’t played out according to plan, can we at least finally admit that Putin was an incompetent buffoon to let a bunch of mercenaries get as far as Voronezh in the first place? And why not arrest them then and there? I mean, did someone shoot down QAnon Shaman in a plane after Jan 6, or did they just arrest the guy, tell him to take off his Fred Flinstone hat, and get his contrite self into a courthouse at the duly appointed hour? You know, like actual functioning countries do?

    And in speaking of “motive”, I take it you’re going to rev us up for one more rousing cheer of “cui bono?”, am I right? If so, you wouldn’t be the first. But the problem with yammering cui bono whenever one has trouble coming up with an original thought is that there’s an underlying assumption of competence, which is generally not how the world operates. I actually see people shoot themselves in the foot all the time on these threads. There’s no “bono” there — they just let a situation get way beyond whatever some competent person would have allowed. Which I’m thinking is what you and those like you need to acknowledge, if not about this crash (or assassination, if you insist), then about the mutiny that led up to the crash. Yes, I guess someone is slapping themselves on the back for skillfully slipping a bomb onto a plane or shooting the plane down with a well-aimed AA missile or somesuch, but no matter how many skilled somersaults the clown performs in order to put out the fire emanating from his backside, it’s still a clown show whose plot line is one of ridiculous incompetence.

    But I guess an admission like that is asking for too much. No, I’m anticipating assurances that much like poor Gunga Din, squattin’ on the coals, and givin’ drink to poor damned souls far from the living Gawd that made ‘im, Prigozhin will continue to do what he was doing earlier, but having graduated beyond recruiting prisoners, he’ll now be conscripting the demons of hell to fight for his boss in what he’ll argue is an easy transition, at which point the “gloves will finally come off”, as Macgregor puts it, and we’ll finally get that much-anticipated pincer movement that shoves the Ukrainians into a cauldron (and hey, the demons of hell know all about cauldrons).

    I.e. this is all just another brilliant psy-op just like that earlier mutiny was, and Putin, I’ll be assured yet again, is the ever-competent genius he always was.

    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA


    I don’t have a problem with Buzz’s five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much.
     
    Well, I think now you and some others have demonstrated once again what I was referring to. I've lost count of how many comments you and your fellows here have made here now about this.

    My point was not about what you and others had written in this thread at that point. No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war.

    Now you have proven my point. Not only that, but we get Jack D deceptively trying to put me and anyone like-minded into a false dichotomy of either supporting your war or supporting Putin!

    This is ridiculous, and other commenters here have made it clear that they too can see the same things I see coming from you and your buddies here.

    Replies: @HA

  184. @Mark G.
    @Hypnotoad666


    Steve only posts about Ukraine when the Deep State has something to cheer about. As a result, he hasn’t posted much.
     
    This is just a subjective impression on my part, but the amount of mainstream media coverage of the Ukraine-Russia war seems to be diminishing. The public appears to be souring on our involvement. A recent CNN poll shows a majority of Americans now oppose further military assistance to the Ukraine.

    Paying less attention to what is happening on the other side of the planet is a good thing. We have serious problems here at home we need to focus on like controlling our borders, reducing crime, making Social Security solvent for the long term and decreasing our expanding federal government deficits.

    Americans have been kicking the can down the road for decades when it comes to dealing with our problems. They were able to do this because the Boomers entered their peak productive years in the nineteen eighties, and this led to economic growth. For example, Boomers like Steve Jobs and Bill Gates. This large generation is now in the process of retiring. We will be seeing drops in tax revenue, declines in economic growth and rapid increases in spending on Social Security and Medicare.

    Replies: @Renard, @Dennis Dale

    But it’s not “happening on the other side of the world”, it originated here. It’s being propagandized here, funded from here, and it’s distorting our politics here. It’s happening because people in our government think it serves our national interests (or other interests). That Ukrainians and Russians are doing all the dying just makes it more criminal.
    It’s not a distraction, it’s another grand criminal enterprise.

    • Replies: @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    At this point I have more respect for those who make an amoral, imperial argument on behalf of our involvement than those who make the moral argument or simply take cover in Putin’s demonization.
    Except the former don’t exist, at least not publicly.
    And the argument is there. The people behind this probably think they’re forestalling a painful decline that is inevitable if we don’t weaken China by fracturing the natural advantage of the Eurasian land mass, soon to be dominated economically by China.
    Where are these people? When is someone going to grab me by the collar and say “listen Dennis, you want your grandchildren to starve speaking Chinese?! You better sprout a pair right now a get with the program!”

    Not that it would change my mind but it would, perversely, restore a small measure of my faith in humanity.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

  185. @William Badwhite
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”?
     
    It doesn't, other than in your fevered mind. Not everyone shares your obsessions.

    Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

     

    More of your mind-reading. I can't for the life of me understand why so many other commenters call you dishonest.

    The last 15 or so comments on this thread are hilarious. Starting around 142 we get comments from: HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack. Complete with them thanking each other and calling people “Rushists” and “Putinists” and “fanboys” and then Johann “German Jack” Ricke, whose comment history consists mostly of agreeing with Jack, agreeing with Jack. You guys should start a band or something.

    Agree: Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA, @HA, @Mr Mox

    “HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack.”

    Oh, OK, I get it. You don’t want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win. You’re not obsessed with Putin at all — you just really need to be seeking professional help for your manic I-see-him-everywhere obsession with Jack.

    Just for you, I stuck “anti-obsession medication” into Google MD, and it says your doctor might at some point suggest Anafranil or Prozac. Consider that a heads-up.

    • Replies: @William Badwhite
    @HA

    Lol two more comments from Hysterical Ass. Btw, I'm laughing at you, not with you.


    Oh, OK, I get it. You don’t want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win.
     
    Unlike you, I'm aware that neither of us have any say in whether Putin "wins" or not. Your desperate need to win the internet and have every commenter here agree with you is...certainly interesting, but your endless walls of text aren't going to actually change anything. What could change things would be for you and Jack to stop blathering endlessly on here and go volunteer in the Ukraine. They are accepting volunteers.

    Just for you, I stuck “anti-obsession medication” into Google MD,
     
    Two uses of "obsession" by a guy with 14 (so far) comments on this thread. Pot meet kettle.


    Consider that a heads-up.
     
    Thanks Internet Toughie.

    Agree: Jack D, HA, Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA

  186. @p38ace
    This is most unusual. Putin's enemies tend to fall out of buildings.

    Replies: @Haxo Angmark

    …or walk into a poisoned umbrella.

  187. Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    What are you saying? It would be of poor character?

    By someone who started a 1930s style invasion when the world was recovering from COVID? A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?

    Eliminating a threat to his power during BRICS would be crossing some type poor taste line?

    This is the dictator that just gave someone 10 years for answering a street interview incorrectly. Can provide a source if you would like.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

  188. @HA
    @Zelo

    "You Zelensky fanboys have been riding his jock pretty hard. You’re also being dishonest when you act like the 'troll propaganda'..."

    Riding his jock? The fanboys sure do love their porn metaphors, I'll give them that. Like the saying goes, you gotta write what you know -- no matter what it reveals about you. And as much as they dislike being called "fanboys", I'm getting the sense they can't take being called "trolls" either. What a bunch of whiners.

    And you'll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn't notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you're angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    And as for all that money Soros is tossing around to further Ukrainian support, it sure seems to have bypassed Unz-dot-com. The same cannot be said about Moscow trolls (and fellow travelers and useful idiots) who keep an active presence here. So much for your honesty.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Bardon Kaldian, @Zelo

    Your little feelings get upset when the Fanboy accusation is turned back on you. The truth is you guys have some weird ethnic hatred going on and you’re getting hundreds of thousands of people killed. You are all mentally unstable.

    You had the same style of argument with Covid. You went into hysterical personal attacks. You have a thin veneer of lawyerly dramatics without engaging the topic like a grown man.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Zelo

    "Your little feelings get upset when the Fanboy accusation is turned back on you."

    My "little" feelings? And where do you get "upset"? a I'm just pointing out that as of 134 comments in, no one had bothered to even mention Zelensky until you yourself did. So your accusation makes no sense whatsoever outside the fiction you spin in your own head, as John Johnson elaborated.

    And none of that is a "personal" attack, except the part about "little", and you're the one who pitched that. The crack about porn metaphors? Yeah, that was arguably personal, but you're the one who chose to go there, and having done so, you don't get to to lecture others on "engaging like a grown man" without being called out as the laughably hypocritical buffoon that you are. If you think that's too personal, stop throwing so much of your personal baggage into your comments.

  189. @Cagey Beast
    https://twitter.com/narrative_hole/status/1694835210343334238?s=20

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

    This explains a lot. White carpet and white leather. That’s just asking for trouble right there. Spill one glass of Cabernet and the whole plane is ruined. A disaster waiting to happen.

    • LOL: kaganovitch
  190. @Pop Warner
    @Lurker

    Utkin was the actual military leader, and he was on the plane with Prigozhin. In hindsight, it would have been better to keep them separated because they should have known they would be targeted.

    Oh well. Putin seems hellbent on removing any competent commanders in favor of prolonging the war and getting more Russians killed. At this point, I would question whose side he's even on, because he seems to be handing victories to the West now.

    Replies: @Jack D, @Bill Jones

    I like your confidence in asserting that you know who was on the plane.

  191. @Bardon Kaldian
    @Ennui

    Yet another example of black-and -white approach. Putin is anti-Peter in his activity & his ideological struggle against Westernization is the best example of how he is deeply historically wrong. His, and those Russians who support him, is a collective emotional-cognitive defeat of epic proportions.

    That goes far beyond geopolitics, NATO or gays. Russia under Putin is committing a national suicide because she has unleashed the worst Asiatic traits in collective identity/being & has explicitly denied its "racial"-cultural-historical identity through a pack of lies & civilizational orientation toward China, India, Iran, Turkey... countries completely alien & historical enemies of Russia.

    That is a truly epic identitarian disorder & derangement.

    Replies: @Loyalty Over IQ Worship

    Why do you put “racial” identity in quotes? You don’t think race is real?

  192. @William Badwhite
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”?
     
    It doesn't, other than in your fevered mind. Not everyone shares your obsessions.

    Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

     

    More of your mind-reading. I can't for the life of me understand why so many other commenters call you dishonest.

    The last 15 or so comments on this thread are hilarious. Starting around 142 we get comments from: HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack. Complete with them thanking each other and calling people “Rushists” and “Putinists” and “fanboys” and then Johann “German Jack” Ricke, whose comment history consists mostly of agreeing with Jack, agreeing with Jack. You guys should start a band or something.

    Agree: Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA, @HA, @Mr Mox

    “HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack.”

    Also note the anomalous “poor FRAU KATZE”. I.e. as obsessed as he is with outsider and “Foreign” Jacks, and really any Jacks at all, he somehow failed to notice that he wound up favoring and empathizing someone whose name is explicitly foreign. It’s like the last few lines of some rightfully forgotten O. Henry story that an editor trashcanned because it was too obviously fictional.

  193. @HA
    @YetAnotherAnon

    "NINE now…"

    Again, try not to be a dullard. If I were criticizing others for posting too much while dispensing nine comments of my own, you'd have something worth arguing about. But I didn't do that, did I? I don't have a problem with Buzz's five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much. So go harangue him.

    "3 senior Wagner leaders have apparently gone. Certainly there’s a motive there…while Russia will miss these guys."

    I was assured by more than one fan of Lil' BB that Prigozhin's mutiny was actually an ingenious psy-op that would set-up Wagner so as to be able to attack Kyiv from Ukraine's nearby border with Belorussia. Lil' BB must never be under-appreciated!

    But since that hasn't played out according to plan, can we at least finally admit that Putin was an incompetent buffoon to let a bunch of mercenaries get as far as Voronezh in the first place? And why not arrest them then and there? I mean, did someone shoot down QAnon Shaman in a plane after Jan 6, or did they just arrest the guy, tell him to take off his Fred Flinstone hat, and get his contrite self into a courthouse at the duly appointed hour? You know, like actual functioning countries do?

    And in speaking of "motive", I take it you're going to rev us up for one more rousing cheer of "cui bono?", am I right? If so, you wouldn't be the first. But the problem with yammering cui bono whenever one has trouble coming up with an original thought is that there's an underlying assumption of competence, which is generally not how the world operates. I actually see people shoot themselves in the foot all the time on these threads. There's no "bono" there -- they just let a situation get way beyond whatever some competent person would have allowed. Which I'm thinking is what you and those like you need to acknowledge, if not about this crash (or assassination, if you insist), then about the mutiny that led up to the crash. Yes, I guess someone is slapping themselves on the back for skillfully slipping a bomb onto a plane or shooting the plane down with a well-aimed AA missile or somesuch, but no matter how many skilled somersaults the clown performs in order to put out the fire emanating from his backside, it's still a clown show whose plot line is one of ridiculous incompetence.

    But I guess an admission like that is asking for too much. No, I'm anticipating assurances that much like poor Gunga Din, squattin’ on the coals, and givin’ drink to poor damned souls far from the living Gawd that made 'im, Prigozhin will continue to do what he was doing earlier, but having graduated beyond recruiting prisoners, he'll now be conscripting the demons of hell to fight for his boss in what he'll argue is an easy transition, at which point the "gloves will finally come off", as Macgregor puts it, and we'll finally get that much-anticipated pincer movement that shoves the Ukrainians into a cauldron (and hey, the demons of hell know all about cauldrons).

    I.e. this is all just another brilliant psy-op just like that earlier mutiny was, and Putin, I'll be assured yet again, is the ever-competent genius he always was.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

    I don’t have a problem with Buzz’s five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much.

    Well, I think now you and some others have demonstrated once again what I was referring to. I’ve lost count of how many comments you and your fellows here have made here now about this.

    My point was not about what you and others had written in this thread at that point. No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war.

    Now you have proven my point. Not only that, but we get Jack D deceptively trying to put me and anyone like-minded into a false dichotomy of either supporting your war or supporting Putin!

    This is ridiculous, and other commenters here have made it clear that they too can see the same things I see coming from you and your buddies here.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war."

    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?, trying to tell us that everything you yourself have managed to invest in this thread is all red, white and yankee-doodle blue but anyone who goes beyond that -- and who is NOT an enthusiastic fanboy (because for some strange reason, you have no problem whatsoever with them) -- is acting so bizarrely that they warrant an interrogation.

    You and your fellow fanboys (or useful idiots, as the case may be) might not see the comedy in all that. I do. I'll say this much -- your primary conception of being an American is that no real American could know the things this person knows, or care about that place over there -- i.e. it is, at its core, an appeal to ignorance and provincialism (not to mention a pathetic lack of self-awareness). Spare me. You and I obviously read the lessons of the history of the last century very differently. I'm not interested in repeating any of that. You are content to remain "indifferent".

    And by the way, why is it the most die-hard Americans who demand the rest of us to be as ignorant as they are about the outside world, and to not "care so much", always seem to boast of their foreign wives, be it from Romania or Georgia or wherever, or else mope about their thwarted hankering to scoot off to Beijing were it not for the fact that they don't know Mandarin, or that their progeny needs more than tiger penis and rhino horn and the placebo effect to keep them functioning at optimum level -- demonstrating to all of us that they are actually the ones who were "just visiting").? Weird how with some people, it's always 'do as I say and not as I do', hoping all the while that the rest of us won't notice your hypocrisy. Sorry, Buzz, I ain't having it. You had your chance to mind your own business and avoid "foreign entanglements" whether on your own, or vicariously through your spouse. As it is, in for a penny, in for a pound.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

  194. @HA
    @William Badwhite

    "HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack."

    Oh, OK, I get it. You don't want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win. You're not obsessed with Putin at all -- you just really need to be seeking professional help for your manic I-see-him-everywhere obsession with Jack.

    Just for you, I stuck "anti-obsession medication" into Google MD, and it says your doctor might at some point suggest Anafranil or Prozac. Consider that a heads-up.

    Replies: @William Badwhite

    Lol two more comments from Hysterical Ass. Btw, I’m laughing at you, not with you.

    Oh, OK, I get it. You don’t want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win.

    Unlike you, I’m aware that neither of us have any say in whether Putin “wins” or not. Your desperate need to win the internet and have every commenter here agree with you is…certainly interesting, but your endless walls of text aren’t going to actually change anything. What could change things would be for you and Jack to stop blathering endlessly on here and go volunteer in the Ukraine. They are accepting volunteers.

    Just for you, I stuck “anti-obsession medication” into Google MD,

    Two uses of “obsession” by a guy with 14 (so far) comments on this thread. Pot meet kettle.

    Consider that a heads-up.

    Thanks Internet Toughie.

    Agree: Jack D, HA, Johann Ricke

    • Thanks: YetAnotherAnon, Mark G.
    • Replies: @HA
    @William Badwhite

    "but your endless walls of text aren’t going to actually change anything."

    When you devote a proportional amount of your obsessing to quelling all the commentary from the fanboys as you do to mine, get back to me.

    Until then, reflect on the fact that you hectoring me won't change anything what I write either, and evidently, that's still not enough to shut YOU up. No, you still gotta have your chance to spew. So much for your objections to pointless commentary that leads nowhere. Seems to me you're pretty fine with it, after all.

    "Two uses of “obsession” by a guy with 14 (so far) comments on this thread. Pot meet kettle."

    As opposed to the implicit notion that seeing 11, count 'em 11, emanations of Jack is perfectly sane and healthy? Also note that a significant portion of my comments happen only because people -- like you, for example -- feel they need to reply to what I say. I have no problem with that, but I might just want a chance to return the favor. If you want me to write less, maybe give your own keyboard a rest next time you want to respond to me.

    The responsibility for those 14 comments is shared among all those who kept the discussion going. Whereas seeing 11 versions of Jack? That's pretty much all on you. Womp womp.

  195. @Cagey Beast
    @Reg Cæsar

    That second photo is some nasty looking poutine. Those aren't cheese curds and the gravy is cold. The fries look like they're battered too. Three failures out of three ingredients.

    Good lobster poutine is much better but it's a dish you have to split with someone else; too heavy otherwise.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    The Manx were making poutine a good century before the Canucks. It’s their national dish. But give a knockoff a French name, and it takes off.

    Same thing happened with sudoku, which was invented in Indiana.

  196. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA


    I don’t have a problem with Buzz’s five comments. I do have a problem with him plugging five comments and then complaining in answer to my first about how I comment too much.
     
    Well, I think now you and some others have demonstrated once again what I was referring to. I've lost count of how many comments you and your fellows here have made here now about this.

    My point was not about what you and others had written in this thread at that point. No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war.

    Now you have proven my point. Not only that, but we get Jack D deceptively trying to put me and anyone like-minded into a false dichotomy of either supporting your war or supporting Putin!

    This is ridiculous, and other commenters here have made it clear that they too can see the same things I see coming from you and your buddies here.

    Replies: @HA

    “No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war.”

    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?, trying to tell us that everything you yourself have managed to invest in this thread is all red, white and yankee-doodle blue but anyone who goes beyond that — and who is NOT an enthusiastic fanboy (because for some strange reason, you have no problem whatsoever with them) — is acting so bizarrely that they warrant an interrogation.

    You and your fellow fanboys (or useful idiots, as the case may be) might not see the comedy in all that. I do. I’ll say this much — your primary conception of being an American is that no real American could know the things this person knows, or care about that place over there — i.e. it is, at its core, an appeal to ignorance and provincialism (not to mention a pathetic lack of self-awareness). Spare me. You and I obviously read the lessons of the history of the last century very differently. I’m not interested in repeating any of that. You are content to remain “indifferent”.

    And by the way, why is it the most die-hard Americans who demand the rest of us to be as ignorant as they are about the outside world, and to not “care so much”, always seem to boast of their foreign wives, be it from Romania or Georgia or wherever, or else mope about their thwarted hankering to scoot off to Beijing were it not for the fact that they don’t know Mandarin, or that their progeny needs more than tiger penis and rhino horn and the placebo effect to keep them functioning at optimum level — demonstrating to all of us that they are actually the ones who were “just visiting”).? Weird how with some people, it’s always ‘do as I say and not as I do’, hoping all the while that the rest of us won’t notice your hypocrisy. Sorry, Buzz, I ain’t having it. You had your chance to mind your own business and avoid “foreign entanglements” whether on your own, or vicariously through your spouse. As it is, in for a penny, in for a pound.

    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA


    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?
     
    Well, let's see.. I know I'm wasting my time here with you, but of my total of seven comments before this one:

    Two were short jokes having nothing serious to do with the subject matter, expressing no opinions at all.

    So were already down to five...

    Another one was simply the word "Agree," a redundant attempt to agree with someone else's comment when the "Agree" button that I clicked didn't show up on my end here until later.

    Unless somebody counts that as a comment, we are now down to four...

    Still another was mostly a human observation, a remark about Prigozhin stupidly flying in a small jet, and a description of why I think guys like him and Putin are not so special and that they make mistakes like everybody else. Only the last line counts as commentary on concerns such as yours, where I write, "And this is none of our business."

    Even my first comment was one-third joke, then one-third observation that nothing has changed in Russia, that Putin does indeed murder his enemies (and you should agree with that!) Only the last third states my consistent opinion that we do not belong there.

    My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me was mostly a description of why I agree with you that the Soviet Union had a lousy moon program. It was there that I asked a question that I have been asking for some time, "why is this war so important to you and some other people?" That is what lit your fire, which is still flaming.

    My last comment was simply a reply to your disingenuous claim that I am a hypocrite.

    This comment is too.

    You are an intelligent person, so I can only surmise that you are being deceptive for the purpose of winning an argument only you want to have.

    As for my "foreign wife," she was an American citizen teaching mathematics in Connecticut when I met her. She is more Yankee Doodle than I am. If you think I'm bad, you should try your stinking arguments on her. She lived the tragedy of Eastern Europe, and she agrees with me that it is America that brought about this latest tragedy by meddling in Ukraine.

    Oh, and you're right. You and I don't see things the same way. If I could change history, the United States would have stayed out of both world wars and every war since and let the chips fall. That's not provincial; that's isolationist, and I mean it.

    Replies: @HA

  197. Anonymous[378] • Disclaimer says:
    @Ennui
    @Bardon Kaldian

    You forgot about Peter's Westernization push, cutting beards and forcing nobles to give up their caftans for the kind of sus clothes 18th-century Europeans liked. Personally, the caftans looked way more comfortable than the quasi-trans Western shoe buckles and knee breeches and wigs, but who can judge?

    It is odd that a pro-Ukrainian is recognizing that Russians aren't a savage Asiatic horde which is how they are usually described here, wanting to enslave the liberty-loving peoples of Eastern Europe. Shifting the goal posts for propaganda purposes, Bardon?

    At this point, China, India and Iran are looking very reasonable and not evil compared to the NY-London-DC-Tel Aviv-Brussels axis. A live and let live situation. They aren't perfect, but they aren't evil, unlike some power blocks one could name.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian, @Anonymous

    Bardon is just a romantic who refuses to see the West for what it is, and overidentifies with his idealized image of it despite the fact his people have never truly been accepted as part of it. Or maybe he’s such a Western fanboy because of it, now that I think about it.

    Paris, sadly, is truly disgusting.

  198. @William Badwhite
    @HA

    Lol two more comments from Hysterical Ass. Btw, I'm laughing at you, not with you.


    Oh, OK, I get it. You don’t want Putin to win. You just want Jack (and Jack and Jack and Jack) to lose, even if that means letting Putin win.
     
    Unlike you, I'm aware that neither of us have any say in whether Putin "wins" or not. Your desperate need to win the internet and have every commenter here agree with you is...certainly interesting, but your endless walls of text aren't going to actually change anything. What could change things would be for you and Jack to stop blathering endlessly on here and go volunteer in the Ukraine. They are accepting volunteers.

    Just for you, I stuck “anti-obsession medication” into Google MD,
     
    Two uses of "obsession" by a guy with 14 (so far) comments on this thread. Pot meet kettle.


    Consider that a heads-up.
     
    Thanks Internet Toughie.

    Agree: Jack D, HA, Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA

    “but your endless walls of text aren’t going to actually change anything.”

    When you devote a proportional amount of your obsessing to quelling all the commentary from the fanboys as you do to mine, get back to me.

    Until then, reflect on the fact that you hectoring me won’t change anything what I write either, and evidently, that’s still not enough to shut YOU up. No, you still gotta have your chance to spew. So much for your objections to pointless commentary that leads nowhere. Seems to me you’re pretty fine with it, after all.

    “Two uses of “obsession” by a guy with 14 (so far) comments on this thread. Pot meet kettle.”

    As opposed to the implicit notion that seeing 11, count ’em 11, emanations of Jack is perfectly sane and healthy? Also note that a significant portion of my comments happen only because people — like you, for example — feel they need to reply to what I say. I have no problem with that, but I might just want a chance to return the favor. If you want me to write less, maybe give your own keyboard a rest next time you want to respond to me.

    The responsibility for those 14 comments is shared among all those who kept the discussion going. Whereas seeing 11 versions of Jack? That’s pretty much all on you. Womp womp.

    • LOL: William Badwhite
  199. @Dennis Dale
    @Mark G.

    But it’s not “happening on the other side of the world”, it originated here. It’s being propagandized here, funded from here, and it’s distorting our politics here. It’s happening because people in our government think it serves our national interests (or other interests). That Ukrainians and Russians are doing all the dying just makes it more criminal.
    It’s not a distraction, it’s another grand criminal enterprise.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

    At this point I have more respect for those who make an amoral, imperial argument on behalf of our involvement than those who make the moral argument or simply take cover in Putin’s demonization.
    Except the former don’t exist, at least not publicly.
    And the argument is there. The people behind this probably think they’re forestalling a painful decline that is inevitable if we don’t weaken China by fracturing the natural advantage of the Eurasian land mass, soon to be dominated economically by China.
    Where are these people? When is someone going to grab me by the collar and say “listen Dennis, you want your grandchildren to starve speaking Chinese?! You better sprout a pair right now a get with the program!”

    Not that it would change my mind but it would, perversely, restore a small measure of my faith in humanity.

    • Replies: @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    Mitt Romney proves me wrong:


    The single most important thing we can do to strengthen America relative to China is to see Russia defeated in Ukraine. A weakened Russia deters the CCP's territorial ambition, and halts Putin's vision of reestablishing the old Soviet Union. Supporting Ukraine is in our interest. pic.twitter.com/X21GGs0lTW— Senator Mitt Romney (@SenatorRomney) August 25, 2023
     
    Paraphrasing Gunny Hartman, hell I appreciate your honesty, you can come over to my house and recruit my son [gut punch].

    Replies: @Jack D, @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon

  200. Yevgeny,we hardly knew ye.

  201. @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "No, it was obviously about your, and their, whole history here on this blog of fervent comments arguing for American support of the Ukraine/Russia war."

    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?, trying to tell us that everything you yourself have managed to invest in this thread is all red, white and yankee-doodle blue but anyone who goes beyond that -- and who is NOT an enthusiastic fanboy (because for some strange reason, you have no problem whatsoever with them) -- is acting so bizarrely that they warrant an interrogation.

    You and your fellow fanboys (or useful idiots, as the case may be) might not see the comedy in all that. I do. I'll say this much -- your primary conception of being an American is that no real American could know the things this person knows, or care about that place over there -- i.e. it is, at its core, an appeal to ignorance and provincialism (not to mention a pathetic lack of self-awareness). Spare me. You and I obviously read the lessons of the history of the last century very differently. I'm not interested in repeating any of that. You are content to remain "indifferent".

    And by the way, why is it the most die-hard Americans who demand the rest of us to be as ignorant as they are about the outside world, and to not "care so much", always seem to boast of their foreign wives, be it from Romania or Georgia or wherever, or else mope about their thwarted hankering to scoot off to Beijing were it not for the fact that they don't know Mandarin, or that their progeny needs more than tiger penis and rhino horn and the placebo effect to keep them functioning at optimum level -- demonstrating to all of us that they are actually the ones who were "just visiting").? Weird how with some people, it's always 'do as I say and not as I do', hoping all the while that the rest of us won't notice your hypocrisy. Sorry, Buzz, I ain't having it. You had your chance to mind your own business and avoid "foreign entanglements" whether on your own, or vicariously through your spouse. As it is, in for a penny, in for a pound.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?

    Well, let’s see.. I know I’m wasting my time here with you, but of my total of seven comments before this one:

    Two were short jokes having nothing serious to do with the subject matter, expressing no opinions at all.

    So were already down to five…

    Another one was simply the word “Agree,” a redundant attempt to agree with someone else’s comment when the “Agree” button that I clicked didn’t show up on my end here until later.

    Unless somebody counts that as a comment, we are now down to four…

    Still another was mostly a human observation, a remark about Prigozhin stupidly flying in a small jet, and a description of why I think guys like him and Putin are not so special and that they make mistakes like everybody else. Only the last line counts as commentary on concerns such as yours, where I write, “And this is none of our business.”

    Even my first comment was one-third joke, then one-third observation that nothing has changed in Russia, that Putin does indeed murder his enemies (and you should agree with that!) Only the last third states my consistent opinion that we do not belong there.

    My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me was mostly a description of why I agree with you that the Soviet Union had a lousy moon program. It was there that I asked a question that I have been asking for some time, “why is this war so important to you and some other people?” That is what lit your fire, which is still flaming.

    My last comment was simply a reply to your disingenuous claim that I am a hypocrite.

    This comment is too.

    You are an intelligent person, so I can only surmise that you are being deceptive for the purpose of winning an argument only you want to have.

    As for my “foreign wife,” she was an American citizen teaching mathematics in Connecticut when I met her. She is more Yankee Doodle than I am. If you think I’m bad, you should try your stinking arguments on her. She lived the tragedy of Eastern Europe, and she agrees with me that it is America that brought about this latest tragedy by meddling in Ukraine.

    Oh, and you’re right. You and I don’t see things the same way. If I could change history, the United States would have stayed out of both world wars and every war since and let the chips fall. That’s not provincial; that’s isolationist, and I mean it.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me..."


    Man, what a little girl you're turning out to be. It was five comments -- own them. Why do you want to mansplain what is and isn't a real comment? It's beside the point.

    Moreover, if you want to lessen the number of mine, you can just ignore me. Or don't -- I'm OK, either way. No hard feelings whatsoever, and I mean that sincerely; and I won't try to dictate what you should and shouldn't care about. That's where we fundamentally differ.

    That being said, if you continue to conspicuously fail to question any of the fanboys why they care so much, that's your prerogative, too, but in that case I'm going to call you out on it because it vitiates your argument. Yeah, you can try to mansplain why all the off-topic updates on Ukraine and Putin from the fanboys are a-OK, while mine are totally beyond the pale, but I don't think anyone is gong to be swayed by that, either.

    Replies: @anon

  202. @HA
    @YetAnotherAnon

    "SEVEN comments so far on this thread, and the day is young in the States…"

    Try and keep up. I'm not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I'm not the hypocrite, here, I'm just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla... oh, wait, you're a fanboy. Never mind.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @AKAHorace

    Try and keep up. I’m not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I’m not the hypocrite, here, I’m just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla… oh, wait, you’re a fanboy. Never mind.

    My theory. The whole Ukrainian/Russian conflict is a sideshow in the central titanic struggle of intellects on Steve Sailer’s comments threads. Keep posting boys. Remember, for every post that goes unchallenged the Ukrainian fascists/Russian Orcs advance five miles.

    • LOL: Mike Tre
    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @AKAHorace

    Screw the war. I say we start monetizing our comments.

    https://cointelegraph.com/storage/uploads/view/296971f2b38c48fbe993ede58730bfc3.jpg

    https://file.naijauto.com/2018/03/03/gf7sN3IA/mercedes-logo-4-c21f.jpg

    https://marcas-logos.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pornhub-Logo-2009.jpg

  203. Prig-nose-in. Lukashenko’s account of how Yevgeny Prigozhin was talking ecstatically with every other word an obscenity in the negotiation with Lukashenko during the mutiny made clear, to me at least, that Prigozhin was coked out of his skull, as were his minions. After the bomb went off but before the plane crashed there would be time for one last toot.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean

    You are thinking in American terms. The Russian drug of choice is vodka. Russian is a very profane language, especially if you are an ex-con like Prigozhin. Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.

    Replies: @vinteuil, @Sean

  204. @AKAHorace
    @HA


    Try and keep up. I’m not the one disparaging others for commenting too much about Ukraine. No, that would be Buzz Mohawk doing that to me, even though, as I accurately pointed out, his FIVE comments were racked up earlier than mine. Check the timeline. So I’m not the hypocrite, here, I’m just providing evidence of who is. Really, does something that simple and obvious need to be expla… oh, wait, you’re a fanboy. Never mind.
     
    My theory. The whole Ukrainian/Russian conflict is a sideshow in the central titanic struggle of intellects on Steve Sailer's comments threads. Keep posting boys. Remember, for every post that goes unchallenged the Ukrainian fascists/Russian Orcs advance five miles.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

    Screw the war. I say we start monetizing our comments.

  205. @Zelo
    @HA

    Your little feelings get upset when the Fanboy accusation is turned back on you. The truth is you guys have some weird ethnic hatred going on and you're getting hundreds of thousands of people killed. You are all mentally unstable.

    You had the same style of argument with Covid. You went into hysterical personal attacks. You have a thin veneer of lawyerly dramatics without engaging the topic like a grown man.

    Replies: @HA

    “Your little feelings get upset when the Fanboy accusation is turned back on you.”

    My “little” feelings? And where do you get “upset”? a I’m just pointing out that as of 134 comments in, no one had bothered to even mention Zelensky until you yourself did. So your accusation makes no sense whatsoever outside the fiction you spin in your own head, as John Johnson elaborated.

    And none of that is a “personal” attack, except the part about “little”, and you’re the one who pitched that. The crack about porn metaphors? Yeah, that was arguably personal, but you’re the one who chose to go there, and having done so, you don’t get to to lecture others on “engaging like a grown man” without being called out as the laughably hypocritical buffoon that you are. If you think that’s too personal, stop throwing so much of your personal baggage into your comments.

  206. @Buzz Mohawk
    @HA


    So, here you are, having gotten as far as comment #200 or thereabouts, after what, six or seven comments of your own?
     
    Well, let's see.. I know I'm wasting my time here with you, but of my total of seven comments before this one:

    Two were short jokes having nothing serious to do with the subject matter, expressing no opinions at all.

    So were already down to five...

    Another one was simply the word "Agree," a redundant attempt to agree with someone else's comment when the "Agree" button that I clicked didn't show up on my end here until later.

    Unless somebody counts that as a comment, we are now down to four...

    Still another was mostly a human observation, a remark about Prigozhin stupidly flying in a small jet, and a description of why I think guys like him and Putin are not so special and that they make mistakes like everybody else. Only the last line counts as commentary on concerns such as yours, where I write, "And this is none of our business."

    Even my first comment was one-third joke, then one-third observation that nothing has changed in Russia, that Putin does indeed murder his enemies (and you should agree with that!) Only the last third states my consistent opinion that we do not belong there.

    My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me was mostly a description of why I agree with you that the Soviet Union had a lousy moon program. It was there that I asked a question that I have been asking for some time, "why is this war so important to you and some other people?" That is what lit your fire, which is still flaming.

    My last comment was simply a reply to your disingenuous claim that I am a hypocrite.

    This comment is too.

    You are an intelligent person, so I can only surmise that you are being deceptive for the purpose of winning an argument only you want to have.

    As for my "foreign wife," she was an American citizen teaching mathematics in Connecticut when I met her. She is more Yankee Doodle than I am. If you think I'm bad, you should try your stinking arguments on her. She lived the tragedy of Eastern Europe, and she agrees with me that it is America that brought about this latest tragedy by meddling in Ukraine.

    Oh, and you're right. You and I don't see things the same way. If I could change history, the United States would have stayed out of both world wars and every war since and let the chips fall. That's not provincial; that's isolationist, and I mean it.

    Replies: @HA

    “My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me…”

    Man, what a little girl you’re turning out to be. It was five comments — own them. Why do you want to mansplain what is and isn’t a real comment? It’s beside the point.

    Moreover, if you want to lessen the number of mine, you can just ignore me. Or don’t — I’m OK, either way. No hard feelings whatsoever, and I mean that sincerely; and I won’t try to dictate what you should and shouldn’t care about. That’s where we fundamentally differ.

    That being said, if you continue to conspicuously fail to question any of the fanboys why they care so much, that’s your prerogative, too, but in that case I’m going to call you out on it because it vitiates your argument. Yeah, you can try to mansplain why all the off-topic updates on Ukraine and Putin from the fanboys are a-OK, while mine are totally beyond the pale, but I don’t think anyone is gong to be swayed by that, either.

    • Replies: @anon
    @HA

    Hello HA,
    You seem very emotionally invested in war.
    You and Jack D have to step up and volunteer to fight for ukraine.
    If you're old and infirm please send your children in your stead.

    Replies: @Frank McGar, @MGB

  207. Mercouris’ voice is annoying but he makes a lot of good points. Why would Putin kill Prigozhin this way and right in the middle of the BRICS summit?

    He and Christoforou also point out how often these “Putin is a madman” events are timed to cast a shadow on a scheduled public relations win: the Russians hosting the FIFA World Cup, the Sochi Olympics, the BRICS expansion summit.

    • Thanks: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast


    Why would Putin kill Prigozhin this way and right in the middle of the BRICS summit?
     
    Putin had to make this a spectacular public execution in order to put his fingerprints on it, so that his enemies would know to fear him. This is the same reason that Russia uses exotic poisons that are uniquely Russian such as Polonium and Novichok. If Prigozhin had a "heart attack" while visiting Mali it wouldn't send the same unmistakable message.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

  208. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "If it was the Ukrainians and/or Americans who did this, it’s fun to think how much evidence would be required for some guys here to accept it. We will have to wait for David Ignatius to write a piece in the WaPo explaining why it was a stroke of brilliance."

    You mean to say someone did do this? Yeah, makes sense--I mean, given that the Russians "confirmed" that Prigozhin's body was indeed recovered and identified, why would anyone doubt that he's dead? What other evidence does anyone need other than a press-release "confirmation" by Russian authorities? And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @kaganovitch

    And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?

    That’s some pricey artisan shashlik there! I would have thought 100 rubles would cover it.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @kaganovitch

    Maybe it was a SMALL diamond?

    BTW, I have to say that given the decline in the ruble, prices in Russia now are very cheap for domestically produced food and other items (though maybe not so cheap if you are a Russian making $150/week). Too bad it's not safe to visit (not crime wise but bc the regime might hold you hostage) and there are no direct flights because otherwise it would be quite a bargain for someone with American dollars. The current equivalent of a Big Mac (which is no longer called a Big Mac) is like 130 rubles or US$1.30, making Russia perhaps the cheapest country to visit on earth.

    , @HA
    @kaganovitch

    "That’s some pricey artisan shashlik there!"

    Come on, you're thinking like a small-timer. Nowadays, I cultivate my super-villian persona by breeding Peruvian Chysis and Akhal-Tekes, but back when I was slumming with the African rape-and-murder crowd (before rabble like Prigozhin came in and turned that into something cheap and low-brow -- ah, the good old days) being recognized as a big tipper helped to smooth things along with the local warlords. Especially if you had a mug like Prigozhin's.

    And like you said, when your shashlik is made of chunks of some exotic bushmeat just a serving or two away from utter extinction, you gotta expect a premium.

  209. @HA
    @Buzz Mohawk

    "My one and only comment to you before you went nuts on me..."


    Man, what a little girl you're turning out to be. It was five comments -- own them. Why do you want to mansplain what is and isn't a real comment? It's beside the point.

    Moreover, if you want to lessen the number of mine, you can just ignore me. Or don't -- I'm OK, either way. No hard feelings whatsoever, and I mean that sincerely; and I won't try to dictate what you should and shouldn't care about. That's where we fundamentally differ.

    That being said, if you continue to conspicuously fail to question any of the fanboys why they care so much, that's your prerogative, too, but in that case I'm going to call you out on it because it vitiates your argument. Yeah, you can try to mansplain why all the off-topic updates on Ukraine and Putin from the fanboys are a-OK, while mine are totally beyond the pale, but I don't think anyone is gong to be swayed by that, either.

    Replies: @anon

    Hello HA,
    You seem very emotionally invested in war.
    You and Jack D have to step up and volunteer to fight for ukraine.
    If you’re old and infirm please send your children in your stead.

    • Agree: MGB, Buzz Mohawk
    • Replies: @Frank McGar
    @anon

    Any thread involving Russia/Ukraine they are in here showcasing their incredible ability to read Putin's mind. At least they are predictable.

    , @MGB
    @anon

    Once iSteve has finished his tin cup fundraiser he promised to solicit funds for 10 one way tickets to Warsaw for any commenters’ draft-aged kids who want to support the war effort. I will donate 10 Go Pro cams with helmet clips so that we can watch the Russian retreat in real time. Moscow by Christmas!

  210. Well even the Septics are saying it wasn’t a missile, so there go Jack’s “launch pictures”. Could be lying of course.

    A bomb leaves the field wide open again, with the Russian Government imho the least likely suspects.

    Apparently the poor stewardess posted something about takeoff being delayed for “repairs” – was this planting time? Or the plane was apparently up for sale – some potential buyer with good footwork and a team on hand? Alternatively, what’s security like on the ground in Africa? You surely wouldn’t entrust it to locals.

  211. @Cagey Beast
    Mercouris' voice is annoying but he makes a lot of good points. Why would Putin kill Prigozhin this way and right in the middle of the BRICS summit?

    He and Christoforou also point out how often these "Putin is a madman" events are timed to cast a shadow on a scheduled public relations win: the Russians hosting the FIFA World Cup, the Sochi Olympics, the BRICS expansion summit.
    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=27RDtOS1AdM

    Replies: @Jack D

    Why would Putin kill Prigozhin this way and right in the middle of the BRICS summit?

    Putin had to make this a spectacular public execution in order to put his fingerprints on it, so that his enemies would know to fear him. This is the same reason that Russia uses exotic poisons that are uniquely Russian such as Polonium and Novichok. If Prigozhin had a “heart attack” while visiting Mali it wouldn’t send the same unmistakable message.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @Jack D

    Think of another explanation please. Think of the opposite explanation for why spectacular killings -- with, as you say, Putin's fingerprints all over them -- happen when Putin is in the middle of scoring a public relations win on the world stage. Think how the West is run by worshippers of the god Narrative and think of all the practical reasons why the West would want to decapitate the Wagner Group.

  212. @William Badwhite
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”?
     
    It doesn't, other than in your fevered mind. Not everyone shares your obsessions.

    Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?

     

    More of your mind-reading. I can't for the life of me understand why so many other commenters call you dishonest.

    The last 15 or so comments on this thread are hilarious. Starting around 142 we get comments from: HA (Foreign Jack), Peter A (Slavic Jack), Slavic Jack, Foreign Jack, Foreign Jack, poor Frau Katze, Foreign Jack, John Johnson (Goyish Jack), Goyish Jack, Foreign Jack, Goyish Jack, then three in a row from Joo-ish Jack. Complete with them thanking each other and calling people “Rushists” and “Putinists” and “fanboys” and then Johann “German Jack” Ricke, whose comment history consists mostly of agreeing with Jack, agreeing with Jack. You guys should start a band or something.

    Agree: Johann Ricke

    Replies: @HA, @HA, @Mr Mox

    You guys should start a band or something.

    But what should they call the band? “Pavlov’s Dogs” perhaps? Whenever Russia/Putin Ukraine/Zelensky is mentioned, they predictably pop up and start salivating.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

    , @Mike Tre
    @Mr Mox

    How about Steppe West?

  213. @Jack D
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    Ah, the "No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger" argument.

    First of all, you, unlike some folks here, actually admit that Putin does bad things. The ink wasn't even dry on the headlines before some people here started saying that it was a US or Ukrainian operation or maybe it didn't even happen or whatever. Anything but what it appeared to be on its face, which was that Putin was taking revenge on his enemies as he often does.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn't done anything to you YET doesn't mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Probably Ali was right that the Vietnamese Communists mostly just wanted hegemony over all of Vietnam and were not coming for Honolulu or even Tokyo. However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over "Russian World" and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy given the current day reality of Russia where they have to depend on Iran for drones but if a genie gave Putin 3 wishes this would be one of them. If he doesn't achieve it in his lifetime, it won't be for lack of trying. If he can't have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Alec Leamas (working from home), @dimples

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    “Waited too long” to do what?

    How would you specifically prevent the “bad man” from doing something bad to you?

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    You might send weapons and aid to the people whose country he has already invaded. Which is exactly what we are doing and what almost every country in Europe is doing.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

  214. @Mr Mox
    @William Badwhite

    You guys should start a band or something.

    But what should they call the band? "Pavlov's Dogs" perhaps? Whenever Russia/Putin Ukraine/Zelensky is mentioned, they predictably pop up and start salivating.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Mike Tre

    Pavlov’s Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Steve Sailer


    Pavlov’s Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.
     
    Apparently there’s been a bunch of “Pavlov’s Dog(s)” bands/ensembles over the years.

    Future iteration:

    “We’re ‘Pavlov’s Dogs’—sorta punk, sorta metal, we’ve read a little Wikipedia, and our music blows. Live this Thursday at the Boiler Room opening for Uncertainty Principle.”

    , @Anonymous
    @Steve Sailer

    Already taken. Well, Pavlov's Dog, at least.

    , @John Johnson
    @Steve Sailer

    Nah Jack and I are starting a metal band called Agitation of Cognitive Dissonance.

    It's prog-rock metal with Southern blues influence.

    The lyrics are all based on MacGregor/Ritter projections.

    Top hits include:
    War is not coming, it's an illusion
    The war is finished
    2 weeks until it is over
    2 months until it is over
    The Winter Offensive is coming
    The Spring Offensive is coming
    Prigozhin is just a ploy
    The Counter-offensive is over

    , @MGB
    @Steve Sailer

    Didn’t Iggy and The Stooges do a song, ‘I wanna be your Pavlov’s Dog’?

    , @res
    @Steve Sailer

    https://www.loudersound.com/news/how-pavlovs-dog-were-poised-for-megastardom-but-let-it-all-slip-away

  215. @Sean
    Prig-nose-in. Lukashenko's account of how Yevgeny Prigozhin was talking ecstatically with every other word an obscenity in the negotiation with Lukashenko during the mutiny made clear, to me at least, that Prigozhin was coked out of his skull, as were his minions. After the bomb went off but before the plane crashed there would be time for one last toot.

    Replies: @Jack D

    You are thinking in American terms. The Russian drug of choice is vodka. Russian is a very profane language, especially if you are an ex-con like Prigozhin. Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.

    • Replies: @vinteuil
    @Jack D


    Russian is a very profane language...Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.
     
    Yeah - just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn...I mean, the guy simply can't control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Sean
    @Jack D

    Alcohol is frequently used along with coke. People started saying he was showing signs of traumatic stress after Prigozhin did a videos surrounded by a pile of his own men's corpses. It was like Colonel Kurtz's 'Horror' monologue from Apocalypse Now.

    My mindset--formed by some experience--is if you intuitively think someone is on drugs you will rarely be wrong. Prigozhin was described as not merely swearing but in a state of "euphoria" that lasted the half hour Lukashenko was talking to him during the mutiny.


    https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidhambling/2023/02/02/are-drugs-making-russian-soldiers-act-like-zombies/?sh=215ba4d18c98

    Ukrainian soldier speaking to CNN also compared recent attacks to something out of a zombie movie, describing advancing Russians climbing over the bodies of the fallen.

    Elsewhere videos show Russian soldiers staggering around slowly, failing to move out of the way even when grenades are falling around them, while one Ukrainian describes watching Russians move ‘like molasses’ under bombardment.

    What is going on here?

    There are a number of possible explanations. Many Ukrainians are convinced that the Russian soldiers are drugged.

    The orcs have some serious drugs …they have no motivation to fight so they are given some euphoric s***,” says a Ukrainian soldier interviewed by Butusov Plus, describing fighting off four waves of attacks by Russians who did not seem to have any idea what they were doing. “Truly, they are under some kind of influence.”
     
    Prigozhin met Putin when Putin was a customer at Prigozhin's St Petersburg restaurant. I imagine Prigozhin was courtly not raving in front a pile of dead bodies. Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals

    Replies: @Jack D

  216. @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

    Pavlov’s Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Apparently there’s been a bunch of “Pavlov’s Dog(s)” bands/ensembles over the years.

    Future iteration:

    “We’re ‘Pavlov’s Dogs’—sorta punk, sorta metal, we’ve read a little Wikipedia, and our music blows. Live this Thursday at the Boiler Room opening for Uncertainty Principle.”

  217. @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

    Already taken. Well, Pavlov’s Dog, at least.

  218. @anon
    @HA

    Hello HA,
    You seem very emotionally invested in war.
    You and Jack D have to step up and volunteer to fight for ukraine.
    If you're old and infirm please send your children in your stead.

    Replies: @Frank McGar, @MGB

    Any thread involving Russia/Ukraine they are in here showcasing their incredible ability to read Putin’s mind. At least they are predictable.

  219. @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast


    Why would Putin kill Prigozhin this way and right in the middle of the BRICS summit?
     
    Putin had to make this a spectacular public execution in order to put his fingerprints on it, so that his enemies would know to fear him. This is the same reason that Russia uses exotic poisons that are uniquely Russian such as Polonium and Novichok. If Prigozhin had a "heart attack" while visiting Mali it wouldn't send the same unmistakable message.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    Think of another explanation please. Think of the opposite explanation for why spectacular killings — with, as you say, Putin’s fingerprints all over them — happen when Putin is in the middle of scoring a public relations win on the world stage. Think how the West is run by worshippers of the god Narrative and think of all the practical reasons why the West would want to decapitate the Wagner Group.

  220. @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Jack D


    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.
     
    "Waited too long" to do what?

    How would you specifically prevent the “bad man” from doing something bad to you?

    Replies: @Jack D

    You might send weapons and aid to the people whose country he has already invaded. Which is exactly what we are doing and what almost every country in Europe is doing.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Jack D

    Oh. I thought you meant something more aggressive.

  221. @kaganovitch
    @HA


    And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?
     
    That's some pricey artisan shashlik there! I would have thought 100 rubles would cover it.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

    Maybe it was a SMALL diamond?

    BTW, I have to say that given the decline in the ruble, prices in Russia now are very cheap for domestically produced food and other items (though maybe not so cheap if you are a Russian making $150/week). Too bad it’s not safe to visit (not crime wise but bc the regime might hold you hostage) and there are no direct flights because otherwise it would be quite a bargain for someone with American dollars. The current equivalent of a Big Mac (which is no longer called a Big Mac) is like 130 rubles or US$1.30, making Russia perhaps the cheapest country to visit on earth.

  222. @AnotherDad
    Shitty to toast a couple of pilots and a perfectly good E-jet.

    If Putin had offered me the E-jet and given me a good sniper rifle to practice with, I could have handled this with much less waste. But that's Putin, "pointlesswasteovich" ought to be the guy's middle name.

    Replies: @tyrone, @vinteuil, @Buzz Mohawk, @Just Some JB, @Colin Wright, @Colin Wright, @Dennis Dale

    Careful, Lee Harvey Oswald was recruited on social media.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    Oswald may not have been but we do have a lot of "mentally challenged" Muslim teenagers and Michigan militia types being groomed by feds. I'd hate to see Another Dad being talked into attacking Lavrov at the UN or something.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

  223. @Twinkie
    @Robertson


    Did he fake his own death?**
     
    Note:

    was listed as a passenger
     
    All we know now is that he was on the passenger manifest. And everyone onboard died.

    Until you have the body/DNA, no confirmation.

    Replies: @Alrenous

    Until body:
    It’s a great way to fake your own death. Plane crash assassination is extremely common and thus plausible. Putin can be seen to be lethally harsh against his enemies without having to actually kill anyone aside from ukronazis committing suicide by SMO.

  224. @Dennis Dale
    @AnotherDad

    Careful, Lee Harvey Oswald was recruited on social media.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    Oswald may not have been but we do have a lot of “mentally challenged” Muslim teenagers and Michigan militia types being groomed by feds. I’d hate to see Another Dad being talked into attacking Lavrov at the UN or something.

    • Replies: @Dennis Dale
    @Cagey Beast

    I believe it, but where are they? I wonder what the feds batting average is in producing patsies, Muslim or "white nationalist".
    Probably not hall of fame numbers.

  225. https://www.theamericanconservative.com/ukraines-vain-search-for-wonder-weapons/

    In just a year and a half, Ukraine’s military deaths have already surpassed the number of American troops who died during the nearly two decades US units were in Vietnam (roughly 58,000) and about equal the number of Afghan security forces killed over the entire war in Afghanistan, from 2001 to 2021 (around 69,000). … And across Ukraine, in big cities and rural villages, almost everyone knows a family that has lost someone in the fighting. Dry flowers from funerals litter quiet roads, and graveyards are filling up in every corner of the country.

    https://t.me/llordofwar/194998

  226. @Cagey Beast
    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    What are you saying? It would be of poor character?

    By someone who started a 1930s style invasion when the world was recovering from COVID? A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?

    Eliminating a threat to his power during BRICS would be crossing some type poor taste line?

    This is the dictator that just gave someone 10 years for answering a street interview incorrectly. Can provide a source if you would like.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson

    Do you really think I'm saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don't. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritises.

    "A pint sized dictator". Who cares if Putin's short? Putin himself clearly doesn't.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mike Tre

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @John Johnson

    "A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?"

    If only he'd been tall like George Bush!

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0yr-LaMhvro

    , @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    It even goes beyond this. The whole point of a spectacular public execution in the midst of an international conference is in order to sow fear in your enemies. Not only is poor character not a consideration, the whole point is to demonstrate how brutal and ruthless you are to those who would dare betray you.

    Putin certainly could have had Prigozhin knocked off in Africa and made it look like he had had a heart attack or something (Prigozhin didn't look like he was a healthy eater) but then people might have missed the message. This was meant to be an unmistakable warning to others (and yet at the same time publicly deniable).

    The only flaw in this demonstration is that Putin's enemies now know more than ever that they must go all the way next time. If you strike at the king you must kill him.

    Why Prigozhin stopped half way to Moscow when he must have known this ancient truth, we may never know. Perhaps in his mind he only wanted to depose Shoigu and not Putin but he should have known that the boss would not accept this loss of face. Why he set foot in Russia again, we won't know either. Prigozhin was a not a stupid man and was especially wise in the ways of the ruthless because he was one of them. It's hard to believe that he would have accepted soothing lies ("All is forgiven, Yevgeny!") knowing that he would have told such lies and taken his revenge anyway if the situation was reversed. Possibly he had the hubris to think that he was an irreplaceable man in Africa and Syria, especially with his other key men sitting right next to him on the plane. Indeed this loss may recreate a setback for Russia in its overseas adventures but Putin must have felt that it was worth it.

    But most people will be deterred from trying at all. Prigozhin was the man most likely to try this - the only man in Russia with his own private army. If Prigozhin couldn't succeed, who else in Russia is going to have the balls to try this a 2nd time?

    Replies: @John Johnson

  227. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    What are you saying? It would be of poor character?

    By someone who started a 1930s style invasion when the world was recovering from COVID? A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?

    Eliminating a threat to his power during BRICS would be crossing some type poor taste line?

    This is the dictator that just gave someone 10 years for answering a street interview incorrectly. Can provide a source if you would like.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    Do you really think I’m saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don’t. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritises.

    “A pint sized dictator”. Who cares if Putin’s short? Putin himself clearly doesn’t.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Do you really think I’m saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don’t. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritizes.

    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.

    “A pint sized dictator”. Who cares if Putin’s short? Putin himself clearly doesn’t.

    Yes he clearly cares by the fact that he wears shoe lifts. He also has censors that scour the internet for anyone that calls him a dwarf or crab. In Russia it can lead to an arrest.

    Putin is 5'3 and uses shoe lifts to appear 5'7. We know this because there are older pictures of him next to Medvedev in standard shoes.

    This war wouldn't exist if Putin was 5'7. He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    , @Mike Tre
    @Cagey Beast

    He's probably taller than Zelensky and Victoria Nuland.

  228. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    What are you saying? It would be of poor character?

    By someone who started a 1930s style invasion when the world was recovering from COVID? A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?

    Eliminating a threat to his power during BRICS would be crossing some type poor taste line?

    This is the dictator that just gave someone 10 years for answering a street interview incorrectly. Can provide a source if you would like.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    “A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?”

    If only he’d been tall like George Bush!

  229. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Alexander Mercouris made several good points in his most recent video. He asked why Putin would carry out this killing in Russia and in such a spectacular way, rather than do it while the Wagner team was in Africa the day before. Mercouris also pointed out that Prigozhin was killed right in the middle of the BRICS conference. Why would Putin want to do that?

    What are you saying? It would be of poor character?

    By someone who started a 1930s style invasion when the world was recovering from COVID? A pint sized dictator who launched missiles at Kiev on live television?

    Eliminating a threat to his power during BRICS would be crossing some type poor taste line?

    This is the dictator that just gave someone 10 years for answering a street interview incorrectly. Can provide a source if you would like.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon, @Jack D

    It even goes beyond this. The whole point of a spectacular public execution in the midst of an international conference is in order to sow fear in your enemies. Not only is poor character not a consideration, the whole point is to demonstrate how brutal and ruthless you are to those who would dare betray you.

    Putin certainly could have had Prigozhin knocked off in Africa and made it look like he had had a heart attack or something (Prigozhin didn’t look like he was a healthy eater) but then people might have missed the message. This was meant to be an unmistakable warning to others (and yet at the same time publicly deniable).

    The only flaw in this demonstration is that Putin’s enemies now know more than ever that they must go all the way next time. If you strike at the king you must kill him.

    Why Prigozhin stopped half way to Moscow when he must have known this ancient truth, we may never know. Perhaps in his mind he only wanted to depose Shoigu and not Putin but he should have known that the boss would not accept this loss of face. Why he set foot in Russia again, we won’t know either. Prigozhin was a not a stupid man and was especially wise in the ways of the ruthless because he was one of them. It’s hard to believe that he would have accepted soothing lies (“All is forgiven, Yevgeny!”) knowing that he would have told such lies and taken his revenge anyway if the situation was reversed. Possibly he had the hubris to think that he was an irreplaceable man in Africa and Syria, especially with his other key men sitting right next to him on the plane. Indeed this loss may recreate a setback for Russia in its overseas adventures but Putin must have felt that it was worth it.

    But most people will be deterred from trying at all. Prigozhin was the man most likely to try this – the only man in Russia with his own private army. If Prigozhin couldn’t succeed, who else in Russia is going to have the balls to try this a 2nd time?

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Jack D

    Why he set foot in Russia again, we won’t know either. Prigozhin was a not a stupid man and was especially wise in the ways of the ruthless because he was one of them.

    Not a stupid man but known for reckless behavior which can amount to willful stupidity.

    Possibly he had the hubris to think that he was an irreplaceable man in Africa and Syria, especially with his other key men sitting right next to him on the plane.

    I think he correctly realized that he understood the war better than Putin and Shoigu which made him arrogant. Arrogance will easily lead intelligent people down a path of destruction.

    He understood the war better than the dictator and his top men but context is required. The dictator was a paper pusher at the KGB and the minister of defense has a background in emergency services. So he was dealing with a clueless mob but seemed to think removing one or two captains would make a difference.

    If Prigozhin couldn’t succeed, who else in Russia is going to have the balls to try this a 2nd time?

    The guy has massive balls but he went at it the wrong way. I suspect he believed the Russian military was in better shape and wasn't aware of the lies until he had his troops in Bakhmut. Shoigu was certainly a problem but taking him out wouldn't change the war. He would have been replaced with a competent general but will still leave Wagner troops unsupported. The Wagner troops were always doomed to be fodder. A competent general would be given the same order from Putin which is to march the troops forward and grind down Ukrainians even if it means a battlefield loss. Putin is fighting this war like Stalin fighting the Finns. Men are dead? Oh ok send more men then. Wagner conscripts were ideal fodder because no one would make a fuss over a prisoner who agreed to charge with an AK for a chance at freedom.

    I also wonder if Prigozhin had a terminal disease. He just seemed to have a death wish and returning to Moscow made zero sense. It's just a shame he wasn't able to take out Putin. But it's not the worst case scenario as I really didn't want Shoigu removed. He is a divine a gift for Ukraine. Let's put a 911 operator in charge of a war. Another genius move by the dwarf.

  230. “More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. U.S. sanctimony is world class, with successive administrations wailing about democracy and aggression while invading Iraq based on a lie and arming Saudi Arabia in its unprovoked attack on Yemen, in both cases resulting in more deaths than caused by Russia in Ukraine. Washington’s wretched geopolitics degrades American security, pushing Moscow and Beijing together while encouraging nuclear proliferation among smaller states. And Uncle Sam’s international hubris threatens the country’s fiscal future. The U.S. is functionally bankrupt, its debt to GDP ratio now approaching the record set after World War II and heading toward nearly twice that level by mid-century.

    No wonder the Biden administration is having such a difficult time articulating a convincing justification for squandering precious resources and courting war with a nuclear-armed power over peripheral stakes. Kiev’s political allies dismiss complaints that the average American household already has provided nearly $900 in Ukraine aid. After all, the CARES Act, presented as an antidote to the COVID pandemic, spent some $2 trillion, much of it conspicuously wasted. So what’s a few tens of billions more for Ukraine even if, predictably, the Europeans are yet again backtracking on their promises to do more for themselves?

    The Russo-Ukraine war is terrible for many reasons. It is also dangerous for U.S. Washington policymakers to only see through a glass, darkly, relying on Kiev, which is ever-ready to drag America into the conflict by means both fair and foul. Recognizing that Ukraine might not win its war with Russia is the first step to formulating a better approach for America. Then reality might finally force itself on even the most deluded Washington policymaker.”

    https://www.theamericanconservative.com/ukraines-vain-search-for-wonder-weapons/

    Given the inexorable rise of China, perhaps a more realist foreign policy may have been to encourage Russo/German co-operation, drop the Pride parades and cement Russia AND Ukraine into Europe.

    But alas those at the heart of US policy can’t forgive todays Russia for the indignities, real or amplified, their forebears suffered, more than a hundred years ago, at the hands of assorted Cossacks and Black Hundreds. Like the brilliant musician of Hamelin, they’ve been leading America’s children into the darkness since the 1960s, and the journey continues.

    “There’s a deal of ruin in a nation”

    • Agree: Farenheit
    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @YetAnotherAnon

    I agree with everything you said and everything in that American Conservative excerpt. I'd just add that people have been too easy on the other members of NATO and on the EU. They have only helped destabilise Ukraine (for fun and profit) and enable any crooked politician who made the right noises about being pro-western. They blew past twenty or thirty years of off-ramps too.

    , @Buzz Mohawk
    @YetAnotherAnon

    Thank You! I don't have time to dissect everything here, but yours is one of the most accurate, meaningful comments I have read on this thread.

    , @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon

    “More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy.

    Very nice trick to assume your conclusion. Notice "failing" attempt, not "failed". It hasn't failed yet and whether it is "failing" is not exactly an objective fact. Yes, MAYBE if our attempt FAILS it would be time to do a "rethink" but I think it's a little early to declare defeat.

    American Conservative circa March 1941:

    “More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Britain to wreck Germany should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. "

    How did that work out?

  231. @kaganovitch
    @HA


    And given that one was issued, why would anyone suspect that he might actually still be out there somewhere as we speak, munching down some sashlik that he paid for with a blood diamond or two?
     
    That's some pricey artisan shashlik there! I would have thought 100 rubles would cover it.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

    “That’s some pricey artisan shashlik there!”

    Come on, you’re thinking like a small-timer. Nowadays, I cultivate my super-villian persona by breeding Peruvian Chysis and Akhal-Tekes, but back when I was slumming with the African rape-and-murder crowd (before rabble like Prigozhin came in and turned that into something cheap and low-brow — ah, the good old days) being recognized as a big tipper helped to smooth things along with the local warlords. Especially if you had a mug like Prigozhin’s.

    And like you said, when your shashlik is made of chunks of some exotic bushmeat just a serving or two away from utter extinction, you gotta expect a premium.

  232. @Jack D
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    You might send weapons and aid to the people whose country he has already invaded. Which is exactly what we are doing and what almost every country in Europe is doing.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Oh. I thought you meant something more aggressive.

  233. @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    It even goes beyond this. The whole point of a spectacular public execution in the midst of an international conference is in order to sow fear in your enemies. Not only is poor character not a consideration, the whole point is to demonstrate how brutal and ruthless you are to those who would dare betray you.

    Putin certainly could have had Prigozhin knocked off in Africa and made it look like he had had a heart attack or something (Prigozhin didn't look like he was a healthy eater) but then people might have missed the message. This was meant to be an unmistakable warning to others (and yet at the same time publicly deniable).

    The only flaw in this demonstration is that Putin's enemies now know more than ever that they must go all the way next time. If you strike at the king you must kill him.

    Why Prigozhin stopped half way to Moscow when he must have known this ancient truth, we may never know. Perhaps in his mind he only wanted to depose Shoigu and not Putin but he should have known that the boss would not accept this loss of face. Why he set foot in Russia again, we won't know either. Prigozhin was a not a stupid man and was especially wise in the ways of the ruthless because he was one of them. It's hard to believe that he would have accepted soothing lies ("All is forgiven, Yevgeny!") knowing that he would have told such lies and taken his revenge anyway if the situation was reversed. Possibly he had the hubris to think that he was an irreplaceable man in Africa and Syria, especially with his other key men sitting right next to him on the plane. Indeed this loss may recreate a setback for Russia in its overseas adventures but Putin must have felt that it was worth it.

    But most people will be deterred from trying at all. Prigozhin was the man most likely to try this - the only man in Russia with his own private army. If Prigozhin couldn't succeed, who else in Russia is going to have the balls to try this a 2nd time?

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Why he set foot in Russia again, we won’t know either. Prigozhin was a not a stupid man and was especially wise in the ways of the ruthless because he was one of them.

    Not a stupid man but known for reckless behavior which can amount to willful stupidity.

    Possibly he had the hubris to think that he was an irreplaceable man in Africa and Syria, especially with his other key men sitting right next to him on the plane.

    I think he correctly realized that he understood the war better than Putin and Shoigu which made him arrogant. Arrogance will easily lead intelligent people down a path of destruction.

    He understood the war better than the dictator and his top men but context is required. The dictator was a paper pusher at the KGB and the minister of defense has a background in emergency services. So he was dealing with a clueless mob but seemed to think removing one or two captains would make a difference.

    If Prigozhin couldn’t succeed, who else in Russia is going to have the balls to try this a 2nd time?

    The guy has massive balls but he went at it the wrong way. I suspect he believed the Russian military was in better shape and wasn’t aware of the lies until he had his troops in Bakhmut. Shoigu was certainly a problem but taking him out wouldn’t change the war. He would have been replaced with a competent general but will still leave Wagner troops unsupported. The Wagner troops were always doomed to be fodder. A competent general would be given the same order from Putin which is to march the troops forward and grind down Ukrainians even if it means a battlefield loss. Putin is fighting this war like Stalin fighting the Finns. Men are dead? Oh ok send more men then. Wagner conscripts were ideal fodder because no one would make a fuss over a prisoner who agreed to charge with an AK for a chance at freedom.

    I also wonder if Prigozhin had a terminal disease. He just seemed to have a death wish and returning to Moscow made zero sense. It’s just a shame he wasn’t able to take out Putin. But it’s not the worst case scenario as I really didn’t want Shoigu removed. He is a divine a gift for Ukraine. Let’s put a 911 operator in charge of a war. Another genius move by the dwarf.

  234. @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

    Nah Jack and I are starting a metal band called Agitation of Cognitive Dissonance.

    It’s prog-rock metal with Southern blues influence.

    The lyrics are all based on MacGregor/Ritter projections.

    Top hits include:
    War is not coming, it’s an illusion
    The war is finished
    2 weeks until it is over
    2 months until it is over
    The Winter Offensive is coming
    The Spring Offensive is coming
    Prigozhin is just a ploy
    The Counter-offensive is over

    • LOL: Jack D
  235. Not really O/T (though I’m sure it will shock, shock, many in the audience):

    Newly declassified US intel claims Russia is laundering propaganda through unwitting Westerners

    US intelligence agencies believe that the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) is attempting to influence public policy and public opinion in the West by directing Russian civilians to build relationships with influential US and Western individuals and then disseminate narratives that support Kremlin objectives, obscuring the FSB’s role through layers of ostensibly independent actors.

    …But the official stressed that the Western voices that eventually became mouthpieces for Russian propaganda were almost certainly unaware of the role they were playing.

    Oh, say it ain’t so. Then again, I don’t get the sense that the Putin shills around. here are especially “influential”, though they might be dressing for the promotion they’re hoping to get, as the saying goes. And the article makes no mention of any US shills active in Russia pushing Wester narratives — I guess we’ll have to wait a while for some of that to get declassified, though I’m not holding my breath.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    Scary stuff. Let's all try to stay mentally safe out there. Check in regularly with the regime approved media if you feel your thoughts going wobbly.

    , @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    Here's a neat example of disinformation. We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa as if it's from Russian bombing in 2023:
    https://twitter.com/USEmbassyPrague/status/1693537015436894386?s=20

    I'm sure you know about what happened at the Trade Union building that day (heck, you might even have been there) but others might not:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxcB0PI4ZLg

    Replies: @HA

  236. @HA
    Not really O/T (though I'm sure it will shock, shock, many in the audience):

    Newly declassified US intel claims Russia is laundering propaganda through unwitting Westerners

    US intelligence agencies believe that the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) is attempting to influence public policy and public opinion in the West by directing Russian civilians to build relationships with influential US and Western individuals and then disseminate narratives that support Kremlin objectives, obscuring the FSB’s role through layers of ostensibly independent actors.

    ...But the official stressed that the Western voices that eventually became mouthpieces for Russian propaganda were almost certainly unaware of the role they were playing.

     

    Oh, say it ain't so. Then again, I don't get the sense that the Putin shills around. here are especially "influential", though they might be dressing for the promotion they're hoping to get, as the saying goes. And the article makes no mention of any US shills active in Russia pushing Wester narratives -- I guess we'll have to wait a while for some of that to get declassified, though I'm not holding my breath.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Cagey Beast

    Scary stuff. Let’s all try to stay mentally safe out there. Check in regularly with the regime approved media if you feel your thoughts going wobbly.

  237. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    At what point does “I don’t care about this war one way or the other” or “all I want is for the shooting to stop” become a thinly disguised version of “I really want Russia to win”? It’s like the NY Times reporters who claim to be doing objective journalism but it’s obvious to anyone who is not a fool that they badly want Biden to be re-elected. Who do any of these guys think they are fooling with their false protestations of neutrality?
     
    I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended.

    If that means Putin succeeds to some degree and makes gains in the former Ukraine then I can accept this circumstance. All the more if the result is a more stable geopolitical reality in Eastern Europe which halts provocative NATO expansion Eastward. Those people, nominally "Americans" are much more my enemy than Vladimir Putin or any Russian. The past years have made that fact plain.

    I don't believe I need to fool you for any purpose. What is happening is simply not in the interest of the United States and I feel very comfortable saying so unequivocally.

    Replies: @HA

    “I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended.”

    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated. But I see precious little evidence for that, and conclude that you’re just fine with all that. To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it’s actually America that’s escalating us towards some Armageddon — and that’s not a problem, either.

    That being the case, you’re about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called “peace advocates” were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn’t at all surprising since it’s coming from the very same sources.

    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @HA


    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated.
     
    It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States' NATO defense obligations. Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO (which was at least an obligation arising from a treaty ratified by the U.S. Senate) to the surprise of the Russians is about as stupid a thing as one could do. Even a remedial track 9th grader will have drilled into his head that "secret alliances" are a cause of disaster, but you seem to have missed even this.

    To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it’s actually America that’s escalating us towards some Armageddon — and that’s not a problem, either.
     
    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA'S BORDER.

    That being the case, you’re about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called “peace advocates” were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn’t at all surprising since it’s coming from the very same sources.
     
    You really think "there's a red under every bed" hysteria will work after the last six years?

    The Soviet Union disbanded and the constituent States gave up Communism. The existential threat is long gone. Russia is just a poor Eastern European nation now and does not merit anything like the alarm that you are displaying.

    Replies: @HA

  238. @anon
    @HA

    Hello HA,
    You seem very emotionally invested in war.
    You and Jack D have to step up and volunteer to fight for ukraine.
    If you're old and infirm please send your children in your stead.

    Replies: @Frank McGar, @MGB

    Once iSteve has finished his tin cup fundraiser he promised to solicit funds for 10 one way tickets to Warsaw for any commenters’ draft-aged kids who want to support the war effort. I will donate 10 Go Pro cams with helmet clips so that we can watch the Russian retreat in real time. Moscow by Christmas!

  239. @HA
    @Anonymous

    "Russia had to protect itself from Ukraine becoming a George Soros/NATO base in the future, which they’ve done."

    Yeah, sure, it's always sunny in Moscow, at least when the drones aren't dropping bombs and scuttled moon landings aren't raining down shards of debris. Shame about Finland and Sweden, tho. Maybe if Russia hadn't been so distracted by Ukraine, NATO and Soros wouldn't have been able to slip two whole extra bordering states in there after decades of rejection. Looks like the old one-two-misdirection psych finally did the trick.

    And according to the latest troll propaganda, once Poland swoops in and takes Western Ukraine for itself, isn't Russia back to being crammed right next to a NATO state with no buffer in between, except one that mistrusts it far more than Ukraine ever did? And you don't see how any of that hurts Russia?

    Like I said, according to the fanboys, every hand's a winner as long as Putin is holding the cards. Weird how that works.

    Replies: @Zelo, @dimples

    I guess Putin factored in that the inhabitants of Finland and Sweden are relatively sane, whereas the Ukes were mentally retarded Nazis. Which would you like as your next door neighbour?

    • Replies: @HA
    @dimples

    "I guess Putin factored in that the inhabitants of Finland and Sweden are relatively sane, whereas the Ukes were mentally retarded Nazis."

    Sounds like just the right kind of people to try and merge with Russia, eh? And again, according to the trolls' own propaganda, Poland will be Russia's neighbor as soon as it swallows up Western Ukraine (which I'm guessing will occur right after "the gloves finally come off" which Macgregor says -- and has said for the last year and a half -- will happen any day now). If that kind of confrontation is what Putin is hoping to find, what was all this nonsense about buffer states?

  240. @Jack D
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    Ah, the "No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger" argument.

    First of all, you, unlike some folks here, actually admit that Putin does bad things. The ink wasn't even dry on the headlines before some people here started saying that it was a US or Ukrainian operation or maybe it didn't even happen or whatever. Anything but what it appeared to be on its face, which was that Putin was taking revenge on his enemies as he often does.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn't done anything to you YET doesn't mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Probably Ali was right that the Vietnamese Communists mostly just wanted hegemony over all of Vietnam and were not coming for Honolulu or even Tokyo. However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over "Russian World" and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy given the current day reality of Russia where they have to depend on Iran for drones but if a genie gave Putin 3 wishes this would be one of them. If he doesn't achieve it in his lifetime, it won't be for lack of trying. If he can't have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Alec Leamas (working from home), @dimples

    Ah, the “No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger” argument.

    Is it an argument? I rather see it as an acknowledgement that our interests don’t conflict.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Perhaps it has escaped your notice that the U.S. has gone around the world during the past 20 years or so killing bad men first so they can’t kill us later (well, sometimes we help bad men hurt the worse men, or sometimes the bad men become ‘moderate rebels’ – aw hell, you get it). I don’t see this as having been good policy. It’s not our job to get rid of all of the World’s bad men.

    However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over “Russian World” and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    I very much doubt that even my summer home is situate within the bounds of Putin’s expansionist “Russian World.”

    If he doesn’t achieve it in his lifetime, it won’t be for lack of trying. If he can’t have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    Well, it seems he’s positively stuffed with a few parts of Eastern Ukraine. I think I will be able to dine in peace myself.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)


    I very much doubt that even my summer home is situate within the bounds of Putin’s expansionist “Russian World.”
     
    Depends where it is. Alaska seems to be on his list.

    Well, it seems he’s positively stuffed with a few parts of Eastern Ukraine. I think I will be able to dine in peace myself.

     

    That's not how it works with dictators. Most people, they eat a country or even a few provinces and they feel full. For dictators, each conquest only whets their appetite for the next one. If Putin is feeling "stuffed" in Ukraine it is only because, thanks to us, he bit off more than he could chew. If the meal had gone down easily (for example if we had not helped the Ukrainians) then it would have been on to the next course.
  241. @HA
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "I want the people in and around my own Nation who made this conflict an American one at the heart of all political discussion to lose and to be discredited and humiliated. I want the inordinate and unjustifiable risk of a direct conflict between the U.S. and Russia ended. I want the increased risk of a nuclear exchange ended."

    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated. But I see precious little evidence for that, and conclude that you're just fine with all that. To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it's actually America that's escalating us towards some Armageddon -- and that's not a problem, either.

    That being the case, you're about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called "peace advocates" were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn't at all surprising since it's coming from the very same sources.

    Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated.

    It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States’ NATO defense obligations. Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO (which was at least an obligation arising from a treaty ratified by the U.S. Senate) to the surprise of the Russians is about as stupid a thing as one could do. Even a remedial track 9th grader will have drilled into his head that “secret alliances” are a cause of disaster, but you seem to have missed even this.

    To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it’s actually America that’s escalating us towards some Armageddon — and that’s not a problem, either.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    That being the case, you’re about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called “peace advocates” were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn’t at all surprising since it’s coming from the very same sources.

    You really think “there’s a red under every bed” hysteria will work after the last six years?

    The Soviet Union disbanded and the constituent States gave up Communism. The existential threat is long gone. Russia is just a poor Eastern European nation now and does not merit anything like the alarm that you are displaying.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States’ NATO defense obligations."

    Given the arm-twisting applied to hammer out the Budapest Memorandum and to get Ukraine's end of it satisfied, our hands aren't exactly clean. And getting other countries to de-nuclearize the way Ukraine did -- which is indeed in NATO's and America's interest -- won't happen if any state that does so is left to the tender mercies of neighboring bullies.

    "I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER."

    Given that he launched the invasion that kicked off this so-called "proxy war", getting piquant about it subsequently does demonstrate a certain amount of chutzpah, now that you mention it.

    "You really think 'there’s a red under every bed' hysteria will work after the last six years?"

    I expect it to work as long as Putin keeps threatening to push that button and keeps getting misty-eyed about the break-up of the USSR (which he referred to as the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century). If he wants to build USSR 2.0 -- and he clearly does -- I have no problem fast-forwarding to the part where that one breaks up, too. It's no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders or the generals wearing Botticelli wigs and spandex, so I'll wait until you start lambasting all the people here who believe that before being impressed by what you say of me.

    Replies: @Jack D

  242. @Jack D
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    Ah, the "No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger" argument.

    First of all, you, unlike some folks here, actually admit that Putin does bad things. The ink wasn't even dry on the headlines before some people here started saying that it was a US or Ukrainian operation or maybe it didn't even happen or whatever. Anything but what it appeared to be on its face, which was that Putin was taking revenge on his enemies as he often does.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn't done anything to you YET doesn't mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.

    Probably Ali was right that the Vietnamese Communists mostly just wanted hegemony over all of Vietnam and were not coming for Honolulu or even Tokyo. However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over "Russian World" and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.

    In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy given the current day reality of Russia where they have to depend on Iran for drones but if a genie gave Putin 3 wishes this would be one of them. If he doesn't achieve it in his lifetime, it won't be for lack of trying. If he can't have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Alec Leamas (working from home), @dimples

    “In his fondest dreams, Russia will again sit at the table as a co-equal of the US in the game of global dominance. This might sound a little nutsy…….”.

    It sure does, although it may work after Fatmerika becomes overrun with wetbacks. The taxes just won’t be there to pay for all the totalitarian accessories.

  243. @vinteuil
    @Bardon Kaldian


    How low can you fall from the state of mind that adored Paris, created magnificent works in sonnet, ballet, novel, symphony …. to hang around with Iran, China and India (and contemporary South Africa)- with whom you have nothing in common.
     
    BK, are you under the impression that Paris today is the Paris of Proust & Debussy?

    When was the last time anybody in Western Europe or the USA wrote a genuinely great ballet, novel or symphony?

    Well, OK, there's Stravinsky's Orfeo, there's Nabokov's Lolita, there's Shostakovich's 15th...

    Uh-oh...

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    When anyone from indigenous South Africa wrote anything worth reading?

    • Replies: @vinteuil
    @Bardon Kaldian


    When anyone from indigenous South Africa wrote anything worth reading?

     

    Well, OK, so you don't just despise Russians, you also despise black South Africans?

    Or what was your point?
  244. @Anonymous
    @Bardon Kaldian

    I don't know why you talk so much about Russians. Croats are basically Catholic Turks and Gypsies who are best known for torturing and slaughtering elderly civilians:

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/croats-slaughter-elderly-by-the-dozen-1600351.html

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    Our people don’t fully understand how much we reset them with that Storm.

    The political and geographical capital of 2 Serbian uprisings, 2 Balkan wars, 2 world wars went to dust and ashes in 2 months of 1995.

    Two hundred years of the development of the Serbian state and Serbian political thought, expansion and unification of the Serbs on both sides of the Drina river (Greater Serbia) imploded epically and irretrievably went into the dustbin of history.

    In addition, we destroyed the image of them, dominant among their Western allies as the victorious side, and those who comforted them, rooted for them and let them rule from Karavanke to Vardar are now playing tricks on them with genocide and Kosovo.

    Bonus points for Tuđman, he directly knocked Montenegro and Kosovo out of Serbia with an epic defeat – nobody wants to be part of a defeated and hated country.

    And what would have happened if we had continued and taken Banja Luka, we would have dismantled them like Stalin Germany’s imperial ambitions- forever.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Bardon Kaldian


    unification of the Serbs on both sides of the Drina river (Greater Serbia) imploded epically and irretrievably went into the dustbin of history
     
    You must be thinking of the wrong river. There are only Serbs now on both sides of almost the entirety of the Drina. Only Serbs on 49% of Bosnia. Unification is a formality and only a question of time.

    And what would have happened if we had continued and taken Banja Luka
     
    It would be a Muslim ruled city. Do you really wish your own side would have sacrificed lives to make that happen, just because you dislike the Serbs more?
  245. Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO

    If Ukraine was a de facto protectorate then the US would have launched cruise missiles upon invasion and immediately provided them with Apaches, A10s, spectres, spookys, long range HIMARs and F-35s. Limited US military aid only started rolling after Ukraine pushed the Russians out of Kiev. Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    Putin was threatening to use nukes before the US sent military aid. He actually threatened to use them upon invasion and that was after he swore it was all a training exercise. Can provide sources if you would like.

    Both Putin and Medvedev have in fact threatened to nuke the whole world over Ukraine from the very beginning. The West was told that the nukes could go off if they aid Ukraine. That was around the time that the dictator declared LPR/DPR to be new countries and has since taken them as Russian territory. The weasel betrayed his own supporters and had the LPR/DPR militia men sent to the front.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a “special military operation” that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan.

    The weasel dictator can’t even respect the dead. Hot off the press in Weasel Dictator News:

    Russia removes graves of Wagner fallen

    What a total POS. Unreal that some of you continue to defend him.

    Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge. I can’t believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn’t think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    • Replies: @used tire
    @John Johnson

    Looks like John McCain's AI upload escaped the containment unit.

    , @Putinandhisfansaremorons
    @John Johnson

    If Ukraine was an US protectorate, all Russian military units in Ukraine and on the Russian border would cease to exist in a week. It’s hilarious Russia’s peer military is Ukraine’s, but they larp that they’d have a chance against the US, let alone all of NATO lol

    , @Sean
    @John Johnson


    Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope
     
    Ben Hodges did not think that, he correctly predicted the invasion would not work. Certainty does not exist in this world, something you may with to ponder in relation to your belief that Russia is at best stalemated, Putin will fall and, his only hope is to give up. Vietnam was on the other side of the world, and America could not exert its full strength, because there was an ocean between it and a very foreign land in which America would lose interest after it left. Russia does not look at Ukraine as a far off country that could be forgotten about in the same way. No not at all. Vietnam style ambushes of over extended armored columns was how Ukraine did fight and it was very effective. Unfortunately for Ukraine, Russia altered tack last June, and they are standing on the defensive, where their artillery can support them in the traditional way the Russian army fights. Bakhmut was an infantry and artillery led slow head on type of fighting that the Ukrainians accepted battle in and Russian tactics evolved in. The greatest mistake of Ukraine has been taking Western advice to mount conventional combined arms offensives yet doing so on on too broad a front that included the East where Russian logistics are strong. Ukraine ought to have concentrated all available forces for a concentric offensive in the South as Western military experts continue to urge.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a “special military operation” that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan
     

    For the world to be blown up the US would have to get directly involved in fighting Russia, and no one in Washington ought to be in any doubt about that, so it is good that Putin is threatening. Moreover, were Ukraine to start seriously pushing Russia back out of Ukraine, Putin quite possibly would resort to a theatre thermonuclear option against the Ukrainian army, which is why Ukraine has not been given seriously effective arms by America. He is not going to quit and neither is he going to swallow a loss, or at least a worse loss than he has already suffered. Anyway, most people do not think Russia is going to be pushed back significantly.

    I can’t believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn’t think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.
     
    Britain is an island. Real conflicts of interest exist between sovereign states with land borders, and when theseget settled, it often comes about by fighting it out. Not flouts and jeers.
    , @Colin Wright
    @John Johnson


    'Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge....'
     
    Not yet. We're trying to make that happen, though.

    I can't get over how people assume that if we just undermine Putin, we get someone better.

    Oh, au contraire...

  246. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @HA


    I could understand that as something else than a cheap rationalization if you had any similar antipathy for the Russians and their shills who make this conflict an American one to be discredited and humiliated.
     
    It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States' NATO defense obligations. Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO (which was at least an obligation arising from a treaty ratified by the U.S. Senate) to the surprise of the Russians is about as stupid a thing as one could do. Even a remedial track 9th grader will have drilled into his head that "secret alliances" are a cause of disaster, but you seem to have missed even this.

    To heighten the black-comedy of it all, Putin is the one who is (or at least was) actually threatening to press that red button, and yet, according to the shills who actively propagate his narrative on this website and tell us it’s actually America that’s escalating us towards some Armageddon — and that’s not a problem, either.
     
    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA'S BORDER.

    That being the case, you’re about as convincing as all the other moral equivalence flim-flam that so-called “peace advocates” were shilling back during the Cold War, which isn’t at all surprising since it’s coming from the very same sources.
     
    You really think "there's a red under every bed" hysteria will work after the last six years?

    The Soviet Union disbanded and the constituent States gave up Communism. The existential threat is long gone. Russia is just a poor Eastern European nation now and does not merit anything like the alarm that you are displaying.

    Replies: @HA

    “It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States’ NATO defense obligations.”

    Given the arm-twisting applied to hammer out the Budapest Memorandum and to get Ukraine’s end of it satisfied, our hands aren’t exactly clean. And getting other countries to de-nuclearize the way Ukraine did — which is indeed in NATO’s and America’s interest — won’t happen if any state that does so is left to the tender mercies of neighboring bullies.

    “I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.”

    Given that he launched the invasion that kicked off this so-called “proxy war”, getting piquant about it subsequently does demonstrate a certain amount of chutzpah, now that you mention it.

    “You really think ‘there’s a red under every bed’ hysteria will work after the last six years?”

    I expect it to work as long as Putin keeps threatening to push that button and keeps getting misty-eyed about the break-up of the USSR (which he referred to as the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century). If he wants to build USSR 2.0 — and he clearly does — I have no problem fast-forwarding to the part where that one breaks up, too. It’s no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders or the generals wearing Botticelli wigs and spandex, so I’ll wait until you start lambasting all the people here who believe that before being impressed by what you say of me.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @HA


    It’s no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders
     
    Or alternatively that he wants to save Ukraine from the "neo-Nazis" who run it (which he mentioned just yesterday when eulogizing the Wagner guys) , apparently the kind of neo-Nazis that have a Jewish president and don't get enough votes to be represented in the parliament.

    I guess the West is too far left for Putin and the neo-Nazis of Ukraine are too far right but Russia is just right.

    Also mentioning neo-Nazis in the same breath as Wagner and Utkin ("Wagner" himself, he of the Nazi tattoos) is sort of strange. Maybe neo-Nazis are good if they are Russian neo-Nazis but bad if they are Ukrainian ones.

    I think Alec commits a sort of Kinsley gaffe where he accidentally tells the truth. He doesn't really love Putin (honestly, he is a hard guy to love) he just hates Current Year America, so the enemy of his enemy is his friend.

    In the past, the thought (on the right at least) was always that politics stopped at the border so that we were all Americans vs. a foreign power (for example, Lindbergh kinda liked that Hitler guy but once the war started he acted like a loyal American and fought on our side) but I think that the American extreme right today sees that it has about as much chance of taking power unassisted in future America as the neo-Nazis have of taking power in Ukraine so they are not above rooting for someone else who will maybe cut the Current Year America that they hate down a notch, since they are in no position to do it themselves.

    Replies: @HA

  247. @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Jack D


    Ah, the “No Vietcong ever called me a N*gger” argument.
     
    Is it an argument? I rather see it as an acknowledgement that our interests don't conflict.

    2nd, when someone is a bad man, that he hasn’t done anything to you YET doesn’t mean that he might not get around to it eventually. If you wait until he gets around to you, you have waited too long.
     
    Perhaps it has escaped your notice that the U.S. has gone around the world during the past 20 years or so killing bad men first so they can't kill us later (well, sometimes we help bad men hurt the worse men, or sometimes the bad men become 'moderate rebels' - aw hell, you get it). I don't see this as having been good policy. It's not our job to get rid of all of the World's bad men.

    However, Putin has not disguised the fact that he wants to preside over “Russian World” and that he take a broad view of where Russian World begins and ends.
     
    I very much doubt that even my summer home is situate within the bounds of Putin's expansionist "Russian World."

    If he doesn’t achieve it in his lifetime, it won’t be for lack of trying. If he can’t have the full meal he will at least snatch as many bits and pieces as he can manage.
     
    Well, it seems he's positively stuffed with a few parts of Eastern Ukraine. I think I will be able to dine in peace myself.

    Replies: @Jack D

    I very much doubt that even my summer home is situate within the bounds of Putin’s expansionist “Russian World.”

    Depends where it is. Alaska seems to be on his list.

    Well, it seems he’s positively stuffed with a few parts of Eastern Ukraine. I think I will be able to dine in peace myself.

    That’s not how it works with dictators. Most people, they eat a country or even a few provinces and they feel full. For dictators, each conquest only whets their appetite for the next one. If Putin is feeling “stuffed” in Ukraine it is only because, thanks to us, he bit off more than he could chew. If the meal had gone down easily (for example if we had not helped the Ukrainians) then it would have been on to the next course.

  248. @Jack D
    @Sean

    You are thinking in American terms. The Russian drug of choice is vodka. Russian is a very profane language, especially if you are an ex-con like Prigozhin. Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.

    Replies: @vinteuil, @Sean

    Russian is a very profane language…Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @vinteuil

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I've listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I've never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypq65UMkq8A

    Not a good look for Russia. I'm not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn't a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    Replies: @Mr Mox, @Anonymous, @vinteuil, @Sean

  249. @HA
    @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    "It may come as a surprise to you to learn that the Ukraine is not a part of the United States’ NATO defense obligations."

    Given the arm-twisting applied to hammer out the Budapest Memorandum and to get Ukraine's end of it satisfied, our hands aren't exactly clean. And getting other countries to de-nuclearize the way Ukraine did -- which is indeed in NATO's and America's interest -- won't happen if any state that does so is left to the tender mercies of neighboring bullies.

    "I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER."

    Given that he launched the invasion that kicked off this so-called "proxy war", getting piquant about it subsequently does demonstrate a certain amount of chutzpah, now that you mention it.

    "You really think 'there’s a red under every bed' hysteria will work after the last six years?"

    I expect it to work as long as Putin keeps threatening to push that button and keeps getting misty-eyed about the break-up of the USSR (which he referred to as the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century). If he wants to build USSR 2.0 -- and he clearly does -- I have no problem fast-forwarding to the part where that one breaks up, too. It's no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders or the generals wearing Botticelli wigs and spandex, so I'll wait until you start lambasting all the people here who believe that before being impressed by what you say of me.

    Replies: @Jack D

    It’s no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders

    Or alternatively that he wants to save Ukraine from the “neo-Nazis” who run it (which he mentioned just yesterday when eulogizing the Wagner guys) , apparently the kind of neo-Nazis that have a Jewish president and don’t get enough votes to be represented in the parliament.

    I guess the West is too far left for Putin and the neo-Nazis of Ukraine are too far right but Russia is just right.

    Also mentioning neo-Nazis in the same breath as Wagner and Utkin (“Wagner” himself, he of the Nazi tattoos) is sort of strange. Maybe neo-Nazis are good if they are Russian neo-Nazis but bad if they are Ukrainian ones.

    I think Alec commits a sort of Kinsley gaffe where he accidentally tells the truth. He doesn’t really love Putin (honestly, he is a hard guy to love) he just hates Current Year America, so the enemy of his enemy is his friend.

    In the past, the thought (on the right at least) was always that politics stopped at the border so that we were all Americans vs. a foreign power (for example, Lindbergh kinda liked that Hitler guy but once the war started he acted like a loyal American and fought on our side) but I think that the American extreme right today sees that it has about as much chance of taking power unassisted in future America as the neo-Nazis have of taking power in Ukraine so they are not above rooting for someone else who will maybe cut the Current Year America that they hate down a notch, since they are in no position to do it themselves.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Jack D

    "I think Alec commits a sort of Kinsley gaffe where he accidentally tells the truth. He doesn’t really love Putin (honestly, he is a hard guy to love) he just hates Current Year America, so the enemy of his enemy is his friend."

    Maybe he is one of the people who only "tolerate" Putin, much like Moscow has no genuine fondness for the useful idiots and fellow travelers who slurp up their propaganda -- actually, they're probably loathed and sneered at. I think it was Solovyev who in an unguarded moment once lamented on his talk show how stupid Russia's supporters in the West were, or something similar.

    But people react to cognitive dissonance differently, and many of those who started out merely tolerating Putin have since contorted their attitudes into something approaching genuine affection and enthusiasm, perhaps to make their own back-stabbing less egregious. I saw the same thing with the white supremacists who once merely tolerated the Iranians they initially regarded as just one more rag-tag band of 3rd world riff-raff -- because there was at least a slight possibility that they might thrash or even nuke Israel, which meant they couldn't be all bad. As time went on, they became downright chummy with the mullahs. It's wishful thinking in action. Some wives catch a husband cheating, and their immediate attitude is that it must have -- must have -- been the other woman's fault -- it'd just be easier for them to rationalize staying with him if that were the case.

  250. @Jack D
    @Sean

    You are thinking in American terms. The Russian drug of choice is vodka. Russian is a very profane language, especially if you are an ex-con like Prigozhin. Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.

    Replies: @vinteuil, @Sean

    Alcohol is frequently used along with coke. People started saying he was showing signs of traumatic stress after Prigozhin did a videos surrounded by a pile of his own men’s corpses. It was like Colonel Kurtz’s ‘Horror’ monologue from Apocalypse Now.

    My mindset–formed by some experience–is if you intuitively think someone is on drugs you will rarely be wrong. Prigozhin was described as not merely swearing but in a state of “euphoria” that lasted the half hour Lukashenko was talking to him during the mutiny.

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidhambling/2023/02/02/are-drugs-making-russian-soldiers-act-like-zombies/?sh=215ba4d18c98

    Ukrainian soldier speaking to CNN also compared recent attacks to something out of a zombie movie, describing advancing Russians climbing over the bodies of the fallen.

    Elsewhere videos show Russian soldiers staggering around slowly, failing to move out of the way even when grenades are falling around them, while one Ukrainian describes watching Russians move ‘like molasses’ under bombardment.

    What is going on here?

    There are a number of possible explanations. Many Ukrainians are convinced that the Russian soldiers are drugged.

    The orcs have some serious drugs …they have no motivation to fight so they are given some euphoric s***,” says a Ukrainian soldier interviewed by Butusov Plus, describing fighting off four waves of attacks by Russians who did not seem to have any idea what they were doing. “Truly, they are under some kind of influence.”

    Prigozhin met Putin when Putin was a customer at Prigozhin’s St Petersburg restaurant. I imagine Prigozhin was courtly not raving in front a pile of dead bodies. Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean


    Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals
     
    That's one way of looking at it and the other way is that he was personally brave and not willing to prescribe any medicine to his men that he would not take himself. Whereas the cowardly Shoigu, Putin, etc. would not be caught within 100 km of the front lines.

    It's good for Ukraine that Prigozhin, Utkin, etc. are dead and Wagner is out of Ukraine and I am glad for them. And they were both vile human beings although not as vile as the slimy Putin so the world is well rid of them. But if you are a soldier (I'm not) you have to admire them for their effectiveness and for the loyalty that they instilled in their men, which is a lot more than you can say of Shoigu and Gerasimov.

    BTW, I'm not sure we have heard the last of Wagner. It may be that the decapitation strike was enough to kill the body too, but maybe not.

    Replies: @HA

  251. @Bardon Kaldian
    @vinteuil

    When anyone from indigenous South Africa wrote anything worth reading?

    Replies: @vinteuil

    When anyone from indigenous South Africa wrote anything worth reading?

    Well, OK, so you don’t just despise Russians, you also despise black South Africans?

    Or what was your point?

  252. @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    Oswald may not have been but we do have a lot of "mentally challenged" Muslim teenagers and Michigan militia types being groomed by feds. I'd hate to see Another Dad being talked into attacking Lavrov at the UN or something.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

    I believe it, but where are they? I wonder what the feds batting average is in producing patsies, Muslim or “white nationalist”.
    Probably not hall of fame numbers.

  253. @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

    Wow, ID – maybe, after all, you have the talent to write that novel about the brothers Gracchi that I’ve been wanting to commission from you.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.

    Heck if I know.

  254. @YetAnotherAnon

    "More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. U.S. sanctimony is world class, with successive administrations wailing about democracy and aggression while invading Iraq based on a lie and arming Saudi Arabia in its unprovoked attack on Yemen, in both cases resulting in more deaths than caused by Russia in Ukraine. Washington’s wretched geopolitics degrades American security, pushing Moscow and Beijing together while encouraging nuclear proliferation among smaller states. And Uncle Sam’s international hubris threatens the country’s fiscal future. The U.S. is functionally bankrupt, its debt to GDP ratio now approaching the record set after World War II and heading toward nearly twice that level by mid-century.

    No wonder the Biden administration is having such a difficult time articulating a convincing justification for squandering precious resources and courting war with a nuclear-armed power over peripheral stakes. Kiev’s political allies dismiss complaints that the average American household already has provided nearly $900 in Ukraine aid. After all, the CARES Act, presented as an antidote to the COVID pandemic, spent some $2 trillion, much of it conspicuously wasted. So what’s a few tens of billions more for Ukraine even if, predictably, the Europeans are yet again backtracking on their promises to do more for themselves?

    The Russo-Ukraine war is terrible for many reasons. It is also dangerous for U.S. Washington policymakers to only see through a glass, darkly, relying on Kiev, which is ever-ready to drag America into the conflict by means both fair and foul. Recognizing that Ukraine might not win its war with Russia is the first step to formulating a better approach for America. Then reality might finally force itself on even the most deluded Washington policymaker."
     

    https://www.theamericanconservative.com/ukraines-vain-search-for-wonder-weapons/

    Given the inexorable rise of China, perhaps a more realist foreign policy may have been to encourage Russo/German co-operation, drop the Pride parades and cement Russia AND Ukraine into Europe.

    But alas those at the heart of US policy can't forgive todays Russia for the indignities, real or amplified, their forebears suffered, more than a hundred years ago, at the hands of assorted Cossacks and Black Hundreds. Like the brilliant musician of Hamelin, they've been leading America's children into the darkness since the 1960s, and the journey continues.

    "There's a deal of ruin in a nation"

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Buzz Mohawk, @Jack D

    I agree with everything you said and everything in that American Conservative excerpt. I’d just add that people have been too easy on the other members of NATO and on the EU. They have only helped destabilise Ukraine (for fun and profit) and enable any crooked politician who made the right noises about being pro-western. They blew past twenty or thirty years of off-ramps too.

  255. @YetAnotherAnon

    "More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. U.S. sanctimony is world class, with successive administrations wailing about democracy and aggression while invading Iraq based on a lie and arming Saudi Arabia in its unprovoked attack on Yemen, in both cases resulting in more deaths than caused by Russia in Ukraine. Washington’s wretched geopolitics degrades American security, pushing Moscow and Beijing together while encouraging nuclear proliferation among smaller states. And Uncle Sam’s international hubris threatens the country’s fiscal future. The U.S. is functionally bankrupt, its debt to GDP ratio now approaching the record set after World War II and heading toward nearly twice that level by mid-century.

    No wonder the Biden administration is having such a difficult time articulating a convincing justification for squandering precious resources and courting war with a nuclear-armed power over peripheral stakes. Kiev’s political allies dismiss complaints that the average American household already has provided nearly $900 in Ukraine aid. After all, the CARES Act, presented as an antidote to the COVID pandemic, spent some $2 trillion, much of it conspicuously wasted. So what’s a few tens of billions more for Ukraine even if, predictably, the Europeans are yet again backtracking on their promises to do more for themselves?

    The Russo-Ukraine war is terrible for many reasons. It is also dangerous for U.S. Washington policymakers to only see through a glass, darkly, relying on Kiev, which is ever-ready to drag America into the conflict by means both fair and foul. Recognizing that Ukraine might not win its war with Russia is the first step to formulating a better approach for America. Then reality might finally force itself on even the most deluded Washington policymaker."
     

    https://www.theamericanconservative.com/ukraines-vain-search-for-wonder-weapons/

    Given the inexorable rise of China, perhaps a more realist foreign policy may have been to encourage Russo/German co-operation, drop the Pride parades and cement Russia AND Ukraine into Europe.

    But alas those at the heart of US policy can't forgive todays Russia for the indignities, real or amplified, their forebears suffered, more than a hundred years ago, at the hands of assorted Cossacks and Black Hundreds. Like the brilliant musician of Hamelin, they've been leading America's children into the darkness since the 1960s, and the journey continues.

    "There's a deal of ruin in a nation"

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Buzz Mohawk, @Jack D

    Thank You! I don’t have time to dissect everything here, but yours is one of the most accurate, meaningful comments I have read on this thread.

  256. @John Johnson
    Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO

    If Ukraine was a de facto protectorate then the US would have launched cruise missiles upon invasion and immediately provided them with Apaches, A10s, spectres, spookys, long range HIMARs and F-35s. Limited US military aid only started rolling after Ukraine pushed the Russians out of Kiev. Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    Putin was threatening to use nukes before the US sent military aid. He actually threatened to use them upon invasion and that was after he swore it was all a training exercise. Can provide sources if you would like.

    Both Putin and Medvedev have in fact threatened to nuke the whole world over Ukraine from the very beginning. The West was told that the nukes could go off if they aid Ukraine. That was around the time that the dictator declared LPR/DPR to be new countries and has since taken them as Russian territory. The weasel betrayed his own supporters and had the LPR/DPR militia men sent to the front.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a "special military operation" that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan.

    The weasel dictator can't even respect the dead. Hot off the press in Weasel Dictator News:

    Russia removes graves of Wagner fallen

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQSw4xgitrg

    What a total POS. Unreal that some of you continue to defend him.

    Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge. I can't believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn't think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    Replies: @used tire, @Putinandhisfansaremorons, @Sean, @Colin Wright

    Looks like John McCain’s AI upload escaped the containment unit.

  257. “We were marching out of Bratislava when we ran into a sweet old woman. She insisted I take a religious medal she had. I thanked her,and said goodbye.
    Later on,Kuznetsov asked me why I was wearing a medal with the visage of St. Jude. I asked him what he meant.
    ‘ St. Jude,” said Kuznetsov,” is the patron saint of impossible causes!’
    It took a long time to find that woman. But I did.”
    from:
    “The Wit And Wisdom of Yevgeny Progozhian”

  258. @Sean
    @Jack D

    Alcohol is frequently used along with coke. People started saying he was showing signs of traumatic stress after Prigozhin did a videos surrounded by a pile of his own men's corpses. It was like Colonel Kurtz's 'Horror' monologue from Apocalypse Now.

    My mindset--formed by some experience--is if you intuitively think someone is on drugs you will rarely be wrong. Prigozhin was described as not merely swearing but in a state of "euphoria" that lasted the half hour Lukashenko was talking to him during the mutiny.


    https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidhambling/2023/02/02/are-drugs-making-russian-soldiers-act-like-zombies/?sh=215ba4d18c98

    Ukrainian soldier speaking to CNN also compared recent attacks to something out of a zombie movie, describing advancing Russians climbing over the bodies of the fallen.

    Elsewhere videos show Russian soldiers staggering around slowly, failing to move out of the way even when grenades are falling around them, while one Ukrainian describes watching Russians move ‘like molasses’ under bombardment.

    What is going on here?

    There are a number of possible explanations. Many Ukrainians are convinced that the Russian soldiers are drugged.

    The orcs have some serious drugs …they have no motivation to fight so they are given some euphoric s***,” says a Ukrainian soldier interviewed by Butusov Plus, describing fighting off four waves of attacks by Russians who did not seem to have any idea what they were doing. “Truly, they are under some kind of influence.”
     
    Prigozhin met Putin when Putin was a customer at Prigozhin's St Petersburg restaurant. I imagine Prigozhin was courtly not raving in front a pile of dead bodies. Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals

    Replies: @Jack D

    Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals

    That’s one way of looking at it and the other way is that he was personally brave and not willing to prescribe any medicine to his men that he would not take himself. Whereas the cowardly Shoigu, Putin, etc. would not be caught within 100 km of the front lines.

    It’s good for Ukraine that Prigozhin, Utkin, etc. are dead and Wagner is out of Ukraine and I am glad for them. And they were both vile human beings although not as vile as the slimy Putin so the world is well rid of them. But if you are a soldier (I’m not) you have to admire them for their effectiveness and for the loyalty that they instilled in their men, which is a lot more than you can say of Shoigu and Gerasimov.

    BTW, I’m not sure we have heard the last of Wagner. It may be that the decapitation strike was enough to kill the body too, but maybe not.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Jack D

    "BTW, I’m not sure we have heard the last of Wagner. It may be that the decapitation strike was enough to kill the body too, but maybe not."

    They're definitely in a bind. If they don't do anything, they come off as weak and insufficiently ruthless -- not a good look for mercenaries. Whereas becoming a bunch of mercenaries who are willing to lash out at their putative masters is going make an African warlord think twice about hiring them, though I suppose that Rubicon was already crossed somewhere around Voronezh. Plus, I imagine the Russians at the least have bribed a few of their members since the mutiny to provide Moscow with ongoing intel.

  259. @HA
    Not really O/T (though I'm sure it will shock, shock, many in the audience):

    Newly declassified US intel claims Russia is laundering propaganda through unwitting Westerners

    US intelligence agencies believe that the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) is attempting to influence public policy and public opinion in the West by directing Russian civilians to build relationships with influential US and Western individuals and then disseminate narratives that support Kremlin objectives, obscuring the FSB’s role through layers of ostensibly independent actors.

    ...But the official stressed that the Western voices that eventually became mouthpieces for Russian propaganda were almost certainly unaware of the role they were playing.

     

    Oh, say it ain't so. Then again, I don't get the sense that the Putin shills around. here are especially "influential", though they might be dressing for the promotion they're hoping to get, as the saying goes. And the article makes no mention of any US shills active in Russia pushing Wester narratives -- I guess we'll have to wait a while for some of that to get declassified, though I'm not holding my breath.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Cagey Beast

    Here’s a neat example of disinformation. We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa as if it’s from Russian bombing in 2023:
    https://twitter.com/USEmbassyPrague/status/1693537015436894386?s=20

    I’m sure you know about what happened at the Trade Union building that day (heck, you might even have been there) but others might not:

    • Thanks: vinteuil
    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa..."

    Yes I do know what happened in Odessa in 2014, which is why, even though I read to the end of your comment, you pretty much lost me there. Better luck next time. As the tweet "clarification" notes, it doesn't affect the meme's gist.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

  260. @YetAnotherAnon

    "More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. U.S. sanctimony is world class, with successive administrations wailing about democracy and aggression while invading Iraq based on a lie and arming Saudi Arabia in its unprovoked attack on Yemen, in both cases resulting in more deaths than caused by Russia in Ukraine. Washington’s wretched geopolitics degrades American security, pushing Moscow and Beijing together while encouraging nuclear proliferation among smaller states. And Uncle Sam’s international hubris threatens the country’s fiscal future. The U.S. is functionally bankrupt, its debt to GDP ratio now approaching the record set after World War II and heading toward nearly twice that level by mid-century.

    No wonder the Biden administration is having such a difficult time articulating a convincing justification for squandering precious resources and courting war with a nuclear-armed power over peripheral stakes. Kiev’s political allies dismiss complaints that the average American household already has provided nearly $900 in Ukraine aid. After all, the CARES Act, presented as an antidote to the COVID pandemic, spent some $2 trillion, much of it conspicuously wasted. So what’s a few tens of billions more for Ukraine even if, predictably, the Europeans are yet again backtracking on their promises to do more for themselves?

    The Russo-Ukraine war is terrible for many reasons. It is also dangerous for U.S. Washington policymakers to only see through a glass, darkly, relying on Kiev, which is ever-ready to drag America into the conflict by means both fair and foul. Recognizing that Ukraine might not win its war with Russia is the first step to formulating a better approach for America. Then reality might finally force itself on even the most deluded Washington policymaker."
     

    https://www.theamericanconservative.com/ukraines-vain-search-for-wonder-weapons/

    Given the inexorable rise of China, perhaps a more realist foreign policy may have been to encourage Russo/German co-operation, drop the Pride parades and cement Russia AND Ukraine into Europe.

    But alas those at the heart of US policy can't forgive todays Russia for the indignities, real or amplified, their forebears suffered, more than a hundred years ago, at the hands of assorted Cossacks and Black Hundreds. Like the brilliant musician of Hamelin, they've been leading America's children into the darkness since the 1960s, and the journey continues.

    "There's a deal of ruin in a nation"

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Buzz Mohawk, @Jack D

    “More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Ukraine to wreck Russia should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy.

    Very nice trick to assume your conclusion. Notice “failing” attempt, not “failed”. It hasn’t failed yet and whether it is “failing” is not exactly an objective fact. Yes, MAYBE if our attempt FAILS it would be time to do a “rethink” but I think it’s a little early to declare defeat.

    American Conservative circa March 1941:

    “More broadly, Washington’s failing attempt to use Britain to wreck Germany should spur a broad rethink of America’s destructive foreign policy. ”

    How did that work out?

  261. @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

    “This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation”

    If someone says something is obvious, then it’s the opposite. If it was really obvious you wouldn’t have to say it.

    It is high time—it was high time long ago—to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    LOL. Maybe this hasn’t been done because it’s not within Russia’s capability short of starting a nuclear war and Russia doesn’t dare to start a nuclear war?

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky,

    Neat trick Hitler/Stalin worthy trick – assassinate Prigozhin, blame it on your enemies and then attack them. However, see above. If Russia was capable of (non-nuclear) high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, they would have done them already. What do you think they have been trying to do for the last 18 months?

    Lots of folks here have drunk the Rushist Kool-Aid (stronger than vodka) but you must have drunk a gallon of the stuff. Even Russians are not so deluded anymore.

  262. Prigozhin may have died in a plane crash for reasons very similar to Dag Hammarskjöld’s:

  263. @Jack D
    @HA


    It’s no more fanciful than believing Putin actually wants to save us from the gender-benders
     
    Or alternatively that he wants to save Ukraine from the "neo-Nazis" who run it (which he mentioned just yesterday when eulogizing the Wagner guys) , apparently the kind of neo-Nazis that have a Jewish president and don't get enough votes to be represented in the parliament.

    I guess the West is too far left for Putin and the neo-Nazis of Ukraine are too far right but Russia is just right.

    Also mentioning neo-Nazis in the same breath as Wagner and Utkin ("Wagner" himself, he of the Nazi tattoos) is sort of strange. Maybe neo-Nazis are good if they are Russian neo-Nazis but bad if they are Ukrainian ones.

    I think Alec commits a sort of Kinsley gaffe where he accidentally tells the truth. He doesn't really love Putin (honestly, he is a hard guy to love) he just hates Current Year America, so the enemy of his enemy is his friend.

    In the past, the thought (on the right at least) was always that politics stopped at the border so that we were all Americans vs. a foreign power (for example, Lindbergh kinda liked that Hitler guy but once the war started he acted like a loyal American and fought on our side) but I think that the American extreme right today sees that it has about as much chance of taking power unassisted in future America as the neo-Nazis have of taking power in Ukraine so they are not above rooting for someone else who will maybe cut the Current Year America that they hate down a notch, since they are in no position to do it themselves.

    Replies: @HA

    “I think Alec commits a sort of Kinsley gaffe where he accidentally tells the truth. He doesn’t really love Putin (honestly, he is a hard guy to love) he just hates Current Year America, so the enemy of his enemy is his friend.”

    Maybe he is one of the people who only “tolerate” Putin, much like Moscow has no genuine fondness for the useful idiots and fellow travelers who slurp up their propaganda — actually, they’re probably loathed and sneered at. I think it was Solovyev who in an unguarded moment once lamented on his talk show how stupid Russia’s supporters in the West were, or something similar.

    But people react to cognitive dissonance differently, and many of those who started out merely tolerating Putin have since contorted their attitudes into something approaching genuine affection and enthusiasm, perhaps to make their own back-stabbing less egregious. I saw the same thing with the white supremacists who once merely tolerated the Iranians they initially regarded as just one more rag-tag band of 3rd world riff-raff — because there was at least a slight possibility that they might thrash or even nuke Israel, which meant they couldn’t be all bad. As time went on, they became downright chummy with the mullahs. It’s wishful thinking in action. Some wives catch a husband cheating, and their immediate attitude is that it must have — must have — been the other woman’s fault — it’d just be easier for them to rationalize staying with him if that were the case.

  264. @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson

    Do you really think I'm saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don't. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritises.

    "A pint sized dictator". Who cares if Putin's short? Putin himself clearly doesn't.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mike Tre

    Do you really think I’m saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don’t. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritizes.

    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.

    “A pint sized dictator”. Who cares if Putin’s short? Putin himself clearly doesn’t.

    Yes he clearly cares by the fact that he wears shoe lifts. He also has censors that scour the internet for anyone that calls him a dwarf or crab. In Russia it can lead to an arrest.

    Putin is 5’3 and uses shoe lifts to appear 5’7. We know this because there are older pictures of him next to Medvedev in standard shoes.

    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7. He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson


    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.
     
    Because it makes Russia look unstable and therefore an unreliable partner.

    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7.
     
    I find it genuinely interesting that you believe this.

    He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.
     
    Look through the Kremlin site or a Russian news site and you'll find no shortage of evidence to the contrary. Look at the recent ceremony in Kursk for starters. I've seen Putin happily standing next to teenage girls and boys taller than him.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  265. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    Do you really think I’m saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don’t. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritizes.

    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.

    “A pint sized dictator”. Who cares if Putin’s short? Putin himself clearly doesn’t.

    Yes he clearly cares by the fact that he wears shoe lifts. He also has censors that scour the internet for anyone that calls him a dwarf or crab. In Russia it can lead to an arrest.

    Putin is 5'3 and uses shoe lifts to appear 5'7. We know this because there are older pictures of him next to Medvedev in standard shoes.

    This war wouldn't exist if Putin was 5'7. He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.

    Because it makes Russia look unstable and therefore an unreliable partner.

    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7.

    I find it genuinely interesting that you believe this.

    He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.

    Look through the Kremlin site or a Russian news site and you’ll find no shortage of evidence to the contrary. Look at the recent ceremony in Kursk for starters. I’ve seen Putin happily standing next to teenage girls and boys taller than him.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast


    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.
     
    Because it makes Russia look unstable and therefore an unreliable partner.

    They already know he is unstable. They aren't stupid.

    He poisons the opposition and started a 1930s style invasion without running it by the Duma or even all of his generals.

    They know he is unstable but he sells cheap oil and gas. An unstable Putin that lowers the Ruble in fact makes the oil even cheaper.


    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7.
     
    I find it genuinely interesting that you believe this.

    Then you haven't spent much time around small and bitter men. They always want to "one up" you when possible which becomes very tiring. They are best avoided in general. Sad really because a lot of it comes from unrealistic societal standards.

    Putin's autobiographer believes that he is deeply insecure and driven by a subconscious desire to overcome the bullies of his youth. She believes he is stuck in a state of arrested development. I independently reached a similar conclusion as many of his mannerisms are child like. I truly think he is a boy in an old man's body. I can dig up some videos where he sits and reacts like a child when sitting. The scripted interview with Kadyrov is really creepy.

    You don't find it odd that Putin basically owns the world's largest country and still wanted this war? It's his hopeless insecurities that are directly tied to being small.

    Look through the Kremlin site or a Russian news site and you’ll find no shortage of evidence to the contrary. Look at the recent ceremony in Kursk for starters. I’ve seen Putin happily standing next to teenage girls and boys taller than him.

    I've never seen him with a female dignitary that is over 5'8. Merkel had a lot of meetings with Putin and she is about his height.

    Regardless we know he wears shoe lifts so it is obviously an issue for him. Here is an old picture of him next to Medvedev before he started wearing them:
    https://i.ndtvimg.com/i/2015-08/putin-work-out-reuters_650x400_41440959396.jpg

    His own men were caught tape calling him and Medvedev insure half men. I never followed up on that story but my guess is that they got the stairs treatment.

  266. @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    Here's a neat example of disinformation. We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa as if it's from Russian bombing in 2023:
    https://twitter.com/USEmbassyPrague/status/1693537015436894386?s=20

    I'm sure you know about what happened at the Trade Union building that day (heck, you might even have been there) but others might not:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxcB0PI4ZLg

    Replies: @HA

    “We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa…”

    Yes I do know what happened in Odessa in 2014, which is why, even though I read to the end of your comment, you pretty much lost me there. Better luck next time. As the tweet “clarification” notes, it doesn’t affect the meme’s gist.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    I'm not trying to convince you or Jack D of anything. I'm posting comments here to clarify my own thinking, to pass the time and to share new information with others here.

    Replies: @HA

  267. @Jack D
    @Sean


    Another thing is Prigozhin repeatedly getting right up to the front line in Bakhmut for videos; that was extremely reckless of him, given US surveillance and assassinations by HIMARS of Russian Generals
     
    That's one way of looking at it and the other way is that he was personally brave and not willing to prescribe any medicine to his men that he would not take himself. Whereas the cowardly Shoigu, Putin, etc. would not be caught within 100 km of the front lines.

    It's good for Ukraine that Prigozhin, Utkin, etc. are dead and Wagner is out of Ukraine and I am glad for them. And they were both vile human beings although not as vile as the slimy Putin so the world is well rid of them. But if you are a soldier (I'm not) you have to admire them for their effectiveness and for the loyalty that they instilled in their men, which is a lot more than you can say of Shoigu and Gerasimov.

    BTW, I'm not sure we have heard the last of Wagner. It may be that the decapitation strike was enough to kill the body too, but maybe not.

    Replies: @HA

    “BTW, I’m not sure we have heard the last of Wagner. It may be that the decapitation strike was enough to kill the body too, but maybe not.”

    They’re definitely in a bind. If they don’t do anything, they come off as weak and insufficiently ruthless — not a good look for mercenaries. Whereas becoming a bunch of mercenaries who are willing to lash out at their putative masters is going make an African warlord think twice about hiring them, though I suppose that Rubicon was already crossed somewhere around Voronezh. Plus, I imagine the Russians at the least have bribed a few of their members since the mutiny to provide Moscow with ongoing intel.

  268. @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson


    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.
     
    Because it makes Russia look unstable and therefore an unreliable partner.

    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7.
     
    I find it genuinely interesting that you believe this.

    He has massive insecurities over being small. He avoids pictures with women unless they are similar in height. In his talks with the public they never put anyone that tall next to him.
     
    Look through the Kremlin site or a Russian news site and you'll find no shortage of evidence to the contrary. Look at the recent ceremony in Kursk for starters. I've seen Putin happily standing next to teenage girls and boys taller than him.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Well you explain why it would be a problem if he murdered Prigozhin during BRICs.

    Because it makes Russia look unstable and therefore an unreliable partner.

    They already know he is unstable. They aren’t stupid.

    He poisons the opposition and started a 1930s style invasion without running it by the Duma or even all of his generals.

    They know he is unstable but he sells cheap oil and gas. An unstable Putin that lowers the Ruble in fact makes the oil even cheaper.

    This war wouldn’t exist if Putin was 5’7.

    I find it genuinely interesting that you believe this.

    Then you haven’t spent much time around small and bitter men. They always want to “one up” you when possible which becomes very tiring. They are best avoided in general. Sad really because a lot of it comes from unrealistic societal standards.

    Putin’s autobiographer believes that he is deeply insecure and driven by a subconscious desire to overcome the bullies of his youth. She believes he is stuck in a state of arrested development. I independently reached a similar conclusion as many of his mannerisms are child like. I truly think he is a boy in an old man’s body. I can dig up some videos where he sits and reacts like a child when sitting. The scripted interview with Kadyrov is really creepy.

    You don’t find it odd that Putin basically owns the world’s largest country and still wanted this war? It’s his hopeless insecurities that are directly tied to being small.

    Look through the Kremlin site or a Russian news site and you’ll find no shortage of evidence to the contrary. Look at the recent ceremony in Kursk for starters. I’ve seen Putin happily standing next to teenage girls and boys taller than him.

    I’ve never seen him with a female dignitary that is over 5’8. Merkel had a lot of meetings with Putin and she is about his height.

    Regardless we know he wears shoe lifts so it is obviously an issue for him. Here is an old picture of him next to Medvedev before he started wearing them:
    His own men were caught tape calling him and Medvedev insure half men. I never followed up on that story but my guess is that they got the stairs treatment.

  269. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "We have the US embassy in Prague putting out a picture of the massacre of ethnic Russians in 2014 Odessa..."

    Yes I do know what happened in Odessa in 2014, which is why, even though I read to the end of your comment, you pretty much lost me there. Better luck next time. As the tweet "clarification" notes, it doesn't affect the meme's gist.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    I’m not trying to convince you or Jack D of anything. I’m posting comments here to clarify my own thinking, to pass the time and to share new information with others here.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "I’m posting comments here to clarify my own thinking,..."

    Given that all your content comes from troll-farm central, and is couched in the usual RT propaganda (e.g. "Odessa Massacre"), I think "clarify" is a euphemism for shoring up the flimsy walls of your echo chamber, given that even you admit it won't convince many on the outside.

    And it's been awhile since any trolls brought out the old chestnut about the so-called Odessa Massacre. They're having to dig deep, I'm guessing as their own inventory risks being depleted. What, the poor shelled children of Donbass meme just isn't doing it anymore?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @anon

  270. @vinteuil
    @Jack D


    Russian is a very profane language...Every other word an expletive is about par for the course.
     
    Yeah - just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn...I mean, the guy simply can't control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    Not a good look for Russia. I’m not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn’t a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    • Replies: @Mr Mox
    @John Johnson

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    LOL.
    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word 'gullible' comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    https://i.imgur.com/fKRIY88.jpg

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Anonymous
    @John Johnson


    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home...I’m not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape
     
    This is a typical John Johnson post. He's both lazy and stupid, so he's not very good at telling lies.

    "I was walking through my neighborhood on my way home from banging three different chicks, when I saw a wolf. Since I am 6'5" and not a midget like Vlad I killed the wolf with my bare hands. Then I decided to try the SAT and got 1600, with no test prep".
    , @vinteuil
    @John Johnson


    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.
     
    So I guess you checked out of American popular culture about fifty years ago.

    A wise choice.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Sean
    @John Johnson


    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.
     
    Ukraine was allowed to leave and take Crimea with it. Also many millions of ethnic Russians. What was wrong with the Ukrainian state's population that they thought they would become safest of all in the enjoyment of their large territory of enviable potential by trying to join the Western security order?

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people.
     
    People, yes. Unlike Tsarist Russia and the Soviet Union, the Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state, and one in which 80% of the population support Putin. There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Replies: @Jack D

  271. @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

    Didn’t Iggy and The Stooges do a song, ‘I wanna be your Pavlov’s Dog’?

  272. @Steve Sailer
    @Mr Mox

    Pavlov's Dogs is a _great_ name for a rock band.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Anonymous, @John Johnson, @MGB, @res

  273. @John Johnson
    @vinteuil

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I've listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I've never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypq65UMkq8A

    Not a good look for Russia. I'm not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn't a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    Replies: @Mr Mox, @Anonymous, @vinteuil, @Sean

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    LOL.
    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word ‘gullible’ comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mr Mox


    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.
     
    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word ‘gullible’ comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    And who else could we expect to capture Russian calls to put on the internet? Some type of international hacking group?

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Since you like newspaper cartoons I have a good Calvin and Hobbes for you:


    https://cdn.quotesgram.com/img/97/7/1768794901-denial.jpg

    Replies: @Mr Mox

  274. @John Johnson
    Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO

    If Ukraine was a de facto protectorate then the US would have launched cruise missiles upon invasion and immediately provided them with Apaches, A10s, spectres, spookys, long range HIMARs and F-35s. Limited US military aid only started rolling after Ukraine pushed the Russians out of Kiev. Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    Putin was threatening to use nukes before the US sent military aid. He actually threatened to use them upon invasion and that was after he swore it was all a training exercise. Can provide sources if you would like.

    Both Putin and Medvedev have in fact threatened to nuke the whole world over Ukraine from the very beginning. The West was told that the nukes could go off if they aid Ukraine. That was around the time that the dictator declared LPR/DPR to be new countries and has since taken them as Russian territory. The weasel betrayed his own supporters and had the LPR/DPR militia men sent to the front.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a "special military operation" that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan.

    The weasel dictator can't even respect the dead. Hot off the press in Weasel Dictator News:

    Russia removes graves of Wagner fallen

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQSw4xgitrg

    What a total POS. Unreal that some of you continue to defend him.

    Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge. I can't believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn't think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    Replies: @used tire, @Putinandhisfansaremorons, @Sean, @Colin Wright

    If Ukraine was an US protectorate, all Russian military units in Ukraine and on the Russian border would cease to exist in a week. It’s hilarious Russia’s peer military is Ukraine’s, but they larp that they’d have a chance against the US, let alone all of NATO lol

  275. @John Johnson
    Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO

    If Ukraine was a de facto protectorate then the US would have launched cruise missiles upon invasion and immediately provided them with Apaches, A10s, spectres, spookys, long range HIMARs and F-35s. Limited US military aid only started rolling after Ukraine pushed the Russians out of Kiev. Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    Putin was threatening to use nukes before the US sent military aid. He actually threatened to use them upon invasion and that was after he swore it was all a training exercise. Can provide sources if you would like.

    Both Putin and Medvedev have in fact threatened to nuke the whole world over Ukraine from the very beginning. The West was told that the nukes could go off if they aid Ukraine. That was around the time that the dictator declared LPR/DPR to be new countries and has since taken them as Russian territory. The weasel betrayed his own supporters and had the LPR/DPR militia men sent to the front.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a "special military operation" that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan.

    The weasel dictator can't even respect the dead. Hot off the press in Weasel Dictator News:

    Russia removes graves of Wagner fallen

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQSw4xgitrg

    What a total POS. Unreal that some of you continue to defend him.

    Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge. I can't believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn't think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    Replies: @used tire, @Putinandhisfansaremorons, @Sean, @Colin Wright

    Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope

    Ben Hodges did not think that, he correctly predicted the invasion would not work. Certainty does not exist in this world, something you may with to ponder in relation to your belief that Russia is at best stalemated, Putin will fall and, his only hope is to give up. Vietnam was on the other side of the world, and America could not exert its full strength, because there was an ocean between it and a very foreign land in which America would lose interest after it left. Russia does not look at Ukraine as a far off country that could be forgotten about in the same way. No not at all. Vietnam style ambushes of over extended armored columns was how Ukraine did fight and it was very effective. Unfortunately for Ukraine, Russia altered tack last June, and they are standing on the defensive, where their artillery can support them in the traditional way the Russian army fights. Bakhmut was an infantry and artillery led slow head on type of fighting that the Ukrainians accepted battle in and Russian tactics evolved in. The greatest mistake of Ukraine has been taking Western advice to mount conventional combined arms offensives yet doing so on on too broad a front that included the East where Russian logistics are strong. Ukraine ought to have concentrated all available forces for a concentric offensive in the South as Western military experts continue to urge.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a “special military operation” that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan

    For the world to be blown up the US would have to get directly involved in fighting Russia, and no one in Washington ought to be in any doubt about that, so it is good that Putin is threatening. Moreover, were Ukraine to start seriously pushing Russia back out of Ukraine, Putin quite possibly would resort to a theatre thermonuclear option against the Ukrainian army, which is why Ukraine has not been given seriously effective arms by America. He is not going to quit and neither is he going to swallow a loss, or at least a worse loss than he has already suffered. Anyway, most people do not think Russia is going to be pushed back significantly.

    I can’t believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn’t think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    Britain is an island. Real conflicts of interest exist between sovereign states with land borders, and when theseget settled, it often comes about by fighting it out. Not flouts and jeers.

  276. Anonymous[419] • Disclaimer says:
    @John Johnson
    @vinteuil

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I've listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I've never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypq65UMkq8A

    Not a good look for Russia. I'm not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn't a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    Replies: @Mr Mox, @Anonymous, @vinteuil, @Sean

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home…I’m not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape

    This is a typical John Johnson post. He’s both lazy and stupid, so he’s not very good at telling lies.

    “I was walking through my neighborhood on my way home from banging three different chicks, when I saw a wolf. Since I am 6’5″ and not a midget like Vlad I killed the wolf with my bare hands. Then I decided to try the SAT and got 1600, with no test prep”.

  277. @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    I'm not trying to convince you or Jack D of anything. I'm posting comments here to clarify my own thinking, to pass the time and to share new information with others here.

    Replies: @HA

    “I’m posting comments here to clarify my own thinking,…”

    Given that all your content comes from troll-farm central, and is couched in the usual RT propaganda (e.g. “Odessa Massacre”), I think “clarify” is a euphemism for shoring up the flimsy walls of your echo chamber, given that even you admit it won’t convince many on the outside.

    And it’s been awhile since any trolls brought out the old chestnut about the so-called Odessa Massacre. They’re having to dig deep, I’m guessing as their own inventory risks being depleted. What, the poor shelled children of Donbass meme just isn’t doing it anymore?

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    https://twitter.com/I_Katchanovski/status/1695475353341333630?s=20

    Replies: @HA

    , @anon
    @HA

    Oh no HA!
    the Ghost of KIEV was brought down by a pickle jar thrown by a RuZZian Babushka!
    https://www.news.com.au/technology/innovation/military/ukrainian-pilot-juice-part-of-ghost-of-kyiv-unit-and-two-others-dead-in-midair-collision/news-story/3168f3480b91c9df08a0f226afc4cdc7

  278. Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people. No real person would write so many posts and push their propaganda so relentlessly. These pseudonyms must be a committee of writers sitting in a room at the CIA or somewhere cranking out slander and rejoinders to every other commenter. The “fanboy” vitriol and insults are exactly the tactics of government propaganda agencies.

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @rebel yell

    I think they're real people who insist on using mass media techniques (aka the Megaphone) despite this being a person-to-person playing field. I mean they're acting like talk radio, TV or print journalists when they just keep hammering their shortlist of talking points and insisting their opponents are really saying X when they say Y. These techniques still work in the wider world so it's not surprising HA and Jack D use them here.

    Replies: @Wokechoke

    , @Intelligent Dasein
    @rebel yell


    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.
     
    They aren't, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I've been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term "real person" is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as "Steve Sailer" is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who's trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    Replies: @Jack D, @Wokechoke, @John Johnson, @Twinkie

  279. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "I’m posting comments here to clarify my own thinking,..."

    Given that all your content comes from troll-farm central, and is couched in the usual RT propaganda (e.g. "Odessa Massacre"), I think "clarify" is a euphemism for shoring up the flimsy walls of your echo chamber, given that even you admit it won't convince many on the outside.

    And it's been awhile since any trolls brought out the old chestnut about the so-called Odessa Massacre. They're having to dig deep, I'm guessing as their own inventory risks being depleted. What, the poor shelled children of Donbass meme just isn't doing it anymore?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @anon

    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "Nobody cares about evidence & academic studies of this massacre."

    No, nobody aside from RT and their trolls care about HIS so-called academic studies. This is classic anti-vaxxer logic -- let's just skip over everyone except a cherry-picked selection of oddball cranks and loons who happen to align with our prejudices.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  280. @Mr Mox
    @William Badwhite

    You guys should start a band or something.

    But what should they call the band? "Pavlov's Dogs" perhaps? Whenever Russia/Putin Ukraine/Zelensky is mentioned, they predictably pop up and start salivating.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Mike Tre

    How about Steppe West?

  281. @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson

    Do you really think I'm saying it would be in poor taste? I bet you don't. You understood I was saying it would not be consistent with what Putin clearly prioritises.

    "A pint sized dictator". Who cares if Putin's short? Putin himself clearly doesn't.

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Mike Tre

    He’s probably taller than Zelensky and Victoria Nuland.

  282. @Mr Mox
    @John Johnson

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    LOL.
    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word 'gullible' comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    https://i.imgur.com/fKRIY88.jpg

    Replies: @John Johnson

    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word ‘gullible’ comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    And who else could we expect to capture Russian calls to put on the internet? Some type of international hacking group?

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Since you like newspaper cartoons I have a good Calvin and Hobbes for you:

    • Replies: @Mr Mox
    @John Johnson

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Back to WW2, are we now?

    Here's an article from another intellectual russia-hater, Jonathan Littell:

    https://www.rferl.org/a/interview-jonathan-littell-journalist-russia-defeat-ukraine/32549338.html


    One thing that had struck me during the Georgian conflict, [after having much] experience in Chechnya with war: I was very familiar with the Russian Army and its behavior, its practices, its levels of discipline or lack of levels of discipline: violence, alcoholism, torture, mass kidnappings, disappearances, illegal executions, and so forth. So I was extremely surprised in Georgia about how well behaved the Russian Army was, how professional it suddenly seemed compared with the guys I knew from the two Chechen wars.

     

    Of course, Littell manage to snap out of it, and get back on the Russia-bashing track he was supposed to follow. But for some reason some people will rather drink lukewarm morning-urine than admit to the leopard sometimes can change his spots. In their minds, present day Russian troops are no different from the Asiatic hordes that conquered Berlin, raping all the women and, allegedly, stealing lightbulbs and faucets, thinking they would still work back in Mother Russia.

    The Ukrainians, on the other hand... don't you know they selected a Jewish president?! How dare anyone imply they could harbor a Nazi streak, when all they wanted to do, was to be left alone and grow sunflowers? Okay, so they did shell some of their eastern citizens from time to time, but it was all just fun and games. No harm intended.

    Replies: @Jack D

  283. @rebel yell
    Reading through this thread - HA and Jack D don't sound like real people. No real person would write so many posts and push their propaganda so relentlessly. These pseudonyms must be a committee of writers sitting in a room at the CIA or somewhere cranking out slander and rejoinders to every other commenter. The "fanboy" vitriol and insults are exactly the tactics of government propaganda agencies.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Intelligent Dasein

    I think they’re real people who insist on using mass media techniques (aka the Megaphone) despite this being a person-to-person playing field. I mean they’re acting like talk radio, TV or print journalists when they just keep hammering their shortlist of talking points and insisting their opponents are really saying X when they say Y. These techniques still work in the wider world so it’s not surprising HA and Jack D use them here.

    • Replies: @Wokechoke
    @Cagey Beast

    Spot on.

    He takes on certain apparently radical view points but twists them in such a way that you have to agree with the StatusQuo policy anyway.

    It’s pretty interesting to witness a CIA committee in action.

  284. OT but related too:
    The Germans are being told what story their rulers are going with on the Nord Stream sabotage:

    Investigating the Nord Stream Attack
    All the Evidence Points To Kyiv

    It’s a spy thriller that has the potential to change the course of international politics: A year ago, a secret commando blew up the Nord Stream pipelines in the Baltic Sea. Since then, investigators have been searching for the perpetrators. The leads they have found are extremely politically sensitive.

    https://www.spiegel.de/international/investigating-the-attack-on-nord-stream-all-the-clues-point-toward-kyiv-a-124838c7-992a-4d0e-9894-942d4a665778?sara_ref=re-so-tw-sh

  285. @dimples
    @HA

    I guess Putin factored in that the inhabitants of Finland and Sweden are relatively sane, whereas the Ukes were mentally retarded Nazis. Which would you like as your next door neighbour?

    Replies: @HA

    “I guess Putin factored in that the inhabitants of Finland and Sweden are relatively sane, whereas the Ukes were mentally retarded Nazis.”

    Sounds like just the right kind of people to try and merge with Russia, eh? And again, according to the trolls’ own propaganda, Poland will be Russia’s neighbor as soon as it swallows up Western Ukraine (which I’m guessing will occur right after “the gloves finally come off” which Macgregor says — and has said for the last year and a half — will happen any day now). If that kind of confrontation is what Putin is hoping to find, what was all this nonsense about buffer states?

  286. @John Johnson
    @HA

    And you’ll never guess who was the very first person on this thread (about goings on in Russia, in case you didn’t notice) to mention Zelensky. Why, that would be you, surprise-surprise, followed by another Putin fanboy in the comment right after you. I.e., if you’re angry about people obsessed with Zelensky, you guys should maybe take a look in the mirror.

    It's a very bizarre phenomenon that we have observed in Putin defenders since the beginning of the war.

    They seem obsessed with Zelensky and assume we idolize him like they do with Putin. They don't seem to realize that they are usually the only ones talking about him. It's a classic case of projection. They don't get that we aren't tribal alpha brained to Zelensky.

    Even stranger is that they think Zelensky is keeping Ukraine in the war. As if the country would accept Russian rule without him.

    Polls show that a strong majority of the Ukrainian public supports the war. Zelensky openly states that he defaults to his generals. Which means his replacement would continue the same policy.

    MacGregor and Ritter are the same way. They will speak of Zelensky as if he is also a dictator and has a cult following. They seem to view this as a war of competing dictators. When MacGregor speaks of Zelensky it looks like a vein is going to pop out of his head. He can't talk about the war without mentioning Zelensky. The will denigrate him as an actor but then speak of him as he if has Jewish spell powers. No mention that Putin has closer ties to Israel and in fact Israel again turned down a weapons request from Ukraine.

    Replies: @HA

    “They seem obsessed with Zelensky and assume we idolize him like they do with Putin.”

    They also don’t want to mention the Ukrainian military leaders that Zelensky defers to, like Zaluzhny and Budanov, since for months they claimed both were dead (or sidelined after receiving a craniotomy), or else just deep fakes. So they’re left with playing projection games about how it’s actually Ukraine that is run by an increasingly unhinged dictator.

    Here’s Budanov — or some deep fake AI, depending on who you listen to — trolling the Russians with a taste of their own medicine.

  287. @Cagey Beast
    @HA

    https://twitter.com/I_Katchanovski/status/1695475353341333630?s=20

    Replies: @HA

    “Nobody cares about evidence & academic studies of this massacre.”

    No, nobody aside from RT and their trolls care about HIS so-called academic studies. This is classic anti-vaxxer logic — let’s just skip over everyone except a cherry-picked selection of oddball cranks and loons who happen to align with our prejudices.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @HA

    This is classic anti-vaxxer logic — let’s just skip over everyone except a cherry-picked selection of oddball cranks and loons who happen to align with our prejudices.

    Also ignore the cranks and loons that died of COVID.

  288. @John Johnson
    @Mr Mox


    I’ve listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.
     
    Brought to you from the security service of Ukraine, no less!
    When reading your post, the word ‘gullible’ comes to mind, Mr. Johnson.

    And who else could we expect to capture Russian calls to put on the internet? Some type of international hacking group?

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Since you like newspaper cartoons I have a good Calvin and Hobbes for you:


    https://cdn.quotesgram.com/img/97/7/1768794901-denial.jpg

    Replies: @Mr Mox

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Back to WW2, are we now?

    Here’s an article from another intellectual russia-hater, Jonathan Littell:

    https://www.rferl.org/a/interview-jonathan-littell-journalist-russia-defeat-ukraine/32549338.html

    One thing that had struck me during the Georgian conflict, [after having much] experience in Chechnya with war: I was very familiar with the Russian Army and its behavior, its practices, its levels of discipline or lack of levels of discipline: violence, alcoholism, torture, mass kidnappings, disappearances, illegal executions, and so forth. So I was extremely surprised in Georgia about how well behaved the Russian Army was, how professional it suddenly seemed compared with the guys I knew from the two Chechen wars.

    Of course, Littell manage to snap out of it, and get back on the Russia-bashing track he was supposed to follow. But for some reason some people will rather drink lukewarm morning-urine than admit to the leopard sometimes can change his spots. In their minds, present day Russian troops are no different from the Asiatic hordes that conquered Berlin, raping all the women and, allegedly, stealing lightbulbs and faucets, thinking they would still work back in Mother Russia.

    The Ukrainians, on the other hand… don’t you know they selected a Jewish president?! How dare anyone imply they could harbor a Nazi streak, when all they wanted to do, was to be left alone and grow sunflowers? Okay, so they did shell some of their eastern citizens from time to time, but it was all just fun and games. No harm intended.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Mr Mox

    A masterpiece of selective quoting.

    Here is some of the rest:



    I was thinking at the time: Has the Russian Army really evolved? As we've seen with the Ukraine war, this was a completely false impression. The only thing I would change about what I was writing then was that this apparent modernization and discipline was completely superficial.</blockquote>
     

     
  289. @John Johnson
    @vinteuil

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I've listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I've never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypq65UMkq8A

    Not a good look for Russia. I'm not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn't a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    Replies: @Mr Mox, @Anonymous, @vinteuil, @Sean

    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    So I guess you checked out of American popular culture about fifty years ago.

    A wise choice.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @vinteuil


    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.
     
    So I guess you checked out of American popular culture about fifty years ago.

    A wise choice.

    I'm actually not a boomer like most of you. I really don't like boomers other than Unz and Steve.

    I watch shows and movies but not to the degree of most Americans. Regardless I don't like hearing F bombs at the grocery store or seeing F-IT stickers on jacked up trucks. I voted for Trump but found the "let's go brandon" to be crass and stupid. Was funny the first 30 seconds of the video but quickly became a dead horse.

    Russians still swear more than Americans based on captured phone calls.

    Americans well may be #2 but I would guess the Irish or British.

  290. @rebel yell
    Reading through this thread - HA and Jack D don't sound like real people. No real person would write so many posts and push their propaganda so relentlessly. These pseudonyms must be a committee of writers sitting in a room at the CIA or somewhere cranking out slander and rejoinders to every other commenter. The "fanboy" vitriol and insults are exactly the tactics of government propaganda agencies.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Intelligent Dasein

    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.

    They aren’t, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I’ve been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term “real person” is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as “Steve Sailer” is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who’s trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    • Thanks: Mike Tre
    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Intelligent Dasein

    We are all AI simulations. Well not all, only the people you disagree with.

    , @Wokechoke
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Spot on.

    He takes on certain apparently radical view points but twists them in such a way that you have to agree with the StatusQuo policy anyway.

    It’s pretty interesting to witness a CIA committee in action.

    , @John Johnson
    @Intelligent Dasein

    They aren’t, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I’ve been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term “real person” is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    LOL I started posting here on the Kersey blog. That was verified by someone who incorrectly assumed I started posting during COVID. Can go verify again if you would like.

    Was I keeping tabs on Dissident Right by revealing secrets about how colleges circumvent Affirmative Action? What about my posts on race and biology? All just an elaborate ruse to build credibility before taking positions that you find threatening? Do you really think a government watchdog group would pay someone to discuss how modern Anthropology is based on Boasnian/Frankfurt fraud and promotes race denial?

    Do you really have that hard of a time with dissenting viewpoints? You do acknowledge that supporting Ukraine and the vaccine is the normal position outside of Unz?

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who’s trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Of all my posts you picked my rant about Whites watching too much sports? You believe some government force that keeps tabs on alt-right is trying to encourage Whites to watch less sports? Does that make sense to you?

    , @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?
     
    I feel badly for you. You once admired me, but then I made you feel stupid, and, now, you go around badmouthing me as some sort of a "Dissident Right" watchdog.

    This was you 4.5 years ago: https://www.unz.com/anepigone/culturally-christian/#comment-3090477

    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.
     
    Move on, young fella. You don't need my approval and you don't need to try to make me fall in the eyes of others to make yourself feel better. The best revenge is living well. Go live well in the real world. Frequenting online worlds like this one is clearly not healthy for your sanity.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

  291. @Intelligent Dasein
    @rebel yell


    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.
     
    They aren't, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I've been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term "real person" is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as "Steve Sailer" is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who's trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    Replies: @Jack D, @Wokechoke, @John Johnson, @Twinkie

    We are all AI simulations. Well not all, only the people you disagree with.

    • Agree: John Johnson
  292. @Mr Mox
    @John Johnson

    So you are taking the position that the calls are fabricated? Do you believe the Russian POW accounts of rape and torture of citizens to also be fabricated? This is going to be the war where Russians are admired for high standards in warfare? A break from Syria, Afghanistan and WW2? You do acknowledge the mass rape of Berlin by the Red Army in WW2, right?

    Back to WW2, are we now?

    Here's an article from another intellectual russia-hater, Jonathan Littell:

    https://www.rferl.org/a/interview-jonathan-littell-journalist-russia-defeat-ukraine/32549338.html


    One thing that had struck me during the Georgian conflict, [after having much] experience in Chechnya with war: I was very familiar with the Russian Army and its behavior, its practices, its levels of discipline or lack of levels of discipline: violence, alcoholism, torture, mass kidnappings, disappearances, illegal executions, and so forth. So I was extremely surprised in Georgia about how well behaved the Russian Army was, how professional it suddenly seemed compared with the guys I knew from the two Chechen wars.

     

    Of course, Littell manage to snap out of it, and get back on the Russia-bashing track he was supposed to follow. But for some reason some people will rather drink lukewarm morning-urine than admit to the leopard sometimes can change his spots. In their minds, present day Russian troops are no different from the Asiatic hordes that conquered Berlin, raping all the women and, allegedly, stealing lightbulbs and faucets, thinking they would still work back in Mother Russia.

    The Ukrainians, on the other hand... don't you know they selected a Jewish president?! How dare anyone imply they could harbor a Nazi streak, when all they wanted to do, was to be left alone and grow sunflowers? Okay, so they did shell some of their eastern citizens from time to time, but it was all just fun and games. No harm intended.

    Replies: @Jack D

    A masterpiece of selective quoting.

    Here is some of the rest:

    I was thinking at the time: Has the Russian Army really evolved? As we’ve seen with the Ukraine war, this was a completely false impression. The only thing I would change about what I was writing then was that this apparent modernization and discipline was completely superficial.</blockquote>

  293. @Intelligent Dasein
    @rebel yell


    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.
     
    They aren't, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I've been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term "real person" is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as "Steve Sailer" is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who's trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    Replies: @Jack D, @Wokechoke, @John Johnson, @Twinkie

    Spot on.

    He takes on certain apparently radical view points but twists them in such a way that you have to agree with the StatusQuo policy anyway.

    It’s pretty interesting to witness a CIA committee in action.

  294. @Cagey Beast
    @rebel yell

    I think they're real people who insist on using mass media techniques (aka the Megaphone) despite this being a person-to-person playing field. I mean they're acting like talk radio, TV or print journalists when they just keep hammering their shortlist of talking points and insisting their opponents are really saying X when they say Y. These techniques still work in the wider world so it's not surprising HA and Jack D use them here.

    Replies: @Wokechoke

    Spot on.

    He takes on certain apparently radical view points but twists them in such a way that you have to agree with the StatusQuo policy anyway.

    It’s pretty interesting to witness a CIA committee in action.

  295. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "Nobody cares about evidence & academic studies of this massacre."

    No, nobody aside from RT and their trolls care about HIS so-called academic studies. This is classic anti-vaxxer logic -- let's just skip over everyone except a cherry-picked selection of oddball cranks and loons who happen to align with our prejudices.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    This is classic anti-vaxxer logic — let’s just skip over everyone except a cherry-picked selection of oddball cranks and loons who happen to align with our prejudices.

    Also ignore the cranks and loons that died of COVID.

  296. @Intelligent Dasein
    @rebel yell


    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.
     
    They aren't, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I've been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term "real person" is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as "Steve Sailer" is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who's trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    Replies: @Jack D, @Wokechoke, @John Johnson, @Twinkie

    They aren’t, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I’ve been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term “real person” is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    LOL I started posting here on the Kersey blog. That was verified by someone who incorrectly assumed I started posting during COVID. Can go verify again if you would like.

    Was I keeping tabs on Dissident Right by revealing secrets about how colleges circumvent Affirmative Action? What about my posts on race and biology? All just an elaborate ruse to build credibility before taking positions that you find threatening? Do you really think a government watchdog group would pay someone to discuss how modern Anthropology is based on Boasnian/Frankfurt fraud and promotes race denial?

    Do you really have that hard of a time with dissenting viewpoints? You do acknowledge that supporting Ukraine and the vaccine is the normal position outside of Unz?

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who’s trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Of all my posts you picked my rant about Whites watching too much sports? You believe some government force that keeps tabs on alt-right is trying to encourage Whites to watch less sports? Does that make sense to you?

  297. @vinteuil
    @John Johnson


    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.
     
    So I guess you checked out of American popular culture about fifty years ago.

    A wise choice.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    I’ve never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    So I guess you checked out of American popular culture about fifty years ago.

    A wise choice.

    I’m actually not a boomer like most of you. I really don’t like boomers other than Unz and Steve.

    I watch shows and movies but not to the degree of most Americans. Regardless I don’t like hearing F bombs at the grocery store or seeing F-IT stickers on jacked up trucks. I voted for Trump but found the “let’s go brandon” to be crass and stupid. Was funny the first 30 seconds of the video but quickly became a dead horse.

    Russians still swear more than Americans based on captured phone calls.

    Americans well may be #2 but I would guess the Irish or British.

  298. Anonymous[240] • Disclaimer says:
    @Bardon Kaldian
    @Anonymous

    Our people don't fully understand how much we reset them with that Storm.

    The political and geographical capital of 2 Serbian uprisings, 2 Balkan wars, 2 world wars went to dust and ashes in 2 months of 1995.

    Two hundred years of the development of the Serbian state and Serbian political thought, expansion and unification of the Serbs on both sides of the Drina river (Greater Serbia) imploded epically and irretrievably went into the dustbin of history.

    In addition, we destroyed the image of them, dominant among their Western allies as the victorious side, and those who comforted them, rooted for them and let them rule from Karavanke to Vardar are now playing tricks on them with genocide and Kosovo.

    Bonus points for Tuđman, he directly knocked Montenegro and Kosovo out of Serbia with an epic defeat - nobody wants to be part of a defeated and hated country.

    And what would have happened if we had continued and taken Banja Luka, we would have dismantled them like Stalin Germany’s imperial ambitions- forever.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    unification of the Serbs on both sides of the Drina river (Greater Serbia) imploded epically and irretrievably went into the dustbin of history

    You must be thinking of the wrong river. There are only Serbs now on both sides of almost the entirety of the Drina. Only Serbs on 49% of Bosnia. Unification is a formality and only a question of time.

    And what would have happened if we had continued and taken Banja Luka

    It would be a Muslim ruled city. Do you really wish your own side would have sacrificed lives to make that happen, just because you dislike the Serbs more?

  299. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "I’m posting comments here to clarify my own thinking,..."

    Given that all your content comes from troll-farm central, and is couched in the usual RT propaganda (e.g. "Odessa Massacre"), I think "clarify" is a euphemism for shoring up the flimsy walls of your echo chamber, given that even you admit it won't convince many on the outside.

    And it's been awhile since any trolls brought out the old chestnut about the so-called Odessa Massacre. They're having to dig deep, I'm guessing as their own inventory risks being depleted. What, the poor shelled children of Donbass meme just isn't doing it anymore?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @anon

  300. @Intelligent Dasein
    @vinteuil

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin's murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    This was obviously a Ukrainian intelligence operation, but the Ukrainians couldn't have pulled it off without assistance from someone inside the Russian security apparatus. That means that Russian security is alarmingly full of holes, which ironically is the very problem Prigozhin was trying to draw attention to with his rebellion.

    Unfortunately, Putin's vacillation when it comes to fighting this "existential" war has gotten yet another Russian patriot killed. Russian warriors are being assassinated inside Russia while Zelensky and his Western contacts are free to traipse around the world with impunity, drumming up more money and weapons for a seemingly limitless campaign that sets no reasonable bounds to the cost.

    This is where the Russian strategy needs to be amended. Russia claims to be winning the war of attrition because it destroys Ukrainian armed forces much faster than its own forces suffer casualties. However, this doesn't matter quite so much when the other side is being resupplied continuously. There is no shortage of obsolete junk and mercenaries that the West can dump into Ukraine, enough to keep the war going for years.

    The only way to stop this is to cut off the head of the serpent. It is high time---it was high time long ago---to destroy the regime in Kiev and interdict the flow of Western weapons into Ukraine. Why this is not being done is an enduring puzzle verging upon a scandal.

    In response to continued escalation and provocation by the West, Putin's countermeasure thus far has been to make war upon grain silos. "The pain in Ukraine stays mainly with the grain," my fair lady.

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over. These are very dark times indeed. The war just became a lot more existential for Russia than it ever had been before, and Putin has no one to blame but himself. He is a capable man, an intelligent man, a great manager and a superb diplomat, but he's not a wartime consigliere.

    Replies: @MGB, @John Johnson, @vinteuil, @Jack D, @Twinkie

    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.

    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/putin-says-prigozhin-made-serious-mistakes-in-first-remarks-since-plane-crash-that-likely-killed-the-wagner-boss/ar-AA1fJPFK

    “With regard to this plane crash, first of all, I want to express my sincere condolences to the families of all the victims. It’s always a tragedy,” Putin said in a televised speech.

    “I’ve known Prigozhin for a long time, since the early ’90′s,” Putin said, describing him as a “talented businessman” with a “complicated fate” who “made serious mistakes in his life.”

    The Russian leader stopped short of confirming Prigozhin’s death but did speak in the past tense when referring to the 62-year-old. Putin said an investigation into what happened to the private jet carrying 10 people and departing from Moscow to St. Petersburg was already underway.

    To what “serious mistakes” of Prigozhin could Putin be referring? And what’s a “complicated fate”?

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.

    Still smarter than everyone else, are you?

    Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while. It’s like the Onion, only much more demented. Kinda like a movie so bad, it’s unintentionally funny and is, therefore, good. Keep it up, rocket scientist.

    • Replies: @MEH 0910
    @Twinkie


    Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while.
     
    Intelligent Dasein has a (seldom used) blog and YouTube channel:

    http://intelligentdasein.blogspot.com/

    Dasein Introductions
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCMzcMA-Yjo
    Mar 1, 2022

    Wanting to be more personal
     
    Sincerity
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PwCVVIuIZvE
    Mar 10, 2022

    In which I talk about who is genuine and who isn't in the Sailer blog comments.
     

    Replies: @Twinkie

    , @HA
    @Twinkie

    "Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while."

    I'm pretty sure he's got a cork board.


    https://fersacambridge.files.wordpress.com/2021/04/charlie-day.jpeg

  301. @Mike Tre
    @Peter Akuleyev

    And your point is what, exactly?

    Paris is more African now than it was 50 years ago, when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction. So you don't seem to have a point, unless it is to applaud the negrofication of the West.

    Replies: @Twinkie

    when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction

    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites – especially Asians – seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Twinkie

    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites – especially Asians – seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    Seattle rarely makes news. It has to be the most boring city on the West coast.

    The nightlife is terrible. The day life is boring. The restaurants serve bland and overpriced food to tourists. The most boring Swedes and Norwegians must have founded Seattle.

    The hills and poor drivers make walking around an annoyance and the downtown has too many buildings crammed in for the view of the sound.

    They have a good football team but that is about it. I really don't see why so many people move there from California. It's not cheap and dominated by boring liberal Whites that tolerate junkies shi-tting in the streets. Oh and good luck to any single guys. The East side is basically White nerds all chasing the same unattractive Asian chick who thinks she is a 10. I knew a guy from college that bought a condo there and I've never seen such a waste of money. What is the point of making 6 figures if you are in a sausage fest? He would have been better off bartending in Nashville or Austin.

    Replies: @nebulafox, @Twinkie

  302. @Intelligent Dasein
    @rebel yell


    Reading through this thread – HA and Jack D don’t sound like real people.
     
    They aren't, and neither is John Johnson or Twinkie. I've been saying this for a very long time. Of course, the term "real person" is a bit ambiguous. They are real human beings, of course, but they are not the people they present themselves to be. They are provocateurs with staged identities and their job is to watch what the Dissident Right is doing and to muddy the waters.

    The fact that all of these characters have auto-approved commenting rights while the rest of us are stuck in Whim-kanda, and the fact that they all repeat some version of the same basic regime propaganda (e.g., they were all Branch Covidians before they became Ukrainiacs) ought to make their status quite clear. In fact, it seems like the whole project known as "Steve Sailer" is nothing but a big honeypot all wormed through with informants, cheesy cutouts, and psyops influencers.

    Read this post by John Johnson. Tell me, does this sound like an authentic person, or someone who's trying to bait you into revealing something?

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    Replies: @Jack D, @Wokechoke, @John Johnson, @Twinkie

    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?

    I feel badly for you. You once admired me, but then I made you feel stupid, and, now, you go around badmouthing me as some sort of a “Dissident Right” watchdog.

    This was you 4.5 years ago: https://www.unz.com/anepigone/culturally-christian/#comment-3090477

    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.

    Move on, young fella. You don’t need my approval and you don’t need to try to make me fall in the eyes of others to make yourself feel better. The best revenge is living well. Go live well in the real world. Frequenting online worlds like this one is clearly not healthy for your sanity.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Twinkie


    I feel badly for you. You once admired me …

    This was you 4.5 years ago:


    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.
     

     
    Are you sure ID’s 2019 comment was in admiration? Or was it sarcasm: The song he included has an ironic title, given the fate of the titular subject.

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein

  303. Prigozhin’s death confirmed by DNA tests – Moscow
    Genetic testing has identified all those listed as aboard the Wagner leader’s doomed flight, the Investigative Committee has said

    https://www.rt.com/russia/581909-prigozhin-death-plane-crash-confirmed/

    • Replies: @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "Prigozhin’s death confirmed by DNA tests..., the Investigative Committee has said"

    Well, who could possibly doubt anything Russia's Investigative Committee has said? Nonetheless, I suspect Prigozhin sightings will outnumber those of Elvis, Bigfoot and Whitey Bulger, all put together, at least for a while. Tenerif, Cyprus, Bangkok -- everywere. Cue the Tom Joad speech -- "wherever they's a fight so hungry people can eat", you can bet ol' Zhenya will be there, cooking up some red hots, nice and juicy.

    Replies: @HA

  304. @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    At this point I have more respect for those who make an amoral, imperial argument on behalf of our involvement than those who make the moral argument or simply take cover in Putin’s demonization.
    Except the former don’t exist, at least not publicly.
    And the argument is there. The people behind this probably think they’re forestalling a painful decline that is inevitable if we don’t weaken China by fracturing the natural advantage of the Eurasian land mass, soon to be dominated economically by China.
    Where are these people? When is someone going to grab me by the collar and say “listen Dennis, you want your grandchildren to starve speaking Chinese?! You better sprout a pair right now a get with the program!”

    Not that it would change my mind but it would, perversely, restore a small measure of my faith in humanity.

    Replies: @Dennis Dale

    Mitt Romney proves me wrong:

    The single most important thing we can do to strengthen America relative to China is to see Russia defeated in Ukraine. A weakened Russia deters the CCP's territorial ambition, and halts Putin's vision of reestablishing the old Soviet Union. Supporting Ukraine is in our interest. pic.twitter.com/X21GGs0lTW— Senator Mitt Romney (@SenatorRomney) August 25, 2023

    Paraphrasing Gunny Hartman, hell I appreciate your honesty, you can come over to my house and recruit my son [gut punch].

    • Thanks: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Dennis Dale

    Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Colin Wright

    , @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    Romney is expressing the Washington consensus there. Thanks for posting it.

    He's wrong on every point.

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @Dennis Dale

    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.

    If Romney thinks that conflict with China is inevitable then why not grab an ally with a large military, long Chinese border and vast energy resources? Instead they've been forced into China's arms.

    And if he thought conflict with China is inevitable, then why send half American industry there?

    Watching the destruction of German industry and the Russian pivot East, Xi must feel like Cromwell at Dunbar.

    "The Lord hath delivered them into our hands"

    Replies: @Jack D

  305. @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.
     
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/putin-says-prigozhin-made-serious-mistakes-in-first-remarks-since-plane-crash-that-likely-killed-the-wagner-boss/ar-AA1fJPFK

    "With regard to this plane crash, first of all, I want to express my sincere condolences to the families of all the victims. It's always a tragedy," Putin said in a televised speech.

    "I've known Prigozhin for a long time, since the early '90′s," Putin said, describing him as a "talented businessman" with a "complicated fate" who "made serious mistakes in his life."

    The Russian leader stopped short of confirming Prigozhin's death but did speak in the past tense when referring to the 62-year-old. Putin said an investigation into what happened to the private jet carrying 10 people and departing from Moscow to St. Petersburg was already underway.
     
    To what "serious mistakes" of Prigozhin could Putin be referring? And what's a "complicated fate"?

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.
     
    Still smarter than everyone else, are you?

    Do you have a blog? If it's full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while. It's like the Onion, only much more demented. Kinda like a movie so bad, it's unintentionally funny and is, therefore, good. Keep it up, rocket scientist.

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @HA

    Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while.

    Intelligent Dasein has a (seldom used) blog and YouTube channel:

    http://intelligentdasein.blogspot.com/

    Dasein Introductions

    Mar 1, 2022

    Wanting to be more personal

    Sincerity

    Mar 10, 2022

    In which I talk about who is genuine and who isn’t in the Sailer blog comments.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @MEH 0910

    Stop right there. He's got a black v-neck t-shirt. My younger subordinates (back when I used to have a day job) told me guys with v-neck t-shirts are "d-bags." And THAT, he apparent thought, was the best, most presentable-looking getup he should wear on the Internet for the world to see.

    This is clearly a man who needs help. ;)

    And, as usual, he gets my biographical details wrong, that is, despite his desperate attempts at sounding erudite, he has basic reading comprehension problems.

  306. @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    Mitt Romney proves me wrong:


    The single most important thing we can do to strengthen America relative to China is to see Russia defeated in Ukraine. A weakened Russia deters the CCP's territorial ambition, and halts Putin's vision of reestablishing the old Soviet Union. Supporting Ukraine is in our interest. pic.twitter.com/X21GGs0lTW— Senator Mitt Romney (@SenatorRomney) August 25, 2023
     
    Paraphrasing Gunny Hartman, hell I appreciate your honesty, you can come over to my house and recruit my son [gut punch].

    Replies: @Jack D, @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon

    Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @Jack D

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    Replies: @Dennis Dale, @Jack D, @John Johnson

    , @Colin Wright
    @Jack D


    'Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?'
     
    Yes -- but why was Putin led to try to seize Kiev?

    You can't just enter events part-way through and then make your judgement. Was the British fire-bombing of Hamburg in 1943 wrong?

    ...but hadn't the Germans done a few things to bring matters to that pass?

    No doubt state prison is cruel and awful -- but what if you did something that led to the mean judge sending you there? Are we just going to omit that?

    Putin -- and everyone else for thirty years -- warned us that there would be a response if we invited the Ukraine to join NATO. So we proceeded to invite the Ukraine to join NATO. What was supposed to happen?
  307. @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    Mitt Romney proves me wrong:


    The single most important thing we can do to strengthen America relative to China is to see Russia defeated in Ukraine. A weakened Russia deters the CCP's territorial ambition, and halts Putin's vision of reestablishing the old Soviet Union. Supporting Ukraine is in our interest. pic.twitter.com/X21GGs0lTW— Senator Mitt Romney (@SenatorRomney) August 25, 2023
     
    Paraphrasing Gunny Hartman, hell I appreciate your honesty, you can come over to my house and recruit my son [gut punch].

    Replies: @Jack D, @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon

    Romney is expressing the Washington consensus there. Thanks for posting it.

    He’s wrong on every point.

  308. @Jack D
    @Dennis Dale

    Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Colin Wright

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    • Replies: @Dennis Dale
    @Cagey Beast

    China knows they only have to wait. Washington understands this too. Thus Ukraine.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    , @Jack D
    @Cagey Beast

    None say these guys:

    https://thehomehut.com/cdn/shop/products/57_e8dc2564-f841-4d92-93a1-4b74b7d6b426_1400x.jpg?v=1621252833

    , @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    They don't recognize Taiwan as a country.

    They have talked about Taiwan returning to China (which would require force as Taiwan does not want to join).

    They have practiced for a massive amphibious landing that included island control:
    https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3142851/chinese-military-drills-simulate-amphibious-landing-and-island

    Is that enough for you?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Jack D

  309. @Cagey Beast
    Prigozhin’s death confirmed by DNA tests – Moscow
    Genetic testing has identified all those listed as aboard the Wagner leader's doomed flight, the Investigative Committee has said

    https://www.rt.com/russia/581909-prigozhin-death-plane-crash-confirmed/

    Replies: @HA

    “Prigozhin’s death confirmed by DNA tests…, the Investigative Committee has said”

    Well, who could possibly doubt anything Russia’s Investigative Committee has said? Nonetheless, I suspect Prigozhin sightings will outnumber those of Elvis, Bigfoot and Whitey Bulger, all put together, at least for a while. Tenerif, Cyprus, Bangkok — everywere. Cue the Tom Joad speech — “wherever they’s a fight so hungry people can eat”, you can bet ol’ Zhenya will be there, cooking up some red hots, nice and juicy.

    • Replies: @HA
    @HA

    "I suspect Prigozhin sightings will outnumber those of Elvis, Bigfoot and Whitey Bulger, all put together, at least for a while. Tenerif, Cyprus, Bangkok — everyw[h]ere."


    Wagner Boss Yevgeny Prigozhin is Still Alive and Plotting His Revenge on Vladimir Putin, Russian Analyst Claims

    A Russian political analyst recently claimed that Wagner boss Yevgeny Prigozhin is still alive and plotting his revenge against Vladimir Putin, RadarOnline.com has learned....Dr. Valery Solovey claimed that Prigozhin is “alive, well, and free” in an undisclosed country.

    According to Solovey, Prigozhin evaded Putin’s alleged assassination attempt by placing a body double on the private jet that mysteriously crashed on its way to St. Petersburg on August 23.

    Even more surprising was the Russian analyst’s claim that Putin was aware Prigozhin was not on the flight that tumbled out of the sky last week... Solovey said on Tuesday, according to Daily Mail. “By the way, Vladimir Putin is perfectly aware of that.”

    “If you believe official statements of the Russian authorities, then what can I say?” the Russian analyst added.
     

  310. @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    If Putin does not respond forcefully to the Prigozhin martyrdom with high-level attacks upon Kiev and the elimination of regime figures including Zelensky, then his government will split and his days in command of Russia will be over.
     
    https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/putin-says-prigozhin-made-serious-mistakes-in-first-remarks-since-plane-crash-that-likely-killed-the-wagner-boss/ar-AA1fJPFK

    "With regard to this plane crash, first of all, I want to express my sincere condolences to the families of all the victims. It's always a tragedy," Putin said in a televised speech.

    "I've known Prigozhin for a long time, since the early '90′s," Putin said, describing him as a "talented businessman" with a "complicated fate" who "made serious mistakes in his life."

    The Russian leader stopped short of confirming Prigozhin's death but did speak in the past tense when referring to the 62-year-old. Putin said an investigation into what happened to the private jet carrying 10 people and departing from Moscow to St. Petersburg was already underway.
     
    To what "serious mistakes" of Prigozhin could Putin be referring? And what's a "complicated fate"?

    Anybody who thinks Putin had anything to do with Prigozhin’s murder is a bigger idiot than I thought the average Stevist to be, which is not something easy to do.
     
    Still smarter than everyone else, are you?

    Do you have a blog? If it's full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while. It's like the Onion, only much more demented. Kinda like a movie so bad, it's unintentionally funny and is, therefore, good. Keep it up, rocket scientist.

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @HA

    “Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while.”

    I’m pretty sure he’s got a cork board.

    • LOL: Twinkie, John Johnson
  311. @Cagey Beast
    @Jack D

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    Replies: @Dennis Dale, @Jack D, @John Johnson

    China knows they only have to wait. Washington understands this too. Thus Ukraine.

    • Agree: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    If Washington wasn't entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along. It's yet another case of "if your only tool is a hammer...".

    Replies: @vinteuil, @John Johnson

  312. @Dennis Dale
    @Cagey Beast

    China knows they only have to wait. Washington understands this too. Thus Ukraine.

    Replies: @Cagey Beast

    If Washington wasn’t entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along. It’s yet another case of “if your only tool is a hammer…”.

    • Replies: @vinteuil
    @Cagey Beast

    If Washington wasn’t entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along.

    Yes. Pushing today for conflict with China over Taiwan is, if possible, even more foolish than pushing ten years ago for conflict with Russia over Ukraine.

    , @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    If Washington wasn’t entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along.

    Taiwan does not want to be part of totalitarian China where you can 7 years for writing a poem.
    https://nationalpost.com/news/this-is-the-poem-that-got-a-chinese-activist-seven-years-in-jail

    The sun does not rise and fall with the United States.

    People in Taiwan have their own dreams and desires that are not determined by Yankees. The conflict of larger states wanting to possess nearby smaller states for whatever reason has gone on for thousands of years.

    Taiwan has a high standard of living and didn't have to go on a Communist killing spree led by a cult leader named Mao. They didn't want to join the great revolution and don't want to join modern China that has since realized that Marxism is a waste of time but kept the totalitarian government.

  313. @Bardon Kaldian
    Strange Steve has supposed spelling difficulties. A scientifically literate man should be aware of Ilya Prigogine for many years. Prigogine was not just a scientist, but a deep thinking natural philosopher.

    Unlike most Nobelists in the past 50 or so years.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Esso, @Esso

    My last reply was hopeless word salad. I mean: Computers are an example of a “dissipative self-organizing system” if any. Trying to model the behavior computers or computer programs with classical dynamical systems or chaos is obviously needless and unmotivated. With biological systems one could do some plausible handwaving in Prigogine’s day but it’s just as pointless IMO.

    I think the interesting thing here is the relation between the meaning of computations (in the sense if two computations are the same in some sense) and dissipation, and the conservation of some of that meaning by reversible laws.

  314. @Cagey Beast
    @Jack D

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    Replies: @Dennis Dale, @Jack D, @John Johnson

    None say these guys:

  315. @Cagey Beast
    @Jack D

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    Replies: @Dennis Dale, @Jack D, @John Johnson

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    They don’t recognize Taiwan as a country.

    They have talked about Taiwan returning to China (which would require force as Taiwan does not want to join).

    They have practiced for a massive amphibious landing that included island control:
    https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3142851/chinese-military-drills-simulate-amphibious-landing-and-island

    Is that enough for you?

    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson

    No that's not enough because that has been the policy of mainland (Red) China since 1949. If nothing much has changed on the Chinese side, then this is more shit-disturbing by Washington.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    No it's not going to be enough until the landings actually start. These guys swore up and down that the Russians were never going to invade until they did.

    Replies: @John Johnson

  316. @Dennis Dale
    @Dennis Dale

    Mitt Romney proves me wrong:


    The single most important thing we can do to strengthen America relative to China is to see Russia defeated in Ukraine. A weakened Russia deters the CCP's territorial ambition, and halts Putin's vision of reestablishing the old Soviet Union. Supporting Ukraine is in our interest. pic.twitter.com/X21GGs0lTW— Senator Mitt Romney (@SenatorRomney) August 25, 2023
     
    Paraphrasing Gunny Hartman, hell I appreciate your honesty, you can come over to my house and recruit my son [gut punch].

    Replies: @Jack D, @Cagey Beast, @YetAnotherAnon

    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.

    If Romney thinks that conflict with China is inevitable then why not grab an ally with a large military, long Chinese border and vast energy resources? Instead they’ve been forced into China’s arms.

    And if he thought conflict with China is inevitable, then why send half American industry there?

    Watching the destruction of German industry and the Russian pivot East, Xi must feel like Cromwell at Dunbar.

    “The Lord hath delivered them into our hands”

    • Agree: Cagey Beast, Dennis Dale
    • Replies: @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.
     
    Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine. It was a total failure. It didn't work. There was no "wandel" (change). Putin just became more and more dictatorial and not at all "cleaved" to the West. He took the West's money and distributed it among his friends and used it to re-arm Russia but he had no use for Western notions of human rights. Fortunately for Ukraine, more of it ended up in LA real estate than in weapons but there was zero "cleaving" going on.

    Ideologically Putin was and is a product of the KGB and is comfortable only with other state security tyrants who are products of Communist systems - Xi is his natural friend.

    Replies: @HA, @YetAnotherAnon

  317. @Twinkie
    @Mike Tre


    when most US cities were already well on their way to being ruined by negro dysfunction
     
    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites - especially Asians - seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    https://cdn.abcotvs.com/dip/images/6246380_061320-cc-ap-seattle-chaz-im.jpg

    Replies: @John Johnson

    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites – especially Asians – seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    Seattle rarely makes news. It has to be the most boring city on the West coast.

    The nightlife is terrible. The day life is boring. The restaurants serve bland and overpriced food to tourists. The most boring Swedes and Norwegians must have founded Seattle.

    The hills and poor drivers make walking around an annoyance and the downtown has too many buildings crammed in for the view of the sound.

    They have a good football team but that is about it. I really don’t see why so many people move there from California. It’s not cheap and dominated by boring liberal Whites that tolerate junkies shi-tting in the streets. Oh and good luck to any single guys. The East side is basically White nerds all chasing the same unattractive Asian chick who thinks she is a 10. I knew a guy from college that bought a condo there and I’ve never seen such a waste of money. What is the point of making 6 figures if you are in a sausage fest? He would have been better off bartending in Nashville or Austin.

    • Replies: @nebulafox
    @John Johnson

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don't mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    I've adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California's weather is just too damn... nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW's with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    >Taiwan does not want to be part of totalitarian China where you can 7 years for writing a poem.

    Mmm. Don't take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they'll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that's an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @Twinkie
    @John Johnson


    Seattle rarely makes news.
     
    You missed my point entirely. Which was that Seattle had become progressively whiter in the recent years (and blacks were never that numerous there to begin with), yet it was the scene of the takeover of an entire police precinct and a part of the city by a Woke mob, which was pretty white in demographic composition as the photograph attests.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Occupied_Protest

    It's not always the blacks that destroy American cities.
  318. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    They don't recognize Taiwan as a country.

    They have talked about Taiwan returning to China (which would require force as Taiwan does not want to join).

    They have practiced for a massive amphibious landing that included island control:
    https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3142851/chinese-military-drills-simulate-amphibious-landing-and-island

    Is that enough for you?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Jack D

    No that’s not enough because that has been the policy of mainland (Red) China since 1949. If nothing much has changed on the Chinese side, then this is more shit-disturbing by Washington.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    No that’s not enough because that has been the policy of mainland (Red) China since 1949. If nothing much has changed on the Chinese side, then this is more shit-disturbing by Washington.

    Would China be fine with the people of Taiwan taking a vote once and for all and with the agreement that both the US and China respect the results?

    A simple vote and everyone agrees to adhere to the will of the Taiwanese people:

    Would you like to join China? [ ] yes [ ] no

  319. @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    If Washington wasn't entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along. It's yet another case of "if your only tool is a hammer...".

    Replies: @vinteuil, @John Johnson

    If Washington wasn’t entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along.

    Yes. Pushing today for conflict with China over Taiwan is, if possible, even more foolish than pushing ten years ago for conflict with Russia over Ukraine.

    • Agree: Cagey Beast
  320. @John Johnson
    @Cagey Beast

    What evidence is there that China wants to take Taiwan by force?

    They don't recognize Taiwan as a country.

    They have talked about Taiwan returning to China (which would require force as Taiwan does not want to join).

    They have practiced for a massive amphibious landing that included island control:
    https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/3142851/chinese-military-drills-simulate-amphibious-landing-and-island

    Is that enough for you?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Jack D

    No it’s not going to be enough until the landings actually start. These guys swore up and down that the Russians were never going to invade until they did.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Jack D

    No it’s not going to be enough until the landings actually start. These guys swore up and down that the Russians were never going to invade until they did.

    Yes I can see the posts now:

    16 attack ships headed towards Taiwan are obviously just a defensive reaction to US provocation. There isn't going to be an invasion. That's just CIA propaganda. China Daily said it was a training exercise. So there you have it.

    two weeks later

    Well the Chinese government took a vote and the Taiwanese people voted 98% to join China and that they support the invasion.

    Looks like you guys were wrong about the Taiwanese people. Wow, 98%.

  321. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Dennis Dale

    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.

    If Romney thinks that conflict with China is inevitable then why not grab an ally with a large military, long Chinese border and vast energy resources? Instead they've been forced into China's arms.

    And if he thought conflict with China is inevitable, then why send half American industry there?

    Watching the destruction of German industry and the Russian pivot East, Xi must feel like Cromwell at Dunbar.

    "The Lord hath delivered them into our hands"

    Replies: @Jack D

    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.

    Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine. It was a total failure. It didn’t work. There was no “wandel” (change). Putin just became more and more dictatorial and not at all “cleaved” to the West. He took the West’s money and distributed it among his friends and used it to re-arm Russia but he had no use for Western notions of human rights. Fortunately for Ukraine, more of it ended up in LA real estate than in weapons but there was zero “cleaving” going on.

    Ideologically Putin was and is a product of the KGB and is comfortable only with other state security tyrants who are products of Communist systems – Xi is his natural friend.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Jack D

    "Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine."

    And a bit beyond that:


    ...the Minister of Finance Christian Lindner sat next to [Ukrainian ambassador to Germany Melnyk] with "such a polite smile" and spoke as if the defeat of the Ukrainians had long been decided in advance. "You have a few hours," [he said]...

    According to Melnyk, Germany's finance minister told the ambassador that supplying weapons to Ukraine or excluding Russia from SWIFT was pointless...[given that a] puppet government [installed by Russia was just hours away].
     

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    You failed to address my point (not for the first time), that Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.

    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*, because Germany has not been the dominant power in Europe since WW2. The US has been and is now the dominant power.

    US policy has been to weaken Russia every which way it can, starting with the looting of the 1990s. The Nuland coup in Ukraine was part and parcel of this. Finally the worm turned.

    "he had no use for Western notions of human rights"

    Like imprisoning the Jan 6 protesters without trial for a couple of years, but allowing BLM to trash one city after another? Anarcho-tyranny?

    Western notions of human rights as currently implemented mean prison for a bad word if you're white, but freedom for four of you kicking a white girl unconscious shouting "kill the white slag".

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2072459/Rhea-Page-Muslim-girl-gang-sentence-sends-wrong-message-street-violence.html

    Replies: @Jack D, @Jack D

  322. @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    Read this post by Twinkie. Tell me, does this sound at all like a man who is who he claims to be? Does anyone who is this way, speak this way?
     
    I feel badly for you. You once admired me, but then I made you feel stupid, and, now, you go around badmouthing me as some sort of a "Dissident Right" watchdog.

    This was you 4.5 years ago: https://www.unz.com/anepigone/culturally-christian/#comment-3090477

    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.
     
    Move on, young fella. You don't need my approval and you don't need to try to make me fall in the eyes of others to make yourself feel better. The best revenge is living well. Go live well in the real world. Frequenting online worlds like this one is clearly not healthy for your sanity.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    I feel badly for you. You once admired me …

    This was you 4.5 years ago:

    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.

    Are you sure ID’s 2019 comment was in admiration? Or was it sarcasm: The song he included has an ironic title, given the fate of the titular subject.

    • Replies: @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

  323. @Cagey Beast
    @Dennis Dale

    If Washington wasn't entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along. It's yet another case of "if your only tool is a hammer...".

    Replies: @vinteuil, @John Johnson

    If Washington wasn’t entirely captured by the military-industrial complex it could easily learn to live with mainland China and Taiwan getting along.

    Taiwan does not want to be part of totalitarian China where you can 7 years for writing a poem.
    https://nationalpost.com/news/this-is-the-poem-that-got-a-chinese-activist-seven-years-in-jail

    The sun does not rise and fall with the United States.

    People in Taiwan have their own dreams and desires that are not determined by Yankees. The conflict of larger states wanting to possess nearby smaller states for whatever reason has gone on for thousands of years.

    Taiwan has a high standard of living and didn’t have to go on a Communist killing spree led by a cult leader named Mao. They didn’t want to join the great revolution and don’t want to join modern China that has since realized that Marxism is a waste of time but kept the totalitarian government.

  324. @Cagey Beast
    @John Johnson

    No that's not enough because that has been the policy of mainland (Red) China since 1949. If nothing much has changed on the Chinese side, then this is more shit-disturbing by Washington.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    No that’s not enough because that has been the policy of mainland (Red) China since 1949. If nothing much has changed on the Chinese side, then this is more shit-disturbing by Washington.

    Would China be fine with the people of Taiwan taking a vote once and for all and with the agreement that both the US and China respect the results?

    A simple vote and everyone agrees to adhere to the will of the Taiwanese people:

    Would you like to join China? [ ] yes [ ] no

  325. @Jack D
    @John Johnson

    No it's not going to be enough until the landings actually start. These guys swore up and down that the Russians were never going to invade until they did.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    No it’s not going to be enough until the landings actually start. These guys swore up and down that the Russians were never going to invade until they did.

    Yes I can see the posts now:

    16 attack ships headed towards Taiwan are obviously just a defensive reaction to US provocation. There isn’t going to be an invasion. That’s just CIA propaganda. China Daily said it was a training exercise. So there you have it.

    two weeks later

    Well the Chinese government took a vote and the Taiwanese people voted 98% to join China and that they support the invasion.

    Looks like you guys were wrong about the Taiwanese people. Wow, 98%.

  326. @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Twinkie


    I feel badly for you. You once admired me …

    This was you 4.5 years ago:


    You’re a very fortunate man, Mr. Twinkie. I admire you.
     

     
    Are you sure ID’s 2019 comment was in admiration? Or was it sarcasm: The song he included has an ironic title, given the fate of the titular subject.

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you’re dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn’t right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies—for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it’s cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn’t seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that’s the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, “Twinkie” has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie’s personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who’s never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain’t no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn’t have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he’s structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is “aspirational.”

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Generally speaking, if Intelligent Daesin is convinced of something, you could do well by betting on the opposite to be true.

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein

    , @AKAHorace
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Intelligent Dasein. I saw a bit of the video of you complaining about other posters here. You came across as a decent but vulnerable person. I may not agree with you as I forget exactly who you are. I have trouble distinguishing the regular posters on Steve Sailer. (Well except for Physist Dave, with more study I could better tell all of you apart)

    But you all spend a lot of time commenting on each other's postings. What if you could all be friends ? Or at least admit that you like arguing with each other. No one much else is listening and you have all committed a lot of time to reading what you say about each other. You all have more in common with each other than you might like to admit. Wouldn't you all miss arguing with each other if this site was shut down or one of you died ? Would you really enjoy it if there was no one here to disagree with ?

    I enjoy reading you all, but it would be better if you admitted that you were a community.

    , @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Intelligent Dasein


    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying.
     

    the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide
     

    His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.
     
    ID, I’m not sure why it’s important to you that Twinkie verifies anything about his life—that would be self-doxxing, which would be stupid to do if that’s not his intent. You are free to believe him or not, but it might be helpful if you could cite, beyond mere impression, any ‘gotcha’ inconsistencies in his stated personal details (debates about theology aside). I haven’t come across any. I generally notice such things and I’d bust him if I found any.

    To be sure, the above doesn’t mean that everything an anon claims is true (‘dog on the internet’ caveat always applies), but that doesn’t mean it isn’t true, either. Certainly a person like Twinkie can exist in real life.

    Replies: @Twinkie

    , @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    It was indulgence.

    Just as when you’re dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn’t right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies—for a time.
     

    Good back-pedaling. But you and I both know that it was earnest and wasn't any kind of "indulgence."

    There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.
     

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic.
     
    With all kidding and ball-busting-across-the-internet aside, this tendency of yours, as I mentioned before, is extremely presumptuous and profoundly un-Christian.

    All our fellow men are deserving of fraternal charity. Even our enemies! (And I am hardly an enemy - just a random stranger on the internet with whom you banter, albeit in an unfriendly manner.) If I ran into you in person and saw that you needed help, I would, despite whatever you may think or say of me on the internet - precisely because you are my fellow man (and fellow American, too, for that matter) and are deserving of, as you put it, my fraternal charity (and loyalty, as my fellow citizen and tribesman).

    Whether you "approve" or not, I am a Catholic. However flawed my theology, piety, or faith, I believe in Christ as my Lord and Savior and I believe in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. That you would sit in judgment of me and of my faith and deny this is a sad testament about you that you care more about quibbling over the canon law and defaming the Christian faith of another than you are in actually loving your neighbor as Christ commanded. It's pharisaical.

    I am really serious. The online world is generally not a good place for just about everyone, but some people suffer more from it than others. You strike me as one of those. Get off the internet, go to daily Mass, and ponder about what's really important. And don't let a random stranger on the internet live rent free in your brain and take up so much of your real, actual life (and definitely don't make any more YouTube videos).

    , @Twinkie
    @Intelligent Dasein


    I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard.
     
    By the way, it isn't nice projecting one's own materialistic obsession onto other people. I am, after all, not the one whining about my parents "depleting my patrimony on their frivolities," thereby "destroy[ing] my own chance at earthly happiness."

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/how-to-get-rich/#comment-5343550

    My maternal grandfather was born to an inordinately rich man (with a main house that had 7 gates), but, out of shame for how that wealth had been earned, he rejected that patrimony and, despite being highly educated overseas, went to a dirt-poor mining town to work as a miner and then later strove tirelessly as an advocate for the miners. He found "earthly happiness" through this work and raising his modest family and, later, on his deathbed, converted to Catholicism. The one material thing I have from him is a crucifix necklace he gave me when I saw him last before he succumbed to stomach cancer. He's the man I admire the most.

    And, much as I have worked hard to achieve prosperity in this life, my earthly happiness comes from gazing upon my children and the knowledge that I have done my best to educate them to seek Heaven and, hopefully, with God's Grace, gain it.

    You once cried about wanting out of "the rat race" and of being a "wage-slave," and instead wanting "freedom, dignity, nobility." I suggest you stop wasting your time commenting on an internet blog and instead build that patrimony for your children. If you found what your parents did - not leaving you a legacy - so bitter, work hard so that you do otherwise for your own progeny.
  327. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.
     
    Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine. It was a total failure. It didn't work. There was no "wandel" (change). Putin just became more and more dictatorial and not at all "cleaved" to the West. He took the West's money and distributed it among his friends and used it to re-arm Russia but he had no use for Western notions of human rights. Fortunately for Ukraine, more of it ended up in LA real estate than in weapons but there was zero "cleaving" going on.

    Ideologically Putin was and is a product of the KGB and is comfortable only with other state security tyrants who are products of Communist systems - Xi is his natural friend.

    Replies: @HA, @YetAnotherAnon

    “Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine.”

    And a bit beyond that:

    …the Minister of Finance Christian Lindner sat next to [Ukrainian ambassador to Germany Melnyk] with “such a polite smile” and spoke as if the defeat of the Ukrainians had long been decided in advance. “You have a few hours,” [he said]…

    According to Melnyk, Germany’s finance minister told the ambassador that supplying weapons to Ukraine or excluding Russia from SWIFT was pointless…[given that a] puppet government [installed by Russia was just hours away].

  328. @John Johnson
    @Twinkie

    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites – especially Asians – seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    Seattle rarely makes news. It has to be the most boring city on the West coast.

    The nightlife is terrible. The day life is boring. The restaurants serve bland and overpriced food to tourists. The most boring Swedes and Norwegians must have founded Seattle.

    The hills and poor drivers make walking around an annoyance and the downtown has too many buildings crammed in for the view of the sound.

    They have a good football team but that is about it. I really don't see why so many people move there from California. It's not cheap and dominated by boring liberal Whites that tolerate junkies shi-tting in the streets. Oh and good luck to any single guys. The East side is basically White nerds all chasing the same unattractive Asian chick who thinks she is a 10. I knew a guy from college that bought a condo there and I've never seen such a waste of money. What is the point of making 6 figures if you are in a sausage fest? He would have been better off bartending in Nashville or Austin.

    Replies: @nebulafox, @Twinkie

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don’t mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    I’ve adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California’s weather is just too damn… nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW’s with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    >Taiwan does not want to be part of totalitarian China where you can 7 years for writing a poem.

    Mmm. Don’t take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they’ll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that’s an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    • Agree: Twinkie
    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @nebulafox

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don’t mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    Yea but a lot of states have that.

    Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn't raining and they have more snow.

    I’ve adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California’s weather is just too damn… nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW’s with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    I assume you mean Southern/Central California. The one season all year is kind of weird and especially if you grew up in a state with snow.

    Northern California would be nice if not for the fact that you are still in the tax zone. A lot of that rural California property has been bought up by the wealthy which drives up property taxes even further.

    Mmm. Don’t take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they’ll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that’s an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    I wouldn't bet on an invasion next year. The Ukraine war disaster has certainly given China second thoughts.

    But Taiwan honestly isn't making the right moves. They should be buying up drones and small arms.

    I support Taiwan but on some level I don't like them as a nation. They are too passive in the face of Chinese aggression. Their president is basically a naive female Democrat. She doesn't want to copy Swiss style defense measures. The US has recommended specific defense measures that have been ignored. Zelensky also ignored certain measures when the "training exercise" started building. What else do you need?

    A properly planned drone swarm could save Taiwan from a conventional invasion but I just don't think they have the guts to do it.

    Replies: @nebulafox

  329. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

    Generally speaking, if Intelligent Daesin is convinced of something, you could do well by betting on the opposite to be true.

    • LOL: Twinkie
    • Replies: @Intelligent Dasein
    @Steve Sailer

    Let's run through the record of the last 3 years of what Intelligent Dasein said vs what Steve Sailer said about:

    1. Covid being dangerous.
    2. Masks working.
    3. Lockdowns working.
    4. Vaccines safe and effective.
    5. Ukraine winning the war.

    Replies: @HA

  330. @John Johnson
    @vinteuil

    Yeah – just read Pushkin! Sh*t, F*ck, D*mn…I mean, the guy simply can’t control himself! To say nothing of Gogol, or Turgenev, whose language I dare not even repeat here.

    I've listened to a few dozen captured transcripts of Russians calling home.

    I've never heard anyone swear as much as the Russians.

    Reminds of me Tarantino movies where the swearing is overdone to where it is meaningless.

    Some of the calls with the wives are truly disturbing:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypq65UMkq8A

    Not a good look for Russia. I'm not going to repost the one where the wife encourages the husband to rape. Too disturbing.

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people. During WW2 the rape and pillaging of Berlin by the Red Army was mostly a rumor. There wasn't a youtube at the time to confirm it.

    Replies: @Mr Mox, @Anonymous, @vinteuil, @Sean

    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.

    Ukraine was allowed to leave and take Crimea with it. Also many millions of ethnic Russians. What was wrong with the Ukrainian state’s population that they thought they would become safest of all in the enjoyment of their large territory of enviable potential by trying to join the Western security order?

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people.

    People, yes. Unlike Tsarist Russia and the Soviet Union, the Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state, and one in which 80% of the population support Putin. There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean

    The Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state,

    Russia is a very big country and there are large sections where Russian ethnics are not the majority. And a lot of "Russians" have that identity because it's the currently preferable one. If things changed there would be a "flight from white" just like you see in the US.



    and one in which 80% of the population support Putin.

    And Saddam Hussein got 99% of the vote in his last election. Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure. When Wagner did its coup in Rostov, people cheered them and nobody seemed noticeably upset or ready to take up arms against them, not even the army.

    There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Were you one of the guys who said that Russia would never invade Ukraine either? All things must pass. The USSR seemed to be a permanent edifice until one day it just disappeared. Dictatorships are very brittle. They appear solid as a rock but they can shatter like glass.

    Replies: @Sean, @David In TN

  331. @Steve Sailer
    @Intelligent Dasein

    Generally speaking, if Intelligent Daesin is convinced of something, you could do well by betting on the opposite to be true.

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein

    Let’s run through the record of the last 3 years of what Intelligent Dasein said vs what Steve Sailer said about:

    1. Covid being dangerous.
    2. Masks working.
    3. Lockdowns working.
    4. Vaccines safe and effective.
    5. Ukraine winning the war.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Intelligent Dasein

    "Ukraine winning the war."

    Did Sailer ever come out and say that Ukraine is winning the war? (As opposed to believing that invading a neighboring country so as to start a land-war in Eurasia has historically proven to be a really regrettable idea?) As it is, your list is like what you see in a daily horoscope or a slip of paper from a fortune cookie. Vague context-free invocations of 'dangerous', 'safe and effective', as compared to...well, nothing really, which is why they can affirm or disprove anything.

    As another example, here's your clear-eyed straightforward take on what Ukraine is all about, issued to Sailer a year and a half ago:


    the problem with your whole understanding of the war in Ukraine. You are analyzing a hyperreality, a copy of a copy with no original...the Western powers, are thinking about this whole affair as an information war, and an information war is already itself a metalogical take on a real situation... But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct, and the meta of a meta is a solipsism...The simulacrum of an information war that you are analyzing exists literally only in your imagination...
     
    Whew! That's some "Transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity" you got there, except the guy who wrote that was actually in on the joke.

    Or how about this -- back on 9/11 of the last year, you ominously predicted that in 72 hours, Ukraine will no longer be a real country. How'd that work out? On second thought, I suppose one can play meta-of-a-meta semantic games with "real country" to make ANY day of the year contain that precise moment when a country stops being real, as in "a copy of a copy with no original". But I'd remind you that to this day, according to Putin's Twitter trolls, the Ukrainians are still doing pretty well. So what went wrong, ID? What exactly happened in those 72 hours that was subsequently obscured ty the "simulacrum of an information war" that the CIA is playing on us?

    But even that's not your biggest howler. For that, let me note that in the 5 seconds or so of the above Youtube video that I sampled, you referred to yourself as a "traditional Catholic", which is odd indeed, given that in order to make your version of De Civitate Dei function properly, we're gonna have to push grandma and grandpa out onto the ice floe:


    I think the main factor (and this would account for the evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies) is that too many people are surviving to old age. The genius of the race... The birthrate will rise moderately once the overburden of old people are removed,...
     
    Wow -- "evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies"? Did you crib that from some Derrida fangurl? Is this some horseshoe theory of ideological extremes where blue-haired feminists who have to feed too many cats meld with traditional Catholics complaining about being overburdened with too many aging Boomers?

    And I'm no expert on theology, Christian or otherwise, or the "genius of the race", whatever that's supposed to mean, but I do know enough about Western Civ to suspect that whatever you want to call the above-cited Malthusian/Logan'sRun/No-country-for-old-men mish-mash, it ain't "traditional Catholicism". I mean, even your meta-of-a-meta handwaving is not going to be enough to rework "remove the overburden of old people" into the 11th commandment, let alone affix it to the Sermon on the Mount.

    Replies: @HA, @Dumbo

  332. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

    Intelligent Dasein. I saw a bit of the video of you complaining about other posters here. You came across as a decent but vulnerable person. I may not agree with you as I forget exactly who you are. I have trouble distinguishing the regular posters on Steve Sailer. (Well except for Physist Dave, with more study I could better tell all of you apart)

    But you all spend a lot of time commenting on each other’s postings. What if you could all be friends ? Or at least admit that you like arguing with each other. No one much else is listening and you have all committed a lot of time to reading what you say about each other. You all have more in common with each other than you might like to admit. Wouldn’t you all miss arguing with each other if this site was shut down or one of you died ? Would you really enjoy it if there was no one here to disagree with ?

    I enjoy reading you all, but it would be better if you admitted that you were a community.

  333. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying.

    the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide

    His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    ID, I’m not sure why it’s important to you that Twinkie verifies anything about his life—that would be self-doxxing, which would be stupid to do if that’s not his intent. You are free to believe him or not, but it might be helpful if you could cite, beyond mere impression, any ‘gotcha’ inconsistencies in his stated personal details (debates about theology aside). I haven’t come across any. I generally notice such things and I’d bust him if I found any.

    To be sure, the above doesn’t mean that everything an anon claims is true (‘dog on the internet’ caveat always applies), but that doesn’t mean it isn’t true, either. Certainly a person like Twinkie can exist in real life.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Jenner Ickham Errican


    Twinkie verifies anything about his life—that would be self-doxxing, which would be stupid to do if that’s not his intent.
     
    Exactly.

    any ‘gotcha’ inconsistencies in his stated personal details
     
    The guy can't read and gets things wrong about me repeatedly. Example: https://www.unz.com/isteve/ripped-from-the-headlines/#comment-5453255


    He claims that his father-in-law is a WWII vet
     
    You should read more carefully, you know, back to the days when you “admired” me: https://www.unz.com/anepigone/culturally-christian/#comment-3090477

    My wife’s grandfather was the WWII Vet (he was an artillery observation officer). I wrote about him quite a bit in the above link (right up-thread from “I admire you” comment from you).

    My father-in-law was a Vietnam vet, as were his brothers.
     
    He's done this numerous times about a variety of different things. He even sheepishly admitted once that he got things wrong about me. I am too lazy to track that comment down, but it's there in the search if you care.
  334. Anonymous[264] • Disclaimer says:
    @zoos
    @ydydy


    I miss Saddam.

    That dude didn’t hide behind pseudosuicides and curious crashes.
     
    Now, now! Putin is just wittier about it. I recall when one of his extremely vocal critics–he went after Putin personally–was poisoned with radiation, if memory serves, Putin said, and I’m paraphrasing,"well, if you defect and decide to be a spy against your own country, and talk a lot of shit, sometimes bad things happen. It’s part of that job, isn’t it?"

    I couldn’t really disagree with him.

    Putin reminds me a bit of trump, in that he doesn’t tend to go after people unless they screw with him first. Not saying putin’s a good guy. Just a predictable one. At least you know what you have to do for your plane to crash, so you can plan your day around it.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    Putin reminds me a bit of trump, in that he doesn’t tend to go after people unless they screw with him first.

    As I understand it, the reason Wagner was mad at Putin is that he sent them into battle promising air support and ammunition but both failed to materialize when needed, resulting in unnecessarily heavy casualties. If true, it was Putin who was screwing with Prigozhin.

    Why Putin do this? Maybe it was just the usual incompetence/disorganization and there was no deliberate malice. However I’m sure paranoid Wagnerites assumed Putin was deliberately getting them killed because he feared they would coup him. If true, then a coup is exactly what he deserved. You can’t betray someone who already betrayed you.

  335. @MEH 0910
    @Twinkie


    Do you have a blog? If it’s full of writings like this, I might check it out once in a while.
     
    Intelligent Dasein has a (seldom used) blog and YouTube channel:

    http://intelligentdasein.blogspot.com/

    Dasein Introductions
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bCMzcMA-Yjo
    Mar 1, 2022

    Wanting to be more personal
     
    Sincerity
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PwCVVIuIZvE
    Mar 10, 2022

    In which I talk about who is genuine and who isn't in the Sailer blog comments.
     

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Stop right there. He’s got a black v-neck t-shirt. My younger subordinates (back when I used to have a day job) told me guys with v-neck t-shirts are “d-bags.” And THAT, he apparent thought, was the best, most presentable-looking getup he should wear on the Internet for the world to see.

    This is clearly a man who needs help. 😉

    And, as usual, he gets my biographical details wrong, that is, despite his desperate attempts at sounding erudite, he has basic reading comprehension problems.

  336. @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Intelligent Dasein


    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying.
     

    the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide
     

    His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.
     
    ID, I’m not sure why it’s important to you that Twinkie verifies anything about his life—that would be self-doxxing, which would be stupid to do if that’s not his intent. You are free to believe him or not, but it might be helpful if you could cite, beyond mere impression, any ‘gotcha’ inconsistencies in his stated personal details (debates about theology aside). I haven’t come across any. I generally notice such things and I’d bust him if I found any.

    To be sure, the above doesn’t mean that everything an anon claims is true (‘dog on the internet’ caveat always applies), but that doesn’t mean it isn’t true, either. Certainly a person like Twinkie can exist in real life.

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Twinkie verifies anything about his life—that would be self-doxxing, which would be stupid to do if that’s not his intent.

    Exactly.

    any ‘gotcha’ inconsistencies in his stated personal details

    The guy can’t read and gets things wrong about me repeatedly. Example: https://www.unz.com/isteve/ripped-from-the-headlines/#comment-5453255

    He claims that his father-in-law is a WWII vet

    You should read more carefully, you know, back to the days when you “admired” me: https://www.unz.com/anepigone/culturally-christian/#comment-3090477

    My wife’s grandfather was the WWII Vet (he was an artillery observation officer). I wrote about him quite a bit in the above link (right up-thread from “I admire you” comment from you).

    My father-in-law was a Vietnam vet, as were his brothers.

    He’s done this numerous times about a variety of different things. He even sheepishly admitted once that he got things wrong about me. I am too lazy to track that comment down, but it’s there in the search if you care.

  337. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

    It was indulgence.

    Just as when you’re dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn’t right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies—for a time.

    Good back-pedaling. But you and I both know that it was earnest and wasn’t any kind of “indulgence.”

    There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic.

    With all kidding and ball-busting-across-the-internet aside, this tendency of yours, as I mentioned before, is extremely presumptuous and profoundly un-Christian.

    All our fellow men are deserving of fraternal charity. Even our enemies! (And I am hardly an enemy – just a random stranger on the internet with whom you banter, albeit in an unfriendly manner.) If I ran into you in person and saw that you needed help, I would, despite whatever you may think or say of me on the internet – precisely because you are my fellow man (and fellow American, too, for that matter) and are deserving of, as you put it, my fraternal charity (and loyalty, as my fellow citizen and tribesman).

    Whether you “approve” or not, I am a Catholic. However flawed my theology, piety, or faith, I believe in Christ as my Lord and Savior and I believe in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church. That you would sit in judgment of me and of my faith and deny this is a sad testament about you that you care more about quibbling over the canon law and defaming the Christian faith of another than you are in actually loving your neighbor as Christ commanded. It’s pharisaical.

    I am really serious. The online world is generally not a good place for just about everyone, but some people suffer more from it than others. You strike me as one of those. Get off the internet, go to daily Mass, and ponder about what’s really important. And don’t let a random stranger on the internet live rent free in your brain and take up so much of your real, actual life (and definitely don’t make any more YouTube videos).

  338. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Cleaving Russia to Europe and cementing Russian links with Germany would have been far more in the rational interests of the USA.
     
    Wandel durch Handel was German policy right up to the day that Putin invaded Ukraine. It was a total failure. It didn't work. There was no "wandel" (change). Putin just became more and more dictatorial and not at all "cleaved" to the West. He took the West's money and distributed it among his friends and used it to re-arm Russia but he had no use for Western notions of human rights. Fortunately for Ukraine, more of it ended up in LA real estate than in weapons but there was zero "cleaving" going on.

    Ideologically Putin was and is a product of the KGB and is comfortable only with other state security tyrants who are products of Communist systems - Xi is his natural friend.

    Replies: @HA, @YetAnotherAnon

    You failed to address my point (not for the first time), that Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.

    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*, because Germany has not been the dominant power in Europe since WW2. The US has been and is now the dominant power.

    US policy has been to weaken Russia every which way it can, starting with the looting of the 1990s. The Nuland coup in Ukraine was part and parcel of this. Finally the worm turned.

    “he had no use for Western notions of human rights”

    Like imprisoning the Jan 6 protesters without trial for a couple of years, but allowing BLM to trash one city after another? Anarcho-tyranny?

    Western notions of human rights as currently implemented mean prison for a bad word if you’re white, but freedom for four of you kicking a white girl unconscious shouting “kill the white slag”.

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2072459/Rhea-Page-Muslim-girl-gang-sentence-sends-wrong-message-street-violence.html

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon

    This is the modern day version of "but you are lynching Negroes" , which was an old Soviet favorite. The West doesn't have a perfect human rights record but it's a hell of a lot better than Russia's.

    The answer to this sort of comeback is found in elementary school wisdom: Two wrongs do not make a right. Point out the West's less than flawless record doesn't make Putin's atrocities acceptable.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    , @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.
     
    Like the way Stalin "helped" us in the war against Japan? He helped himself to N. Korea when the war was all but over and it's a problem to this day.


    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*,

    So you are saying wandel durch handel just wasn't tried hard enough? That if the US had gone for it as hard as Germany then Putin would not have invaded? I suppose this is true in the sense that if you gave Putin everything he wanted then he would have had no reason to invade.

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia's sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @John Johnson

  339. @John Johnson
    @Twinkie

    Over the last several decades, Seattle has become progressively more white (with more and more nonwhites – especially Asians – seeking jobs on the Eastside, e.g. Bellevue, Redmond, etc.).

    Do you remember any recent news about Seattle?

    Seattle rarely makes news. It has to be the most boring city on the West coast.

    The nightlife is terrible. The day life is boring. The restaurants serve bland and overpriced food to tourists. The most boring Swedes and Norwegians must have founded Seattle.

    The hills and poor drivers make walking around an annoyance and the downtown has too many buildings crammed in for the view of the sound.

    They have a good football team but that is about it. I really don't see why so many people move there from California. It's not cheap and dominated by boring liberal Whites that tolerate junkies shi-tting in the streets. Oh and good luck to any single guys. The East side is basically White nerds all chasing the same unattractive Asian chick who thinks she is a 10. I knew a guy from college that bought a condo there and I've never seen such a waste of money. What is the point of making 6 figures if you are in a sausage fest? He would have been better off bartending in Nashville or Austin.

    Replies: @nebulafox, @Twinkie

    Seattle rarely makes news.

    You missed my point entirely. Which was that Seattle had become progressively whiter in the recent years (and blacks were never that numerous there to begin with), yet it was the scene of the takeover of an entire police precinct and a part of the city by a Woke mob, which was pretty white in demographic composition as the photograph attests.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitol_Hill_Occupied_Protest

    It’s not always the blacks that destroy American cities.

  340. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    You failed to address my point (not for the first time), that Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.

    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*, because Germany has not been the dominant power in Europe since WW2. The US has been and is now the dominant power.

    US policy has been to weaken Russia every which way it can, starting with the looting of the 1990s. The Nuland coup in Ukraine was part and parcel of this. Finally the worm turned.

    "he had no use for Western notions of human rights"

    Like imprisoning the Jan 6 protesters without trial for a couple of years, but allowing BLM to trash one city after another? Anarcho-tyranny?

    Western notions of human rights as currently implemented mean prison for a bad word if you're white, but freedom for four of you kicking a white girl unconscious shouting "kill the white slag".

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2072459/Rhea-Page-Muslim-girl-gang-sentence-sends-wrong-message-street-violence.html

    Replies: @Jack D, @Jack D

    This is the modern day version of “but you are lynching Negroes” , which was an old Soviet favorite. The West doesn’t have a perfect human rights record but it’s a hell of a lot better than Russia’s.

    The answer to this sort of comeback is found in elementary school wisdom: Two wrongs do not make a right. Point out the West’s less than flawless record doesn’t make Putin’s atrocities acceptable.

    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    "this is the modern day version of “but you are lynching Negroes”"

    No, because in Soviet days lynching was pretty much defunct, so it was a lie. Probably went down well in the Third World, where to be fair the US were bombing SE Asia flat.I wonder where the communists learned that lie technique?

    Whereas not only are these things happening now in the US and UK, they're accelerating.

  341. @Sean
    @John Johnson


    The depravity of Russian culture was kept secret until now.
     
    Ukraine was allowed to leave and take Crimea with it. Also many millions of ethnic Russians. What was wrong with the Ukrainian state's population that they thought they would become safest of all in the enjoyment of their large territory of enviable potential by trying to join the Western security order?

    The whole world watches these videos and wonders what the hell is wrong with the Russian people.
     
    People, yes. Unlike Tsarist Russia and the Soviet Union, the Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state, and one in which 80% of the population support Putin. There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Replies: @Jack D

    The Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state,

    Russia is a very big country and there are large sections where Russian ethnics are not the majority. And a lot of “Russians” have that identity because it’s the currently preferable one. If things changed there would be a “flight from white” just like you see in the US.

    and one in which 80% of the population support Putin.

    And Saddam Hussein got 99% of the vote in his last election. Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure. When Wagner did its coup in Rostov, people cheered them and nobody seemed noticeably upset or ready to take up arms against them, not even the army.

    There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Were you one of the guys who said that Russia would never invade Ukraine either? All things must pass. The USSR seemed to be a permanent edifice until one day it just disappeared. Dictatorships are very brittle. They appear solid as a rock but they can shatter like glass.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @Jack D

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there, and so did Tsarist Russia. Yeltsin accidently broke up an empire and then sent in tanks against the Russian parliament killing scores of people, yet there was no shattering. And this was when Russia was in much worse economic trouble than is is now. C

    Putin heads a nation state; that is, a country formatted so that the mass of the people (ethnic Russians) find it a satisfying repository of their allegiance. Putin is a Russian you know It is not at all obvious that Putin is responsible creating for the long held and widely shared view among and the mass of Russian stem from the same source: a separate civilisation with its own particularist perspective


    All things must pass
     
    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia's geopolitical interests.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @David In TN
    @Jack D

    "Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure."

    When I read Robert Conquest's The Great Terror long ago concerning Stalin's purges of the 1930s, there was a passage that asserted something like:

    "You never knew how far the official lies were believed."

    Replies: @Jack D

  342. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    You failed to address my point (not for the first time), that Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.

    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*, because Germany has not been the dominant power in Europe since WW2. The US has been and is now the dominant power.

    US policy has been to weaken Russia every which way it can, starting with the looting of the 1990s. The Nuland coup in Ukraine was part and parcel of this. Finally the worm turned.

    "he had no use for Western notions of human rights"

    Like imprisoning the Jan 6 protesters without trial for a couple of years, but allowing BLM to trash one city after another? Anarcho-tyranny?

    Western notions of human rights as currently implemented mean prison for a bad word if you're white, but freedom for four of you kicking a white girl unconscious shouting "kill the white slag".

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2072459/Rhea-Page-Muslim-girl-gang-sentence-sends-wrong-message-street-violence.html

    Replies: @Jack D, @Jack D

    Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.

    Like the way Stalin “helped” us in the war against Japan? He helped himself to N. Korea when the war was all but over and it’s a problem to this day.

    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*,

    So you are saying wandel durch handel just wasn’t tried hard enough? That if the US had gone for it as hard as Germany then Putin would not have invaded? I suppose this is true in the sense that if you gave Putin everything he wanted then he would have had no reason to invade.

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    • Agree: John Johnson
    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    "Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not."

    We have a winner!

    I wonder why Mexico decided it wasn't going to join BRICS+ ?

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @John Johnson
    @Jack D

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    This is correct. In fact anything short of a puppet regime is a loss. With a rump state you create more division between the two countries and permanently send the majority of Ukraine into Western arms. Taking Donbas and Crimea won't make up for the economic loss of trade and limitless hostility. The irony in all this is that Zelensky wanted Ukraine to be neutral between the two sides. But Putin started getting closer to the end of his reign and decided that it was time to try and rebuild the Warsaw pact and wanted more than a neutral Ukraine.

    Putin's plan was to rebuild part of the USSR but without Communism. LPR/DPR were to be their own puppet states and Ukraine was to be completely Russofied. He wasn't going to risk Ukraine as an independent country that could leave Russian influence. Very similar to how Hitler planned to eliminate Poland so they would never again exist as a country. That would prevent the scenario whereby Germany lost in a future conflict. There wouldn't be a Versailles 2 because the Poles would not exist as a people. It would be German farmland. Break the area up and it would still be German.

    Putin planned on phasing out Ukrainian language and culture. So in 100 years it's just another Russian puppet state that is majority Russian. A pro-Western Ukraine would never return. The identity would be gone.

  343. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.
     
    Like the way Stalin "helped" us in the war against Japan? He helped himself to N. Korea when the war was all but over and it's a problem to this day.


    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*,

    So you are saying wandel durch handel just wasn't tried hard enough? That if the US had gone for it as hard as Germany then Putin would not have invaded? I suppose this is true in the sense that if you gave Putin everything he wanted then he would have had no reason to invade.

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia's sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @John Johnson

    “Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.”

    We have a winner!

    I wonder why Mexico decided it wasn’t going to join BRICS+ ?

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon

    I wonder why Cuba decide it could join the East Bloc and we let them?

    You are admitting that Ukraine should take Putin's advice and "lie back and enjoy it" while Russia rapes them. Sorry, Ukraine doesn't have to follow his advice. It's up to them if they want to resist getting raped and it's proper for the West to help them resist.

    The fact that Ukraine sits on Russia's border is not determinative. Finland is on Russia's border and is no longer in its sphere of influence. Ukraine will be in Russia's sphere of influence if Russia wins the war but so far they haven't won it yet.

    Instead of getting a puppet regime they are going to have another enemy on their border for the foreseeable future, plus a couple of more NATO countries on their other borders. Heckuva job, Putie!

    Even if Russia "wins" and gets the puppet regime it wants now and maybe a bit of Ukrainian territory (after all we know that Russia is short on land), all it has bought itself is an eternal headache. 70 years of Soviet rule was not enough to douse Ukrainian nationalism. After this, the Ukrainians are going to hate Russia for generations to come, win or lose.

    Meanwhile, according to Rushists, Nuland was able to swing Ukraine over to the American sphere of influence just by offering them a plate of pastries. Russia tried billions of $ of bribes and that didn't work because the guys that they bribed were on a bullion laden helicopter out of Kyiv at the 1st sign of trouble.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

  344. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon

    This is the modern day version of "but you are lynching Negroes" , which was an old Soviet favorite. The West doesn't have a perfect human rights record but it's a hell of a lot better than Russia's.

    The answer to this sort of comeback is found in elementary school wisdom: Two wrongs do not make a right. Point out the West's less than flawless record doesn't make Putin's atrocities acceptable.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    “this is the modern day version of “but you are lynching Negroes””

    No, because in Soviet days lynching was pretty much defunct, so it was a lie. Probably went down well in the Third World, where to be fair the US were bombing SE Asia flat.I wonder where the communists learned that lie technique?

    Whereas not only are these things happening now in the US and UK, they’re accelerating.

  345. @Jack D
    @Sean

    The Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state,

    Russia is a very big country and there are large sections where Russian ethnics are not the majority. And a lot of "Russians" have that identity because it's the currently preferable one. If things changed there would be a "flight from white" just like you see in the US.



    and one in which 80% of the population support Putin.

    And Saddam Hussein got 99% of the vote in his last election. Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure. When Wagner did its coup in Rostov, people cheered them and nobody seemed noticeably upset or ready to take up arms against them, not even the army.

    There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Were you one of the guys who said that Russia would never invade Ukraine either? All things must pass. The USSR seemed to be a permanent edifice until one day it just disappeared. Dictatorships are very brittle. They appear solid as a rock but they can shatter like glass.

    Replies: @Sean, @David In TN

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there, and so did Tsarist Russia. Yeltsin accidently broke up an empire and then sent in tanks against the Russian parliament killing scores of people, yet there was no shattering. And this was when Russia was in much worse economic trouble than is is now. C

    Putin heads a nation state; that is, a country formatted so that the mass of the people (ethnic Russians) find it a satisfying repository of their allegiance. Putin is a Russian you know It is not at all obvious that Putin is responsible creating for the long held and widely shared view among and the mass of Russian stem from the same source: a separate civilisation with its own particularist perspective

    All things must pass

    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia’s geopolitical interests.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Sean

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there

    Yea as in all of them. Hungary showed the world that it wasn't a voluntary alliance. Even Russians would not have voted to stay. The Communists didn't even pull 10% before the revolution. Communism is an alliance of losers that suppresses democracy because they know the people won't support it. Even Marx said that they would eventually lose in a democracy.

    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia’s geopolitical interests.

    An end to the war would be in Russia's economic interests. Inflation is most likely past 23% and they are addicted to oil and gas exports to Western Europe. Even though their production is nominal they are still taking a hit on lost margins. A major drop of the Ruble could cause panic and civil chaos. Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn't have a backup plan. Russia is too dependent on the West which is why he cannot sit this war out for years.

    I think Putin would walk with Donbas at this point and without Zaporizhzhia oblast. The Zap was not part of LPR/DPR and voted for Zelensky.

    But Ukraine isn't willing to let him have that deal at this point. And why would they? Putin would get land and Ukraine would be stuck with the cost of the invasion.

    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.

    Replies: @Sean

  346. @nebulafox
    @John Johnson

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don't mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    I've adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California's weather is just too damn... nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW's with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    >Taiwan does not want to be part of totalitarian China where you can 7 years for writing a poem.

    Mmm. Don't take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they'll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that's an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don’t mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    Yea but a lot of states have that.

    Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn’t raining and they have more snow.

    I’ve adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California’s weather is just too damn… nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW’s with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    I assume you mean Southern/Central California. The one season all year is kind of weird and especially if you grew up in a state with snow.

    Northern California would be nice if not for the fact that you are still in the tax zone. A lot of that rural California property has been bought up by the wealthy which drives up property taxes even further.

    Mmm. Don’t take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they’ll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that’s an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    I wouldn’t bet on an invasion next year. The Ukraine war disaster has certainly given China second thoughts.

    But Taiwan honestly isn’t making the right moves. They should be buying up drones and small arms.

    I support Taiwan but on some level I don’t like them as a nation. They are too passive in the face of Chinese aggression. Their president is basically a naive female Democrat. She doesn’t want to copy Swiss style defense measures. The US has recommended specific defense measures that have been ignored. Zelensky also ignored certain measures when the “training exercise” started building. What else do you need?

    A properly planned drone swarm could save Taiwan from a conventional invasion but I just don’t think they have the guts to do it.

    • Replies: @nebulafox
    @John Johnson

    >Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn’t raining and they have more snow.

    Yeah, but I'm too fond of the water, ever since I was little.

    >But Taiwan honestly isn’t making the right moves.

    No, they aren't. The issue at the heart of it all is that Taiwanese military-civilian relations are dysfunctional. Some of this is a hangover from the Cold War-era KMT dictatorship, making things even more complicated. It's sad because unlike Ukraine, Taiwan actually is a high-functioning democratic state, and the PRC routinely commits human rights abuses that make Putin look like a schoolboy, but what can you do? The Ukrainians have made it clear they'll fight, whatever your opinion on the war. It's not clear whether the Taiwanese will if push comes to shove. Maybe they will. Maybe they won't. Next year, they've got elections. Beijing knows this.

    Taiwan's semiconductor elites are also worth paying attention, particularly the heads of smaller businesses who don't make the papers like TSMC. They are private businesses with the autonomy that goes along with it: back in the 1980s, there was of course a heavy degree of state control, but that's long since dissipated. Anybody familiar with the process of IC manufacture can intuit that they have to worry about the prospect of the PRC poaching their talent. They might not be as cutting-edge as TSMC, but they have the training necessary to get there with the right funding.

    Replies: @Twinkie

  347. @Sean
    @Jack D

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there, and so did Tsarist Russia. Yeltsin accidently broke up an empire and then sent in tanks against the Russian parliament killing scores of people, yet there was no shattering. And this was when Russia was in much worse economic trouble than is is now. C

    Putin heads a nation state; that is, a country formatted so that the mass of the people (ethnic Russians) find it a satisfying repository of their allegiance. Putin is a Russian you know It is not at all obvious that Putin is responsible creating for the long held and widely shared view among and the mass of Russian stem from the same source: a separate civilisation with its own particularist perspective


    All things must pass
     
    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia's geopolitical interests.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there

    Yea as in all of them. Hungary showed the world that it wasn’t a voluntary alliance. Even Russians would not have voted to stay. The Communists didn’t even pull 10% before the revolution. Communism is an alliance of losers that suppresses democracy because they know the people won’t support it. Even Marx said that they would eventually lose in a democracy.

    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia’s geopolitical interests.

    An end to the war would be in Russia’s economic interests. Inflation is most likely past 23% and they are addicted to oil and gas exports to Western Europe. Even though their production is nominal they are still taking a hit on lost margins. A major drop of the Ruble could cause panic and civil chaos. Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn’t have a backup plan. Russia is too dependent on the West which is why he cannot sit this war out for years.

    I think Putin would walk with Donbas at this point and without Zaporizhzhia oblast. The Zap was not part of LPR/DPR and voted for Zelensky.

    But Ukraine isn’t willing to let him have that deal at this point. And why would they? Putin would get land and Ukraine would be stuck with the cost of the invasion.

    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @John Johnson


    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.
     
    Wagner had a lot of ethnic minorities both contract and excons. Latvian regiments of the Tsars's army were instrumental in the Bolshevik revolution Ordinary Russians are going to be at least loyal, they will do for manning the line in defence, which is what Russia is apparently set on at the strategic level.

    An end to the war would be in Russia’s economic interests
     
    Although diplomats are surely trying to wave the prospects of good times for Russia if it stops fighting and hands back at least its gains since Feb 2022, I doubt carrots would be forthcoming as sweet as advertised. Energy sales to the West are gone forever, and were Putin to actually take a deal, the West would than insist on Russia undertaking to pay reparations on a gigantically greater scale than Russia thought was agreed. Russian economic resurgence is not going to happen if the West can help it.

    Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn’t have a backup plan
     
    The invasion plan's objective must have long since been abandoned; the Russian army has been essentially on the defensive since June 2021. In the first few months he may have toyed with the idea of a quick end by successful offensive or a complete withdrawal even, but by my way of thinking that Putin has decided to lets things play out to the bitter end means he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia's total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.

    Replies: @Jack D

  348. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon


    Russia onside would be good for the US in a conflict with China.
     
    Like the way Stalin "helped" us in the war against Japan? He helped himself to N. Korea when the war was all but over and it's a problem to this day.


    German policy towards Russia could not work *in isolation*,

    So you are saying wandel durch handel just wasn't tried hard enough? That if the US had gone for it as hard as Germany then Putin would not have invaded? I suppose this is true in the sense that if you gave Putin everything he wanted then he would have had no reason to invade.

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia's sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @John Johnson

    Putin was never going to accept anything short of allowing him to install a puppet regime in Ukraine. In his mind, Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not.

    This is correct. In fact anything short of a puppet regime is a loss. With a rump state you create more division between the two countries and permanently send the majority of Ukraine into Western arms. Taking Donbas and Crimea won’t make up for the economic loss of trade and limitless hostility. The irony in all this is that Zelensky wanted Ukraine to be neutral between the two sides. But Putin started getting closer to the end of his reign and decided that it was time to try and rebuild the Warsaw pact and wanted more than a neutral Ukraine.

    Putin’s plan was to rebuild part of the USSR but without Communism. LPR/DPR were to be their own puppet states and Ukraine was to be completely Russofied. He wasn’t going to risk Ukraine as an independent country that could leave Russian influence. Very similar to how Hitler planned to eliminate Poland so they would never again exist as a country. That would prevent the scenario whereby Germany lost in a future conflict. There wouldn’t be a Versailles 2 because the Poles would not exist as a people. It would be German farmland. Break the area up and it would still be German.

    Putin planned on phasing out Ukrainian language and culture. So in 100 years it’s just another Russian puppet state that is majority Russian. A pro-Western Ukraine would never return. The identity would be gone.

  349. @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    "Ukraine is in Russia’s sphere of influence whether it likes it or not."

    We have a winner!

    I wonder why Mexico decided it wasn't going to join BRICS+ ?

    Replies: @Jack D

    I wonder why Cuba decide it could join the East Bloc and we let them?

    You are admitting that Ukraine should take Putin’s advice and “lie back and enjoy it” while Russia rapes them. Sorry, Ukraine doesn’t have to follow his advice. It’s up to them if they want to resist getting raped and it’s proper for the West to help them resist.

    The fact that Ukraine sits on Russia’s border is not determinative. Finland is on Russia’s border and is no longer in its sphere of influence. Ukraine will be in Russia’s sphere of influence if Russia wins the war but so far they haven’t won it yet.

    Instead of getting a puppet regime they are going to have another enemy on their border for the foreseeable future, plus a couple of more NATO countries on their other borders. Heckuva job, Putie!

    Even if Russia “wins” and gets the puppet regime it wants now and maybe a bit of Ukrainian territory (after all we know that Russia is short on land), all it has bought itself is an eternal headache. 70 years of Soviet rule was not enough to douse Ukrainian nationalism. After this, the Ukrainians are going to hate Russia for generations to come, win or lose.

    Meanwhile, according to Rushists, Nuland was able to swing Ukraine over to the American sphere of influence just by offering them a plate of pastries. Russia tried billions of $ of bribes and that didn’t work because the guys that they bribed were on a bullion laden helicopter out of Kyiv at the 1st sign of trouble.

    • Replies: @YetAnotherAnon
    @Jack D

    "they are going to have another enemy on their border for the foreseeable future"

    You are right - Poland.


    “The heroic characteristics of the Polish race must not blind us to their errors, which over centuries have led them through measureless suffering…it is a mystery and tragedy of European history that a people capable of every heroic virtue, gifted, valiant, charming, as individuals, should repeatedly show such inveterate faults in almost every aspect of their governmental life.” - Winston Churchill
     
  350. @John Johnson
    @Sean

    The USSR had a lot of countries in it that did not want to be there

    Yea as in all of them. Hungary showed the world that it wasn't a voluntary alliance. Even Russians would not have voted to stay. The Communists didn't even pull 10% before the revolution. Communism is an alliance of losers that suppresses democracy because they know the people won't support it. Even Marx said that they would eventually lose in a democracy.

    I think the war is will be interminably kept going by Putin, who is intent on standing on the defensive while threatening Ukraine with a large force so as to keep it maximally mobilised. An end to the war would not be in Russia’s geopolitical interests.

    An end to the war would be in Russia's economic interests. Inflation is most likely past 23% and they are addicted to oil and gas exports to Western Europe. Even though their production is nominal they are still taking a hit on lost margins. A major drop of the Ruble could cause panic and civil chaos. Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn't have a backup plan. Russia is too dependent on the West which is why he cannot sit this war out for years.

    I think Putin would walk with Donbas at this point and without Zaporizhzhia oblast. The Zap was not part of LPR/DPR and voted for Zelensky.

    But Ukraine isn't willing to let him have that deal at this point. And why would they? Putin would get land and Ukraine would be stuck with the cost of the invasion.

    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.

    Replies: @Sean

    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.

    Wagner had a lot of ethnic minorities both contract and excons. Latvian regiments of the Tsars’s army were instrumental in the Bolshevik revolution Ordinary Russians are going to be at least loyal, they will do for manning the line in defence, which is what Russia is apparently set on at the strategic level.

    An end to the war would be in Russia’s economic interests

    Although diplomats are surely trying to wave the prospects of good times for Russia if it stops fighting and hands back at least its gains since Feb 2022, I doubt carrots would be forthcoming as sweet as advertised. Energy sales to the West are gone forever, and were Putin to actually take a deal, the West would than insist on Russia undertaking to pay reparations on a gigantically greater scale than Russia thought was agreed. Russian economic resurgence is not going to happen if the West can help it.

    Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn’t have a backup plan

    The invasion plan’s objective must have long since been abandoned; the Russian army has been essentially on the defensive since June 2021. In the first few months he may have toyed with the idea of a quick end by successful offensive or a complete withdrawal even, but by my way of thinking that Putin has decided to lets things play out to the bitter end means he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia’s total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean


    he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia’s total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.
     
    And people accuse ME of trying to mindread Putin.

    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other. Sometimes it leans one way and sometime the other but it has never completely cut its ties with either. Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency). His children attended Western schools and have lived in the West. Yes he has told the Russian execs that they should all drive Ladas from now on but frankly they don't like it and I doubt that he does either. For now, it's "those grapes were sour anyway" but he's just saying that and if the West would start trading again most Russians including Putin would love to have their European cars, the European vacations, their European everything. They don't want to learn Chinese.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don't think he ever really changed his mind about this - he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.

    Replies: @HA, @Sean

  351. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Steve Sailer

    Let's run through the record of the last 3 years of what Intelligent Dasein said vs what Steve Sailer said about:

    1. Covid being dangerous.
    2. Masks working.
    3. Lockdowns working.
    4. Vaccines safe and effective.
    5. Ukraine winning the war.

    Replies: @HA

    “Ukraine winning the war.”

    Did Sailer ever come out and say that Ukraine is winning the war? (As opposed to believing that invading a neighboring country so as to start a land-war in Eurasia has historically proven to be a really regrettable idea?) As it is, your list is like what you see in a daily horoscope or a slip of paper from a fortune cookie. Vague context-free invocations of ‘dangerous’, ‘safe and effective’, as compared to…well, nothing really, which is why they can affirm or disprove anything.

    As another example, here’s your clear-eyed straightforward take on what Ukraine is all about, issued to Sailer a year and a half ago:

    the problem with your whole understanding of the war in Ukraine. You are analyzing a hyperreality, a copy of a copy with no original…the Western powers, are thinking about this whole affair as an information war, and an information war is already itself a metalogical take on a real situation… But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct, and the meta of a meta is a solipsismThe simulacrum of an information war that you are analyzing exists literally only in your imagination…

    Whew! That’s some “Transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity” you got there, except the guy who wrote that was actually in on the joke.

    Or how about this — back on 9/11 of the last year, you ominously predicted that in 72 hours, Ukraine will no longer be a real country. How’d that work out? On second thought, I suppose one can play meta-of-a-meta semantic games with “real country” to make ANY day of the year contain that precise moment when a country stops being real, as in “a copy of a copy with no original”. But I’d remind you that to this day, according to Putin’s Twitter trolls, the Ukrainians are still doing pretty well. So what went wrong, ID? What exactly happened in those 72 hours that was subsequently obscured ty the “simulacrum of an information war” that the CIA is playing on us?

    But even that’s not your biggest howler. For that, let me note that in the 5 seconds or so of the above Youtube video that I sampled, you referred to yourself as a “traditional Catholic”, which is odd indeed, given that in order to make your version of De Civitate Dei function properly, we’re gonna have to push grandma and grandpa out onto the ice floe:

    I think the main factor (and this would account for the evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies) is that too many people are surviving to old age. The genius of the race… The birthrate will rise moderately once the overburden of old people are removed,

    Wow — “evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies”? Did you crib that from some Derrida fangurl? Is this some horseshoe theory of ideological extremes where blue-haired feminists who have to feed too many cats meld with traditional Catholics complaining about being overburdened with too many aging Boomers?

    And I’m no expert on theology, Christian or otherwise, or the “genius of the race”, whatever that’s supposed to mean, but I do know enough about Western Civ to suspect that whatever you want to call the above-cited Malthusian/Logan’sRun/No-country-for-old-men mish-mash, it ain’t “traditional Catholicism”. I mean, even your meta-of-a-meta handwaving is not going to be enough to rework “remove the overburden of old people” into the 11th commandment, let alone affix it to the Sermon on the Mount.

    • LOL: Twinkie
    • Replies: @HA
    @HA

    "But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct..."

    Oh, and for what it's worth, while I can't hope to unravel the above gobbledy-gook, I think maybe. just maybe, ID is referring to something like the Keynesian beauty contest which likewise allows for meta-of-a-meta (so to speak) iterations.

    , @Dumbo
    @HA

    LOL. Steve has not only wrong about both Ukraine and Covid, he's been stupidly, abysmally wrong. This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things. As I advised, he should limit himself to the few subjects he's a specialist on -- NYT Op-Eds about "black women hair" and NFL statistics.

    It's weird that you fanboys keep defending him, as he's an adult and can defend himself. It just makes it all the more pathetic, really.

    Replies: @HA

  352. @Jack D
    @Sean

    The Russian Federation is an overwhelmingly (80%) ethnic Russian nation state,

    Russia is a very big country and there are large sections where Russian ethnics are not the majority. And a lot of "Russians" have that identity because it's the currently preferable one. If things changed there would be a "flight from white" just like you see in the US.



    and one in which 80% of the population support Putin.

    And Saddam Hussein got 99% of the vote in his last election. Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure. When Wagner did its coup in Rostov, people cheered them and nobody seemed noticeably upset or ready to take up arms against them, not even the army.

    There is not going to be a revolution and they are not going to quit the war.

    Were you one of the guys who said that Russia would never invade Ukraine either? All things must pass. The USSR seemed to be a permanent edifice until one day it just disappeared. Dictatorships are very brittle. They appear solid as a rock but they can shatter like glass.

    Replies: @Sean, @David In TN

    “Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure.”

    When I read Robert Conquest’s The Great Terror long ago concerning Stalin’s purges of the 1930s, there was a passage that asserted something like:

    “You never knew how far the official lies were believed.”

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @David In TN

    There is also a sort of Stockholm Syndrome that takes place. When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n. These guys turn themselves into the personification of the nation such that people literally can't conceive of how their country can exist without them.

    Sure they suck, but who knows, the next guy might even be worse. At least with (Putin/Stalin/Hitler) you know what you have. And didn't he "make the trains run on time", so he wasn't all bad. There was such chaos before he took over and there could be again, so better to stick with the devil you know.

    Sure the polls are phony. Who in Russia is going to tell the truth to some guy on the phone who says he is a pollster? Probably he is an FSB guy and if I run my mouth about how I don't like Putin they will arrest me and play the phone tape in court.

    This doesn't mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin's complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking.

    Putin has also spent the last 20 years convincing Russians to stay out of politics and it has worked to some extent. When Wagner took over in Rostov, people just went about their business. Who is in charge is not their business.

    Replies: @Johann Ricke, @Colin Wright

  353. @Sean
    @John Johnson


    Putin still has one more card to play which is to draft the urban Slavs. But that is a very risky card and could lead to further embarrassment.
     
    Wagner had a lot of ethnic minorities both contract and excons. Latvian regiments of the Tsars's army were instrumental in the Bolshevik revolution Ordinary Russians are going to be at least loyal, they will do for manning the line in defence, which is what Russia is apparently set on at the strategic level.

    An end to the war would be in Russia’s economic interests
     
    Although diplomats are surely trying to wave the prospects of good times for Russia if it stops fighting and hands back at least its gains since Feb 2022, I doubt carrots would be forthcoming as sweet as advertised. Energy sales to the West are gone forever, and were Putin to actually take a deal, the West would than insist on Russia undertaking to pay reparations on a gigantically greater scale than Russia thought was agreed. Russian economic resurgence is not going to happen if the West can help it.

    Putin thought this war could be won in 2.5 weeks and didn’t have a backup plan
     
    The invasion plan's objective must have long since been abandoned; the Russian army has been essentially on the defensive since June 2021. In the first few months he may have toyed with the idea of a quick end by successful offensive or a complete withdrawal even, but by my way of thinking that Putin has decided to lets things play out to the bitter end means he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia's total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.

    Replies: @Jack D

    he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia’s total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.

    And people accuse ME of trying to mindread Putin.

    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other. Sometimes it leans one way and sometime the other but it has never completely cut its ties with either. Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency). His children attended Western schools and have lived in the West. Yes he has told the Russian execs that they should all drive Ladas from now on but frankly they don’t like it and I doubt that he does either. For now, it’s “those grapes were sour anyway” but he’s just saying that and if the West would start trading again most Russians including Putin would love to have their European cars, the European vacations, their European everything. They don’t want to learn Chinese.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don’t think he ever really changed his mind about this – he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Jack D

    "Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other."

    Not firmly, but when Russophiles boast of the greatness of Russian culture, it's gemerally the peculiarly Western aspects of it -- the composers, the novelists, the painters, the ballet, the theatre. Even the scientists and chess-masters are arguably more a Western thing. And with regard to Eastern Orthodoxy, it's worth noting that the Byzantines are after all Romans. The Five may have been suspicious of Tchaikovsky's overtures to French musical forms, and this count or that might have grumbled that far too much French is spoken among Russian elites, but the argument stands.

    This embrace of the East that Putin and his circle of ideologues want to emphasize seems more a way to forge inroads with (and ride on the coattails of) China, which along with the Soviets was the other big Marxist bloc. Also, it's an overture to Russia's Muslim/Asiatic minorities. So in that sense, it's more recent.

    That being said, Russia's enemies have long regarded them (or the Soviets) as one more Asiatic horde, and Russia is to some extent embracing that outsider/antagonistic status (as far as the West is concerned) as a badge of honor.

    Replies: @Jack D

    , @Sean
    @Jack D


    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other.
     
    You are speaking of a bygone balance of power that involved the Russian Empire with multiple other empires. Russia is now much more of a nation state.

    Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency)
     
    No. Putin is an outsider who the elites thought would be malleable, but rising oil prices coincided with him coming to power and an enormous improvement for the ordinary Russian; his constituency is the common people, and they not the elite are nationalist. Not only did ordinary Russian approved of Russia taking back Crimea., Putin has become more popular as a result of the 2022 invasion and that increase has been maintained. Nationalism is a powerful force multiplier for Putin and those Westerners oppose him and have studied public opinion ns Russia admit that he is popular, and Russians quite like the war.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don’t think he ever really changed his mind about this – he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.
     
    In that regard he is a typical Russian, because the majority of them concur with Putin 's view that invading Ukraine had become necessary. The Western arming and training of Ukraine was greatly increasing in late 2021, if Russia had not acted immediately Ukraine would have been too strong. The course of the invasion has showed that if anything Russia waited too long.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/

    Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.

    As a specialist in Russian propaganda, I have analysed tens of thousands of pro-war Telegram posts and media articles, identifying three main narrative groups, or themes, all upheld by the belief that Ukrainians are in fact Russians, and that Ukraine is not a real country. The first group is rooted in Second World War mythology, arguing that Russians are not fighting against Ukraine but against Nazism, which has reappeared in Ukraine as evidenced by Kyiv’s alleged “genocide of Russian speakers”. The second casts Russians as “misunderstood angels” who are liberating Ukrainians. [...] The third category portrays Russia as the underdog, fighting wildly against the odds to defend itself from a Russophobic Western military machine and malign mercenaries from Nato. Combined with the impact of sanctions, this argument has even appealed to some of the more metropolitan and well-educated Russians, who now feel victimised by their government as well as by the West, and resent the latter’s support for Ukraine. For many in poorer regions, especially those bordering Ukraine, Nato’s military aid simply confirms their long-held suspicion that the West is out to destroy Russia.
     

    So what is Kremlin planned to win at small cost in in 2 weeks but it is now nearly 20 months and they are showing no signs of second thoughts. The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    Replies: @Jack D

  354. @David In TN
    @Jack D

    "Popular support in a dictatorship is impossible to measure."

    When I read Robert Conquest's The Great Terror long ago concerning Stalin's purges of the 1930s, there was a passage that asserted something like:

    "You never knew how far the official lies were believed."

    Replies: @Jack D

    There is also a sort of Stockholm Syndrome that takes place. When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n. These guys turn themselves into the personification of the nation such that people literally can’t conceive of how their country can exist without them.

    Sure they suck, but who knows, the next guy might even be worse. At least with (Putin/Stalin/Hitler) you know what you have. And didn’t he “make the trains run on time”, so he wasn’t all bad. There was such chaos before he took over and there could be again, so better to stick with the devil you know.

    Sure the polls are phony. Who in Russia is going to tell the truth to some guy on the phone who says he is a pollster? Probably he is an FSB guy and if I run my mouth about how I don’t like Putin they will arrest me and play the phone tape in court.

    This doesn’t mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin’s complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking.

    Putin has also spent the last 20 years convincing Russians to stay out of politics and it has worked to some extent. When Wagner took over in Rostov, people just went about their business. Who is in charge is not their business.

    • Replies: @Johann Ricke
    @Jack D


    When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n.
     
    Did they genuinely weep, or were they the survivors of the acid test that determined who lived and who died? Fake sincere devotion and live. Be sincerely loyal while seeming insincere and die. Who was to say a second round of litmus tests revolving around Stalin wouldn't suddenly become a life-and-death question? That's the thing about these frenzies - whether a wicked game or a burst of genuine zealotry, the consequences of being on the wrong side were real enough.
    , @Colin Wright
    @Jack D


    '...This doesn’t mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin’s complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking...'
     
    We're becoming familiar with the process.
  355. @Jack D
    @Sean


    he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia’s total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.
     
    And people accuse ME of trying to mindread Putin.

    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other. Sometimes it leans one way and sometime the other but it has never completely cut its ties with either. Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency). His children attended Western schools and have lived in the West. Yes he has told the Russian execs that they should all drive Ladas from now on but frankly they don't like it and I doubt that he does either. For now, it's "those grapes were sour anyway" but he's just saying that and if the West would start trading again most Russians including Putin would love to have their European cars, the European vacations, their European everything. They don't want to learn Chinese.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don't think he ever really changed his mind about this - he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.

    Replies: @HA, @Sean

    “Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other.”

    Not firmly, but when Russophiles boast of the greatness of Russian culture, it’s gemerally the peculiarly Western aspects of it — the composers, the novelists, the painters, the ballet, the theatre. Even the scientists and chess-masters are arguably more a Western thing. And with regard to Eastern Orthodoxy, it’s worth noting that the Byzantines are after all Romans. The Five may have been suspicious of Tchaikovsky’s overtures to French musical forms, and this count or that might have grumbled that far too much French is spoken among Russian elites, but the argument stands.

    This embrace of the East that Putin and his circle of ideologues want to emphasize seems more a way to forge inroads with (and ride on the coattails of) China, which along with the Soviets was the other big Marxist bloc. Also, it’s an overture to Russia’s Muslim/Asiatic minorities. So in that sense, it’s more recent.

    That being said, Russia’s enemies have long regarded them (or the Soviets) as one more Asiatic horde, and Russia is to some extent embracing that outsider/antagonistic status (as far as the West is concerned) as a badge of honor.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @HA

    When Russia doesn't consider itself part of the West, it mostly thinks of itself as a separate (BETTER!) civilization, the true heir of Rome and the original Church. Not as part of the East. Even if the West thinks of them as Asiatic Hordes, to Russians, Asiatic Hordes exist, it's just that they are not them, the Hordes lie even further to the east. Which has some historical truth.

    Russia doesn't really swing between East and West, it swings between opening the door to the West and closing it into isolationism. It doesn't really ever face east, it just turns its back on the West.

  356. @Jack D
    @Sean


    he has an ulterior motivation of RusFed ceasing interaction with the West, whether cultural, economical or industrial. Actually, I would not be surprised if Russia’s total disengagement from the West is not an unanticipated side effect of Z, but intentional and his unavowable yet primary reason for ordering the invasion.
     
    And people accuse ME of trying to mindread Putin.

    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other. Sometimes it leans one way and sometime the other but it has never completely cut its ties with either. Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency). His children attended Western schools and have lived in the West. Yes he has told the Russian execs that they should all drive Ladas from now on but frankly they don't like it and I doubt that he does either. For now, it's "those grapes were sour anyway" but he's just saying that and if the West would start trading again most Russians including Putin would love to have their European cars, the European vacations, their European everything. They don't want to learn Chinese.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don't think he ever really changed his mind about this - he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.

    Replies: @HA, @Sean

    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other.

    You are speaking of a bygone balance of power that involved the Russian Empire with multiple other empires. Russia is now much more of a nation state.

    Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency)

    No. Putin is an outsider who the elites thought would be malleable, but rising oil prices coincided with him coming to power and an enormous improvement for the ordinary Russian; his constituency is the common people, and they not the elite are nationalist. Not only did ordinary Russian approved of Russia taking back Crimea., Putin has become more popular as a result of the 2022 invasion and that increase has been maintained. Nationalism is a powerful force multiplier for Putin and those Westerners oppose him and have studied public opinion ns Russia admit that he is popular, and Russians quite like the war.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don’t think he ever really changed his mind about this – he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.

    In that regard he is a typical Russian, because the majority of them concur with Putin ‘s view that invading Ukraine had become necessary. The Western arming and training of Ukraine was greatly increasing in late 2021, if Russia had not acted immediately Ukraine would have been too strong. The course of the invasion has showed that if anything Russia waited too long.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/

    Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.

    As a specialist in Russian propaganda, I have analysed tens of thousands of pro-war Telegram posts and media articles, identifying three main narrative groups, or themes, all upheld by the belief that Ukrainians are in fact Russians, and that Ukraine is not a real country. The first group is rooted in Second World War mythology, arguing that Russians are not fighting against Ukraine but against Nazism, which has reappeared in Ukraine as evidenced by Kyiv’s alleged “genocide of Russian speakers”. The second casts Russians as “misunderstood angels” who are liberating Ukrainians. […] The third category portrays Russia as the underdog, fighting wildly against the odds to defend itself from a Russophobic Western military machine and malign mercenaries from Nato. Combined with the impact of sanctions, this argument has even appealed to some of the more metropolitan and well-educated Russians, who now feel victimised by their government as well as by the West, and resent the latter’s support for Ukraine. For many in poorer regions, especially those bordering Ukraine, Nato’s military aid simply confirms their long-held suspicion that the West is out to destroy Russia.

    So what is Kremlin planned to win at small cost in in 2 weeks but it is now nearly 20 months and they are showing no signs of second thoughts. The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean

    Putin has not left any space for dissent on the left (hold up a blank piece of paper, get 10 years in prison), while giving the ultra-nationalist right (somewhat - but see Girkin not to mention Prigogone for what happens if you run with the ball too much) space in order to try to move the Russian Overton window even further to the right. Don't mistake this for actual political opinion.


    The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    No one asks the Russian populace. The Russian populace has been taught to stay out of politics. Whatever the boss says is OK with them. If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.

    they are showing no signs of second thoughts.

    They have PLENTY of 2nd thoughts. But in Russia betraying 2nd thoughts is a sign of weakness so you have to double down until the wheels fall completely off.

    Replies: @Sean

  357. @Sean
    @Jack D


    Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other.
     
    You are speaking of a bygone balance of power that involved the Russian Empire with multiple other empires. Russia is now much more of a nation state.

    Putin himself is no different. He likes European things like fine Swiss watches (and so do the Russian elites who are his main constituency)
     
    No. Putin is an outsider who the elites thought would be malleable, but rising oil prices coincided with him coming to power and an enormous improvement for the ordinary Russian; his constituency is the common people, and they not the elite are nationalist. Not only did ordinary Russian approved of Russia taking back Crimea., Putin has become more popular as a result of the 2022 invasion and that increase has been maintained. Nationalism is a powerful force multiplier for Putin and those Westerners oppose him and have studied public opinion ns Russia admit that he is popular, and Russians quite like the war.

    When the war started Putin probably figured that he would win in 2 weeks and there would be a slap on the wrist and then the Germans would go back to business as usual. I don’t think he ever really changed his mind about this – he is just making the best of a bad situation and pretending that it was all his idea.
     
    In that regard he is a typical Russian, because the majority of them concur with Putin 's view that invading Ukraine had become necessary. The Western arming and training of Ukraine was greatly increasing in late 2021, if Russia had not acted immediately Ukraine would have been too strong. The course of the invasion has showed that if anything Russia waited too long.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/

    Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.

    As a specialist in Russian propaganda, I have analysed tens of thousands of pro-war Telegram posts and media articles, identifying three main narrative groups, or themes, all upheld by the belief that Ukrainians are in fact Russians, and that Ukraine is not a real country. The first group is rooted in Second World War mythology, arguing that Russians are not fighting against Ukraine but against Nazism, which has reappeared in Ukraine as evidenced by Kyiv’s alleged “genocide of Russian speakers”. The second casts Russians as “misunderstood angels” who are liberating Ukrainians. [...] The third category portrays Russia as the underdog, fighting wildly against the odds to defend itself from a Russophobic Western military machine and malign mercenaries from Nato. Combined with the impact of sanctions, this argument has even appealed to some of the more metropolitan and well-educated Russians, who now feel victimised by their government as well as by the West, and resent the latter’s support for Ukraine. For many in poorer regions, especially those bordering Ukraine, Nato’s military aid simply confirms their long-held suspicion that the West is out to destroy Russia.
     

    So what is Kremlin planned to win at small cost in in 2 weeks but it is now nearly 20 months and they are showing no signs of second thoughts. The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    Replies: @Jack D

    Putin has not left any space for dissent on the left (hold up a blank piece of paper, get 10 years in prison), while giving the ultra-nationalist right (somewhat – but see Girkin not to mention Prigogone for what happens if you run with the ball too much) space in order to try to move the Russian Overton window even further to the right. Don’t mistake this for actual political opinion.

    The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    No one asks the Russian populace. The Russian populace has been taught to stay out of politics. Whatever the boss says is OK with them. If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.

    they are showing no signs of second thoughts.

    They have PLENTY of 2nd thoughts. But in Russia betraying 2nd thoughts is a sign of weakness so you have to double down until the wheels fall completely off.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @Jack D


    If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.
     
    The article I quoted takes a different view, one that I think explains much. The idea that ordinary people in Russia are only acted on by Kremlin propaganda and grassroots Russians have no influence on Putin seems less plausible to me after reading the whole piece.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/
    If you were a Russian mother, would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis, or that he died butchering innocent civilians? The former, most likely. It is not easy to admit — to oneself or to others — that you live in a country that has murdered tens of thousands of Ukrainians, or that has pointlessly sacrificed the lives of its own people.

    Yet it is one thing to turn a blind eye to the truth, and quite another to be “brainwashed”. The West is fixated on the idea that “Putin’s war” is not Russia’s, and that the Russian people only support it because they have been “zombified” by a totalitarian regime. But this is missing the wood for the trees. [...]

    Russian TV news channels, which have long been the most trusted form of media, especially among older audiences, latched on to this popular opinion. It would be naïve to think they could get away with anything else, given that they rely on advertising revenue for income. Even today, producers schedule shows because they’re lucrative, not just because they uphold state propaganda (although they do need to stay on the Kremlin’s good side). Such was the demand for war propaganda following Russia’s invasion — from on high and below — that some channels ran pro-war content for up to 10 hours a day. After six months, however, audiences grew tired of the constant barrage and started to switch off, hitting advertising revenues. In response, the channels replaced some of the political propaganda shows with soaps, sports and lifestyle programmes.

    Russians aren’t dependent on state television for all their news. Ordinary people can still read and watch almost all alternative sources using a VPN, which one in four Russians use. Even without a VPN, the Internet is mostly free, if manipulated, and the social media app Telegram acts as an uncensored news source for some 40 million Russians. Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.
     

    Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear. More that anyone wants to admit, Putin's strength comes from pre existing Russian public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know. And just as Russian mass media need to reflect the opinions its viewers approve of or its advertising revenues will fall, the Western MSM have to produce what sells, Westerners want to hear that Russians are all prisoners of a malevolent dictator who has brainwashed them, but will be overthrown because Russians are mainly interested in enjoying material possessions from their oil and gas revenues and don't want to fight for their country. But we are almost two years in and tens of thousands of Russians have been killed yet there are still men choosing to joining up. Some Russia men do not want to be involved and leave their country, but some Ukrainian men have too. This war is going to go on for quite a few more years because both populations think their country's cause in it is just.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

  358. @HA
    @Jack D

    "Russia has always been poised between east and west and never firmly in one sphere or the other."

    Not firmly, but when Russophiles boast of the greatness of Russian culture, it's gemerally the peculiarly Western aspects of it -- the composers, the novelists, the painters, the ballet, the theatre. Even the scientists and chess-masters are arguably more a Western thing. And with regard to Eastern Orthodoxy, it's worth noting that the Byzantines are after all Romans. The Five may have been suspicious of Tchaikovsky's overtures to French musical forms, and this count or that might have grumbled that far too much French is spoken among Russian elites, but the argument stands.

    This embrace of the East that Putin and his circle of ideologues want to emphasize seems more a way to forge inroads with (and ride on the coattails of) China, which along with the Soviets was the other big Marxist bloc. Also, it's an overture to Russia's Muslim/Asiatic minorities. So in that sense, it's more recent.

    That being said, Russia's enemies have long regarded them (or the Soviets) as one more Asiatic horde, and Russia is to some extent embracing that outsider/antagonistic status (as far as the West is concerned) as a badge of honor.

    Replies: @Jack D

    When Russia doesn’t consider itself part of the West, it mostly thinks of itself as a separate (BETTER!) civilization, the true heir of Rome and the original Church. Not as part of the East. Even if the West thinks of them as Asiatic Hordes, to Russians, Asiatic Hordes exist, it’s just that they are not them, the Hordes lie even further to the east. Which has some historical truth.

    Russia doesn’t really swing between East and West, it swings between opening the door to the West and closing it into isolationism. It doesn’t really ever face east, it just turns its back on the West.

  359. @HA
    @Intelligent Dasein

    "Ukraine winning the war."

    Did Sailer ever come out and say that Ukraine is winning the war? (As opposed to believing that invading a neighboring country so as to start a land-war in Eurasia has historically proven to be a really regrettable idea?) As it is, your list is like what you see in a daily horoscope or a slip of paper from a fortune cookie. Vague context-free invocations of 'dangerous', 'safe and effective', as compared to...well, nothing really, which is why they can affirm or disprove anything.

    As another example, here's your clear-eyed straightforward take on what Ukraine is all about, issued to Sailer a year and a half ago:


    the problem with your whole understanding of the war in Ukraine. You are analyzing a hyperreality, a copy of a copy with no original...the Western powers, are thinking about this whole affair as an information war, and an information war is already itself a metalogical take on a real situation... But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct, and the meta of a meta is a solipsism...The simulacrum of an information war that you are analyzing exists literally only in your imagination...
     
    Whew! That's some "Transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity" you got there, except the guy who wrote that was actually in on the joke.

    Or how about this -- back on 9/11 of the last year, you ominously predicted that in 72 hours, Ukraine will no longer be a real country. How'd that work out? On second thought, I suppose one can play meta-of-a-meta semantic games with "real country" to make ANY day of the year contain that precise moment when a country stops being real, as in "a copy of a copy with no original". But I'd remind you that to this day, according to Putin's Twitter trolls, the Ukrainians are still doing pretty well. So what went wrong, ID? What exactly happened in those 72 hours that was subsequently obscured ty the "simulacrum of an information war" that the CIA is playing on us?

    But even that's not your biggest howler. For that, let me note that in the 5 seconds or so of the above Youtube video that I sampled, you referred to yourself as a "traditional Catholic", which is odd indeed, given that in order to make your version of De Civitate Dei function properly, we're gonna have to push grandma and grandpa out onto the ice floe:


    I think the main factor (and this would account for the evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies) is that too many people are surviving to old age. The genius of the race... The birthrate will rise moderately once the overburden of old people are removed,...
     
    Wow -- "evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies"? Did you crib that from some Derrida fangurl? Is this some horseshoe theory of ideological extremes where blue-haired feminists who have to feed too many cats meld with traditional Catholics complaining about being overburdened with too many aging Boomers?

    And I'm no expert on theology, Christian or otherwise, or the "genius of the race", whatever that's supposed to mean, but I do know enough about Western Civ to suspect that whatever you want to call the above-cited Malthusian/Logan'sRun/No-country-for-old-men mish-mash, it ain't "traditional Catholicism". I mean, even your meta-of-a-meta handwaving is not going to be enough to rework "remove the overburden of old people" into the 11th commandment, let alone affix it to the Sermon on the Mount.

    Replies: @HA, @Dumbo

    “But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct…”

    Oh, and for what it’s worth, while I can’t hope to unravel the above gobbledy-gook, I think maybe. just maybe, ID is referring to something like the Keynesian beauty contest which likewise allows for meta-of-a-meta (so to speak) iterations.

  360. @Jack D
    @Sean

    Putin has not left any space for dissent on the left (hold up a blank piece of paper, get 10 years in prison), while giving the ultra-nationalist right (somewhat - but see Girkin not to mention Prigogone for what happens if you run with the ball too much) space in order to try to move the Russian Overton window even further to the right. Don't mistake this for actual political opinion.


    The Russian populace would not let Putin or any other leader have Russia quit the war and and crawl to the West.

    No one asks the Russian populace. The Russian populace has been taught to stay out of politics. Whatever the boss says is OK with them. If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.

    they are showing no signs of second thoughts.

    They have PLENTY of 2nd thoughts. But in Russia betraying 2nd thoughts is a sign of weakness so you have to double down until the wheels fall completely off.

    Replies: @Sean

    If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.

    The article I quoted takes a different view, one that I think explains much. The idea that ordinary people in Russia are only acted on by Kremlin propaganda and grassroots Russians have no influence on Putin seems less plausible to me after reading the whole piece.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/
    If you were a Russian mother, would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis, or that he died butchering innocent civilians? The former, most likely. It is not easy to admit — to oneself or to others — that you live in a country that has murdered tens of thousands of Ukrainians, or that has pointlessly sacrificed the lives of its own people.

    Yet it is one thing to turn a blind eye to the truth, and quite another to be “brainwashed”. The West is fixated on the idea that “Putin’s war” is not Russia’s, and that the Russian people only support it because they have been “zombified” by a totalitarian regime. But this is missing the wood for the trees. […]

    Russian TV news channels, which have long been the most trusted form of media, especially among older audiences, latched on to this popular opinion. It would be naïve to think they could get away with anything else, given that they rely on advertising revenue for income. Even today, producers schedule shows because they’re lucrative, not just because they uphold state propaganda (although they do need to stay on the Kremlin’s good side). Such was the demand for war propaganda following Russia’s invasion — from on high and below — that some channels ran pro-war content for up to 10 hours a day. After six months, however, audiences grew tired of the constant barrage and started to switch off, hitting advertising revenues. In response, the channels replaced some of the political propaganda shows with soaps, sports and lifestyle programmes.

    Russians aren’t dependent on state television for all their news. Ordinary people can still read and watch almost all alternative sources using a VPN, which one in four Russians use. Even without a VPN, the Internet is mostly free, if manipulated, and the social media app Telegram acts as an uncensored news source for some 40 million Russians. Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.

    Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear. More that anyone wants to admit, Putin’s strength comes from pre existing Russian public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know. And just as Russian mass media need to reflect the opinions its viewers approve of or its advertising revenues will fall, the Western MSM have to produce what sells, Westerners want to hear that Russians are all prisoners of a malevolent dictator who has brainwashed them, but will be overthrown because Russians are mainly interested in enjoying material possessions from their oil and gas revenues and don’t want to fight for their country. But we are almost two years in and tens of thousands of Russians have been killed yet there are still men choosing to joining up. Some Russia men do not want to be involved and leave their country, but some Ukrainian men have too. This war is going to go on for quite a few more years because both populations think their country’s cause in it is just.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Sean


    would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis,
     
    Where did Russian mothers get this idea if not from Russian propaganda? It bears no resemblance to the truth.

    Try this on for size:

    Hitler is a German and if he thinks Poland has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Germans have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted .... More that anyone wants to admit, Hitler’s strength comes from pre existing German public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know.

    Did German public opinion change overnight in May of 1945? If Putin has popular backing in Russia (which I doubt - he has shallow backing among certain segments and once he is dead those segments will spit on his grave) then they are BOTH wrong and they are both going to have to change their views or be made to change.

    , @HA
    @Sean

    "Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear.

    Bully for him. No is asking Putin or Russians in general to be happy with NATO. What the West opposes is those who express their disapproval by way of military invasions. As Nuland demonstrated, a few baskets of pastries is all anyone needs to sway the Ukrainians -- no military invasions (3-day or otherwise) are needed. I have yet to find a clear answer from Putin or his alleged supporters as to why invading Ukraine was ever some necessity. Prigozhin, for one, eventually was able to admit openly that Ukraine was never a threat to Russia. Few in Russia are willing to even be among the first to stop clapping, but that doesn't mean they don't agree that Prigozhin was right about that.

    Sure, if Putin had managed to wipe out the Ukrainian military in a few days -- or even just take Kyiv -- plenty in the West would have shrugged their shoulders and written the whole thing off by now. But he bungled it. If NATO is so powerful that even their discarded hand-me-down weaponry is enough to halt Putin's advances, and Western bureacrats are so skilled in their skullduggery that they are able to move entire nations with only some empty carbs, Putin should have admitted he was outmatched and outwitted, and given up, else any further bloodshed was surely his fault. That's after all the advice that the Putin trolls are even now giving to Ukraine. Seems to me they ought to take a swig of their own medicine.

    Replies: @Sean

  361. @Jack D
    @David In TN

    There is also a sort of Stockholm Syndrome that takes place. When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n. These guys turn themselves into the personification of the nation such that people literally can't conceive of how their country can exist without them.

    Sure they suck, but who knows, the next guy might even be worse. At least with (Putin/Stalin/Hitler) you know what you have. And didn't he "make the trains run on time", so he wasn't all bad. There was such chaos before he took over and there could be again, so better to stick with the devil you know.

    Sure the polls are phony. Who in Russia is going to tell the truth to some guy on the phone who says he is a pollster? Probably he is an FSB guy and if I run my mouth about how I don't like Putin they will arrest me and play the phone tape in court.

    This doesn't mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin's complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking.

    Putin has also spent the last 20 years convincing Russians to stay out of politics and it has worked to some extent. When Wagner took over in Rostov, people just went about their business. Who is in charge is not their business.

    Replies: @Johann Ricke, @Colin Wright

    When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n.

    Did they genuinely weep, or were they the survivors of the acid test that determined who lived and who died? Fake sincere devotion and live. Be sincerely loyal while seeming insincere and die. Who was to say a second round of litmus tests revolving around Stalin wouldn’t suddenly become a life-and-death question? That’s the thing about these frenzies – whether a wicked game or a burst of genuine zealotry, the consequences of being on the wrong side were real enough.

  362. @HA
    @Intelligent Dasein

    "Ukraine winning the war."

    Did Sailer ever come out and say that Ukraine is winning the war? (As opposed to believing that invading a neighboring country so as to start a land-war in Eurasia has historically proven to be a really regrettable idea?) As it is, your list is like what you see in a daily horoscope or a slip of paper from a fortune cookie. Vague context-free invocations of 'dangerous', 'safe and effective', as compared to...well, nothing really, which is why they can affirm or disprove anything.

    As another example, here's your clear-eyed straightforward take on what Ukraine is all about, issued to Sailer a year and a half ago:


    the problem with your whole understanding of the war in Ukraine. You are analyzing a hyperreality, a copy of a copy with no original...the Western powers, are thinking about this whole affair as an information war, and an information war is already itself a metalogical take on a real situation... But when you start talking about how the CIA is performing in the information war, as if that were a substantial reality in its own right, then you’ve taken a metalogical take on metalogical construct, and the meta of a meta is a solipsism...The simulacrum of an information war that you are analyzing exists literally only in your imagination...
     
    Whew! That's some "Transformative hermeneutics of quantum gravity" you got there, except the guy who wrote that was actually in on the joke.

    Or how about this -- back on 9/11 of the last year, you ominously predicted that in 72 hours, Ukraine will no longer be a real country. How'd that work out? On second thought, I suppose one can play meta-of-a-meta semantic games with "real country" to make ANY day of the year contain that precise moment when a country stops being real, as in "a copy of a copy with no original". But I'd remind you that to this day, according to Putin's Twitter trolls, the Ukrainians are still doing pretty well. So what went wrong, ID? What exactly happened in those 72 hours that was subsequently obscured ty the "simulacrum of an information war" that the CIA is playing on us?

    But even that's not your biggest howler. For that, let me note that in the 5 seconds or so of the above Youtube video that I sampled, you referred to yourself as a "traditional Catholic", which is odd indeed, given that in order to make your version of De Civitate Dei function properly, we're gonna have to push grandma and grandpa out onto the ice floe:


    I think the main factor (and this would account for the evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies) is that too many people are surviving to old age. The genius of the race... The birthrate will rise moderately once the overburden of old people are removed,...
     
    Wow -- "evil affecting traditional patriarchal as well as Westernized societies"? Did you crib that from some Derrida fangurl? Is this some horseshoe theory of ideological extremes where blue-haired feminists who have to feed too many cats meld with traditional Catholics complaining about being overburdened with too many aging Boomers?

    And I'm no expert on theology, Christian or otherwise, or the "genius of the race", whatever that's supposed to mean, but I do know enough about Western Civ to suspect that whatever you want to call the above-cited Malthusian/Logan'sRun/No-country-for-old-men mish-mash, it ain't "traditional Catholicism". I mean, even your meta-of-a-meta handwaving is not going to be enough to rework "remove the overburden of old people" into the 11th commandment, let alone affix it to the Sermon on the Mount.

    Replies: @HA, @Dumbo

    LOL. Steve has not only wrong about both Ukraine and Covid, he’s been stupidly, abysmally wrong. This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things. As I advised, he should limit himself to the few subjects he’s a specialist on — NYT Op-Eds about “black women hair” and NFL statistics.

    It’s weird that you fanboys keep defending him, as he’s an adult and can defend himself. It just makes it all the more pathetic, really.

    • Replies: @HA
    @Dumbo

    "This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things."

    I'm guessing he stopped talking about COVID because, unlike anti-vaxx loons like yourself, he was able to get on with his life and move on to other interests once the pandemic ended and excess death tolls returned to normal, which was some time ago. If you still want to hyperventilate about that, even though the ER's are no longer over-flowing and restrictions have been lifted, consider the possibility that maybe long-COVID addled your brain.

    As for Ukraine, Prigozhin played a role of some importance in what went on there last year, and Sailer is apparently willing to discuss that.

    Which means you're 0 for 2, i.e., I'm guessing you have some first-hand experience when it comes to being stupidly, abysmally wrong.

    Replies: @Dumbo

  363. @Sean
    @Jack D


    If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.
     
    The article I quoted takes a different view, one that I think explains much. The idea that ordinary people in Russia are only acted on by Kremlin propaganda and grassroots Russians have no influence on Putin seems less plausible to me after reading the whole piece.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/
    If you were a Russian mother, would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis, or that he died butchering innocent civilians? The former, most likely. It is not easy to admit — to oneself or to others — that you live in a country that has murdered tens of thousands of Ukrainians, or that has pointlessly sacrificed the lives of its own people.

    Yet it is one thing to turn a blind eye to the truth, and quite another to be “brainwashed”. The West is fixated on the idea that “Putin’s war” is not Russia’s, and that the Russian people only support it because they have been “zombified” by a totalitarian regime. But this is missing the wood for the trees. [...]

    Russian TV news channels, which have long been the most trusted form of media, especially among older audiences, latched on to this popular opinion. It would be naïve to think they could get away with anything else, given that they rely on advertising revenue for income. Even today, producers schedule shows because they’re lucrative, not just because they uphold state propaganda (although they do need to stay on the Kremlin’s good side). Such was the demand for war propaganda following Russia’s invasion — from on high and below — that some channels ran pro-war content for up to 10 hours a day. After six months, however, audiences grew tired of the constant barrage and started to switch off, hitting advertising revenues. In response, the channels replaced some of the political propaganda shows with soaps, sports and lifestyle programmes.

    Russians aren’t dependent on state television for all their news. Ordinary people can still read and watch almost all alternative sources using a VPN, which one in four Russians use. Even without a VPN, the Internet is mostly free, if manipulated, and the social media app Telegram acts as an uncensored news source for some 40 million Russians. Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.
     

    Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear. More that anyone wants to admit, Putin's strength comes from pre existing Russian public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know. And just as Russian mass media need to reflect the opinions its viewers approve of or its advertising revenues will fall, the Western MSM have to produce what sells, Westerners want to hear that Russians are all prisoners of a malevolent dictator who has brainwashed them, but will be overthrown because Russians are mainly interested in enjoying material possessions from their oil and gas revenues and don't want to fight for their country. But we are almost two years in and tens of thousands of Russians have been killed yet there are still men choosing to joining up. Some Russia men do not want to be involved and leave their country, but some Ukrainian men have too. This war is going to go on for quite a few more years because both populations think their country's cause in it is just.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

    would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis,

    Where did Russian mothers get this idea if not from Russian propaganda? It bears no resemblance to the truth.

    Try this on for size:

    Hitler is a German and if he thinks Poland has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Germans have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted …. More that anyone wants to admit, Hitler’s strength comes from pre existing German public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know.

    Did German public opinion change overnight in May of 1945? If Putin has popular backing in Russia (which I doubt – he has shallow backing among certain segments and once he is dead those segments will spit on his grave) then they are BOTH wrong and they are both going to have to change their views or be made to change.

    • Thanks: Johann Ricke
  364. @Jack D
    @Dennis Dale

    Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?

    Replies: @Cagey Beast, @Colin Wright

    ‘Is he wrong? If the Russians had taken Kiev in two weeks and the West did nothing but shrug, then would have this made the Chinese more or less likely to try for Taipei?’

    Yes — but why was Putin led to try to seize Kiev?

    You can’t just enter events part-way through and then make your judgement. Was the British fire-bombing of Hamburg in 1943 wrong?

    …but hadn’t the Germans done a few things to bring matters to that pass?

    No doubt state prison is cruel and awful — but what if you did something that led to the mean judge sending you there? Are we just going to omit that?

    Putin — and everyone else for thirty years — warned us that there would be a response if we invited the Ukraine to join NATO. So we proceeded to invite the Ukraine to join NATO. What was supposed to happen?

  365. @Jack D
    @David In TN

    There is also a sort of Stockholm Syndrome that takes place. When Stalin died, people genuinely wept, even people who had been victims of repressi0n. These guys turn themselves into the personification of the nation such that people literally can't conceive of how their country can exist without them.

    Sure they suck, but who knows, the next guy might even be worse. At least with (Putin/Stalin/Hitler) you know what you have. And didn't he "make the trains run on time", so he wasn't all bad. There was such chaos before he took over and there could be again, so better to stick with the devil you know.

    Sure the polls are phony. Who in Russia is going to tell the truth to some guy on the phone who says he is a pollster? Probably he is an FSB guy and if I run my mouth about how I don't like Putin they will arrest me and play the phone tape in court.

    This doesn't mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin's complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking.

    Putin has also spent the last 20 years convincing Russians to stay out of politics and it has worked to some extent. When Wagner took over in Rostov, people just went about their business. Who is in charge is not their business.

    Replies: @Johann Ricke, @Colin Wright

    ‘…This doesn’t mean that Putin is without support but even that support is in part manufactured thru Putin’s complete control of the media and in part from the above sort of thinking…’

    We’re becoming familiar with the process.

  366. @John Johnson
    Making the Ukraine an ad hoc and de facto protectorate of the U.S. as if it were part of NATO

    If Ukraine was a de facto protectorate then the US would have launched cruise missiles upon invasion and immediately provided them with Apaches, A10s, spectres, spookys, long range HIMARs and F-35s. Limited US military aid only started rolling after Ukraine pushed the Russians out of Kiev. Western military analysts expected Kiev to fall and that Vietnam style partisan warfare was their only hope.

    I imagine that Putin has become piquant about nuclear weapons BECAUSE THE U.S. IS FIGHTING A PROXY WAR ON RUSSIA’S BORDER.

    Putin was threatening to use nukes before the US sent military aid. He actually threatened to use them upon invasion and that was after he swore it was all a training exercise. Can provide sources if you would like.

    Both Putin and Medvedev have in fact threatened to nuke the whole world over Ukraine from the very beginning. The West was told that the nukes could go off if they aid Ukraine. That was around the time that the dictator declared LPR/DPR to be new countries and has since taken them as Russian territory. The weasel betrayed his own supporters and had the LPR/DPR militia men sent to the front.

    Your little weasel dwarf dictator complains of US agitation while threatening to blow up the entire world over a "special military operation" that is in year 1.5 of a 2.5 week plan.

    The weasel dictator can't even respect the dead. Hot off the press in Weasel Dictator News:

    Russia removes graves of Wagner fallen

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQSw4xgitrg

    What a total POS. Unreal that some of you continue to defend him.

    Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge. I can't believe that over 100 years ago the British suggested that Russia would be an ongoing problem due to the insecurities of the Tsars. They didn't think the Russians would ever compete with Western Europe and Tsars would over-compensate with imperial wars. Boy were they way off.

    Replies: @used tire, @Putinandhisfansaremorons, @Sean, @Colin Wright

    ‘Russia is a gas station with nukes and has a maniacal height insecure Tsar in charge….’

    Not yet. We’re trying to make that happen, though.

    I can’t get over how people assume that if we just undermine Putin, we get someone better.

    Oh, au contraire…

  367. @Dumbo
    @HA

    LOL. Steve has not only wrong about both Ukraine and Covid, he's been stupidly, abysmally wrong. This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things. As I advised, he should limit himself to the few subjects he's a specialist on -- NYT Op-Eds about "black women hair" and NFL statistics.

    It's weird that you fanboys keep defending him, as he's an adult and can defend himself. It just makes it all the more pathetic, really.

    Replies: @HA

    “This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things.”

    I’m guessing he stopped talking about COVID because, unlike anti-vaxx loons like yourself, he was able to get on with his life and move on to other interests once the pandemic ended and excess death tolls returned to normal, which was some time ago. If you still want to hyperventilate about that, even though the ER’s are no longer over-flowing and restrictions have been lifted, consider the possibility that maybe long-COVID addled your brain.

    As for Ukraine, Prigozhin played a role of some importance in what went on there last year, and Sailer is apparently willing to discuss that.

    Which means you’re 0 for 2, i.e., I’m guessing you have some first-hand experience when it comes to being stupidly, abysmally wrong.

    • Replies: @Dumbo
    @HA

    LOL. The problem of people like you (until proof in contrary, I am assuming you're a Fed, a Jewish activist or at any rate some moron troll with a "neocon mentality") is that they NEVER admit they are wrong. Long Covid, LOL. Whatever, dude. Now, Steve's problem is something else -- he's just not very deep, and he doesn't care.

  368. @Sean
    @Jack D


    If Putin flipped 180 degrees and made a deal tomorrow all the mouthpieces on Russian TV would praise the deal to the skies and the Russian population would go along with that too.
     
    The article I quoted takes a different view, one that I think explains much. The idea that ordinary people in Russia are only acted on by Kremlin propaganda and grassroots Russians have no influence on Putin seems less plausible to me after reading the whole piece.

    https://unherd.com/2023/02/do-ordinary-russians-support-putins-war/
    If you were a Russian mother, would you rather believe that your son gave his life heroically fighting Ukrainian Nazis, or that he died butchering innocent civilians? The former, most likely. It is not easy to admit — to oneself or to others — that you live in a country that has murdered tens of thousands of Ukrainians, or that has pointlessly sacrificed the lives of its own people.

    Yet it is one thing to turn a blind eye to the truth, and quite another to be “brainwashed”. The West is fixated on the idea that “Putin’s war” is not Russia’s, and that the Russian people only support it because they have been “zombified” by a totalitarian regime. But this is missing the wood for the trees. [...]

    Russian TV news channels, which have long been the most trusted form of media, especially among older audiences, latched on to this popular opinion. It would be naïve to think they could get away with anything else, given that they rely on advertising revenue for income. Even today, producers schedule shows because they’re lucrative, not just because they uphold state propaganda (although they do need to stay on the Kremlin’s good side). Such was the demand for war propaganda following Russia’s invasion — from on high and below — that some channels ran pro-war content for up to 10 hours a day. After six months, however, audiences grew tired of the constant barrage and started to switch off, hitting advertising revenues. In response, the channels replaced some of the political propaganda shows with soaps, sports and lifestyle programmes.

    Russians aren’t dependent on state television for all their news. Ordinary people can still read and watch almost all alternative sources using a VPN, which one in four Russians use. Even without a VPN, the Internet is mostly free, if manipulated, and the social media app Telegram acts as an uncensored news source for some 40 million Russians. Use of Telegram has tripled since the war began but, of the top 10 political channels, nine are virulently pro-war. Clearly, these are narratives that Russians are seeking out and choosing to believe.
     

    Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear. More that anyone wants to admit, Putin's strength comes from pre existing Russian public opinion, and that is why his position is stronger that the West knows or wants to know. And just as Russian mass media need to reflect the opinions its viewers approve of or its advertising revenues will fall, the Western MSM have to produce what sells, Westerners want to hear that Russians are all prisoners of a malevolent dictator who has brainwashed them, but will be overthrown because Russians are mainly interested in enjoying material possessions from their oil and gas revenues and don't want to fight for their country. But we are almost two years in and tens of thousands of Russians have been killed yet there are still men choosing to joining up. Some Russia men do not want to be involved and leave their country, but some Ukrainian men have too. This war is going to go on for quite a few more years because both populations think their country's cause in it is just.

    Replies: @Jack D, @HA

    “Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear.

    Bully for him. No is asking Putin or Russians in general to be happy with NATO. What the West opposes is those who express their disapproval by way of military invasions. As Nuland demonstrated, a few baskets of pastries is all anyone needs to sway the Ukrainians — no military invasions (3-day or otherwise) are needed. I have yet to find a clear answer from Putin or his alleged supporters as to why invading Ukraine was ever some necessity. Prigozhin, for one, eventually was able to admit openly that Ukraine was never a threat to Russia. Few in Russia are willing to even be among the first to stop clapping, but that doesn’t mean they don’t agree that Prigozhin was right about that.

    Sure, if Putin had managed to wipe out the Ukrainian military in a few days — or even just take Kyiv — plenty in the West would have shrugged their shoulders and written the whole thing off by now. But he bungled it. If NATO is so powerful that even their discarded hand-me-down weaponry is enough to halt Putin’s advances, and Western bureacrats are so skilled in their skullduggery that they are able to move entire nations with only some empty carbs, Putin should have admitted he was outmatched and outwitted, and given up, else any further bloodshed was surely his fault. That’s after all the advice that the Putin trolls are even now giving to Ukraine. Seems to me they ought to take a swig of their own medicine.

    • Replies: @Sean
    @HA

    Ukraine in Nato would not have to worry if Russia was happy. Ukraine that decided to stay out of Nato would have had to keep Russia happy. Ukraine got a raincheck from Nato, which seems to have resulted--courtesy of Russia--in the worst of all possible worlds for Ukraine. And there is absolutely no end in sight..

    Replies: @HA

  369. @Jack D
    @YetAnotherAnon

    I wonder why Cuba decide it could join the East Bloc and we let them?

    You are admitting that Ukraine should take Putin's advice and "lie back and enjoy it" while Russia rapes them. Sorry, Ukraine doesn't have to follow his advice. It's up to them if they want to resist getting raped and it's proper for the West to help them resist.

    The fact that Ukraine sits on Russia's border is not determinative. Finland is on Russia's border and is no longer in its sphere of influence. Ukraine will be in Russia's sphere of influence if Russia wins the war but so far they haven't won it yet.

    Instead of getting a puppet regime they are going to have another enemy on their border for the foreseeable future, plus a couple of more NATO countries on their other borders. Heckuva job, Putie!

    Even if Russia "wins" and gets the puppet regime it wants now and maybe a bit of Ukrainian territory (after all we know that Russia is short on land), all it has bought itself is an eternal headache. 70 years of Soviet rule was not enough to douse Ukrainian nationalism. After this, the Ukrainians are going to hate Russia for generations to come, win or lose.

    Meanwhile, according to Rushists, Nuland was able to swing Ukraine over to the American sphere of influence just by offering them a plate of pastries. Russia tried billions of $ of bribes and that didn't work because the guys that they bribed were on a bullion laden helicopter out of Kyiv at the 1st sign of trouble.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    “they are going to have another enemy on their border for the foreseeable future”

    You are right – Poland.

    “The heroic characteristics of the Polish race must not blind us to their errors, which over centuries have led them through measureless suffering…it is a mystery and tragedy of European history that a people capable of every heroic virtue, gifted, valiant, charming, as individuals, should repeatedly show such inveterate faults in almost every aspect of their governmental life.” – Winston Churchill

  370. @John Johnson
    @nebulafox

    The awesome part about Seattle is being close enough to the outdoors outside Seattle. As long as you don’t mind the rain in winter, keeps you young.

    Yea but a lot of states have that.

    Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn't raining and they have more snow.

    I’ve adapted to all kinds of climates during my life and can thrive in most of them (California’s weather is just too damn… nice for my tastes, though), but the PNW’s with snow substituted for rain in the winters would be my ideal.

    I assume you mean Southern/Central California. The one season all year is kind of weird and especially if you grew up in a state with snow.

    Northern California would be nice if not for the fact that you are still in the tax zone. A lot of that rural California property has been bought up by the wealthy which drives up property taxes even further.

    Mmm. Don’t take bets if the KMT does as well as they look like they’ll do next year. Memories of HK have been fading, and Xi would probably still prefer politics to war if that’s an option for bringing Taiwan into the fold.

    I wouldn't bet on an invasion next year. The Ukraine war disaster has certainly given China second thoughts.

    But Taiwan honestly isn't making the right moves. They should be buying up drones and small arms.

    I support Taiwan but on some level I don't like them as a nation. They are too passive in the face of Chinese aggression. Their president is basically a naive female Democrat. She doesn't want to copy Swiss style defense measures. The US has recommended specific defense measures that have been ignored. Zelensky also ignored certain measures when the "training exercise" started building. What else do you need?

    A properly planned drone swarm could save Taiwan from a conventional invasion but I just don't think they have the guts to do it.

    Replies: @nebulafox

    >Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn’t raining and they have more snow.

    Yeah, but I’m too fond of the water, ever since I was little.

    >But Taiwan honestly isn’t making the right moves.

    No, they aren’t. The issue at the heart of it all is that Taiwanese military-civilian relations are dysfunctional. Some of this is a hangover from the Cold War-era KMT dictatorship, making things even more complicated. It’s sad because unlike Ukraine, Taiwan actually is a high-functioning democratic state, and the PRC routinely commits human rights abuses that make Putin look like a schoolboy, but what can you do? The Ukrainians have made it clear they’ll fight, whatever your opinion on the war. It’s not clear whether the Taiwanese will if push comes to shove. Maybe they will. Maybe they won’t. Next year, they’ve got elections. Beijing knows this.

    Taiwan’s semiconductor elites are also worth paying attention, particularly the heads of smaller businesses who don’t make the papers like TSMC. They are private businesses with the autonomy that goes along with it: back in the 1980s, there was of course a heavy degree of state control, but that’s long since dissipated. Anybody familiar with the process of IC manufacture can intuit that they have to worry about the prospect of the PRC poaching their talent. They might not be as cutting-edge as TSMC, but they have the training necessary to get there with the right funding.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @nebulafox


    Yeah, but I’m too fond of the water, ever since I was little.
     
    Idaho is great, but Washington State has natural beauty in spades (lots of different climates too, from rainforest, to dry Mediterranean climate for vineyards to alpine mountains). Too bad the people there have ruined it all with their insane politics.

    By the way, fully agree on Taiwan. The only caveat I'd give is that unlike Ukraine that shares a large contiguous border with Russia, Taiwan is an island. And being off the coast has its benefits (just ask the Britons since 1066 AD).
  371. @Intelligent Dasein
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    To be perfectly honest, JIE, it was not sarcasm, but neither was it literally true. It was indulgence.

    Just as when you're dealing with children, or simple adults, or the newly converted, or students, or basically anybody who is not yet developed, you have to humor their clumsy efforts. It isn't right to judge them by a standard they cannot meet yet, so you validate their earnestness and overlook their insufficiencies---for a time.

    Twinkie makes a lot of extravagant and unverifiable claims about his life, which is annoying. In the first place, it's cheesy and exasperating, because nobody really wants to hear it. But he seems to need the attention, so I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard. There was a time when I actually thought he was a Catholic and deserving of fraternal charity. I was wrong about that.

    In the second place, you begin to detect psychological inconsistencies in someone who doesn't seem to have the global situational awareness to realize that the extraordinary claims he makes about his life cannot be believed (and should not be believed by responsible adults) without extraordinary evidence, which he fails to provide.

    And that's the problem. Nobody ought to believe Twinkie based on his track record. If you consider your online persona to be like a startup company that you want investors to buy into, "Twinkie" has about the same level of credibility as Theranos. His inability to provide verifiable evidence for his personal claims cannot be the result of a good-faith error, so it must signify something disingenuous in the claimant. There is nobody else on this forum who says so much about himself and backs up so little.

    Thirdly, the spirit of Twinkie's personality is incongruent with the letter. He alludes, vaguely, to some kind of background in the military or intelligence services and he peppers his posts with judo trivia, but he speaks in the twatty tone of voice of somebody who's never been punched in the face in his life. That guy ain't no marine, is the best way to put it. He also claims to have a large but unspecified number of children and yet acts nothing like a father. There is a tone acquired by men who have changed diapers and scrubbed puke out of carpets at 3AM. Twinkie doesn't have it.

    And Twinkie is not a Catholic. He loves the faith not at all, says nothing about it unless pressed, and what he does say is laughably phony.

    I would guess that he's structured his online persona using details from his real life, but fortified with a heavy embellishment. He is Korean, studied history at university, and has some low-level job in a federal agency. He lives around rich people but is not wealthy. He is pathologically status-conscious and very afraid of black people. Everything else is "aspirational."

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @AKAHorace, @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie, @Twinkie

    I indulged him in a sympathetic sense of admiration for the baubles of wealth and status that he holds in such high regard.

    By the way, it isn’t nice projecting one’s own materialistic obsession onto other people. I am, after all, not the one whining about my parents “depleting my patrimony on their frivolities,” thereby “destroy[ing] my own chance at earthly happiness.”

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/how-to-get-rich/#comment-5343550

    My maternal grandfather was born to an inordinately rich man (with a main house that had 7 gates), but, out of shame for how that wealth had been earned, he rejected that patrimony and, despite being highly educated overseas, went to a dirt-poor mining town to work as a miner and then later strove tirelessly as an advocate for the miners. He found “earthly happiness” through this work and raising his modest family and, later, on his deathbed, converted to Catholicism. The one material thing I have from him is a crucifix necklace he gave me when I saw him last before he succumbed to stomach cancer. He’s the man I admire the most.

    And, much as I have worked hard to achieve prosperity in this life, my earthly happiness comes from gazing upon my children and the knowledge that I have done my best to educate them to seek Heaven and, hopefully, with God’s Grace, gain it.

    You once cried about wanting out of “the rat race” and of being a “wage-slave,” and instead wanting “freedom, dignity, nobility.” I suggest you stop wasting your time commenting on an internet blog and instead build that patrimony for your children. If you found what your parents did – not leaving you a legacy – so bitter, work hard so that you do otherwise for your own progeny.

    • Thanks: MEH 0910
  372. @nebulafox
    @John Johnson

    >Boise is even better in that regard. Half the year it isn’t raining and they have more snow.

    Yeah, but I'm too fond of the water, ever since I was little.

    >But Taiwan honestly isn’t making the right moves.

    No, they aren't. The issue at the heart of it all is that Taiwanese military-civilian relations are dysfunctional. Some of this is a hangover from the Cold War-era KMT dictatorship, making things even more complicated. It's sad because unlike Ukraine, Taiwan actually is a high-functioning democratic state, and the PRC routinely commits human rights abuses that make Putin look like a schoolboy, but what can you do? The Ukrainians have made it clear they'll fight, whatever your opinion on the war. It's not clear whether the Taiwanese will if push comes to shove. Maybe they will. Maybe they won't. Next year, they've got elections. Beijing knows this.

    Taiwan's semiconductor elites are also worth paying attention, particularly the heads of smaller businesses who don't make the papers like TSMC. They are private businesses with the autonomy that goes along with it: back in the 1980s, there was of course a heavy degree of state control, but that's long since dissipated. Anybody familiar with the process of IC manufacture can intuit that they have to worry about the prospect of the PRC poaching their talent. They might not be as cutting-edge as TSMC, but they have the training necessary to get there with the right funding.

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Yeah, but I’m too fond of the water, ever since I was little.

    Idaho is great, but Washington State has natural beauty in spades (lots of different climates too, from rainforest, to dry Mediterranean climate for vineyards to alpine mountains). Too bad the people there have ruined it all with their insane politics.

    By the way, fully agree on Taiwan. The only caveat I’d give is that unlike Ukraine that shares a large contiguous border with Russia, Taiwan is an island. And being off the coast has its benefits (just ask the Britons since 1066 AD).

  373. @HA
    @Sean

    "Putin is a Russian and if he thinks Ukraine has no right to become part of a Western security order, where did that come from? The majority of Russians have shared that opinion from when the possibility was first seriously mooted as the Burns memorandum to Rice made clear.

    Bully for him. No is asking Putin or Russians in general to be happy with NATO. What the West opposes is those who express their disapproval by way of military invasions. As Nuland demonstrated, a few baskets of pastries is all anyone needs to sway the Ukrainians -- no military invasions (3-day or otherwise) are needed. I have yet to find a clear answer from Putin or his alleged supporters as to why invading Ukraine was ever some necessity. Prigozhin, for one, eventually was able to admit openly that Ukraine was never a threat to Russia. Few in Russia are willing to even be among the first to stop clapping, but that doesn't mean they don't agree that Prigozhin was right about that.

    Sure, if Putin had managed to wipe out the Ukrainian military in a few days -- or even just take Kyiv -- plenty in the West would have shrugged their shoulders and written the whole thing off by now. But he bungled it. If NATO is so powerful that even their discarded hand-me-down weaponry is enough to halt Putin's advances, and Western bureacrats are so skilled in their skullduggery that they are able to move entire nations with only some empty carbs, Putin should have admitted he was outmatched and outwitted, and given up, else any further bloodshed was surely his fault. That's after all the advice that the Putin trolls are even now giving to Ukraine. Seems to me they ought to take a swig of their own medicine.

    Replies: @Sean

    Ukraine in Nato would not have to worry if Russia was happy. Ukraine that decided to stay out of Nato would have had to keep Russia happy. Ukraine got a raincheck from Nato, which seems to have resulted–courtesy of Russia–in the worst of all possible worlds for Ukraine. And there is absolutely no end in sight..

    • Thanks: MEH 0910
    • Replies: @HA
    @Sean

    "Ukraine in Nato would not have to worry if Russia was happy."

    Yes, a happy Russia. We'll get right on that, Sean. Given Russia's history of being a brimming basket of bouncy puppies and kittens, that'll be a piece of cake. and once we're done, no neighbor of Russia will ever have to worry about Russia again.

  374. @Sean
    @HA

    Ukraine in Nato would not have to worry if Russia was happy. Ukraine that decided to stay out of Nato would have had to keep Russia happy. Ukraine got a raincheck from Nato, which seems to have resulted--courtesy of Russia--in the worst of all possible worlds for Ukraine. And there is absolutely no end in sight..

    Replies: @HA

    “Ukraine in Nato would not have to worry if Russia was happy.”

    Yes, a happy Russia. We’ll get right on that, Sean. Given Russia’s history of being a brimming basket of bouncy puppies and kittens, that’ll be a piece of cake. and once we’re done, no neighbor of Russia will ever have to worry about Russia again.

  375. @HA
    @Cagey Beast

    "Prigozhin’s death confirmed by DNA tests..., the Investigative Committee has said"

    Well, who could possibly doubt anything Russia's Investigative Committee has said? Nonetheless, I suspect Prigozhin sightings will outnumber those of Elvis, Bigfoot and Whitey Bulger, all put together, at least for a while. Tenerif, Cyprus, Bangkok -- everywere. Cue the Tom Joad speech -- "wherever they's a fight so hungry people can eat", you can bet ol' Zhenya will be there, cooking up some red hots, nice and juicy.

    Replies: @HA

    “I suspect Prigozhin sightings will outnumber those of Elvis, Bigfoot and Whitey Bulger, all put together, at least for a while. Tenerif, Cyprus, Bangkok — everyw[h]ere.”

    Wagner Boss Yevgeny Prigozhin is Still Alive and Plotting His Revenge on Vladimir Putin, Russian Analyst Claims

    A Russian political analyst recently claimed that Wagner boss Yevgeny Prigozhin is still alive and plotting his revenge against Vladimir Putin, RadarOnline.com has learned….Dr. Valery Solovey claimed that Prigozhin is “alive, well, and free” in an undisclosed country.

    According to Solovey, Prigozhin evaded Putin’s alleged assassination attempt by placing a body double on the private jet that mysteriously crashed on its way to St. Petersburg on August 23.

    Even more surprising was the Russian analyst’s claim that Putin was aware Prigozhin was not on the flight that tumbled out of the sky last week… Solovey said on Tuesday, according to Daily Mail. “By the way, Vladimir Putin is perfectly aware of that.”

    “If you believe official statements of the Russian authorities, then what can I say?” the Russian analyst added.

  376. @HA
    @Dumbo

    "This is why he basically stopped talking about those two things."

    I'm guessing he stopped talking about COVID because, unlike anti-vaxx loons like yourself, he was able to get on with his life and move on to other interests once the pandemic ended and excess death tolls returned to normal, which was some time ago. If you still want to hyperventilate about that, even though the ER's are no longer over-flowing and restrictions have been lifted, consider the possibility that maybe long-COVID addled your brain.

    As for Ukraine, Prigozhin played a role of some importance in what went on there last year, and Sailer is apparently willing to discuss that.

    Which means you're 0 for 2, i.e., I'm guessing you have some first-hand experience when it comes to being stupidly, abysmally wrong.

    Replies: @Dumbo

    LOL. The problem of people like you (until proof in contrary, I am assuming you’re a Fed, a Jewish activist or at any rate some moron troll with a “neocon mentality”) is that they NEVER admit they are wrong. Long Covid, LOL. Whatever, dude. Now, Steve’s problem is something else — he’s just not very deep, and he doesn’t care.

  377. Anonymous[269] • Disclaimer says:

    The Ukrainian counterparts of Wagner would be the Azovites. Like Wagner in Russia, they’re the best soldiers Ukraine has, but also hard to control, with leaders who think they should be running the country.

    Indeed, they bear much responsibility for this war, having forced Zelensky to take a hard line with Russia against his better judgement, with the presumed threat that they would kill him as a traitor if he refused.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Steve Sailer Comments via RSS
PastClassics
The Shaping Event of Our Modern World
Analyzing the History of a Controversial Movement
The JFK Assassination and the 9/11 Attacks?